A Second Opinion on Trump’s Drug Proposal

 

President Trump wants Americans to pay less for Medicare Part B drugs. (Trump’s Radical Plan to Lower Medicare Drug Prices) That’s certainly a good thing. But does that come with an unacceptable cost?

The Wall Street Journal editorial board thinks it may. They say prices in Europe are artificially lower because these countries run single-payer healthcare systems that dictate the prices they’re willing to pay. In other words, market forces do not set the price.

They say that Europe pays for these artificially lower prices in the form of reduced access to healthcare. That certainly is typical of single-payer healthcare systems. Of 74 cancer drugs launched between 2011 and 2018, 95% of them (70 drugs) are available in the U.S. But only 74% are available in the U.K., 49% in Japan, and 8% in Greece. People in these countries are paying for lower prices with their lives.

Better quality care in the U.S. is why America outpaces 10 European countries on cancer survival rates. These countries simply are willing to deny people treatment if it saves the government money. This should be remembered the next time Bernie Sanders pushes his single-payer healthcare!

Then there’s the impact on investment in new drugs. The Trump plan is expected to save $17 Billion over five years by establishing price controls based on an international index of prices in sixteen other countries. HHS Secretary Alex Azar says this amount represents a fraction of pharmaceutical research and development. That may be true, but is it a fraction investors are willing to ignore? It’s always easy to spend other people’s money more readily than your own.

WSJ says investors who are considering bankrolling the cure for Alzheimer’s disease are already staring at a very small chance of success. The Trump proposal adds another potential limit on return that will be restricted further if Democrats retake power and use it as a precedent. The rule deals with Medicare Part B, or drugs administered by doctors like specialty drugs, whose development is especially tough.

They say these investors may choose less difficult drug development, for less significant cures, or they may simply choose other investments like the next Uber or other new business model. New drug development can only be sustained by a reasonable chance of a healthy return on investment in R&D.

These are reasonable criticisms that are not new. Pharmaceutical companies have been making these arguments for years to ensure the high drug prices and flow of investment capital they believe they need to sustain their industry. The real question is this:

Is the American consumer willing to pay higher prices for drugs to enable the development of new treatments or are lower prices for currently available drugs more important?

 

How would you answer the question?

Republicans Propose a New Healthcare Vision

 

An ideal healthcare system should take care of sick people. Seems obvious, but sometimes you just have to get back to basics.

Republicans in Congress have reached just that conclusion and have put forth a new congressional resolution to make this point. House Resolution 1089, introduced by Rep. Pete Sessions (R – TX) and Rep. Mark Meadows (R – NC) gives states broad authority to reform their own insurance markets with certain provisions:

  • Pre-existing Conditions – must provide for:
    • Lower premiums
    • Lower out-of-pocket costs
    • Greater accessibility to in-network providers
  • Workers who lose their job due to illness – must have:
    • Have access to individual health insurance similar to their group plan

 

John C. Goodman, healthcare economist writing in Forbes, says the resolution lays out a vision of what state reform should aim for. People who pay premiums to employer plans for many years and then become too sick to work should have access to individual health insurance coverage that is similar to group insurance “in price, quality, and access to care, regardless of any pre-existing condition.”

But that’s not all. The resolution also calls for something that is explicitly outlawed under ObamaCare: a market in which health plans specialize in certain diseases and compete to enroll and solve the problems of patients who have those conditions, such as cancer, diabetes, and heart disease.

Democrats are pushing the false narrative that Republicans can’t govern on healthcare due to their failure to repeal and replace ObamaCare as they promised in the 2016 election. This conveniently dismisses the fact that Democrats failed to support Republican efforts with a single vote.

But more important is the Republican track record on Medicare. Though passed during the Democratic administration of President Johnson, it was Republicans who steered this new healthcare legislation for seniors through Congress. More recently, it was Republicans who created the Medicare Advantage program during the Bush presidency that today insures one out of every three seniors.

Goodman says when it comes to healthcare legislation we have Medicare (created by Republicans) which works, and ObamaCare (created by Democrats) which has been a disaster.

To reform ObamaCare, using principles that work so well for seniors in Medicare Advantage (MA), Goodman says there are three principles needed:

  • Fair Prices for Sellers – In MA, enrollees pay a community rated premium. Medicare tops up those premiums so that health plans receive compensation that reflects the expected cost for each enrollee. That means insurers benefit from taking care of the sick as well as the healthy. ObamaCare is the opposite – it incentivizes insurers to avoid the sick and attract the healthy. The result is most plans exclude the best doctors and hospitals.
  • Fair Prices for Buyers – ObamaCare has allowed group plans to dump their most expensive patients on this market – which drives up the price of premiums for everyone. By ending state risk pools, even more sick patients were dumped on the exchanges. Therefore, it is no surprise that individual premiums have skyrocketed. The solution is re-establishment of risk pools in the states, and a small employer fee to subsidize insurance for workers who lose their job due to illness. The net result will be lower premiums for everyone.
  • No gaming – Today there are about 30 million Americans who don’t have health insurance. But as soon as they get sick they can purchase health insurance at the same premium amount as those who are currently insured. This “gaming” of the system increases the price for everyone. This is not allowed under Medicare – there is a penalty for failure to enroll when you are eligible. By eliminating “gaming” more will be insured and everyone will pay less.

