ObamaCare Fails to Protect Pre-existing Conditions

 

In my last post, Pre-existing Conditions Latest Victim in War on Truth, I talked about the importance of protecting pre-existing conditions coverage. ObamaCare made an issue of this problem, and rightly so, but it didn’t go far enough.

Democrats are misleading voters by rousing fears that they will lose their pre-existing coverage if ObamaCare is repealed. But the truth is that ObamaCare has failed to adequately protect some people from this devastating problem.

Grace-Marie Turner, writing in Forbes, tells how ObamaCare failed to deliver in producing a sensible and sustainable mechanism to support pre-existing protections. After creating a temporary high risk pool that ended in 2014, it then permanently shoved their extra costs onto other Americans who are now struggling to afford coverage.

She tells the story of a woman, named Janet, who wrote to her about why ObamaCare isn’t working.

Janet reports, “In 1999, I was diagnosed with Hepatitis C, which made me ineligible for insurance (denied for pre-existing conditions).  I live in Colorado, and they had a high-risk pool that covered people like me. I applied for that and was accepted.

“My premiums in 2010 were $275/month with a total out of pocket of $2,500.  [While I was on] this plan, my liver failed, and I needed a liver transplant. It was approved without a question.  My $600,000 transplant was covered 100% with a $2,500 out of pocket maximum!”

When Obamacare went into effect, Colorado’s high-risk pool was closed.  “I was forced into the regular marketplace that everyone was telling me was a good thing because I couldn’t get denied.  I think my first year on that policy, my premiums were in the $450 range—which I thought wasn’t too terrible, but still more than I had been paying.

“The thing I noticed from the start was that instead of full coverage, almost everything I needed was denied, which threw me into the world of having to appeal (sometimes several times) to get the basic care I needed.

“Since then, my premiums skyrocketed.  In 2017, I paid $735 a month with total out-of-pocket costs of $5,500.  In 2018, my premiums went up to $1,100 a month with a deductible of $6,300.  Once I hit that mark, I’m covered 80%.

“Further, none of my anti-rejection meds are on the formulary of my insurance. If I could not afford them, my body would most certainly reject my liver, causing another liver transplant that would not be covered 100%.

“I don’t get any credits from the government to reduce my premiums.  Those of us who are self employed but make more than the threshold for tax credits wind up footing the whole bill ourselves.  I have to spend $19,500 before my insurance pays anything, and it doesn’t cover all my prescription costs.  My old plan was almost a third of what I have to pay now.

“I have many friends and work associates in the same boat as me.   Many of them are doing without insurance and are betting that they won’t need more than what they can afford to pay out of pocket.  I cannot do that, because if something happened and I needed another transplant, it would bankrupt my family.

“The system is broken beyond imagination.”

 

Even though Janet has coverage for pre-existing conditions, her access to care is worse and the cost of her coverage is much higher than before ObamaCare. This isn’t the kind of protection we were promised. Republicans are right to want to find a better healthcare system – but they must protect Americans from losing coverage for their pre-existing conditions – and do a better job of that than ObamaCare.

Pre-existing Conditions Latest Victim in War on Truth

 

Most Americans would agree that the best thing about ObamaCare was the elimination of pre-existing conditions as an excuse for denial of healthcare insurance. That may be the only good thing about ObamaCare.

Republicans are just as pleased with reassuring Americans about their pre-existing conditions as Democrats. But Democrats are working hard to convince voters that any attempt to repeal and replace ObamaCare is an attempt to eliminate pre-existing conditions protections.

Karl Rove, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says Democratic mid-term campaign ads are promoting this fiction. One Arizona ad says Martha McSally, the Republican congresswoman running for Senate, “voted to gut protections for people with pre-existing conditions.” Another, in North Dakota, accuses GOP Senate nominee Kevin Kramer of “voting five times to let insurance companies deny coverage to people with conditions like cancer.”

This fiction is being promoted all over the country by Democratic candidates because they recognize this is a hot-button issue. It doesn’t matter that these statements are completely false.

Rove explains: “The pre-existing conditions offensive against the GOP is based on its votes to repeal ObamaCare. But the truth is that Ms. McSally, Mr. Cramer and every Republican in Congress who voted for repeal also voted to require states to provide protections for people with pre-existing conditions. The GOP approach was to let each state figure out how best to accomplish this under a federal system that worked better than the Affordable Care Act. Republicans trusted leaders in state capitals to do better than Washington for the people of their states.”

