Access to Healthcare is the Problem – Not Insurance Coverage

(This post was originally posted 11/20/17)

(Author’s note: As we enter the last few weeks of the presidential campaign, there are several campaign issues which have been previously addressed in this blog. These include Medicare for All, single-payer healthcare, socialism, school choice and others. In the next few weeks I will be re-posting many of my previous posts on these issues as a review for voters. For this limited time I will be posting five days a week instead of the usual twice a week. These earlier posts will be intermingled with new posts on current topics.)

 

The American healthcare system is focusing on the wrong problem. Instead of worrying about the impact new legislation will have on health insurance coverage, we should be worrying about providing better access to healthcare treatment.

If you’re wandering alone in a desert looking for water, it will do you no good to discover a Groupon coupon for a free case of bottled water. You can’t drink the coupon and the coupon is worthless unless you can find the water.

That’s why as a doctor I have become increasingly frustrated with the healthcare proposals coming out of Washington. Let me give you a few examples:

Medicaid

Medicaid is essentially free healthcare for those who are eligible. But to carry the analogy further, Medicaid is like having the Groupon coupon for free water in the desert. You may have a Medicaid card that guarantees you free healthcare, but it’s worthless unless you can actually get healthcare treatment.

Medicaid patients have very poor access to healthcare because the reimbursements to providers are so low that few will accept them as patients. Even those who do accept Medicaid usually have very limited numbers of appointments reserved for Medicaid patients. That means long waiting times to receive appointments and therefore to receive healthcare.

This forces Medicaid patients to go to the emergency rooms 40% more often than even the uninsured according to the Oregon Healthcare Experiment study of 2007. This poor access to healthcare is the major reason that Medicaid healthcare outcomes are no better than those without insurance (according to the same study) and worse than those with private insurance in nearly every other study.

VA Healthcare

In 2014 it was revealed that many veterans were actually dying while waiting to see the doctor at VA Hospitals. Long waiting times for appointments due to the inefficiencies and incompetence of the VA system were costing many veterans their lives. Those who served in our military in defense of our country were being neglected because they had poor access to healthcare.

This problem was identified in the Phoenix VA Hospital but was later found in many other VA hospitals around the country. The VA system is a socialized medicine model and like all socialized medicine systems in the world, it rations care by delaying treatment. Rationing is controlled by limiting access to treatment.

ObamaCare

Proponents of the Affordable Care Act (ObamaCare) proudly point to increased coverage of Americans by this healthcare legislation. About 20 million more Americans have coverage since the 2010 passage of this Act.

But about 15 million of those have new Medicaid coverage. However, as discussed above, these newly covered Americans still have an access problem. The other 5 million mostly have ObamaCare exchange policies because large government subsidies have made their premiums affordable.

However, they still have an access problem. They may be able to get in the door of the doctor’s office, and even get an examination, but high deductibles often make it difficult if not impossible for them to get the treatment they need. As a surgeon I know that many of these patients can’t afford the deductibles they need to pay in order to receive the surgery necessary to treat their problem.

(Next post: the solution)

Trump’s Covid-19 Therapy Showcases Great Progress

 

President Trump is back on the campaign trail and all Americans should be happy. Even Democrats should be encouraged to see the incredible progress American medicine has made in treating this new coronavirus.

Despite a fever and at least two blood oxygen levels that dropped to 93%, the president has made a remarkable recovery. As I write this post, he’s already campaigned in at least three states and is showing no signs of after-effects from the virus or his treatment. Certainly, the president of the U.S. is going to receive the best medical care possible, but most of the treatment he received is available to all Americans if needed.

What treatment did the president receive?

President Trump received eight different drugs in his Covid-19 treatment:

  1. Dexamethasone – This is a steroid in common use for many years that is most often used to treat asthma, rheumatoid and other inflammatory forms of arthritis and certain cancers. The president received this drug in response to his blood oxygen levels dropping twice to 93%, according to Becker Hospital Review, to control inflammation in his lungs. A study released in June showed that dexamethasone reduced deaths by one-third for those who had been sick for more than a week and were on mechanical ventilators, but had no impact on patients receiving no respiratory support. The drug is typically given to patients with severe Covid-19 to prevent an immune system overreaction known as a “cytokine storm.” President Trump was briefly given oxygen support but was never on a ventilator.
  2. Remdesivir – President Trump received his first dose of remdesivir on his second day of treatment and received a five-day course. Remdesivir received emergency use authorization (EUA) by the FDA on May 1 after a study showed it caused a 31% faster recovery time compared to placebo. Remdesivir works by targeting the system coronaviruses use to replicate themselves – it blocks viral replication. It has been previously tested for Ebola, but hasn’t been officially approved for routine use. The FDA expanded its EUA to authorize its use on all hospitalized patients. It had previously been authorized for those on ventilators or with low blood oxygen levels.
  3. Regeneron’s monoclonal antibody – The president received a single 8-gram dose of Regeneron’s monoclonal antibody cocktail, called REGN-COV2, the highest does of the drug being tested in late-stage clinical trials, according to Regeneron states a high dose of the drug causes the level of the virus to decrease in patients in an early clinical trial, indicating it may help Covid-19 patients recover faster. The trail seemed to show the drug had a bigger effect on patients who were infected with the virus but hadn’t created high levels of their own antibodies against the virus. The drug uses synthetic versions of the antibodies patients’ bodies create when they recover from a disease. In July, Regeneron received $450 million from President Trump’s Operation Warp Speed, the White House task force to expedite Covid-19 vaccine development, to manufacture thousands of doses of the drug.
  4. Zinc – President Trump was placed on zinc, which helps the immune system fight outside bacteria and viruses. It has been used for many years to reduce the duration and severity of common cold virus illness. Zinc is an essential mineral that is naturally present in some foods and is available as a dietary supplement. At this time there is no proven evidence that zinc helps fight Covid-19, but it has been used widely in combination with other drugs to treat this virus.
  5. Vitamin D – President Trump was given supplements of Vitamin D, which is good for bone health. There is no evidence that vitamin D directly reduces the risk of Covid-19, and the FDA has issued warnings to companies who promote this as a Covide-19 treatment. However, Vitamin D does also help reduce inflammation, according to the National Institutes of Health (NIH).
  6. Famotidene (Pepcid) – This commonly available OTC medication is used to treat stomach ulcers, heartburn, and indigestion. It lowers the amount of acid in the stomach. A clinical trial testing the drug in hospitalized Covid-19 patients in New York wasn’t able to recruit enough patients to properly evaluate its impact, according to
  7. Melatonin – This drug is also available OTC and is commonly used to treat insomnia. Some studies have suggested that melatonin could also help Covid-19 patients with diabetes and obesity, according to The president is not a diabetic but is mildly obese. “The ability of melatonin to decrease viral infections in obese and diabetic patients is attributed to its characteristics, such as patent antioxidant effects, improving the endogenous antioxidant system, immunomodulatory, and the strong anti-inflammatory capability,” according to researchers from Mansoura University in Egypt.
  8. Aspirin – This common OTC medication is often used by older patients to prevent heart disease and strokes by reducing the risk of blood-clotting. The president has mild heart disease according to the New York Times.

