Medical Practice Evolution

I entered medical school in 1975. A lot has changed in the world since then, especially in the field of medicine.

We have technology today that was unthinkable in 1975.  Most surgery today is done through small incisions through the use of endoscopic equipment that allows surgeons to see inside the body through sophisticated cameras rather than through direct visualization. This has greatly shortened healing times for all kinds of surgery.

We have diagnostic equipment unheard of in 1975 – especially magnetic resonance imaging (MRI scanners) that make it possible for us to detect pathology much earlier and more accurately than we ever dreamed of before. Every field of medicine has improved in its ability to diagnose and treat disease.

What hasn’t improved, however, is the practice environment for physicians. I’m talking about the place where they go to work and their autonomy in making decisions about their patients. That has gotten worse.

When I began my orthopedic practice in 1984, about 3 of 4 physicians were in private practice. The rest were employees of hospitals or corporations, particularly in the specialties of radiology, pathology, anesthesiology and emergency medicine. Today those numbers have reversed – about 3 of 4 physicians are now working for hospitals or corporate entities.

Jared Dashevsky, writing for Workweek, says the percentage of hospital or corporate-employed physicians has increased 19% over the last three years, from 62% to 74%. This has likely been impacted by the Covid-19 pandemic, which placed great pressures on those in private practice. What’s particularly interesting is the difference between hospital and corporate entity acquisitions:

  • Hospitals acquired 4,800 physician practices since January 2019, a 9% increase.
  • Corporate entities, like PE firms or health insurers, acquired 31,300 physician practices since 2019, an 86% increase.

 

What is driving this change?

Pandemic pressures and the current labor and supply shortages have stressed physician practices both financially and mentally. Physician burnout has become a big problem with more and more physicians retiring early or finding alternative working environments. An acquisition is a quick and lucrative way for physicians to shift the responsibility of running a practice to someone else. These benefits include:

  • Financial risk protection
  • Less administrative burdens
  • Electronic Health Records (EHR) implementation
  • More routine scheduling

 

These benefits have driven many physicians into the arms of hospitals or corporate entities. However, there is a downside to these changes:

  • Decreased income
  • Decreased autonomy in decision-making
  • Profit-driven motives of their employers
  • Decreased flexibility of hours

 

Dr. Dashevsky believes the pendulum that has shifted from private practice to hospital/corporate practice will someday shift back. As physicians crave the autonomy they once had, or want to experience it for the first time, change is likely. Personally, I hope it does. There is nothing quite like knowing there is no one getting between your patient and you when it comes to deciding what’s best for your patient. That feeling is being lost, and the sooner it returns, the better for all patients.

Medicare for All Not Dead

 

We haven’t heard much about Medicare for All recently, but it is far from dead. If you’ve forgotten, Medicare for All is the socialized medicine plan of Senator Bernie Sanders. Sanders pushed his plan hard during the presidential campaign of 2020, but even the Democratic Party couldn’t stomach it so they made sure Joe Biden won the party’s nomination. They knew Sanders’ plan would never be accepted in the general election.

Since then, we haven’t heard much more about Medicare for All. The Covid pandemic changed the subject and demonstrated once again why the government should not be in charge of your healthcare. The tsunami of misinformation about Covid treatment driven by political agendas shows us what happens when the government gets between you and your doctor.

But lest you think Senator Sanders has given up on his plan, think again. Recently he held a Senate Budget Committee hearing on the subject of Medicare for All – again. Grace-Marie Turner, writing for The Galen Institute, says she and Professor Charles Blahous of George Mason University’s Mercatus Center were called as witnesses by Republicans on the committee.

Turner says, “The divisiveness on this issue is so clear it’s hard to find any center ground. That’s largely because the passion for Medicare for All is so detached from reality: The Left insists nurses and doctors would spend almost all their time on patient care, not forms and paperwork. Administrative costs would virtually vanish by shutting down insurance companies and other private players. Health costs would plummet while life expectancy would dramatically increase as everyone has access to all the care they need any time.”

I have highlighted this last line since it clearly shows how divorced from reality these advocates for socialized medicine really are. The truth about socialized medicine is well-known to anyone who objectively studies the subject. In every nation where socialized medicine has been implemented, including Canada, Great Britain, Sweden, Cuba and others, three things have been consistently found:

  • Reduced access to healthcare
  • Rationing of healthcare
  • Reduced quality of healthcare

 

It’s really quite simple. When the government is allowed to dictate who receives healthcare and how much treatment they receive, they cut costs by rationing access and eligibility for treatments. The inevitable result is reduced quality of healthcare. I have written extensively on this subject in the past and I refer you to my blog search box where you can find much more information by simply entering the words “Medicare for All.”

Turner tells us the Republican committee members asked pertinent questions. Senator Lindsey Graham (R-SC) asked, “If the U.S. system is so horrible, why are so many people coming to America?” “Why aren’t we leaving to go to someplace else where you don’t die in the streets and where you don’t have to live under “one of the most disgusting examples of the healthcare on the planet? – as suggested by Senator Sanders.

Senator Ron Johnson (R-WI) talked about governments’ “miserable failures” in response to the Covid-19 pandemic on testing, shutdowns, school closures, restrictions on access to treatments, and more. “Why in the world would anybody put government more in charge of health care? What makes you think there would be less bureaucracy with government-run healthcare? There would be greater bureaucracy, more rules, less innovation, and higher costs.”

Senator Rick Scott (R-FL) reinforced that Medicare for All “would abolish the current Medicare program and make private insurance illegal. It would have the federal government deciding which procedures you get and when you get them. Do you want the government to makes these choices for you?” These are all good questions for which there are no good answers. Medicare for All needs to die, but Bernie won’t let it go.

