Omicron Makes Biden’s Mandates Obsolete

 

The Supreme Court of the U.S. (SCOTUS) is deliberating the constitutionality of President Biden’s vaccine mandates. Many legal scholars believe the Biden Administration is on shaky ground and anticipate SCOTUS will strike down these mandates on legal grounds.

But there may be an even better reason to end these vaccine mandates. Dr. Luc Montagnier and Jed Rubenfeld, writing in The Wall Street Journal, say the nature of the Omicron variant has made these mandates moot. Dr. Montagnier won the Nobel prize in 2008 for his discovery of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). They say, “It would be irrational, legally indefensible and contrary to the public interest for government to mandate vaccines absent any evidence that the vaccines are effective in stopping the spread of the pathogen they target.”

The mandates were issued on November 5, 2021, when the Omicron variant had yet to be discovered in South Africa. At that time, the Delta variant represented almost all U.S. Covid-19 cases, and both the Occupational Safety and Health Administration and the Department of Health and Human Services appropriately considered Delta their concern and that vaccines were effective against it. But all of that has changed since then.

These authors say since January 1, 2022, Omicron represented more than 95% of U.S. Covid cases, according to estimates from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Because some of Omicron’s 50 mutations are known to evade antibody protection, because more than 30 of those mutations are to the spike protein used as an immunogen by the existing vaccines, and because there have been mass Omicron outbreaks in heavily vaccinated populations, scientists are highly uncertain the existing vaccines can stop it from spreading.

The legal argument is that SCOTUS held in Jacobson v. Massachusetts (1905) that the right to refuse medical treatment could be overcome when society needs to curb the spread of a contagious epidemic. This is the crux of the case as argued before SCOTUS last week. But mandating a vaccine to stop the spread of a disease requires evidence that the vaccines will prevent infection or transmission. While it is true that the vaccines are effective in reducing hospitalizations and death, they are less effective in preventing infection or transmission.

To be sure, the mandates are defining “vaccinated” as having received at least two shots of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines and one shot of the Johnson & Johnson vaccine. The protection from getting Omicron is poor with this definition, but improves with booster shots, though it’s uncertain how long this added protection will last.

The good news is that the overwhelming majority of symptomatic U.S. Omicron cases have been mild, according to the CDC. These authors suggest “The best policy might be to let Omicron run its course while protecting the most vulnerable, naturally immunizing the vast majority against Covid through infection by a relatively benign strain. As Sir Andrew Pollard, head of the U.K.’s Committee on Vaccination and Immunization, said in a recent interview, “We can’t vaccinate the planet every four or six months. It’s not sustainable or affordable.”

The main point of these authors is that mandating a vaccine for all workers will not prevent the spread of the Omicron variant and therefore is bad public health policy. In their words, “In other words, there is no scientific basis for believing these mandates will curb the spread of the disease.”

Unfortunately, it seems some of the SCOTUS justices are getting their scientific facts from unreliable sources. Justice Steven Breyer suggested that if mandatory vaccination went forward, that would prevent all new Covid infections – 750,000 new cases every day. Justice Sonia Sotomayor asserted that “we have over 100,000 children. . . in serious condition, many on ventilators.” Both Justices have their facts completely wrong. According to Health and Human Services Department data, there are currently fewer than 3,500 confirmed pediatric Covid hospitalizations, and that includes patients who tested positive but were hospitalized for other reasons.

Hopefully, SCOTUS will decide this case based on the U.S. Constitution, not on misinformation regarding the effectiveness of the vaccines or the number of hospitalizations in children.

The Blue State Exodus

 

The Exodus recorded in the Bible was so the Hebrew people could escape the bondage of slavery in Egypt and find freedom in the Promised Land. A new exodus is happening as people seek escape from a modern-day slavery – bondage to government overreach. People are moving to new states to find freedom from overbearing governance.

A steady movement of people from blue states to red states was already happening before the Covid pandemic due to high taxes, high real estate prices, and rising crime rates. But Covid has added to the incentives to leave blue states due to government lockdowns, mask and vaccine mandates, and school closures.

