Conformity Confusion by the Media

Conformity can be a good or a bad thing. Conformity to obeying the law, or playing by the rules of a game, or dressing like the other members of a choir are all good things. But conformity with a false narrative is never a good thing.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says the year 2021 was full of conformity to false narratives by politicians and the media alike. This kind of conformity promotes misinformation and can be dangerous. WSJ says, “By conformity we mean the progressive political and media consensus that forms quickly around an issue and then reinforces itself no matter the competing arguments or new information. This isn’t a conspiracy in any formal sense; there are no organized calls or Zoom meetings. This is about a shared set of political values and preferences that leads people to reach the same conclusions about an event. The reporters and commentators of the major progressive media – the Washington Post, Bloomberg, the Financial Times, the New York Times, the Atlantic, and more – all then reinforce what they now like to call the “narrative” of a story.”

Here are a few examples from 2021:

The Wuhan Virology Lab origin theory of Covid-19

Although this was a definite possible source of the origins of Covid-19, the idea was quickly shut down by a group of scientists who stood to be embarrassed and possibly lose grant money if this was found to be true. The Lancet, a British medical journal, published a letter in February 2020 “to strongly condemn conspiracy theories suggesting that Covid-19 does not have a natural origin.”

This year we learned that the Lancet letter was part of a coordinated effort to quash the lab theory. We learned about the conflicts of interest of Anthony Fauci and others who provided funding for the Wuhan lab. Eventually even the press noticed that China had blocked an honest inquiry, and that no evidence for a natural origin has emerged.

Lockdowns stop Covid-19

WSJ says, “There was no fiercer consensus in the early days of the virus than the belief that locking down the economy to stop the virus was an unadulterated social good. We felt the consensus wrath when we raised doubts in an editorial on March 20, 2020, about the harm that lockdowns would do to the economy and public health.” 

Two years later their skepticism has proven well founded. At most, lockdowns only delay the spread of the virus, but cause severe damage to the education of children, lost livelihoods for many workers and employers, and damage to mental health leading to increased rates of drug abuse and suicide. Even Randi Weingarten, the teachers union president who was most responsible for school closures, now pretends she wanted to keep them open all along.

The supply side of the economy doesn’t matter

Keynesian economists, who dominate the U.S. and European media, have long held that the demand for goods and services drives the economy. The ability or incentive to supply those goods is largely ignored or dismissed. Spurring demand was the theory behind the trillions of dollars in spending by Congress and easy money from the Federal Reserve. They dismiss supply-side economists like Arthur Laffer, who was so successful in the Reagan administration.

What did these Keynesians produce? – the worst inflation in forty years. WSJ says, “All that money did spur demand. But the Keynesians ignored the disincentives to increase supply from paying people not to work and restricting work with lockdowns and mandates. The result was the surging inflation that caught nearly all of them by surprise. Their demand-side models never saw it coming.”

The Steele dossier and Russia collusion narrative

In 2019 the Mueller report exposed the lack of evidence for the claims that Donald Trump and the Kremlin were in cahoots. This past year the indictments by special counsel John Durham have revealed how Democrats and the press worked together to promote the dossier that was based on disinformation.  WSJ says, “Yet for four years nearly everyone in the dominant media bought the collusion narrative. One or two of the gullible have apologized, but most want everyone to forget what they wrote or said at the time.”

Vilifying police won’t affect crime

Where did common sense go? Anyone with half a brain should realize that reducing the presence of police will lead to more crime. If it were not so, we wouldn’t need police at all. But man is basically sinful and needs to have accountability to control his nature.

WSJ says, “The fast-congealing consensus after George Floyd’s murder was that most police were racist, as was most of American society, and violent protests against this were justified -even admirable. Woe to anyone who pointed out that the victims of these riots and crime were mostly poor and minority communities.”

Unfortunately, police funding was cut and bail laws eased in many large cities. Eighteen months later we see the result in rising crime rates and a soaring murder count. A political backlash now has even many Democrats claiming they really do want more funding for police. All of this was entirely predictable.

