Vaccinating Children

 

Should my child get the Covid-19 vaccine? Now that Pfizer/BioNTech has received authorization from the FDA to begin vaccinating children age 12 to 15, that question is on the minds of many parents.

Previous FDA authorization was limited to those age 16 years and older, so parents had no decision to make. They were told to force their children to wear masks, keep their distance from other children, and stay home from school. It has been a devastating year for these children emotionally, educationally, if not physically. Mental health has declined as evidenced by increased rates of suicide and substance abuse, even in this age group.

Now that the vaccine is available to these children, how should parents react? Should they quickly sign their children up for vaccinations? Or should they wait for more proof of the safety of these vaccines?

Naturally, there are some children who should not be vaccinated. Those with compromised immune systems may be warned by their doctors to avoid vaccination. Some doctors may also advise against vaccination since the risk to children with Covid-19 is very low. Yet many parents are eager for their children to resume normal activities which have been denied for over a year.

Robbie Whelan, science writer for The Wall Street Journal, reports the CDC recommended last week the use of the vaccine in the younger age group. More than a dozen states – including California, Washington, Maine, Illinois, Massachusetts, Arkansas and Florida – followed the recommendation and made the 12-to-15 age group eligible, many scheduling vaccine appointments.

Public health officials say vaccinating children is crucial to protecting them from infection and achieving community-wide immunity. Some parents and school officials want children to be vaccinated ahead of summer camps and the start of the next school year. Many teens are eager to resume social activities.

State officials are ramping up ways to make getting children vaccinated even easier. In North Carolina, state officials have signed up 400 pediatricians to do outreach to parents and administer vaccines at their offices. Hospitals will break up Pfizer’s 1,200 dose packets into smaller batches to distribute at pediatric practices, says Mandy Cohen, state health secretary. In addition, dozens of public-school districts in the state have expressed interest in holding on-site vaccination events or joining with local agencies to transport students to vaccination sites.

Since the risk of infection is low, and the risk of serious illness is even lower, some parents may choose to avoid vaccination for their children. However, if vaccination becomes necessary to attend summer camps, travel, or even attend school, the extremely low risk from the vaccines seems justified. The incidence of vaccine complications has been exceptionally low, the efficacy of the vaccines is high, and the benefits of vaccination are a return to life with some semblance of normalcy.

Parents should weigh the pros and cons of vaccinating their children and discuss it with their pediatrician. Whether you get your child vaccinated or not, we should all be grateful there is now a vaccine that is available and safe for children in this age group.

The High Cost of Youth Protection

 

We’ve heard a lot about the importance of protecting our youth from Covid infection. This has greatly influenced the time frame for re-opening schools. The Biden administration even today won’t commit to fully reopening schools by September. Naturally, we all agree that we should do everything possible to protect everyone, especially our youth from a potentially fatal infection. But few people are talking about the actual cost of that protection, for the young and the elderly.

Charles L. Hooper and David R. Henderson have analyzed this cost in a meaningful way. Hooper is president of Objective Insights, a firm consulting with pharmaceutical clients. Henderson is an economist, research fellow with the Hoover Institution, and was senior health economist with Reagan’s Council of Economic Advisers.

They say the benefits of protection include reducing the potential for death, pain, suffering and healthcare costs, along with reducing the chances of infecting others. But the main benefit of protection is that fewer people die from Covid-19.

First, we must define some terms. The infection fatality rate is the probability that a person will die once infected, whether that person has symptoms or is unaware of the infection. The global average infection fatality rate of SARS-CoV2 (Covid-19) is roughly 0.23%. That means 23 in 10,000 people die if infected. The average U.S. fatality rate is higher, probably 0.3% because Americans are older and less healthy than those in most other countries.

More important, the infection fatality rate increases exponentially with age. We have known for some time now that the elderly are more vulnerable. Now we know how much. For an 85-year-old it may be 2,000 times as high as for an 18-year-old. This increase in morbidity is due to multiple factors including declining immune systems and co-morbidities, especially heart disease, diabetes, pulmonary disease, and obesity.

The primary risk of infection is death. To calculate the risk, economists use the number of years lost based on statistical life expectancy. A person’s expected years lost is equal to the infection fatality rate times life expectancy times probability of infection.

