Biden’s Public Option Paid by the Middle Class

 

Joe Biden wants the middle class think they’re safe from his tax hikes. Although he admits he plans to raise taxes over $4 Trillion, he promises only those earning above $400,000 need worry.

Lanhee J. Chen and Daniel L Heil, writing in The Wall Street Journal, warn the middle class this promise can’t be kept if the Public Option is added to ObamaCare. The Public Option is a government-offered alternative to healthcare insurance for those who don’t qualify for Medicaid, but can’t afford private insurance.

This is a subtle, but effective, means to a long-term goal of complete government take-over of healthcare. Rather than announce an immediate plan for socialized medicine, like the Medicare for All plan of Senator Bernie Sanders, Biden wants you to believe this is just another option for low-income Americans. He doesn’t want the 180 million Americans on private health insurance to worry.

But a Public Option plan will eventually eliminate all other competition in the marketplace. The reason is simple: the Public Option plan can lose money and still be viable because the government will simply pick up the losses by raising your taxes. (see Public Option Kills Private Insurance.)

How much will the Public Option raise your taxes?

Now we have an answer to that question. Chen and Heil tell us:

“With our co-author Tom Church, we estimate that a politically realistic public option would increase 10-year federal deficits by almost $800 billion. Over the long term, it would become the third-largest government program – accounting for one-eighth of future spending excluding interest on the debt. Keeping a public option deficit-neutral would likely require a broad-based tax increase that would add thousands of dollars to a typical middle-income family’s tax bill. Without the tax hike, the public option alone would increase the federal debt by more than 30% of gross domestic product by 2050.”

They point out such an increase in the federal debt couldn’t come at a worse time. The federal debt has risen above 100% of GDP 10 years sooner than expected, due to the viral pandemic, and the Congressional Budget Office now projects debt to reach 195% by 2050. The higher debt will mean fewer economic opportunities for future generations as more tax dollars must be used to pay the debt rather than provide taxpayer services. All this while another Covid relief package is currently under debate in the Congress.

Chen and Heil estimate that Congress would need an across-the-board tax increase of 10.4% beginning in 2026 to return long-term debt projections to CBO’s 2019 forecast. This tax increase would apply to all corporate, payroll and personal income-tax rates, and it would come on top of the scheduled tax increases from the expiration of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017.

As usual, Biden claims that tax hikes on the rich will be sufficient to pay for his new programs. But the math just doesn’t add up. Again, Chen and Heil:

“Even before accounting for his other spending proposals – such as increasing ObamaCare subsidies – a public option would require record high tax increases on corporations or high-income taxpayers. We estimate that to pay for the public option, corporate tax rates would have to rise from 21% today to 58% over the next 30 years. Alternatively, Congress could raise the top three marginal tax rates. But between financing the public option and keeping debt below 150% of GDP, the top rate would eventually exceed 60% – higher than at any point in the past 40 years. . . Taxes for the typical middle-income family would rise by an inflation-adjusted $3,900 to pay for the public option and keep debt below 150% of GDP in 2050.”

One of the first things we learn as adults is “there’s no such thing as a free lunch.” You can be sure everyone’s taxes will be higher under a Biden presidency – and you’ll lose your private health insurance eventually as well.

Biden’s Covid Plan is Trump’s Plan

 

(This post was first posted on 8/31/20.)

(Note: In these last few days before the presidential election, I am reposting earlier posts that concern key issues in the election. In Biden television ads he claims he would have done a better job of protecting the country from Covid. But when the Biden plan was released in August, analysts pointed out the Biden plan is exactly what Trump did!)

 

The long-awaited plan of Joe Biden to solve our Covid-19 pandemic is finally over. In his acceptance speech for the Democratic presidential nomination he revealed his plan – it’s what Trump is already doing!

Despite months of criticism of Trump’s handling of the virus by Biden and every other Democratic leader, they couldn’t come up with anything better. The Wall Street Journal editorial board says, “The Democratic nominee is also promising a better virus strategy, which would be wonderful if he had one. But the virus plan he’s pushing is little different on the substance than what the Trump Administration is already doing.”