 

What could be more sensible?

As the Mid-term elections approach, many Democrats are claiming that Republicans want to “do away” with protections for Pre-existing Conditions. In reality, they want to improve on the protections that currently exist in ObamaCare – and provide them at a lower cost to everyone.

 

Healthcare Myths Dominate Mid-term Elections

 

Healthcare is a major issue in the mid-term elections. That’s understandable since ObamaCare has been such a disaster. What’s not understandable is Democratic claims that voters should trust them to fix the problem they created in the first place!

In my home state of Florida, Democratic Senator Bill Nelson is running ads where he attacks his Republican opponent, Governor Rick Scott, on his healthcare record. He falsely claims Scott and the Republicans want to do away with pre-existing conditions protections. Then he accuses Scott of blocking Medicaid expansion in Florida – as if expanding Medicaid would be a good thing!

ObamaCare tried to force every state into expanding Medicaid for healthy childless adult males who earn up to 138% of the poverty limit. The Supreme Court struck down this provision, allowing states to make their own determinations.

Blue states jumped on board this government give-away train when ObamaCare promised 100% federal coverage of the cost for three years, tapering off to 90% at present. More than 30 states voted to expand Medicaid under these rules.

How has this worked out for those who expanded Medicaid?

There’s no such thing as a “free lunch.” That’s the first lesson you learn when you become an adult. Those states who expanded their Medicaid are learning this lesson the hard way.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says, “Every state that has expanded Medicaid has blown the budget by spending more money on more people. The cost overruns are more than double on average.”

On November 6, four states will consider ballot initiatives on expanding Medicaid: Nebraska, Utah, Idaho and Montana, the last of which would extend an expansion that is set to expire. Montana’s expansion has come in 70% over budget, according to the Foundation for Government Accountability. The state is now proposing to fund its expansion with a tobacco tax, which is impressive cynicism even for politicians.

Utah is proposing to raise the sales tax to 4.85% from 4.7% – a regressive tax on the poor to pay for health care for those above the poverty line. Nebraska and Idaho’s ballot measures leave the funding details for another day, ostensibly because voters might figure out that expansion is more expensive than it appears.

Oregon proposed new taxes this year to fund the cost of Medicaid expansion and Medicaid is already the fastest growing line item in nearly every state in the country. The incentive in all of these states will be to cut services from the needy, who receive traditional Medicaid, because it saves states more money.

Unlike the federal government, states must balance their budgets. That means spending more money to pay for Medicaid means less to pay for other important budget items like education, law enforcement and roads. In Idaho the compound annual growth rate for Medicaid spending over the past decade or so triples that of schools and roads, as the Idaho Freedom Foundation points out. And that’s before expansion. So, that “free money” wasn’t so free!

What about accepting the expense “for compassion’s sake?”

First, these newly enrolled patients are not pregnant women, children or the disabled, who are covered by other government healthcare programs. These are able-bodied adult males – many who refuse to work even though jobs are now plentiful. Medicaid was never intended for this demographic profile from its inception.

Second, Medicaid is the worst form of healthcare insurance – arguably worse than having no insurance at all. The Oregon Healthcare Experiment, begun in 2007, has shown those patients on Medicaid are no better off than those patients with no insurance at all when measuring common healthcare data such as blood sugar and blood pressure control.

These Medicaid patients also use emergency rooms for primary care 40% more than the uninsured. Patients without insurance actually have greater access to healthcare  since they can negotiate cash payments to doctors, which is illegal for Medicaid patients. Studies on Medicaid patients repeatedly show poorer healthcare outcomes than any other form of healthcare insurance.

Here’s how the WSJ summarizes Medicaid expansion: “Medicaid expansion is a bad fiscal and healthcare bargain that looks worse as time passes. States like Kentucky are already looking for reforms like work requirements before the “free” money drowns their state fisc. Voters would be wise to reject the phony compassion and focus scarce resources on the poor and disabled.”

I’m thankful that Governor Scott resisted the pressure to expand Medicaid in the State of Florida – and all Floridians should be thankful, too. Senator Nelson was a part of the problem that created our healthcare mess and he won’t be part of the solution to fix it.