School Choice Progress Continues

 

School choice is gaining ground against the teachers unions despite the pandemic; maybe even because of the pandemic. For years the teachers unions have tried to portray school choice as a threat to the education of children, but the argument is losing traction. Parents of both political parties are seeing school choice for what it really is – a chance for children of all economic classes to get a good education.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says it’s been a banner year for school choice. Across the nation, states are providing more opportunities for children to take advantage of school choice options. They mention four state budgets that passed in the last two weeks in which lawmakers included provisions that give families more educational opportunities.

In New Hampshire, Republican lawmakers approved Education Freedom Accounts, which students can use toward such expense as private school tuition, tutoring, textbooks and technology. Scholarship funds are available to families earning up to 300% of the federal poverty limit (FPL) at an average of $4,600, the state per pupil funding amount for public school students. The state Education Department estimates the program could save the state at least $360 million over a decade. Imagine that – saving money while giving kids better educational opportunities!

Pennsylvania’s Democratic Governor Tom Wolf signed a budget that includes an expansion of a high-demand state tax-credit scholarship program. No, it wasn’t the governor’s idea, but the GOP legislature pushed the measure and now Mr. Wolf wants to get the credit. The Educational Improvement Tax Credit cap will rise by $40 million to $175 million for K-12 scholarships, enough to fund an estimated 13,000 more students.

Ohio also packaged several school choice provisions into their budget that Republican Gov. Mike DeWine signed last week. These include funding for high-performing charter schools and higher scholarship values for the state’s voucher program. The Legislature also created a new K-12 Educational Savings Accounts (ESA) program, which offers students a modest $500.

Progress in school choice is not limited to the east. In Arizona, the Legislature raised the funding cap for a special-needs tax credit scholarship program and allowed low-income students at struggling public schools to switch to the state’s ESA program without a waiting period. It could have been better, however, as lawmakers, including three Republicans, rejected an expansion of ESAs to 600,000 more low-income students.

Seven states have created new tax-credit scholarship or ESA programs this year, and more than a dozen have expanded programs. The benefit will flow to thousands of students and families looking to escape the prison of low-performing public schools. Politicians of both parties should wake up and realize that school choice benefits everyone, except perhaps the teachers unions who are stuffing those same politicians’ campaign coffers. Sooner or later, even they will realize that doing what’s best for the children is the winning political decision.

Attacking Alzheimer’s Progress

 

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), there are an estimated 6.2 million Americans who have Alzheimer’s disease. More than 1 in 9 people (11.3%) age 65 and older has Alzheimer’s disease. The number of people living with the disease doubles every 5 years beyond age 65. This number is projected to nearly triple to 14 million Americans by 2060.

These statistics should alarm everyone, but apparently, they don’t. How else to explain why many in Congress are trying to stop the federal government from paying for the first drug that has ever shown real progress in the battle to combat this dread disease?

Recently I wrote of this breakthrough in the treatment of Alzheimer’s with the FDA approval of the drug aducanumab, which is manufactured by Biogen as Aduhelm (Alzheimer’s Hope Arrives). In that post I explained: “The cause of Alzheimer’s is still elusive but its hallmark is amyloid plaques and tau tangles in the brain, which usually begins long before symptoms become apparent. Many scientists believe removing amyloid could slow disease progression. This is how aducanumab works, by clearing amyloid. A high dose of the drug in a late-stage trial removed 71% of the amyloid buildup after 18 months.”

The Wall Street Journal editorial board tells us that public-health officials and media critics failed to stop federal approval of the drug, so now they’re mounting an assault on the drug’s cost to stop Medicare from paying for it. “It’s unconscionable to ask seniors and taxpayers to pay $56,000 a year for a drug that has yet to be proven effective,” Oregon Senator Ron Wyden tweeted after the FDA approved the drug this month.

The annual cost of treating Alzheimer’s disease and other dementias in the U.S. is expected to reach $355 billion this year. While $56,000 a year is a lot of money, it is not unusual for many other new drugs, especially cancer drugs, and is sure to come down as treatment success spurs competition in the marketplace. The WSJ says a drug price war last decade between Gilead and AbbVie caused Hepatitis C treatment net prices to fall by nearly 80 percent. Competition may also occur with Alzheimer’s treatments as several therapies that have shown promise in clinical trials aim to seek approval in the next few years. If we refuse to pay the high price of breakthroughs in disease treatment, we will never make progress in the treatment of any disease.

The WSJ explains the FDA approval process: “The FDA approved Aduhelm because it significantly reduced amyloid. Many of Aduhelm’s critics in the public-health crowd have criticized the FDA’s accelerated approval program for years. They don’t believe drugs with incremental benefits should be approved.” 