The ObamaCare system of protections for pre-existing conditions also ensured people didn’t have to enroll in healthcare plans until they got sick. Then they could signup for treatment and not be denied coverage. This would be like purchasing fire insurance for your house after the house is on fire! This “gaming of the system” forced other enrollees to pay more for their coverage.

Rove argues that the GOP should tell Americans they can cover their pre-existing conditions without the damage ObamaCare has inflicted. They must convince voters they want to improve the system, not just scrap it. One way to do this would be to require state plans for protection of pre-existing conditions meet certain federal standards.

It’s also important for Republicans to make this issue personal. They have friends and family members who need pre-existing condition coverage, too. Missouri Attorney General and Senate candidate Josh Hawley recently did this in response to attacks by his opponent, Senator Claire McCaskill. He revealed that one of his sons was recently diagnosed with a rare bone disease. He acknowledged that he had joined a lawsuit to declare ObamaCare unconstitutional. But he said that because of his personal experience, “I will never support taking away health insurance coverage for people with pre-existing conditions.”

This issue has raised healthcare to an important subject on the campaign trail even though other issues, like immigration, the environment, and the economy get more attention in the media. Let’s not let misinformation be the deciding factor in this important election.

Solving ObamaCare – A New Proposal – Part II

 

In Part I of this series I discussed a new healthcare proposal known as the Health Care Choices Proposal.

Their policy proposal promises to:

  1. Improve choices and lower costs, while protecting vulnerable Americans
  2. Give flexibility and resources to states to achieve those goals
  3. Ensure people can opt into the private coverage of their choice

 

In Part I we learned what their proposal promises to achieve. Today we will learn how they propose to make it work.

How Real Reform Works

  • The federal government would provide a fixed amount of funding to each state – Under ObamaCare, the federal government sends billions of dollars to insurance companies to subsidize insurance policy premiums. Under this proposal, Washington would issue grants to states. The initial grants would be based on the amount of ACA spending as of a fixed date. Then, over time, the grant would be based on a state’s number of low-income residents. States would use the money to help vulnerable citizens obtain coverage.
  • Each state would take responsibility for using federal money to make insurance more affordable – States would be enabled to be laboratories of innovative policy and thereby:
    • Reduce premiums – by reinvigorating broken, private health insurance markets that failed under ObamaCare’s one-size-fits-all structure.
    • Individuals and families would choose the coverage that best fits their needs – With a consumer-centric approach, the insurance markets can offer plans to meet individual needs – more freedom of choice.
    • Give low-income people more choices – Instead of being forced onto Medicaid or a narrow ObamaCare network, these people would be empowered to use their government assistance to buy a private health plan of their choice.
    • Protect people with pre-existing conditions without making coverage so costly for the young and healthy – ObamaCare forced the young and healthy to subsidize the older and sicker Americans. By eliminating the ObamaCare regulations that made this necessary, the cost of coverage will come down – and states will have resources to help people with more expensive conditions access coverage without driving up costs for everyone.
    • States would have better incentives to protect the most vulnerable – instead of chasing federal Medicaid expansion dollars to add new enrollees while neglecting those already on the program and in need.
    • Encourage wider coverage – by removing restrictions on insurers’ ability to use innovative approaches.
    • Spend grant money only on health care – The federal government must hold states accountable for spending federal dollars.

 

Greater Access to HSAs

This proposal would take two key steps to improve HSAs so they can be more flexible, more widely available, and give consumers greater control over how their HSA dollars are spent, including seeing the doctor of their choice.

  • Roughly double HSA contribution limits – from $3,450 per individual and $6,850 per family today.
  • Make more plans HSA-compatible – Today, a policy must have a deductible of at least $1350 (individual) or $2700 (family). This proposal would change the requirement to qualify, so that any plan with an actuarial value less than a specified level (e.g. 70%, 80%) would be HSA-compatible.

 

Is this new proposal the solution?

It does not promise to fix everything that is wrong with our health sector today. But they believe it is the logical next step in helping our private health sector recover from Washington’s failed approach. It is clear that the top-down big government style of ObamaCare – that would get even worse with single-payer systems – is not the answer.

This approach is to empower consumers to have the choices and control they need to protect themselves and their families. Who do you think should be in control of your healthcare – you or the federal government?