Let’s look at each step in the Biden Covid-19 plan:

  • Virus Testing – Biden promises to “develop and deploy rapid tests with results available immediately.” The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the past week has approved two new rapid tests that can be scaled up quickly. After an initial delay in testing caused by errors at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and FDA, supply-chain delays have been worked out. The U.S. is now conducting 700,000 tests or more per day, up from 400,000 in early June and 100,000 in late March. The cheap saliva tests developed by Yale researchers will avoid chemical reagent shortages and can cost as little as $10.

 

  • More PPE, Test kits, and Lab supplies – Biden is calling for “a coordinated, country-wide, future-facing national effort to acquire, produce, and distribute PPE, test kits, and machines, lab supplies, and other critical supplies, including by fully utilizing the authorities” under the Defense Production Act. The Trump Administration is already doing all of this. In the hospital and surgery center where I work, there has never been a shortage of these supplies.

 

The Trump administration has effectively used public-private partnerships to rally the “arsenal of democracy” (the private sector) to produce the needed supplies for this pandemic. The Pentagon this spring issued $259 million in contracts to 3M, Honeywell, and Owens & Minor to produce tens of millions of N95 face masks for medical workers. U.S. companies like GM and New Balance have retrofitted plants to produce ventilators and PPE, and the Administration has used the Defense Production Act to allocate more tests and protective equipment to hot spots.

 

  • Hire Federal Contact Workers – Biden has called for hiring 100,000 federal workers to track down contacts of people who get sick. States are already doing this, though public health officials say contact tracing is of little use when the virus is widespread in communities. California tried this approach this summer, training 10,000 contact tracers. But the Sacramento Bee last month reported most never were assigned work for inexplicable reasons.

 

  • Increase vaccine production – Biden promises to “ramp up the large-scale manufacturing of as many vaccine candidates as necessary.” I guess he hasn’t been listening to the news from his Delaware basement. The Trump Administration and private industry are already on that. (Vaccine Progress Due to Planning)

 

Health and Human Services this spring issued a $628 million contract to Emergent BioSolutions, a private firm, to coordinate with vaccine developers ramping up manufacturing capacity. The Administration has contracted with Johnson & Johnson, Pfizer, BioNTech, Moderna, and AstraZeneca for hundreds of millions of dosages as soon as their vaccines are proven safe and effective in trials. Pfizer and BioNTeach recently announced their vaccine is on track to seek regulatory approval as early as October.

The National Institutes of Health (NIH) is also funding promising treatments. Last month the Trump Administration signed a contract with Regeneron to manufacture 300,000 doses of its antibody cocktail by the end of the summer. On the other hand, Biden has proposed price controls and threats of prosecution of health-care executives. These measures would surely dampen the incentive to develop therapies and vaccines as soon as possible.

 

  • Money for Schools to Reopen – Biden says he’ll give schools “the resources they need to be open, safe, and effective.” President Trump has said the same thing – if they reopen. Biden’s support for teachers unions threatens the ability of schools to reopen regardless of the federal financial support.

 

  • National Mask Mandate – Biden also says he’ll impose a national mask mandate. Trump has encouraged masks in public, but left the decision up to the state governors. The Constitution doesn’t give the federal government the authority to mandate masks on a national level. That authority is left to the states.

 

There you have it, the Biden plan revealed. If you were looking for something exciting and different, you will be very disappointed. The Trump Administration is already way ahead of Biden and has implemented everything in his plan – except a national mask mandate. I guess Uncle Joe isn’t familiar with the Constitution.

 

Epidemiologists Reject Political Correctness

 

It takes a lot of courage to be politically incorrect. That’s especially true in this era of the Covid-19 pandemic. Fortunately, there are some individuals willing to take the heat.

Two of those are Jay Bhattacharya and Martin Kulldorff.  Dr. Bhattacharya is a physician and economist at Stanford Medical School and Mr. Kulldorff is a biostatistician at Harvard Medical School. They both study epidemiology at these highly respected medical institutions. Though they work thousands of miles apart, they have come to regard each other so closely they believe they could complete each other’s sentences.

They come from widely different backgrounds. Bhattacharya is from Kolkata, India, while Kulldorff is from Umea, Sweden. What brings them together is their agreement on the best means of handling this Covid-19 pandemic. They are the authors, along with Sunetra Gupta, a professor of epidemiology at Oxford, of the Great Barrington Declaration.