If Aduhelm delays the progression of the disease for some patients by even a year or two, it will save tens of billions of dollars in Medicare, Medicaid, home care, and other health costs. The WSJ summarizes the real problem: “The hostility to Aduhelm illustrates the healthcare paternalism of American progressives. They believe we spend too much money on old people. They want to put the government in charge of paying for all healthcare, and then put “experts” in charge of determining what treatments patients can receive so that the elderly can go gently into the night.”

These are the same people who want us all to have socialized medicine. You can be sure that if that ever happens, drugs for the elderly – in fact treatment of any disease for the elderly – will be their lowest priority.

 

The AMA Doesn’t Represent Most Doctors

 

When I became a doctor, the most prestigious organization that represented doctors was the American Medical Association (AMA). That was 1979 and today is 2021. A lot of water has passed under the bridge since then and the AMA is no longer representing most doctors.

In 1991 I left the AMA because they were promoting abortion. Membership in the AMA was already declining since the days of my training and in 1979 they represented only 27% of all physicians in the U.S. Today that number continues to decline, despite attempts by the AMA to cover up this fact.

Two years ago, Kevin Campbell, MD, a cardiologist from North Carolina, analyzed the data and came up with the following figures for 2019:

  • There were 1,341,682 physicians, medical students/residents/ fellows in the U.S.
  • There were 250,253 AMA members – 18%
  • According to the AMA, 22.5% of AMA members are students; 24.7% are residents
  • If you remove these numbers, there are 1,093,472 practicing physicians in the U.S.
  • 132,133 of these physicians are AMA members – 12.1%

 

Therefore, the AMA represents only about 12% of U.S. physicians. This decline has been continuing for decades. Campbell says, “It’s an interesting angle that the AMA paints a picture of membership growth in their marketing literature but skirts the fact that it’s essentially like a fraternity claiming growth by rushing tons of freshmen the first day they get to college, with not many of them ever becoming full dues paying members and staying active for the four years of college.”

Why is this important?

The continuing decline of AMA membership reflects the organization’s continuing deviation from the values of American doctors. I left because they promoted abortion; others left because their voices were never heard and the AMA promoted political views they disagreed with. A classic example is the AMA’s promotion of ObamaCare even though most physicians opposed this move toward socialized medicine.

The latest controversy is the AMA’s move toward progressive politics. The Wall Street Journal editorial board says, “The American Medical Association is a lobby of doctors that’s supposed to promote policies that improve public health and medicine. But it seems to be evolving into another arm of progressive politics, like the teachers unions.”

The AMA delegates met last week for a policy-making meeting. Delegates spent much of the time discussing systemic racism in health care and adopted guidelines for workplaces to establish training requirements for explicit and implicit bias and microaggressions. AMA trustee Willarda Edwards called systemic racism “the most serious barrier to the advancement of health equity and appropriate medical care.” This is just as ludicrous as President Biden calling climate change the most serious threat to our country. Both ignore the real problems in favor of “woke” platitudes.

I am proud to say that medicine is perhaps the most egalitarian profession in the world. I have never in my forty-six years of medical training and practice experienced an incident where race, religion, or economic status influenced the treatment of individuals by me or any other healthcare provider in my presence. Racism is not a problem in the world of medicine.

The most serious problem in medicine today is access to healthcare. This is influenced by economic status, not race. Not all healthcare insurance is the same. Medicaid is the worst form of insurance available, not because of racism, but because of low reimbursement rates for treatment. Doctors who refuse to accept Medicaid do so because they don’t want to lose money, not because they are racist.

I have been an outspoken critic of ObamaCare because it doesn’t solve the problem of access to healthcare; it actually made it worse. ObamaCare is largely an expansion of Medicaid by federal government changes in eligibility and subsidies. This expansion of Medicaid has only exacerbated the problem of access to healthcare by giving millions of Americans an inferior form of healthcare which most doctors will not accept.

Medicaid is not just bad healthcare insurance; it is actually worse than no insurance at all. This alarming fact was discovered in a 2007 study called the Oregon Health Insurance Experiment. This ongoing study has taught us that Medicaid does not improve health, at least in standard measurements of blood pressure, blood sugar, and cholesterol. Medicaid reduced observed rates of depression by 30%, but increased the probability of being diagnosed with depression. It also significantly increased the probability of being diagnosed with diabetes, but did not have a positive impact on lowering blood sugar.

The reason for these surprising findings is the lack of access to healthcare. Patients with Medicaid have great difficulty getting doctor appointments because so few doctors accept Medicaid, and those that do usually limit the number of such appointments in their schedule. The uninsured, however, do not have this problem. They can always get a doctor’s appointment quickly because they pay cash and nearly all doctors will give generous discounts for cash patients. Medicaid patients cannot do the same because it is unlawful for doctors to accept cash payments from Medicaid enrollees.

Sadly, the AMA no longer represents the interests of most physicians. Specialty organizations, which represent only those in their specialty, have become the voice of most doctors, but there is no organization speaking out for the majority of doctors. The AMA, with its new political wokeness, is becoming just as irrelevant to doctors as most teachers unions are to teachers.