Do Adults Need the Measles Vaccine?

 

Recent outbreaks of measles have raised the alarm again about measles vaccinations. More than 760 cases of measles have been reported in 23 states, including two in my home state of Florida. This is the highest number of cases recorded in the United States in the past 25 years.

The reason for this increase in measles cases is no mystery. Measles vaccinations have declined in recent years due to widespread false reports that measles vaccine can cause autism.

This hysteria over the safety of the vaccine was started by a British doctor, Andrew Wakefield, who published an article in the respected medical journal, The Lancet, in which he claimed an association between autism and the measles vaccine. Although Wakefield’s research has since been widely discredited, the myth he spawned continues to impact vaccination rates largely because of social media promotion of the myth.

This problem is not unique to the United States. Rising cases of measles in Europe, especially Romania, are sounding alarms.

Pietro Lombardi, writing for The Wall Street Journal, says Romania is fighting a deadly measles outbreak that has seen more than 15,000 people infected with the disease and that has claimed 59 lives since one of Europe’s most lethal measles outbreaks in decades started in 2016. More than 41,000 people were infected with measles in the first half of this year in the wider European region, compared with roughly 24,000 for all of 2017, according to the World Health Organization (WHO).

The problem, once again, is skepticism about vaccine safety. Despite consistent medical evidence that these vaccines are safe, ignorance and misinformation continues to plague attempts to improve rates of vaccination.

Concern has now spread to even adults who worry they could get measles, too. The risk for adults depends on your age and exposure to measles in the past. Any adult who has had measles previously is at virtually no risk of ever contracting measles again. Those who never had measles but were vaccinated in 1969, the first year of the vaccine, probably should consider getting a booster vaccination because the original was less effective.

If you’re unsure of your vaccination history or about prior measles infection as a child, the simple answer is to be vaccinated. If you’re already immune, the additional vaccination won’t hurt you. If you’re not, you’ll be protecting yourself from the disease. If this is your first vaccination, a second shot is recommended to increase your protection from about 95% with one to 100% with two.

Measles is not an innocuous disease. Before 1963, when the measles vaccine became available in the U. S., there were more than 500,000 reported measles cases every year, according to the CDC. On average, 432 cases a year resulted in death. By the year 2000 the number of cases had dwindled to 86 and the number of deaths in the U.S. to zero.

But recent outbreaks in Europe mentioned above prove the virus has not lost its deadly potential. Parents should be aware that the risk of serious neurological disease following vaccination is one in 365,000 doses – but the risk of death with the disease is one or two in just 1,000. Adults who have never had the disease nor the vaccination should be vaccinated as soon as possible.

The Canadian Medicare for All Experience

 

The Bernie Sanders’ push for Medicare for All is gaining some steam as his presidential campaign ratchets up the rhetoric.

In a recent Fox News town hall appearance, Sanders said, “What we are talking about is simply a single-payer insurance program, which means that you will have a card which says Medicare on it, you go to any doctor that you want, you will go to any hospital that you want. You’re not paying any more premiums, you’re not paying any more copayments, you’re not paying any more deductibles.” He went on to say the plan, “would allow all Americans, regardless of their income, to get the healthcare they need when they need it.”

How do these statements by Sanders compare with the real world? The best comparison to his Medicare for All system is our northern neighbor, Canada. What has been their experience?

Regina E. Herzlinger and Bacchus Barua, discussed the answer to this question in a recent Op-ed for The Wall Street Journal. Herzlinger is a professor at Harvard Business School and Barua is associate director of the Canadian Fraser Institute’s Centre for Health Policy Studies.

They say the Canadian model follows Sanders’ Medicare for All single-payer plan but “is not the best way to achieve the goal of access to timely care.” Like the Sanders plan, it is universal, taxpayer funded without deductibles or copays, and excludes premiums for most users. But objective measures of performance show it’s a comparatively expensive system whose results are mediocre at best – and sometimes very poor.

A Fraser Institute study published in November, 2018, examined 28 universal healthcare systems across 45 indictors of performance. Canada’s system ranked among the top spenders – fourth highest as percentage of GDP and 10thhighest per capita. Yet it had less medical resources available for patients and painfully long wait times for specialists (emphasis mine).