James Freeman, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says the change seen in the District of Columbia is the most dramatic. The U.S. Census Bureau reports on data covering the period July 1, 2020, through July 1, 2021, and states:

“Over the past year, the District of Columbia’s population declined by 2.9%, or 20,043 residents, to a population of 670,050 in 2021. This was the largest annual percent decrease in the nation. The decline in the District of Columbia’s population can be attributed to negative net domestic migration (-23,030), which was large enough to offset gains from natural increase (2,171) and net international migration (1,128).”

Freeman says the media industry certainly devoted plenty of time during the Covid pandemic to instructing citizens that it was safer to live in areas ruled by coercion than ones reliant on individual judgment. Apparently, many Americans are just not listening! The Biden Census Bureau notes the remarkable trend of citizens moving into states governed by the most notorious liberty-loving villains of contemporary media:

“The South, with a population of 127,225,329, was the most populous of the four regions (encompassing 38.3% of the total national population) and was the only region that had positive net domestic migration of 657,682 (the movement of people from one area to another within the United States) between 2020 and 2021. The Northeast region, the least populous of the four regions with a population of 57,159,838 in 2021, experienced a population decrease of -365,795 residents due to natural decrease (-31,052) and negative net domestic migration (-389,638)…With a population of 29,527,941 in 2021, Texas had the largest annual and cumulative numeric gain, increasing by 310,288 (1.1%) and 382,436 (1.3%), respectively…

The largest net domestic migration gains were in Florida (220,890), Texas (170,307) and Arizona (93,026).”

Freeman recalls that television networks like CNN and MSNBC frequently lauded New York’s political leadership during the period studied, but for whatever reason, Americans on the move didn’t share the media’s opinion of Empire State governance. The Census Bureau notes:

“New York had the largest annual and cumulative numeric population decline, decreasing by 319,020 (1.6%) and 365,336 (1.8%), respectively. New York’s declining population in the last year was attributed to negative domestic migration (-352,185).”

This would seem to suggest that travelers forced to watch these programs in airport departure lounges aren’t taking them seriously.  Freeman suggests they may even view them as cartoonish entertainment.

But don’t look for changes in places like the District of Columbia. According to a report in The Washington Post, “Meanwhile, the city is doing what it can to lure people back: Mayor Muriel E. Bowser this past week said coronavirus vaccines would be required for patrons to enter restaurants, gyms, and other businesses starting in mid-January, and a mask mandate was reinstated amid rising coronavirus case counts. These measures, said Deputy Mayor John Falcicchio, are part of a long-term strategy to make D.C. visitors and residents feel secure. “We want to make sure when people come back and enjoy the vibrancy the city has to offer that they know we’ll put in more steps to make the city safe,” he said. “We’re on our way to a comeback.”

Freeman says, “And what better way is there to “enjoy the vibrancy” of a city than to be forced to wear a face covering? In the city that brought us protest tourism, perhaps all things are possible. But the latest Census data say that Americans prefer liberty.”

Once again, I am reminded it is a blessing to live in the free state of Florida.

 

Lockdowns Historically Failed

The word “lockdown” was unfamiliar to most of us until March 2020. The rising tide of Covid-19 cases that month prompted public health officials to advocate a lockdown for “fifteen days to slow the spread” as it was promoted. Now, nearly two years later, it seems a good time, if somewhat belated, to evaluate why that course was chosen and how effective it was in containing the virus.

Phillip W. Magness and Peter C. Earle give us a good history of the effectiveness of lockdowns in an article published in The Wall Street Journal. Before March 2020, the mainstream scientific community, including the World Health Organization, strongly opposed lockdowns and similar measures against infectious disease. Those conclusions came from historical analysis of pandemics and an awareness that society wide restrictions have severe socioeconomic costs and almost entirely speculative benefits. Our pandemic response, premised on lockdowns and closely related “non-pharmaceutical interventions,” or NPIs, represented an unprecedented and unjustified shift in scientific opinion from where it stood a few months before the discovery of Covid-19.