 

There you have it – the whole therapeutic regimen that has enabled President Trump to return to full duties less than two weeks after he was first diagnosed with Covid-19. He received multiple negative virus tests in the days just before his doctors released him to resume full activities.

This is a testimonial to the incredible progress American medicine has made in less than a year since this new virus was released into the world, causing such devastation from the pandemic. We can all be thankful the president has recovered quickly, and we can all be greatly encouraged that effective treatment is now available for most who contract the virus. This should significantly lower the mortality of this dread disease until effective vaccines are available in the coming months.

A Tragic Lesson About Socialism

(This post was originally posted 9/10/18)

(Author’s note: As we enter the last few weeks of the presidential campaign, there are several campaign issues which have been previously addressed in this blog. These include Medicare for All, single-payer healthcare, socialism, school choice and others. In the next few weeks I will be re-posting many of my previous posts on these issues as a review for voters. For this limited time I will be posting five days a week instead of the usual twice a week. These earlier posts will be intermingled with new posts on current topics.)

 

For most people with any gray hairs it is a given that socialism is evil. The lessons of the failed governments of Cuba and the Soviet Union are still fresh in our memories.

But for many young people socialism has become the “latest thing.” Recent polls suggest as many as 43% of Americans favor socialism over capitalism – and most of these are young people. Unfortunately, they are being led down this destructive path by an elder statesman, Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, and his young acolyte, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Democratic Congressional candidate from New York.

The evils of socialism are being demonstrated in dramatic fashion not far from our southern border in Venezuela. Venezuela is a tragic example how socialism has brought economic disaster and resultant famine and hyperinflation upon a nation with the world’s richest oil reserves!

This dramatic real-world tragedy is playing out in Venezuela while American socialists talk of utopian dreams with their heads firmly planted in the sand. The real story is told by Daniel Pipes, president of the Middle East Forum, in a article published in The Wall Street Journal.

Pipes gives us the background needed to understand just how bad socialism can be. Venezuela discovered vast oil reserves in 1914 that brought the country vast revenues and produced a relatively free economy. By 1950 Venezuela enjoyed the fourth highest per capita income in the world, behind only the U.S., Switzerland, and New Zealand. As late as 1980, it boasted the world’s fastest growing economy in the 20th century.

However, beginning in 1958, government interference in the economy, including price and exchange controls, higher taxes, and restrictions on property rights, led to decades of stagnation. Per capita real income declined0.13% from 1960-1997, despite their strong oil production.

A Tragic Decline

Pipes tells us the reality of Venezuela today:

“Today the country with the world’s largest oil reserves suffers from a severely contracting economy, runaway inflation, despotism, mass emigration, criminality, disease, hunger and starvation, with circumstances deteriorating daily. Venezuela’s economy contracted by 16% in 2016, 14% last year and a predicted 15% in 2018. Inflation was at 112% in 2015 and 2,800% at the end of last year. Economist Steve Hanke finds an annualized rate of around 65,000% for 2018, making Venezuela’s one of the most severe hyperinflations ever. Food shortages led to an average weight loss among Venezuelans of 18 pounds in 2016 and 24 pounds in 2017.”

What caused this crisis?

Socialism. Hugo Chavez convinced Venezuelans to try it in 1999, then stole, dominated, polarized and jailed anyone who disagreed. With about a $1 trillion in oil sales during his 14 years as president, he had the means to launch massive social spending programs to secure votes to strengthen his control. Then he replaced oil professionals with his agents, stooges, and sycophants further consolidating control.

As former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher once said, “The trouble with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people’s money.”

Hugo Chavez didn’t reach that situation because he died in 2013, about a year before oil prices tumbled, when he sought cancer treatment in Cuba and was “assassinated by Cuban malpractice” according to Fox News reports. However, his successor, Nicolas Maduro, has proven even more brutal and incompetent. The result of Maduro’s handling of the economy is the disaster chronicled above.

The lesson of the evils of socialism could not be clearer for the world today. It is the job of our national media, and all clear-thinking Americans, to educate people to the tragedy playing out not far from our southern beaches. It’s time our young people stopped listening to the sirens of socialism and got in touch with reality.