Expected years lost = infection fatality rate x life expectancy x probability of infection

Perfect protection is unachievable. Based on data from the University of California, Berkeley, they assume that actual protection reduced the risk of infection by roughly half. Herd immunity is the point in the life cycle of an infectious disease when enough of the population has immunity that the number of people to whom a newly infected person passes the disease drops below one. Assuming this would be reached when about 70% of the population has been infected (or vaccinated), imperfect protection reduced the risk of infection for the average American from 70% to 35%.

Now they calculate the benefits of protection for each age group. They find the benefits of protection are disproportionately higher for older people than for young people. Compare an 18-year-old v. an 85 -year-old. If the 18-year-old dies, he loses 61.2 years of expected life. But the probability of him dying is only about 0.0004%. Therefore, the expected years of life lost are only 0.0004% times 35% times 61.2 years. This calculates to 0.0009 year, or only 7.5 hours.

Now consider the 85-year-old. If he dies, he will lose 6.4 years of expected life. His probability of dying is much higher, about 8%. So, the expected years of life lost are 8% times 35% times 6.4 years, which equals 0.179 year – or 65 days. The benefits of protection as measured in life expectancy, are 210 times as high for the older person.

What does it cost to protect the youth?

The costs of protection of the youth include reduced schooling and economic activity, increased substance abuse and suicides, more loneliness, reduced contact with loved ones, delayed cancer diagnoses and childhood vaccinations, increased anxiety, lowered wage growth, travel restrictions, reduced entertainment choices, and fewer opportunities for socializing and building friendships. Whew! Quite a list.

The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) estimated in 2020 the loss of lifetime income for individual students would be 6%, assuming schools were closed or reduced for approximately 67% of the school year. This translates to a loss of lifetime earnings of $102,000 per student using a U.S. median lifetime earnings of $1.7 million. The elderly, mostly retired, were largely unaffected.

This brings us to the important question: Would you pay $102,000 to live an extra 7.5 hours?

What 18-year-old values his time at $13,600 per hour?

The costs for the 85-year-old are negligible – and the benefit is 65 days. The 85-year-old has little to lose and much to gain. The cost-benefit ratio for the young is just the opposite.

This information was not available a year ago when decisions were being made for the young and the old. In hindsight, we should have done more to protect the elderly – and less to protect the young. But having learned these lessons, why are we still keeping schools closed and making young people endure wearing masks?

Higher ObamaCare Subsidies Means Higher Healthcare Costs

The Democrats just passed the American Rescue Plan, also known as the Covid Relief Bill. It is $1.9 Trillion in additional government spending that has little to do with Covid-19.

It also has little to do with providing a “rescue” for the American worker. In an earlier post, Covid-19 Relief Bill Kills Jobs, I discussed how economists Casey B. Mulligan and Stephen Moore estimate this bill will result in between five and eight million fewer Americans being employed. But today I want to talk about its impact on healthcare costs.

It is no secret that healthcare costs continue to rise at a faster rate than inflation. This is evident in the graphic below. ObamaCare was passed by the Democratic Congress of President Barack Obama in 2010 and was supposed to reign in the cost of healthcare. It was promoted as a way to “flatten the curve” of ever-increasing healthcare costs. Obviously, this was just one of many broken promises in that healthcare legislation.

 

 

Now, President Biden has pushed through another bill without a single Republican vote that promises to improve upon the original ObamaCare. This time the government will pay higher subsidies for Obamacare premiums by expanding the eligibility rolls for the subsidies. But none of this will lower the cost of healthcare.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board put it this way: “Instead of making the underlying product better or less expensive, Democrats now want to pass more of the cost onto taxpayers. More low-income buyers would pay little to nothing for insurance. Democrats would also remove the income cap for receiving subsidies, which is 400% of the poverty line, and reduce a person’s maximum contribution to 8.5% of income from 10%.”

Josh Archambault, writing in Forbes, says the impact of this legislation will be even higher healthcare costs, which means higher taxes. He says, “Washington has just written a blank check to the biggest players in healthcare for at least two years and these subsidies just cover up problems that will only get worse. The twisted logic of the bill even grants more assistance to higher-income enrollees, compared to those with lower incomes. To make matters worse, the subsidy expansion will result in millions of workers losing their employer-based insurance. It will crowd out private spending on health coverage as some employers drop coverage and switch employees off employer-based overage to taxpayer-subsidized coverage.”

All of this will simply put a Band-Aid on a problem that needs surgery. ObamaCare has been a flawed healthcare legislation from its inception and this additional legislation will only make it worse. The only winners in this scenario are the Democratic politicians who profit from the votes they get from unsuspecting voters who believe this is in their best interest.