The lessons of this past year should be clear; jumping to quick conclusions is rarely justified and frequently leads to misinterpretation and misunderstanding. What is needed is a media that does its job – independently investigating stories until they get it right. Simply repeating what others have said is sloppy journalism and a successful democracy depends on the media doing better.

States Can Reform Healthcare

In my last post, we discussed Republican ideas for transforming healthcare. Former Louisiana Governor Booby Jindal gave us several ideas to consider as an alternative to the Democratic push for socialized medicine.

Today, healthcare economist John C. Goodman gives us several ways that states can improve your healthcare without federal changes. While this is unlikely in Democratic-controlled legislatures, Republicans can certainly make changes where they are in charge. Goodman says we tend to think we have one healthcare system in all 50 states, but the reality is we have 50 different healthcare systems.

In a new report called “Don’t Wait for Washington”, Paragon Health Institute has revealed some startling differences in healthcare according to which state you live in. In Montana, for example, the state payment for inpatient procedures at some hospitals was more than three times the Medicare rate. For outpatient procedures, that state was paying more than six times the Medicare rate in some instances. To solve this problem, Montana negotiated with all the hospitals and got a better deal. It now pays a little more than two times the Medicare rate for all procedures – regardless of where the patient gets treated.

To avoid the time-consuming problem of negotiating with hospitals, California began an approach called “reference pricing.” California state employees, retirees and their families are enrolled in CalPERS – one of the largest employee benefits plans in the country. With the help of the health insurer Anthem, CalPERS discovered that its charges for hip and knee replacements varied from about $15,000 to $110,000 at various hospitals across the state. CalPERS agreed to pay the full cost for beneficiaries who got a joint replacement at any of about 40 hospitals that routinely charged $30,000 or less. If employees went elsewhere, they had to pay the difference. No hospital negotiations were needed.

Within two years, the average cost of hip and knee replacements across the whole state of California fell below $30,000!

In our last post, we discussed the importance of eliminating Certificate of Need (CON) laws, which create huge regulatory obstacles to newcomers who want to open a hospital or nursing home. Studies show that CON laws raise costs and lower quality (the opposite of competition!) As a result ,15 states have repealed them. In contrast, Hawaii has CON barriers to entry for 28 different services, North Carolina for 27 services, and the District of Columbia for 25 services. You can be sure that healthcare is more expensive in all of these states.

States can also create alternatives to ObamaCare. The average premium for an individual last year was $7,100 and the average deductible was $4,364. That means if you’re not getting a subsidy from the government, you will have to pay more than $11,000 before you will get any benefits whatsoever from your health plan!

But there are alternatives. Some states exempt plans sold through the Farm Bureau from state insurance regulation. Since federal regulation, like ObamaCare, only applies to plans regulated by states as insurance, Farm Bureau plans are not subject to ObamaCare regulations. It is true that these plans can exclude applicants because of health conditions, but once enrolled, membership is guaranteed to be renewable even with a change in health status. Premiums and deductibles are far more affordable than under ObamaCare and satisfaction is very high.

There are also so-called “short-term insurance” plans. These plans have been available for years to serve as gap insurance for people moving between jobs, from home to school or from school to a job. Traditionally, these plans last for about 12 months and ObamaCare mandated benefits don’t apply. As a result they are cheaper, more affordable and good for meeting limited needs.

The Obama administration tried to limit the use of these plans to three months with no renewals. The Trump administration reversed these policies, extending them again to 12 months and allowing renewals up to three years. Furthermore, people are allowed to buy a second type of insurance to bridge the gaps between three-year periods, allowing the use of these plans indefinitely. Critics have claimed that these plans destabilize the Obamacare individual market, but studies by Paragon CEO Brian Blasé found that in half the states that are allowing short-term plans to take full advantage of the Trump reforms, the overall market is actually working better.

For more information on reforms, read the full Paragon Institute report.

Republican Ideas for Healthcare Reform

 

Our healthcare system is broken. As a healthcare practitioner for the last 38 years, I’ve seen the system deteriorate right before my eyes. We can do remarkable things in the operating room we couldn’t do forty years ago, but we can’t seem to deliver high quality care consistently with a personal touch like we used to.

