CDC Director Caves to Politics

 

Dr. Rochelle Walensky didn’t know any better. As the newly appointed Director of the Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) she didn’t realize that politics comes before science. So, she did that rare thing in Washington – she told the truth.

In an article published January 26th in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA), three researchers from the CDC found “little evidence that schools have contributed meaningfully to increased community transmission” of the coronavirus. The CDC researchers looked at more than 90,000 students in 11 North Carolina districts and found that only 32 students and staff members were infected in school, while 773 got infected during the same period out of school. The science was clear; reopening schools was safe for children and teachers.

Then Dr. Walensky made her big mistake. On February 3rd, she announced these findings to the press. She made it clear that the science supported reopening schools.  In her statement she said, “Vaccination of teachers is not a prerequisite for safe reopening of schools.” This was a direct refutation of the demands being made by teachers unions before they would return to the classrooms. When asked about her statement, White House press secretary Jen Psaki responded Dr. Walensky was speaking “in her personal capacity” and not as the director of the CDC.

In other words, Dr. Walensky hadn’t cleared her statement with the White House. Even though she was their newly appointed scientist to lead the nation’s largest organization for disease prevention, she was not considered the final authority on disease and safety.

Since that day she has learned her lesson. If she wants to keep her job, she must toe the line with the White House. Science must take a backseat to politics, despite all the Biden administration claims they would “follow the science.”

On February 12th, Dr. Walensky held another press conference to clarify the CDC position on reopening schools. In her new statement she said, “We strongly encourage states to prioritize teachers and other school staff to get vaccinated. If we want our children to receive in-person instruction, we must ensure the teachers and school staff are healthy, and protected from getting Covid-19 in places outside of schools where they might be at higher risk.”

Then she added insult to injury when she said, “I want to reassure you that our operational strategy is science based, with the goal of protecting students, teachers, and staff, and their families while getting back to the classroom safely.”

Anyone who is shocked by this turn of events hasn’t been paying attention. President Biden made it clear before he was elected that he was a big fan of the teachers unions. His wife, Jill, is a member of the NEA, the nation’s largest teachers union. The president can only be accused of keeping his promise to the teachers unions, while ignoring his promise to “follow the science.”

The clear winners in this battle are the teachers unions. The clear losers are all the children who can’t return to the classrooms and their agonizing parents. Former N. J. Governor Chris Christie, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says, “The CDC is being used as a political tool, flip-flopping on the science under pressure from the national unions and their Biden administration allies. This betrayal of our children and their families must end. The long-term mental health effects and educational deficits created by continuing this policy will be devastating. It’s time to put our children’s interests first in this pandemic.”

Dr. Walensky has learned a hard lesson; unless you follow the White House political agenda you can be replaced. As a nation we have also learned some hard lessons; for the next four years the CDC has lost all credibility and “follow the science” means whatever the Biden administration says it means.

 

Vaccines Versus the Variants

 

As more and more Americans get vaccinated, optimism for the future of this pandemic should be on the rise. Yet many are fearful of the new coronavirus variants detected in other parts of the world, and recently some of those in the U.S. Should we be worried?

Naturally, the media wants us to be fearful; they seem to believe that’s their special role. Yet news from the world is mostly comforting. A recent report from London declared the vaccine developed by AstraZeneca/University of Oxford is effective against a variant of the coronavirus that is spreading rapidly in the U.S. and around the world. This is a reassuring sign for governments banking on mass vaccinations to bring the pandemic to an end.

Other manufacturers reported similar results including Pfizer and Moderna. They found their Covid-19 shots offer protection against new virus variants that have contributed to a fresh surge in cases in the U.K., Europe, South Africa, and elsewhere. Nevertheless, these same vaccine makers are preparing new shots that zero in on the new variants even more precisely. It is likely that such adaptation in the vaccines may be needed in the future much like changes in the flu vaccine are made annually.

Speculation abounds about the new variants and many suggest they are more easily transmissible than the original Covid-19. Some even suggest these may be deadlier, but this is all speculation at this time. Current studies indicate the AstraZeneca vaccine is about 75% effective against the new variants while it is 84% effective against the older strains.

Almost 120 million doses of vaccine have been administered world-wide, according to figures compiled by oxford’s Our World in Data project. Some countries have been more aggressive than others, with Israel and the U.K. moving rapidly to inoculate their most-at-risk citizens. Vaccine makers say the technology behind Covid-19 vaccines should allow them to swiftly retool their production lines to produce shots targeted more precisely at new and emerging variants.

