Disinformation Depends on Politics

 

There’s an old saying, “One man’s junk is another man’s treasure.” It depends on your point of view – and what you’re looking for. Information is much the same. What one man calls “disinformation” may actually be accurate information. It depends on your point of view – your bias – especially when politics is involved.

The most recent example of this is the origins of the coronavirus pandemic. Shortly after the onset of the pandemic, two theories quickly arose to explain where the virus originated. The first was it originated in a “wet market” in China, where bats and other animals may play host to such viruses. The second was it originated as a leak in the labs at the Wuhan Institute of Virology in Wuhan, China.

Since the first cases of the novel coronavirus were discovered in Wuhan, you might have concluded the virology lab leak was the most plausible explanation. Instead, Chinese officials insisted it originated in the “wet market” about a thousand miles away! Epidemiologists and other infectious disease researchers were quick to jump on this hypothesis, perhaps because it didn’t threaten their research grants. The World Health Organization, deeply connected to the Chinese government, insisted the virology lab leak was not rational and dismissed this possibility.

Facebook, and other social media outlets, labeled the virology lab hypothesis “disinformation” and quickly took steps to censor anyone who disagreed. Yet, one year later the virology lab leak hypothesis is now considered more than likely, not just by the Biden administration that earlier rejected this idea, but even by the WHO. Now the “disinformation” is quite likely the truth.

But despite this about-face on the origins of the coronavirus, the Biden White House has recently taken steps to coordinate with Facebook on taking down any information that they consider “problematic.” White House press secretary Jen Psaki admitted, “We’re flagging problematic posts for Facebook.” The Surgeon General, an officer in the department of Health and Human Services, released a report with a page of suggestions on “what technology platforms can do” to crack down on certain information. The Verge reported that officials at Twitter “met with the surgeon general’s office on Monday to discuss its misinformation policies.”


The Wall Street Journal
editorial board says, “It’s been clear for some time that the tech giants look to government to determine what coronavirus-related speech to allow. YouTube’s misinformation policy bans content that contradicts the evolving guidance of “health authorities.” Facebook stopped blocking some commentary on the lab-leak theory of the virus’s origins only after President Biden ordered an investigation into the possibility.”

In an earlier post (Free Speech in America), I recalled my own experience with censorship by Amazon when trying to publish a book that included coronavirus information. They were following the same approach as YouTube by banning any content that “contradicted the evolving guidance of health authorities.” Yet most of that information has since become public information acknowledged by health officials even today.

We are in a dangerous place when the government is restricting the flow of information based on their assessment of what constitutes “disinformation” – based on their political agenda. We’ve already witnessed the complete retraction of statements made by the Director of the CDC, Dr. Rochelle Walensky, when her bosses in the White House didn’t approve (CDC Director Caves to Politics). Why should we have any faith in any other statements coming from health officials who have been so obviously compromised?

The WSJ says “Wherever the legal line is drawn, the rise in Big Tech censorship that happens to align with government preferences ought to draw scrutiny. If it can happen on coronavirus, it can happen on other issues. Americans shouldn’t let that become the new normal.”

 

No Returning to Lockdowns

 

Lockdowns have produced immeasurable damage to our economy, our mental and physical health, and the emotional development of our children. They have failed to stem the spread of the virus and there is no discernible data to suggest they have accomplished anything worthwhile at all. Yet despite this undeniable history, there are those in government today considering a return to lockdowns!

Dr. Anthony Fauci – the often heralded, frequently misguided, often outspoken, but never remorseful infectious disease physician advising the Biden administration actually said he is considering advising a return to lockdowns. He recently admitted to CNN anchor Jake Tapper that they are considering requiring masks even for vaccinated individuals while in public.

The Washington Examiner editorial board says, “No. No. No. We believe in science. Therefore, we believe the vaccinated should not have to pretend vaccination doesn’t work – to live under the performative restrictions of public health theater, just to appease the insufferable mask-scolds among us and allay their pandemic era superstitions.”

It is true that the number of new cases of Covid-19 are rising, but the problem is the unvaccinated, not the vaccinated. The vast number of new cases and hospitalizations are occurring in low-vaccinated areas. Yet the CDC wants the vaccinated to resume wearing masks? The CDC justification for this change is an obscure study in India that has been harshly criticized in peer reviews and used the AstroZeneca vaccine, which isn’t even available in the U.S.! There is absolutely no justification for making the vaccinated continue to wear masks – anywhere!

