Fake Science Behind Long Covid Symptoms

How long does Covid last? Most Covid patients recover in 14 days, but some have symptoms longer. There is a growing effort by some to contend they have chronic Covid symptoms, sometimes referred to as “long Covid”, also known as post-Covid syndrome. Is this a real or imagined condition?

Dr. Jeremy Devine, a psychiatry resident at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ontario says there is no scientific basis for this condition. Yet, the National Institutes of Health last month announced a $1.15 billion initiative to research the “prolonged health consequences” of Covid-19 infection.

Dr. Devine, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says it deserves serious study. There is evidence that some elderly patients, with co-morbidities, do experience symptoms that outlast the coronavirus infection. But, as a psychiatrist, he notes that such symptoms can also be psychologically generated or caused by a physical illness unrelated to the prior infection. He says “long Covid” is largely an invention of vocal patient activist groups. Legitimizing it with generous funding risks worsening the symptoms the NIH is hoping to treat.

It seems that the concept of “long Covid” has its origin in a patient advocacy group called Body Politic. Launched in 2018, this group describes itself on its website as “a queer feminist wellness collective merging the personal and the political.” In March 2020, the group’s cofounders created the Body Politic Covid-19 Support Group. As part of their mission of “cultivating patient-led research,” the organization coordinated a series of online surveys on persistent symptoms. Based on the results of these surveys, the group produced the first report on “long Covid” in May, 2020.

Yet, many of the respondents never had Covid-19. Of those who self-identified as having persistent symptoms attributed to Covid and responded to the survey, not even a quarter had tested positive for the virus. Nearly half (47.8%) never had any testing and 27.5% tested negative for Covid-19. Body Politic published these results in a second, larger survey in December, 2020. Of 3,762 respondents, only 600 or 15.9% had actually tested positive for Covid at any time.

This shoddy research was nevertheless supported by NIH Director Dr. Francis Collins, who has repeatedly supported the Body Politic Covid-19 Support Group’s patient-led research initiatives, promoting the surveys in a series of official blog posts, according to Dr. Devine. In fact, he points out, the NIH announcement of their decision to commit $1.15 billion to long Covid research explicitly referred to the Body Politic research surveys.

Why would a scientific institution, such as NIH, support unscientific conclusions?

Dr. Devine opines that this subjugation of scientific rigor to preconceived belief reflects a common dynamic encountered in clinical practice. He says, “Patients who struggle with chronic and vague symptoms often vehemently reject a physician’s diagnosis that suggests an underlying mental health issue, in part because of the stigma around mental illness and the false belief that psychologically generated symptoms aren’t “real.”

This situation is not unique in medicine. Other medical conditions, such as chronic fatigue syndrome, have advocacy groups to support those who claim to suffer from their symptoms. Solve ME/CFS is a support group, founded for those who claim to suffer from myalgic encephalomyelitis and chronic fatigue syndrome. This group was founded in 1987 by patients who felt their chronic and numerous medical complaints – including fatigue, “brain fog,” and an inability to exert themselves physically or mentally – were being dismissed by their physicians and neglected by the medical community.

The common denominator in all these support groups is the fundamental resistance to accept the idea that their chronic symptoms are related to an underlying mental health issue despite mainstream medicine’s assertions to the contrary. They reject the notion that these patients actually suffer from anxiety or depression or both.

In an effort to strengthen their political and media support for their position, Body Politic and Solve ME/CFS have announced they are launching the Long Covid Alliance. Its mission they declare: “To transform the current understanding of Long Covid and related post-infectious illnesses” including ME/CFS.

Dr. Devine says a central feature underlying many psychosomatic-symptom disorders is a fixed belief that one is ill and unlikely to recover. By drawing attention to and legitimizing the ever-present threat of long Covid, medical authorities will lead a large group of impressionable patients to believe that their Covid-19 symptoms have not resolved and that they are helpless victims of an unrelenting sickness.

The media has perpetuated such thinking in the past. Dr. Devine reminds us this occurred in the 1940s with chronic brucellosis, in the 1980s with Epstein Barr virus, and even today with chronic Lyme’s disease.  He concludes “The NIH’s decision is a victory for pseudoscience and will do more to harm than help patients.”

 

What do you believe? Send me your comments.

School Choice Improves Scores

 

Although this is mainly a healthcare blog, I sometimes write about other important issues. One of those is school choice. I have a passion for school choice, because it opens doors for poor and disadvantaged children to escape their situations and lead productive lives.

The biggest obstacle to school choice is teachers unions. Teachers unions have been in the news a lot lately, since they have demanded vaccinations for all their teachers before returning to the classrooms, despite scientific evidence that clearly shows this is unnecessary. Teachers unions also promote the false narrative that school choice is bad for public schools. Recent evidence is proving school choice is beneficial, not only for the students who choose charter or private schools, but also for those still in public schools.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says the latest study shows a positive correlation between the education options states offer and test results on the National Assessment of Education Progress (NAEP) exam. Researchers at the University of Arkansas’s School Choice Demonstration Project developed an Education Freedom Index to measure school choice environments in the states and Washington, D. C. The index considers offerings for private school choice like vouchers and tax-credit scholarships, home-schooling, public school choice (the ability to switch schools or districts) and charter schools.