Just a year before in March 2019, WHO held a conference in Hong Kong to consider NPI measures against pandemic influenza. The WHO team evaluated a quarantine proposal – “home confinement of non-ill contacts of a person with proven or suspected influenza” – less indiscriminate than the Covid lockdowns. They called attention to the lack of data to support such a policy, noting that “most of the currently available evidence on the effectiveness of quarantine on influenza control was drawn from simulation studies, which have a low strength of evidence.” The WHO issued a statement that large-scale home quarantine was “not recommended because there is no obvious rationale for this measure.”

The conclusions of the WHO were supported by a September 2019 report from Johns Hopkins University Center for Health Security. They stated, “In the context of a high-impact respiratory pathogen, quarantine may be the least likely NPI to be effective in controlling the spread due to high transmissibility.” This was especially true of a fast-spreading airborne virus.

Where did they come up with these conclusions? The Covid-19 pandemic is certainly not the first, or the last, pandemic to spread throughout the world. Perhaps the greatest, though tragic, experience came with the Spanish flu pandemic of 1918. In 2006, the WHO issued a report following their study of this pandemic and concluded “forced isolation and quarantine are ineffective and impractical.” In particular, they referenced the example of Edmonton, Alberta, where “public meetings were banned; schools, churches, colleges, theaters, and other public gathering places were closed; and business hours were restricted without obvious impact on the epidemic.” Using data from a 1927 analysis of the Spanish flu in the U.S., the study concluded that lockdowns were “not demonstrably effective in urban areas.”

It is precisely in urban areas where we have seen the greatest emphasis on lockdowns, especially in New York and Los Angeles.

Medical historian, John Barry, who wrote the standard account of the 1918 Spanish flu, concurred about the ineffectiveness of lockdowns. “Historical data clearly demonstrate that quarantine does not work unless it is absolutely rigid and complete.” This statement comes from a report in 2009, summarizing the results of a study of influenza outbreaks on U.S. Army bases during World War I. Of 120 training camps that experienced outbreaks, 99 imposed on-base quarantines and 21 did not. Case rates between the two categories of camps showed “no statistical difference.” Barry concluded, “If a military camp cannot be successfully quarantined in wartime, it is highly unlikely a civilian community can be quarantined during peacetime.”

This begs the question why lockdowns were promoted in March, 2020. Even the once heralded, but now embattled, Dr. Anthony Fauci questioned the wisdom of lockdowns in January, 2020. When the Wuhan region of China imposed harsh restrictions on January 23, 2020, Fauci said, “That’s something that I don’t think we could possibly do in the United States. I can’t imagine shutting down New York or Los Angeles. Historically, when you shut things down, it doesn’t have a major effect.”

It seems the blame for the lockdowns that began in March, 2020, falls at the feet of the Imperial College London. In April, 2020, the journal Nature credited the Imperial team, led by Neil Ferguson, with developing one of the main computer simulations “driving the world’s responses to Covid-19.” The New York Times described it as the report that “jarred the U.S. and the U.K. into action.”

After predicting catastrophic casualty rates for an “unmitigated” pandemic, Ferguson’s model promised to bring Covid-19 under control through increasingly severe NPI policies, leading to event cancellations, school and business closures, and ultimately lockdowns. Ferguson produced his model by recycling a decades-old influenza model that was noticeably deficient in tis scientific assumptions. For one thing, it lacked a means of even estimating viral spread in nursing homes.

Magness and Earle say the record of Mr. Ferguson’s previous models should have been a warning. In 2001 he predicted that mad cow disease would kill up to 136,000 people in the U.K., chastising conservative estimates of only 10,000. The actual death toll by 2018 was only 178. He also miscalculated predictions of catastrophes for mad sheep disease, avian flu and swine flu that never panned out.

These authors calculated the performance of Imperial’s Covid-19 predictions in 189 different countries at the first anniversary of their publication, March 26, 2021. Not a single country reached the predicted mortality rates of their “unmitigated spread” or even the “mitigation model” – the latter premised on social-distancing measures similar to what many governments enacted. For example, Imperial predicted up to 42,473 Covid deaths in Sweden under mitigation and 84,777 under uncontrolled spread. The country, which famously refused to lock down, had some 13,400 deaths in the first year.

All of this should be a warning to those who would impose lockdowns again, in the face of rising case numbers, but not deaths, from the new Omicron variant. By now it should be clear to everyone that “following the science” does not mean lockdowns.