ObamaCare has made it easier for low-income families to get healthcare insurance, but they still can’t afford the deductibles and co-pays that are necessary to actually receive treatments, especially surgery. Hospital systems are hiring physicians more and more which eliminates much of the independent private competition that thrived on providing high-quality, attentive healthcare. Now you’re likely stuck with whoever the hospital provides.

These are just a couple of examples of the decline in healthcare. But it could get much, much worse. If we ever actually go to socialized medicine, which Democrats are pushing, you’ll be lucky if you get hospitalized at all. Rationing of care is a fundamental of socialized medicine. If you’re too old, you may be denied the care you need. “Too expensive for someone your age.”

What’s the alternative to socialized medicine? Republicans have been trying to abolish ObamaCare and prevent socialized medicine, but what ideas do they have? Former Louisiana Governor Bobby Jindal, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says he has some answers to that question. Gindal says the time is now for Republican state legislatures to advance federalism while also strengthening consumer-based healthcare. He proposes several specific policies Republicans should champion and expand:

Require more price transparency

He advocates states to build on the Trump administration’s rules requiring price transparency for health plans and hospitals by including more providers, including physicians; beefing up enforcement to ensure compliance; and compiling data online in a format that allows for easy comparisons. At least nine states have built price-comparison websites for consumers, and many have or are bu8ilding all-payer claims databases for payers and employers. This will allow consumers to shop for the best healthcare values. Employers can also use this information to set reference prices for procedures, allowing comparison shopping and creating incentives for providers to become more efficient. Price transparency also increases pressure on intermediaries like health plans, third-party administrators, and pharmacy benefit managers to negotiate more effectively on behalf of their customers.

Expand scopes of practice, repeal certificate -of-need requirements, and promote cross-border licensing.

 Legal scopes of practice should be expanded so that doctors, nurses, pharmacists, therapists and other professionals can provide services up to their training and competence. What particular providers are currently allowed to do varies by state, with many restrictions unsupported by evidence of adverse outcomes. Many restrictions are dated and intentionally difficult to update to reflect advances in training, technology and research.

Certificates of need (CON) require government permission before new facilities can be built, so that such decisions are based on politics rather than market demand. New Hampshire repealed its CON program in 2016, and Florida partly did so in 2019. State-specific licensing requirements have impeded the ability of providers, especially in mental health, to care for patients remotely. As Covid expedited federal payment reforms to encourage telehealth, states should enact automatic reciprocal licensing and other arrangements to allow providers to treat patients across state lines.

Incorporate patient-based Medicaid reforms

States have been aggressive in enrolling healthier beneficiaries in private managed-care plans, but they can do more to ensure their programs are giving patients access to mainstream medical services rather than creating a separate public infrastructure. Conservatives in Washington have long fought for block grants to give states more flexibility over Medicaid, but state Republicans should maximize the flexibility they already have to try new delivery systems, cost-sharing arrangements and benefit designs.

Simplified Medicaid enrollment and renewal requirements have increased program participation, but states should encourage beneficiaries to use sliding-scale subsidies to obtain and retain affordable private coverage rather than forcing them into one-size-fits-all, all or nothing government coverage. States should adopt aggressive premium support and anti-crowd-out policies, combined with more-flexible wraparound benefit requirements, rather than unnecessarily replacing private dollars with taxpayer subsidies. The goal is to get people off Medicaid, especially as their circumstances improve.

Enforce antitrust laws to counter overconsolidation among hospitals, physicians, payers, and other healthcare entities.

Mergers in fragmented markets can result in efficiencies and quality improvements, but many markets are already dominated by three or fewer health systems. Larger systems are more able to comply with increasingly complicated and costly government regulations, but also more likely to become dependent on government funding and less entrepreneurial. These large systems are becoming “too big to fail,” developing unhealthy codependent relationships with the government agencies that pay the, regulate them, and depend on them to deliver essential program benefits.

These are just a few suggestions for improving our healthcare system. Since Democrats seem determined to push socialized medicine, it remains for Republicans to advocate more consumer-oriented reforms through their state legislatures now, and on the federal level if they regain control of Congress.