Canada ranked:

  • 26thout of 28 for number of physicians
  • 22ndout of 27 for MRI units
  • 25thout of 26 for hospital beds
  • 11thout of 11 for waiting times greater than 4 weeks

Canada performed well on only five of the 12 indicators of clinical performance and quality included in the Fraser Institute’s study. Its performance on the other seven was poor or average.

Why these dismal results for Canada in comparison to systems in Europe? Unlike Canada’s single-payer system, the Swiss, Dutch and German systems rely on private insurers, whether nonprofit or for-profit. The Sanders Medicare for All system would eliminate private health insurers.

Unlike the U.S., with Medicare and its massive trillion-dollar unfunded liabilities, these countries cannot pass unreimbursed current expenses onto future generations. If the expenses of private insurers exceed their revenues, they face bankruptcy. There is also an advantage to private vendors who can access private capital to fund medical innovations – unlike government-run systems, which need bureaucratic approval to use tax revenues.

The Canadian experience is a lesson American voters should be learning. Medicare for All will not produce the utopian healthcare system of Senator Sanders’ rhetoric. His healthcare promises are no better than President Obama’s who famously said, “If you like your doctor, you can keep your doctor.” The American people should not be fooled again.

Middle Class Healthcare

 

The quality of your healthcare depends on your economic class. That’s a sad truth but reality. But it isn’t unique to America.

Progressives that support socialized medicine think that system eliminates this problem. They believe socialized medicine guarantees quality healthcare regardless of economic status. But single-payer systems in Canada and the United Kingdom still offer two levels of healthcare; one for the rich and another for everyone else.

The problem of poor access to healthcare for the poor is so well known in Britain that the press refers to the NHS as a “postcode lottery”. They mean a person’s chances for timely, high-quality treatment depends on the neighborhood or “postcode” in which he or she lives. The Guardian sums up the situation with this statement, “Generally speaking, the poorer you are and the more socially deprived your area, the worse your care and access is likely to be.”

In our country we have three levels of healthcare; the poor, the rich, and the middle class. Which one is getting the worst deal?

The Poor

Let’s look at the poor first. ObamaCare failed to achieve many of its promises but it did increase the number of people with healthcare insurance by about 20 million. Most of these people are on the expanded rolls of Medicaid and the rest are receiving private healthcare insurance they purchase on the ObamaCare exchanges at low, heavily-subsidized prices. You could say that all of these 20 million have benefited from ObamaCare. These people are all poor by definition because they are eligible for Medicaid or ObamaCare exchange subsidies.

 

The Rich

The rich will always be able to purchase the healthcare they need, regardless of the system. ObamaCare has not really affected them; most of them have employer-provided healthcare insurance, Medicare, or top-quality private insurance they can easily afford to purchase. They can travel to the best hospitals and doctors anywhere in the world for their healthcare. This is true in our country and in every other country, regardless of their healthcare system.

 

The Middle Class

The middle class is most affected by ObamaCare. The middle class makes too much money to qualify for ObamaCare exchange subsidies or Medicaid, but not enough to afford high-priced healthcare insurance premiums and deductibles. They must pay the full price of inflated premiums driven up by ObamaCare mandates and regulations. They bear the full burden of a system designed to make the young and healthy pay for the old and sick.

They can no longer customize their healthcare coverage for their specific needs due to ObamaCare regulations. The result is that many of these people have chosen to go without healthcare insurance because the premiums and deductibles are just too high for their budgets. ObamaCare has taken away their healthcare.

The irony of this situation is that the Democrats who designed and passed ObamaCare don’t understand its impact on the middle class. Recently, the Trump administration announced plans to replace ObamaCare with a better plan. In response, Senate Minority Leader, Chuck Schumer (D – NY) said, “Well, I say, ‘God help the middle class.’ What, dare I ask, is their plan?”

Clearly, Senator Schumer has no idea how badly his plan has treated the middle class. Anything Republicans propose would be an improvement over ObamaCare for the middle class.