What’s Wrong With Medicare For All? – Part II

 

In Part I of this series, we talked about the Democratic claims for a new healthcare system called Medicare for All, introduced by Senator Bernie Sanders. All of the following claims have been made about this idea:

  • Universal access to healthcare
  • Elimination of insurance company approvals for treatment
  • Increased taxes will be no more than current expenses for healthcare
  • Lowered healthcare costs for patients and the government
  • Improved healthcare quality for all Americans
  • Americans will love this “free healthcare”

 

Part I began a discussion of the impact of Medicare for All on access to healthcare. Supporters of this bill believe it will increase access to healthcare because more people will have insurance coverage. Currently about 90% of Americans have some form of healthcare insurance coverage. Supporters of Medicare for All believe this bill will provide 100% coverage for all Americans.

However, as I discussed in Part I, having insurance coverage does not necessarily mean having increased access to healthcare. If you can’t get into a doctor’s office for treatment because your coverage doesn’t pay the doctor enough to cover his expenses, you still don’t have access to healthcare. This is often the case with those currently enrolled on Medicaid. Even though they have “coverage” by the expansion of Medicaid, their accessto healthcare has not improved.

Will Medicare for All increase access to healthcare?

To be sure, Medicare for All is a misnomer. It will not be Medicare expanded to cover everyone. It will mean the eliminationof private healthcare insurance, which currently provides healthcare coverage for about 200 million Americans, including those with Medicare supplement plans or Medicare Advantage plans.

Medicare for All is a clever but misleading catchphrase that polls better than describing it as single-payer healthcare– which is exactly what it is. A single-payer healthcare system means the government is the only payer – provider of healthcare. All doctors and hospitals must submit their bills to the government for approval and payment. The government controls the prices, the approvals, and the payments. Nothing gets done without government approval and no one gets paid more than the government allows.

Simply put, this is socialized medicine.Democrats don’t call it that because they know the word “socialized medicine” doesn’t poll well; just like the phrase “pro-abortion” doesn’t poll as well as “pro-choice.”

In every socialized medicine system in the world, including Canada, United Kingdom, Sweden, Denmark, etc., costs are controlled by reducing payments to providers (which reduces providers) and rationing care. This means long waits to see a doctor, government control of approvals, elimination of certain costly treatment options (especially for the elderly), and reduced medical innovation.

Elimination of insurance company approvals

Senator Kamala Harris recently announced her candidacy for president and declared her support for Medicare for All. When asked if her plan would eliminate private healthcare insurers, she agreed it would. She argued, who would miss them? “Who of us has not had that situation where you’ve got to wait for approval and the doctor says, “Well, I don’t know if your insurance company is going to cover this’? Let’s eliminate all of that, let’s move on.”

The naiveté of Senator Harris in this statement is appalling. Even the liberal Washington Post editorial board had to chastise her thinking when they responded, “Actually, no one can really eliminate “all of that” – not Ms. Harris and not possible 2020 candidate Senator Bernie Sanders. Even if the United States adopted Medicare for All or some other version of national health insurance, Americans would not get everything they want whenever they want it. No one, in any country, does.”

Every socialized healthcare system on the planet controls costs by rationing – by decreasing access to healthcare. The Washington Post editors agree. They write, “But what Medicare for All could not do – and what Ms. Harris and others who may tout the idea during the coming campaign cannot claim honestly, – is end healthcare rationing.”

How has this impacted accessto healthcare in other socialized medicine countries?

Here is a sample of waiting times in two countries with similar socialized medicine.

United Kingdom

  • 2 million patients on the NHS waiting lists
  • 362,600 patients waited longer than four monthsfor hospital treatment as of March last year
  • 95,252 patients waited longer than six months
  • 4,300 patients were on the waiting list more than a yearby July
  • 19%of patients wait 2 months or longer to begin their first “urgent” cancer treatment
  • 17% wait more than 4 months for brain surgery

 

Canada

  • The median waiting time between seeing a general practitioner and a specialist was 10.2 weeks.
  • 5 months between seeing a doctor and beginning treatment
  • 3 months to see an ophthalmologist
  • 4 months to see an orthopedist
  • 10 months for orthopedic hip or knee replacement
  • 5 months to see a neurosurgeon
  • 8 months for neurosurgery
  • 3 months for initialtreatment of heart disease

 

These excessive waiting times are not only for seeing doctors but also for obtaining diagnostic studies like CT Scans, MRI scans, and heart catheterizations, as well as to obtain the newest drugs for cancer and other serious diseases. Aside from transplants, the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), which compares other countries, states, “waiting lists are not a feature in the United States.”

