Biden’s Payback to Teachers’ Unions

 

The fox is about to get the key to the henhouse. The inmates are running the asylum. These cliches don’t begin to describe the insanity that may soon be reality.

It is well known that Joe Biden supports the teachers’ unions. Since his wife, Jill, is a member of the NEA teachers’ union, he openly declared to the union, “When we win this election, we’re going to get the support you need and the respect you deserve. You don’t just have a partner in the White House, you’ll have an NEA member in the White House. And if I’m not listening, I’m going to be sleeping alone in the Lincoln Bedroom.” Little did we know how serious he was.

William McGurn, writing in The Wall Street Journal, tells us Biden is now considering the leaders of the two largest teachers’ unions for Secretary of Education. The two names most often mentioned in his discussions are American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten and former National Education Association President Lily Eskelsen Garcia.

McGurn explains the insanity of this idea: “Everyone has understood that a Biden Education Department would mark a change of direction from the past four years. But to elevate to education secretary someone whose career has been spent fighting any reform aimed at relaxing the teachers unions’ stranglehold on the public schools would be an astonishingly bleak admission about whose interests come first.”

“Appointing either Weingarten or Garcia would be the biggest union payback since Jimmy Carter created the Department of Education in 1979,” says Jeanne Allen, who is founder and CEO of the Center for Education Reform and worked in the Reagan Education Department. “It’s a sign that the teachers’ unions now own him lock, stock, and barrel.”

The teachers’ unions have made it clear they prefer school lockdowns to education. I have written about this in earlier posts (Teachers Unions Weaponize Covid-19) (Children Suffering Under Covid and Teachers Unions).

There is no question that lockdowns are hurting the education of children. A recent Stanford University study of 19 states estimates that students lost on average between 57 to 183 days of learning in reading and 136 to 232 days in math during the spring closures. New York City students lost 122 days in reading and 209 days in math – essentially a year of education in a few months.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) has said, “In person learning is in the best interest of students, when compared to virtual learning.” The CDC has further laid out guidelines for how schools can reopen safely. Instead of cooperating, however, the teachers unions have largely held students hostage to their demands.

McGurn gives us an example. Resistance from the teachers unions forced the District of Columbia to scrap a plan that would have brought about 7,000 kids back for limited in-person learning starting November 9. These were among the most at-risk students in Washington’s school system. The Washington Post reported the president of the Washington Teachers Union characterized the cancellation as a “win.”

These school closures are justified by the teachers unions on health grounds, claiming they are necessary to protect teachers and staff from Covid-19. But they have been embarrassed that private and parochial schools have managed, often working with a far smaller staff and less resources, to resume classroom instruction while keeping the virus at bay. Recent closures of schools in New York City were declared necessary by the teachers unions despite the fact that merely 0.074% of students have tested positive over the last two months, and only 0.0011% on November 11, the day of the order. That’s one in a hundred thousand children.

If Biden actually goes through with this idea to place a teachers’ union president in charge of the Department of Education, he might as well change the name to the Department of Teachers Unions – since education will be their least priority.

 

Children Suffering Under Covid and Teachers’ Unions

 

Children are perhaps the least vulnerable demographic of our population to the Covid pandemic, but they are being disproportionately harmed. Despite exceedingly low rates of infection and negligible mortality, children in many parts of the country are being forced to stay home from school. This is not based on science, but on partisan politics – and especially teachers’ unions.

Case in point is a recent report in The Wall Street Journal of New York Teachers Union chief, Michael Mulgrew, who told parents to brace for another round of school shutdowns. New York Mayor Bill de Blasio naturally complied with the teachers’ union chief’s directive. The rationale for this egregious interruption of education is based on the virus testing positive rate that neared the arbitrary threshold of 3%.

But the benchmark is based on the city population, not schools. Merely 0.074% of students have tested positive over the last two months, and only 0.0011% on November 11, the day of the order. That’s one in a hundred thousand children. If New York City’s 1,126,000 million student population was its own metro region, it would have among the lowest per-capita case rates in the U.S. Only 955 of the 150,000 or so public-school employees have tested positive since mid-September. Most evidence shows children are less likely to transmit the virus than adults, so schools are less likely to be sources of contagion than are the city’s restaurants or offices, which are still open.