Based on the index, Arizona, which has education savings accounts, tax-credit scholarships and expansive charter school programs, takes first place. Indiana is second, and Hawaii ranks last. The study finds the rankings strongly correlate with state NAEP scores for 8th grade math and reading. “Higher levels of education freedom,” the authors write, “are significantly associated with higher NAEP achievement levels and higher NAEP achievement gains” between 2003 and 2019 in all of their models.

Each model controls for per-pupil spending, student-teacher ratio, household income, and percentage of white students. Some models also control for teacher quality policies including education, evaluation policies, and compensation requirements.

How could this impact the lives of students?

The author of the study, Jay Greene, says to consider a student about to enter kindergarten in New York, which ranks 35th in the Education Freedom Index. If his family chose to move to Florida, which ranks 7th, for the child’s K-8 education, the child would climb 10 points on the NAEP (from the 50th to the 60th percentile) by the time he reached 8th grade compared to if he had stayed in New York. If the family moved to Arizona, the child would see an 18-point improvement. He says this is using the most conservative model.

It is also worth noting that the study finds a negative correlation between per-pupil spending and NAEP scores. In other words, spending more money per pupil does not translate into better scores. This challenges the union claims that insufficient funding is to blame for failing public schools. The authors believe that school choice increases competitive pressure on public schools – well documented in other studies – which could help improve NAEP scores across the board.

WSJ says, “Unions and the left argue that expanding school choice does nothing to help the large majority of students who attend traditional public schools. This study shows that’s not true. Expanding school choice creates incentives that help all children.”

This past year has exposed the true agenda of the teachers unions and their disdain for the students they teach. This study only adds more strength to the arguments of school choice advocates who only want students to have the best possible education and the best chances of success in the future.

Vaccine Passports – Good or Bad Idea?

Passports are intended to restrict travel to only those who have been properly documented. Vaccine passports are intended to restrict access to anyone who isn’t vaccinated. Is this a good or a bad idea?

Full disclosure – I am fully vaccinated and therefore have my “vaccine passport.” I have no personal dog in this fight. But there are good arguments against vaccine passports and it’s time for this discussion.

Martin Kulldorff and Jay Bhattacharya are two of the three authors of The Great Barrington Declaration. Kulldorff, from Harvard University, and Bhattacharya, from Stanford University, have been outspoken opponents of lockdowns. (see Epidemiologists Reject Political Correctness) These scientists have pushed back because of the unscientific basis and destructive impact lockdowns have had on the physical and emotional health of millions of Americans, not to mention the economic disaster they have caused. Now they are outspoken in their criticism of vaccine passports.

Writing in The Wall Street Journal, these authors say vaccine passports are promoted as a way of easing coercive lockdown restrictions, but in fact they will be the opposite. Vaccinepassports will be used for restricting much more than travel. They will also be used to restrict access to restaurants, theaters, sports arenas, offices, and schools.

To understand their argument, consider restaurants. Most have already reopened in most states in the U.S. A vaccine passport would prohibit entry by potential customers who haven’t received their shots. It would also restrict the freedom of those vaccinated if their dinner partners have not been vaccinated. Planes and trains, which have continued to operate throughout the pandemic, would suddenly be off limits to anyone without a passport. This is, in effect, a coercive effort by the government to force people to be vaccinated.

I am a strong proponent of vaccination. I have encouraged everyone to get vaccinated unless their doctor believes they have a medical condition that prohibits vaccination. Those people will fortunately benefit from herd immunity once that has been achieved. To require vaccine passports for them would restrict their personal freedom unnecessarily.

The authors say, “The idea that everybody needs to be vaccinated is as scientifically baseless as the idea that nobody does. Covid vaccines are essential for older, high-risk people and their caretakers and advisable for many others. But those who’ve been infected are already immune. The young are at low risk, and children – for whom no vaccine has been approved anyway – are at far less risk of death than from the flu. If authorities mandate vaccination of those who don’t need it, the public will start questioning vaccines in general.”

This issue also destroys trust. When the government mandates you must do something, the public tends to react with distrust. They think, “If this is so good for me, why are they forcing me to do it?” Vaccines are good, but the public must be given the freedom to make that decision on their own.

The authors also say, “Vaccine passports are unjust and discriminatory. Most of those endorsing the idea belong to the laptop class – privileged professionals who worked safely and comfortably at home during the epidemic. Millions of Americans did essential jobs at their usual workplaces and became immune the hard way. Now they would be forced to risk adverse reactions from a vaccine they don’t need. Passports would entice young, low-risk professionals, in the West and the developing world, to get the vaccine before older, higher-risk but less affluent members of society. Many unnecessary deaths would result.”

History is filled with vaccination successes against devastating illnesses like polio, measles, mumps, rubella, rabies and many others. Vaccination passports could undermine public trust in vaccines and threaten all this progress. It is good for politicians like Florida Governor Ron DeSantis and Texas Governor Greg Abbott to push pack against vaccine passports.

What do you believe? Let me know your responses.