Medicare Advantage Growing in Popularity

Everyone knows Medicare is a healthcare system for seniors. Since 1965, Medicare has been providing healthcare for Americans age 65 or older. But Medicare Advantage is a newer plan, first begun in 1985 as a limited option available only in select markets, known as “HMO risk contracting.” It evolved to a new program established in 1997 as Medicare+Choice. The name changed later to Medicare Advantage in 2003.

Healthcare economist James C. Capretta, writing for the American Enterprise Institute, says Medicare Advantage (MA) has come a long way since those early days. He gives us a review of the present state of MA using three recent reports along with data supplied by the Medicare trustees.

Medicare Advantage is Medicare managed care. Managed care enrollment in Medicare has increased at a steady pace since the option’s first introduction in the 1980’s, with particularly high growth rates over the last decade. MA plans accounted for 40.1 percent of program enrollment in 2020, up from 25.3 percent in 2011.

This trend continues, according to an analysis from The Chartis Group. MA enrollment grew from 37 percent in 2019 to 45 percent in 2022. Much of the growth in MA has been fueled by a drop in enrollment in traditional fee-for-service (FFS) Medicare with many new program enrollees choosing MA. FFS Medicare enrollees have declined by 2.6 million since 2019.

The reasons for this trend are clear. Researchers at the Kaiser Family Foundation have found 39 different MA plans, up from 19 in 2011. Nationwide, insurers are offering a total of 3,834 different MA options! The market is dominated by HMOs and PPOs, which together account for 96 percent of all the plans offered in 2022.

These multiple options offer less expensive supplemental and drug coverage than the alternative options. In 2022, 89 percent of MA plan offerings include part D prescription drug coverage (called MA-PD), and 98 percent of all Medicare beneficiaries have the option to enroll in MA-PD plans that charge no premium beyond what is required for Medicare Part B. A study by Mark Farrah Associates reports that 82 percent of all MA offerings have premiums below $50 per month.

Furthermore, all MA plans are required by regulation to include an out-of-pocket limit on annual costs for services covered by parts A and B. This limit is a major advantage of MA over FFS plans that have no catastrophic protection. To compensate, most FFS enrollees purchase Medigap policies. Most MA plans offer other coverage options, too. Kaiser reports 98 percent include eye exams and eyeglasses, 95 percent cover fitness services, and 94 percent provide dental care at some level.

What’s not to like?

Not every doctor accepting Medicare will also be available on every MA plan. Personally, I participate in some plans, but not others. Many doctors are excluded from certain plans that promise high patient volumes to those who accept lower reimbursements. Recently, a long-time patient of mine switched to an MA plan only to find out later I was not a provider on her new MA plan. Be sure your doctors are providers on a MA panel before you switch.

Mr. Capretta says there is no turning back the clock. MA plans will likely continue to grow in popularity since they have significant potential to bring innovation and efficiency to the provision of medical services to the nation’s elderly. He says the next step should be to improve the payment system so that the competition among MA plans, and between MA and FFs, is fair and delivers savings to taxpayers as well as the program’s beneficiaries.

Transparency in Career Planning

Fifty-three years ago, I went off to college with a plan to be a doctor. I had no idea how much it would cost nor how much debt I would have when I finished school. I had no idea how much money I would make, but I knew doctors made better than average income. I wasn’t worried about any of those issues; I just knew I was excited about learning how to take care of people.

Today, it’s much more complicated. Young people are worried about the amount of debt they will have when they finish college. They’re worried about the income they’ll make to pay off that debt. They’re worried about finding a job in their chosen profession. I don’t envy their situation; but at least they have better tools to make their decisions than I had.

Florida is one of several states that have passed “right-to-know” laws that provide young people information that assists them in choosing a career and a college to prepare for that career; or maybe instead of college a trade school. Last year Gov. Ron DeSantis signed the bill to make it easier for high-school students and parents to find more-affordable college paths and financially rewarding degrees.

Tarren Bragdon, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says his eldest son, a 10th-grader, is already considering whether college will help him become an entrepreneur. His daughter, a ninth-grader, has already told him she wants a “return on investment” for whatever path she picks post-graduation. He and his wife also have twin boys in seventh grade. They’re still five years away from finishing high school, but he’s already worried about the cost of possibly having four children in college at the same time!