Of course, these excessive waiting times lead to poorer healthcare outcomes. Single-payer systems have proved inferior to the U.S. in outcomes for almost all serious diseases, including cancer, diabetes, high blood pressure, stroke and heart disease.

While America is considering implementing a single-payer system like Medicare for All, those countries that currently have such a system are backing away from it with increased spending on private care.

  • Swedenhas increased its spending on private care for the elderly by 50% in the last decade, abolished its government’s monopoly over pharmacies, and made other reforms.
  • The United Kingdomlast year spent more than $1 Billion on private care according to the Financial Times.
  • In Denmarkpatients can now choose a private hospital or a hospital outside the country if their wait time exceeds one month.
  • Canada is also feeling the pressure on excessive waiting times and is increasing spending on private care for relief.

 

Scott W. Atlas, senior fellow at Stanford’s Hoover Institution recently wrote in The Wall Street Journal: “A single-payer “guarantee” is no promise of access to quality medical care. If brought to the U.S., the only reliable promises of single-payer would be worse health care for Americans and higher taxes. America’s poor and middle class would suffer the most from a turn to single-payer because only they would be unable to circumvent the system.”

(This series will be continued in the next post – Part III.)

What’s Wrong With Medicare For All? – Part I

 

There’s a lot of talk these days about Medicare for All. Already it is shaping up to be the hottest topic of the 2020 Presidential Campaign. What does it mean and is it good for the American people?

Medicare for All is a catchphrase and a legislative bill, both introduced by Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders. Sanders, an avowed socialist, is promoting a government-run, single-payer healthcare system. He promoted this cause in his unsuccessful 2016 bid for the presidency.

The idea has gained traction since then with other Democratic presidential hopefuls. Recently announced Democratic presidential candidates Kamala Harris, Elizabeth Warren, Kirsten Gillibrand and Corey Booker are all supporters of Medicare for All. It is likely to become a platform plank for Democrats in the 2020 election. Therefore, understanding what it means and the impact it will have on healthcare and the nation’s economy is paramount.

Democratic Claims

There are many claims being made about the benefits of Medicare for All. I have heard all of the following:

  • Universal access to healthcare
  • Elimination of insurance company approvals for treatment
  • Increased taxes will be no more than current expenses for healthcare
  • Lowered healthcare costs for patients and the government
  • Improved healthcare quality for all Americans
  • Americans will love this “free healthcare”

 

All of these claims have been made by politicians or their supporters at one time or another. Sorting out the truth from the fiction is necessary if we’re going to make an intelligent conclusion about this new healthcare idea. Let’s analyze each of these statements one at a time.

Universal Access to Healthcare

Prior to ObamaCare about 84% of the population had healthcare insurance of one kind or another. Since ObamaCare it is now about 90%, mostly because of increased Medicaid eligibility and enrollment. That still leaves about 10% of Americans without healthcare insurance. That does not mean they are without healthcare.

Those 10% are mostly individuals who do not receive employer-provided insurance, are not eligible for Medicare or Medicaid and they have chosen not to purchase ObamaCare insurance because they do not receive a subsidy.

These people are not the poorest Americans. They make too much money to be eligible for Medicaid or ObamaCare subsidies. They may have the money to purchase insurance but they have elected to remain uninsured because it is not cost-effective. This may be a very responsible decision on their part, given the current cost of ObamaCare insurance without subsidies.

Medicare for All would increase the roles of those eligible for healthcare insurance provided by the government. It would also eliminatethe private health insurance industry that currently provides health insurance for about 155 million Americans through their employers, as well as all those with private insurance supplements for their Medicare gap insurance or Medicare Advantage plans. That means the current insurance system for about 200 million Americans would be eliminated!