Monkeypox Fears Unfounded

In 2004, Michael Crichton wrote a book called State of Fear. This fictional book had a larger-than-life message: The media want to keep us in a perpetual State of Fear. The obvious reason for this is to sell books, magazines, newspapers and television advertising. The publishing world catch-phrase that stands behind this philosophy is “If it bleeds, it leads.” In other words, fear is good for the media business.

But fear is not necessarily good for society. Truth is much better. In the interest of truth and to tamp down unwarranted fears, here are some facts about the little-known disease known as monkeypox.

Denise Roland, writing in The Wall Street Journal, gives us a good summary of monkeypox. Public-health officials say monkeypox poses little threat to the general public. Unfortunately, after the Covid pandemic experience of the last two and a half years, public health officials have lost a lot of their credibility. Nevertheless, they actually might be right this time.

The monkeypox outbreak, which was first detected in the U.K., has now led to more thn 7,000 confirmed or suspected cases across at least 40 countries including the U.S., Canada, Spain, Portugal and Australia, according to nonprofit data platform Global.health. Until recently, monkeypox was rarely found outside certain parts of West and Central Africa. In the U.S., 560 cases have been confirmed in 33 states, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

The World Health Organization (WHO) has urged countries to take measures to slow the spread of monkeypox, but doesn’t believe at this point it constitutes a global health emergency. You may be thinking this sounds a lot like their advice concerning the Covid pandemic, which initially downplayed the significance of the virus – and you would be correct! The WHO lost much of their credibility, too, during the Covid pandemic. This highlights the importance of having faith in our public health organizations.

What is monkeypox?

Monkeypox, like Covid-19, is a viral disease. It typically circulates mostly among rodents in part of West and Central Africa. It was first discovered in 1958 when two outbreaks of a pox-like disease occurred in research monkeys, thereby giving its name. The first human case was recorded in 1970 in a 9-year-old boy in the Democratic Republic of Congo. Since then, most cases have been reported from rural areas of rainforest regions of the Congo Basin, although the illness has been detected in several countries in West and Central Africa, such as Nigeria.

What are monkeypox symptoms?

Early symptoms include fever, headache, muscle aches, backache, swollen glands, chills and exhaustion. The incubation period is six to 13 days but can be longer, according to the WHO. So far, this sounds much like a case of Covid or influenza. The distinguishing characteristic is a chicken-pox-like rash that usually appears, beginning on the face then spreading to other parts of the body. Eventually the rash forms scabs and then these fall off.

In the current outbreak, doctors have described some cases in which the rash appears before a fever and others in which the rash remains concentrated in the genital area. Some patients have only developed a rash without other symptoms, according to CDC Director Rochelle Walensky.

How contagious is monkeypox?

Monkeypox is not highly contagious. Most cases in Africa came from contact with an infected animal. People are thought to be contagious only when they have the rash. It spreads from person to person through close contact, such as touching clothing, bedding or towels, the skin, or through coughs or sneezes of a person infected. Dr. Walensky says the virus can be transmitted by sexual contact but it remains unknown if it spreads through semen or vaginal fluids. It is unknown at this time if asymptomatic people with the virus can spread the disease.

Close physical contact is the main mode of transmission, but some research suggests the virus can spread short distances via respiratory droplets. It is unknown if it can spread by tinier airborne particles known as aerosols. There is currently no evidence monkeypox is spreading in the absence of close interactions with infected people. U.S. health officials have found that the monkeypox cases are concentrated in specific communities. At least 16 of the cases were people who identify as gay, bisexual or men who have sex with men, according to the CDC, though monkeypox is not currently considered a sexually transmitted disease.

How deadly is monkeypox?

Most patents recover within a few weeks, but the disease can be fatal. The West African monkeypox that is driving the current outbreak is considered a less severe type. While research suggests a fatality rate of 1%, this is far lower than the more severe Central African type, which has a fatality rate of about 10%. However, these numbers are likely much higher in Africa, where healthcare facilities are rudimentary, than in more civilized countries with better healthcare available. So far, no deaths have been reported from nonendemic countries. (outside Africa)

Is monkeypox treatable?

Most cases are treated by relieving patients’ symptoms, skin care, pain relief, and treatment of secondary bacterial infections. In severe cases, an antiviral medication that is aimed at smallpox can be used, called tecovirimat. Another smallpox treatment, called vaccinia immune globulin, can be used if needed. The U.S. keeps doses of both in a national stockpile because of the potential for smallpox outbreak as a biological weapon.

The close relationship between monkeypox and smallpox means smallpox vaccination can be protective against monkeypox. Data from Africa suggest the smallpox vaccine is at least 85% effective at preventing monkeypox., according to the CDC. Therefore, if you have been previously vaccinated for smallpox, you have little to worry about. However, since routine smallpox vaccination hasn’t occurred in the U.S. since that disease was eradicated in 1972, many Americans are vulnerable. A newer smallpox vaccine, called Jynneos, is approved by the FDA for monkeypox. The CDC is now recommending vaccination for people with presumed exposure to the viral illness. This recommendation is especially for men who have sex with men who recently had multiple sex partners in a venue where monkeypox was known to be spreading. The vaccine has also been recommended for healthcare workers in close contact with people with monkeypox.

In summary, monkeypox is a viral illness that spreads mostly through close physical contact, especially among gay men with multiple partners, though it is not considered a sexually transmitted disease. It is rarely fatal in communities with good healthcare facilities. If you have previously been vaccinated for smallpox, you probably have immunity. If not, you don’t need to be vaccinated unless you are a high-risk individual in close contact with others who may be infected.