Further evidence to support this conclusion comes from Brown University economics professor Emily Oster, who has been tracking virus cases at a sample of schools with more than three million students and 422,000 staff. She reports there have been substantially fewer cases among students and teachers than among local populations. But this makes no difference to teachers’ unions.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board concludes what should be obvious to everyone – children are the last priority of teachers’ unions. This is demonstrated by their ferocious fight to block charter school expansions and to keep bad teachers in classrooms. Reams of data show that closing schools in the spring has cost students substantially.

What is the impact of the pandemic on the education of children?

A recent Stanford University study of 19 states estimates that students lost on average between 57 to 183 days of learning in reading and 136 to 232 days in math during the spring closures. New York City students lost 122 days in reading and 209 days in math – essentially a year of education in a few months.

These losses in days of education have been quantified by researchers at the University of Pennsylvania in estimating lost future wages.  They estimate that lower education quality during schools’ closures “costs current students between $12,000 and $15,000 in future earnings, varying by age. By October 1, 2020, we project students in grades 1-12 had lost between $43,000 and $57,000, or 4 to 5 percent of their lifetime wage earnings.”

Don’t expect this to get better under a Biden presidency. Jill Biden is a member of the NEA teachers’ union and Joe Biden has already declared to the teachers’ unions, “When we win this election, we’re going to get the support you need and the respect you deserve. You don’t just have a partner in the White House, you’ll have an NEA member in the White House. And if I’m not listening, I’m going to be sleeping alone in the Lincoln Bedroom.”

The education of our children is the future of our country. That future has taken a serious hit with the election of a president who is sympathetic to teachers’ unions. It’s not a good time to be a child.

(Note: The New York City schools closed on November 19th when they reached the 3% positivity rate.)

Masks Are Not All Created Equal

 

Masks have become the newest fashion accessory. My wife was given three masks recently as a hospitality gift from another woman. They came in three different colors and patterns so she could match them with various outfits. She’s already thinking about which one to wear on Thanksgiving.

We’ve come a long way from the early days of the Covid pandemic when we were first told by U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams that we didn’t need masks. Today, we can be escorted out of stores and restaurants if we’re not wearing one. But does it matter which kind of mask we wear?

Scott Gottlieb, former commissioner of the FDA, says it does. Writing in The Wall Street Journal, Gottlieb says many Americans could protect themselves better if they simply bought a better mask. Not all masks are created equal and therefore not all masks provide the same protection.

Gottlieb says, “A cotton mask offers far less protection than a surgical mask. If a cloth mask is all you can find, buy a thick one. Snug-fitting masks made of cotton-polyester blends will generally offer more protection. But even a very good cloth mask may only be about 30% protective; scarf or bandanna, 10% or less.”

“A surgical mask could offer you better protection, on the order of 60%. But here again, quality matters. Many of the masks sold on Amazon, which say they are for dust and allergens, aren’t surgical masks, even though they look like the blue masks worn by nurses and doctors. A real medical-procedure mask will be cleared by the FDA and designated as offering one of three levels of protection. Generally, a level 2 or level 3 medical mask is best.”

If you want even greater protection, consider an N95 mask, which when used properly, will filter out at least 95% of infectious particles. These must be properly fitted to be effective and they cost more. Equivalent masks are sold in China under the designation KN95 and in Europe as FFP2. These masks have been authorized for emergency use by the FDA and have been tested to show they offer comparable protection to the N95 mask. Beware of counterfeits that claim equivalent protection but have not undergone rigid testing.

The cost of masks is declining after exorbitant prices during the early pandemic days. The normal cost of surgical masks before the pandemic was about 20 cents per mask. During the early pandemic, when shortages were widespread, I was forced to pay more than $1.00 per mask. Just yesterday I found the same masks on sale for about 16 cents each.

The N95 masks may sell for $5 or more per mask. But they may be worth the investment if you find yourself often in high-risk environments. These masks can be reused if properly disinfected. The Department of Homeland Security has published instructions online on disinfecting and reusing N95 masks that can extend their life.

Masks are a necessary reality of our lives today, though this will likely change once the vaccines are widely distributed. With three successful vaccines already in the pipeline, the world can look forward with optimism to a time soon when masks will not be necessary. Until then, find a mask you’re comfortable wearing and wear it when necessary. But remember, not all masks are created equal.