Then there are the children. Nothing makes me cringe more than seeing young children wearing masks, even outdoors, despite volumes of data that prove such children are at little risk from the virus but at greater risk from the masks! (Do Children Need Masks and Vaccines?)

This boils down to a discussion of the proper role of government. The role of government is mainly to protect us from enemies, foreign and domestic, who threaten our lives. Government intervention made some sense in the early period of the pandemic in early 2020 when little was known about the virus and hospital facilities were threatened with overwhelming numbers.

But the advent of three successful vaccines makes government’s role now limited to dissemination of the vaccines and public awareness of their availability. Now that over two thirds of Americans have received vaccination, in part or in full, and another approximate third has already experienced Covid infection giving them natural immunity, the number of unprotected Americans is rapidly diminishing. Those who are getting infected now have mostly chosen to accept the risks of infection rather than the vaccine risks, or have been so advised by their doctors. This is a decision they have a right to make without coercion.

The real reason government and public health officials are contemplating a return to wearing masks is because they never want to give up control of the people. Big government politicians always believe the government is the solution to every problem. But Ronald Reagan said, “Government is not the solution. Government is the problem.” No truer words have been said.

This pandemic has provided government officials and politicians unprecedented opportunities to display their passion for the size of government. Democrats have repeatedly chosen heavy-handed government intervention in states like California, New York, and Michigan, while Republicans in states like Texas and Florida have resisted such urges and allowed the people to make informed decisions of their own.

There’s a reason why both Texas and Florida are seeing a massive inflow of people from blue states where they have given up on Democratic governance. High taxes, pandemic lockdowns, public school closures, rising crime rates, and intrusive government policies are forcing many to escape such enclaves of liberal policies for greener, and freer, pastures – and no lockdowns!

More Good News on the Delta Variant Virus

 

If your local newspaper is anything like mine, you’re probably inundated with scary news about the new Delta variant of the Covid-19 virus. It is true that new infection cases are rising, but they are almost entirely among those who are unvaccinated. A recent post (Vaccines and the Delta Variant) was meant to reassure my readers who are already vaccinated. Today, I have more good news to share.

Two public health researchers, Leslie Bienen of the Oregon Health and Science University – Portland State University School of Public Health and Monica Gandhi, infectious disease physician and professor of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco, share this news in The Wall Street Journal. They say a new study from the U.K. found that the vaccines are still incredibly effective in preventing serious illness, even with the Delta variant. The Pfizer vaccine was 96% effective after two doses in preventing hospitalization, which means the unvaccinated are more than 25 times as likely to be hospitalized with Covid as those who are vaccinated.

This is probably an understatement since the vaccinated cohort was older and had a higher incidence of pre-existing conditions than the unvaccinated one. The Johnson & Johnson vaccine produces strong neutralizing antibodies and cellular responses against the Delta variant, still present eight months after administration. The Moderna vaccine was not used in this study, but may have similar results as Pfizer since they are both mRNA developed vaccines.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) both have asserted their confidence in the vaccines. They also jointly announced that no boosters are necessary at this time.

There is also much talk about the Delta variant making people sicker. There is actually no evidence to support this claim. The authors reviewed publicly available data from the CDC and compared hospitalizations per case, particularly in regions where a new variant is more common. They found that the hospitalization data support none of the alarming headlines suggesting Delta is more dangerous than earlier strains.

Further analysis of hospitalization data tells us whether healthcare systems are overwhelmed, and helps us predict deaths with high reliability. Positivity data are less reliable, especially the relationship between infection and hospitalizations becomes weaker in highly vaccinated countries like the U.S. The authors conducted similar analyses in April, when headlines were raging that the U.K. variant, now called Alpha, was driving surges in kids. They found that it wasn’t, and that juvenile hospitalizations weren’t rising in places with a high prevalence of the Alpha variant.

The authors say, “Whatever else we know or don’t know about Delta, its prevalence clearly isn’t driving hospitalizations. When we look at current hospitalization data across the country, the most striking predictive pattern is that a high vaccination rate in a region accurately predicts a lower hospitalization rate.”

The hardest question to answer is transmissibility, because it isn’t possible to conduct controlled trials comparing how many people get infected with a particular variant. New variants may be more infectious, as some suspect the Delta variant is, or they may only be better at reproducing themselves in an infected person’s body. For whatever reasons, the Delta variant is becoming the dominant strain in the U.S.

Unfortunately, politics continues to influence headlines and even public health policy. The latest concerns the infection rates and hospitalizations in Florida being announced in the headlines, not by the CDC or even the Florida public health officials, but by the White House. Is it possible they fear the rising popularity of Governor Ron DeSantis?