There has been more cause for concern in South Africa. AstraZeneca has temporarily paused a small clinical trial when it appeared to fail to protect recipients against mild and moderate illness from a new variant found only in that country. The country plans to temporarily halt rollout of the vaccine until there is more information on the vaccine’s efficacy.

Johnson & Johnson and Novavax, whose vaccines have yet to be authorized in any country, have also found that their shots were less effective in recent clinical trials in South Africa, compared with trials in the U.S. or U.K. Yet their vaccines were still found to be 50% or more effective at preventing mild or moderate cases of Covid-19 and even more potent at shielding recipients from severe illness and hospitalization from the new strain. The South African health minister still intends to deploy the J & J vaccine soon and has ordered 9 million doses. The J & J vaccine was found to provide 57% efficacy with one shot at preventing mild and moderate cases of Covida-19 and 85% efficacy preventing severe illness.

We are blessed to have so many vaccines available for these new viruses in such a short time. It has only been a year since this pandemic began and there are now two vaccines authorized and being delivered in this country already, and two more likely in the coming weeks. This competition between vaccine makers has been made possible by the public-private partnerships initiated by Operation Warp Speed and these companies will continue to develop new vaccines as more variants of the virus appear worldwide. These vaccines represent the most effective means for ending this pandemic and should be embraced by everyone whenever possible.

School Choice Gaining Momentum

 

School Choice is gaining momentum. Ironically, the credit for this trend probably goes to the teachers unions. By their unwavering assault on public schools and refusal to return to the classrooms, the unions are driving students out of those schools.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says the Biden administration seems committed to indulging teachers unions that oppose charter and private schools. This is no surprise since First Lady, Jill Biden, is a member of the NEA, the nation’s largest teachers union. Even though newly appointed CDC Director, Dr. Rochelle Walensky, recently said, “Vaccination of teachers is not a prerequisite for safe reopening of schools”, the Biden administration has not called for teachers unions to return to the classrooms.

Republican legislatures in more than a dozen states are responding to parental frustration with school closures by introducing legislation to expand school choice. In Iowa, the Senate passed a bill to provide students assigned to low-performing public schools with education savings accounts (ESAs), which are similar to vouchers but can also be used for textbooks, tutoring and more. Parents can roll over unused funds to future years.

The Iowa legislation would also allow charter schools that are independent of local school districts; today the state has only two charter schools. The bill increases a tuition-and-textbook tax credit from a maximum of $250 to $1,000 per student and extends the credit to home schoolers. Iowa Governor Kim Reynolds says, “If there’s one thing the pandemic has taught us about education, it’s that our parents need choice. And it’s not just in-person versus virtual.”

In my home state of Florida, Republican state Senator Manny Diaz has introduced a bill to consolidate the state’s current scholarship programs into taxpayer-funded ESAs. Nearly 200,000 students currently participate in the state’s existing programs, only one of which uses ESAs. The ESAs would give parents more flexibility in how they use the money.

In the state of Arizona, a Republican state Senator is proposing to expand eligibility for the state’s ESAs, which are currently used by fewer than 10,000 students, to low-income students across the state. Republicans are also pushing to expand the aggregate cap for the states’ tax credit scholarship program to $20 million from $5 million over three years. In New Hampshire and Missouri, GOP legislators are also pushing ESA bills. Nebraska legislators are debating a new tax-credit scholarship program.

The impact of public-school closings due to the pandemic is decimating the rolls of public schools. WSJ says public schools in 33 states have lost 500,000 students since the 2019-2020 school year, according to a December Associated Press-Chalkbeat analysis. Many parents with the financial means have enrolled their children in private or parochial schools or formed “pods” with classmates taught by tutors. Some are home-schooling.

For those parents who cannot afford these options, school choice is needed. They already pay through their taxes for public schools that remain closed and remote learning is leaving their children far behind. This could leave their children with lifetime damaging consequences.

To be sure, this situation was predictable. Joe Biden made it clear in his campaign that he would be on the side of the teachers unions and he has kept his word.  WSJ says, “The union boycott of in-school instruction during the pandemic has been a frustrating revelation for millions of parents. All the more so because too many politicians, including those in the Biden administration, are beholden to the unions. Republicans are smart to use this instructive moment to give students more alternatives to the unions school monopoly.”

Maybe Joe Biden will be the best thing to ever happen to the school choice movement.