Advocates of Medicare for All claim this would eliminate the 10% coverage gap and provide universal access to healthcare. Is this true? Would this really improve our healthcare system?

One of the most widely misunderstood words in the healthcare debate is access.Insurance coverage does not mean access. An insurance enrollment card does not increase your access to healthcare unless you can more readily see the doctor. When it comes to Medicaid, this is especially a problem.

In 2007 the State of Oregon was forced to begin an experiment with their Medicaid system because they had inadequate funding to cover everyone eligible. Therefore, they devised a lottery system that arbitrarily determined who would be eligible and who would not. This began what is now known as The Oregon Health Insurance Experiment. This ongoing study has drawn several important conclusions including:

  • Medicaid enrollees do not have better health than the uninsured– when comparing standard measurements of blood pressure, blood sugar, and cholesterol. Medicaid reduced observed rates of depression by 30% but increased the probability of depression. Medicaid increased the probability of being diagnosed with diabetes, but had no impacton lowering blood sugar.
  • Medicaid lowers access to healthcare– Medicaid enrollees were 40% more likely to use emergency rooms for care than the uninsured. This same finding was confirmed by the Colorado Hospital Association, which reported that emergency room use is higher in those states that expanded Medicaid (about 3 times higher). This is explained by the fact that the uninsured (that 10% who chose not to purchase insurance) can pay cash for discounted doctor visits but this is illegal for Medicaid patients. The Medicaid patients cannot get into doctors’ offices so they resort to using emergency rooms for primary care.

 

Government-run healthcare does not increase access to healthcare unless it can provide quality treatment without undue delay. In the Oregon study, access to healthcare was better without insurance! So access to healthcare has not improvedby Medicaid expansion. Will Medicare for All be any better?

(More on this topic next post in Part II of this series.)

Note: Future posts will now be weekly.

DNA Testing or Not?

 

Is DNA testing a good or a bad idea?

Recent advances in DNA testing have made the cost reasonable for everyday people. As a result, many people may have received such a gift for Christmas, or at least are considering the test on their own.

AncestryDNA and 23andMe are the two most widely used commercial products for DNA testing to research your ancestry. A simple saliva swab makes these tests simple and painless. But are there drawbacks to digging into your family heritage?

Paul Hsieh, writing for Forbes, says there are issues to consider. Sometimes background checks through DNA testing will reveal family information best left unknown. These tests can reveal marital infidelity, previously unknown parentage, secret affairs, and other unpleasant family secrets.

Furthermore, if you choose to post your genealogy information on public websites, you may compromise the privacy of others who have never even been tested.

Hsieh gives an example of a man we’ll call “George Doe” who gave 23and Mekits to his parents and himself. He and his sister learned they had an unknown half-brother who shared the same father but was given up for adoption at birth. The result of this new information was his parents divorced and the family isn’t talking to his father. “George” would have never done this if he knew what trouble it would cause.

As Doe told the staff at 23andMe: “I’m not sure all your customers realize that when they participate in your family finder program, they’re participating in what are essentially really advanced paternity tests.”

When Catherine St. Clair took her test from AncestryDNA, she learned that the man she knew all her life as her father was not actually her biological father. Similarly, her siblings were actually half-siblings. It rocked her world.  She said, “I looked into a mirror and started crying. I’ve taken for granted my whole life that what I was looking at in the mirror was part my mother and part my dad. And now that half of that person I was looking at in the mirror, I didn’t know who that was.”

Both companies warn customers of such dangers in the fine print but most people never bother to read the warnings.

Another risk concerns privacy violations. Investigators have learned they can use DNA testing to find individuals they are investigating. Even though you may not personally be tested, if enough of your relatives are tested and they submit the results to a public genealogy data base such as GEDMatch, you may find your privacy violated.

This methodology was used to find the suspected Golden State Killer, James DeAngelo, who is charged with 13 counts of murder and 13 counts of attempted kidnapping. Since DeAngelo was caught last April, 13 other suspected criminals have been identified in the same way.

There are benefits to DNA testing that go beyond your curiosity about your genealogy. Adoptees have been able to find biological parents and siblings, while others have found remote cousins that enrich their family experience. But the old saying certainly applies, “Let the buyer beware.”