To assist them in their planning, the State of Florida now has a web site called My Florida Future, that lets students and parents see average actual earnings for degree programs one, five, and ten years after graduation; average student loan burdens; comparisons of earnings across all 12 state universities; and other helpful information. Using this information, their son has already learned that a degree in business administration at Florida Gulf Coast University near them will pay 10% less than the same degree at Florida State University. After five years, the gap will be $7,900. But he can also see that 42% of business and marketing majors graduate with loans, and more than 20% walk away with more than $20,000 in debt. As a result of this information, he’s already considering other options, like marketing, that could help him learn sales and succeed more quickly as an entrepreneur.

For their daughter, they’ve learned that a career in fashion, which means a degree in fine arts, (who knew?) pays less than a degree in food science. In the latter program, she could be making $100,000 a year a decade after graduation, nearly twice as much as the fashion career likely will pay.

Florida is not alone in providing this information. In the past two years, 10 states have enacted such measures, and some have gone further. West Virginia, Kentucky, Arkansas and Missouri take an even broader approach than Florida to providing families with useful information about college expectations. Most will list their states’ most in-demand jobs and required education levels, the average cost of every college and vocational school, and the average monthly student loan payments and default rates for each school. Additionally, some states will extend the transparency to both public and private schools. Many databases will also give students the typical starting salaries for graduates of trade schools, as well as a breakdown of the benefits of apprenticeships and technical education programs.

It’s a different world from when I went off to college. I’m glad students have much more information available as they consider their futures. But, the most important thing they have to decide is what career they are passionate about. When you know that, the rest is really unimportant.

 

Ending the Mask Mandates

It’s time to put an end to mask mandates, but some politicians just can’t break the habit. They are holding on to this last piece of control over the American public, like a junky trying to get the last drop of heroin out of the syringe.

In a recent post I discussed the absurdity of mask mandates for toddlers, the least vulnerable members of our population (Florida v. New York Covid Guidelines for Children). The good news of that story, however, was that mask mandates were eliminated for all public-school children over age 5. The distinction had to do with vaccinations, which are not available for children under age 5.

In nearly every other public circumstance, masks are no longer required – except for public transportation. The Biden administration continues to demand masks for everyone on pubic transportation, especially airplanes, buses, and trains. The Office of Management and Budget (OMB) released a statement that said, “Public transportation and transportation hubs are places where people across communities congregate, often for extended periods and in close quarters. The determination of the timeline and circumstances under which masks should be required in these settings should be guided by science, not politics.”

I couldn’t agree more. The problem is there is no evidence that masks have any significant impact on preventing the spread of Covid. Yet the Biden administration claims they are “following the science.” Those three words have been repeatedly used to justify decisions that are in fact political, not scientific.

It seems there is bipartisan agreement on this issue, a truly rare phenomenon in this Congress. The Washington Examiner reports the Senate voted 57-40 to pass a resolution sponsored by Senator Rand Paul of Kentucky, an ophthalmologist. The only Republican voting against the bill was Mitt Romney of Utah.  Eight Democrats supported the resolution. The resolution would use the Congressional Review Act to try to roll back the rule, which the Biden administration just extended to April 18 as it was about to expire on March 18. While the resolution probably won’t get the necessary votes in the House of Representatives, it demonstrates clearly that support for the administration’s Covid guidelines is collapsing.

Senator Paul said, “Since March 2020, unelected bureaucrats have incessantly declared that we should ‘follow the science.’ But the same bureaucrats continue to defy science by imposing an ineffective and restrictive mask mandate for individuals traveling on public transit and airplanes. As the entire world is learning to live with Covid, the federal government still uses fearmongering to stubbornly perpetuate its mandates rather than giving clear-eyed rational advice on how to best protect yourself from illness. That is why I am forcing a vote to repeal travel mask mandates on public transportation and put a stop to its anti-science nanny-state requirement.”

This requirement seems particularly unnecessary on airplanes which contain air circulation and filtration systems equal to surgical operating rooms. While travel may increase the risks of disease by close quarters with strangers, there is no evidence that masks lower that risk. Removing mandates does not restrict those who still feel more comfortable wearing masks, but rather frees those who are comfortable without them. Once people understand the risks of the disease, they should be free to take whatever precautions they choose – or not choose – to apply. It’s time for the government to give people back their freedom of choice.