Tunku Varadarajan interviewed them for The Wall Street Journal. Big Tech has tried to censor this information by burying it in any Google search, much like Facebook and Twitter have done with the Hunter Biden laptop story. Hopefully you can read this interview yourself, but this post will give you a preview of their important work.

The Great Barrington Declaration is described as a “cri de coeur against lockdowns and other economic restrictions that have hobbled swaths of the world. It asks instead for “focused protection” – a policy of allowing “those at minimal risk of death” to resume their lives while societies concentrate on “better protecting those who are at highest risk.”

“The politicization of Covid,” Mr. Kulldorff says, “is extremely unfortunate. People automatically assume what your political beliefs are based on your views on the pandemic. This is very strange, in my mind.” Dr. Bhattacharya adds that “the traditional markers for political identity have absolutely no meaning” in the context of Covid. While Bhattacharya admits he leans center-right, Kulldorff refuses to characterize his politics, but Bhattacharya reveals Covid has taught him that he shares values “with people with very, very different political stripes than me. Martin is certainly a great example of this, probably the prime example.”

But when it comes to “current Covid policy”, the two are united. Bhattacharya describes this policy “violates every single value I hold dear, every single one.” He describes these values as “the protection of the vulnerable and the poor world-wide from avoidable death and suffering.” He says “the lockdowns have manifestly failed to do this by inducing economic collapse that has placed the lives of 130 million poor people world-wide at risk of starvation.”

He also cites “the norms of medical ethics that militate against doing harm to patients.” He states the current lockdown policy asks children and young adults – “who face more medical and psychological risk from the lockdowns than they do from Covid infection” – to accept this harm “in the false hope that this sacrifice will protect the vulnerable people.”

Mr. Kulldorff describes lockdowns as “the worst assault on the working class in half a century – the worst assault since segregation and the Vietnam War.” He says “present policies are protecting very low risk professionals – attorneys, bankers, journalists, scientists, because basically we can work from home.” In contrast to privileged professionals, Mr. Kulldorff says, the blue-collar class is “out there working, including high-risk people in their 60s. So the working class is building up the population immunity that will eventually protect all of us.” This explains why minority populations have had higher mortality in the U.S. from the epidemic because they don’t often have the option to stay at home.

Mr. Kulldorff says the Covid-19 restrictions violate two cardinal principles of public health:

  • First – “You can’t just look at Covid, you have to look holistically at health and consider the collateral damage.”This damage includes a worsening incidence of cardiovascular disease and cancer and an alarming decline in immunization. People have been avoiding regular doctor visits that normally would treat these conditions. In India, Bhattacharya says tuberculosis programs have been suspended and malaria eradication programs elsewhere.
  • Second – “You can’t just look short-term.” The health harms from these lockdowns will be counted for a very long time. These lockdowns are sewing the seeds of other epidemics: Dr. Bhattacharya says, “Pertussis – whooping cough – will come back. Polio will come back because of the cessation of vaccination campaigns. All these diseases that we’ve made substantial progress in will start to come back.”

 

Both men say their declaration is nothing really new – it’s just a call to return to traditional public health practices. They say the declaration also reflects “the norms of open scientific discourse, which have been violated by proponents of the Covid lockdowns in the name of protecting the public from ‘dangerous ideas.’”

This leads to a discussion of the term “herd immunity”, which Kulldorff calls “the most misunderstood term of 2020.” He says the term can invite “accusations of mass murder” by those who are misusing it. He defines it as “the end state of any epidemic where some immunity actually happens after infection. It’s a biological fact. It’s not something nefarious or strange.” It is not a strategy, as some in the media have suggested and criticized. It is the inevitable end-stage of any pandemic regardless of how it is treated.

Dr. Bhattacharya prefers the term “population immunity”  because he believes it better conveys that herd immunity is a basic scientific principle, from which flows the one important question epidemiologists and policy makers need to consider: “How do we get to that end state with the least amount of devastation, the least amount of human misery, the least amount of death?”

In the recent Presidential Debate, Trump favored ending lockdowns and re-opening as much as possible. Biden favored more lockdowns if the scientists he listens to recommend them. Now that you’ve heard what these scientists have to say, whose opinion do you believe is best?