Mask Wearing is a Distraction from Reality

 

By now everyone in the world is getting used to wearing masks. It’s safe to say we’re all tired of this “new normal”, but we’re now conditioned to believe it’s necessary. But do masks really make a difference?

The answer to that question is elusive. In the beginning of this pandemic, we were told not to wear masks, unless you were a healthcare worker or first responder. Surgeon General Jerome Adams tweeted in February, “Seriously people- STOP BUYING MASKS! They are NOT effective in preventing general public from catching #Coronavirus, but if healthcare providers can’t get them to care for sick patients, it puts them and our communities at risk!”

Dr. Anthony Fauci, who the press has elevated to near-divine authority, said, “Wearing a mask might make people feel a little bit better” but “it’s not providing the perfect protection that people think it is.” His statement reflected scientific consensus, and was consistent with the World Health Organization’s guidance.

Dr. Joseph Ladapo, professor at UCLA Medical School, gives us more up-to-date insights in an Op-ed in The Wall Street Journal. Weak arguments for mask wearing include preventing asymptomatic transmission of the virus. This has always been true of influenza where some estimates show up to a third of patients with influenza are asymptomatic. But no one ever called for mask wearing with influenza. Anecdotal evidence of outbreaks in isolated communities is never a basis for nation-wide policy.

High value evidence comes from a study published in Health Affairs in June which found that those U.S. states with mask mandates had 2% lower growth rates of Covid infection compared with those who didn’t. But this difference will certainly not prevent the wide-spread dissemination of the virus.

Ladapo states, “The most reasonable conclusion from the available scientific evidence is that community mask mandates have—at most—a small effect on the course of the pandemic. But you wouldn’t know that from watching cable news or sitting next to a mother being forced off an airplane because her small children aren’t able to keep a mask on.”

Claims that low mask compliance is responsible for rising case counts are also not supported by Gallup data, which show that the percentage of Americans reporting wearing masks has been high and relatively stable since June. Health officials and political leaders have assigned mask mandates a gravity unsupported by empirical research.

Ladapo suggests the most unscientific use of masks is for those outdoors. One contact-tracing study identified only a single incident of outdoor transmission among 318 outbreaks. Even the Rose Garden nomination ceremony for Justice Amy Coney Barrett, which the media giddily labeled a “superspreader” event, likely wasn’t; transmission more likely occurred during indoor gatherings associated with the ceremony.

Ladapo says the oversized attention to wearing masks has the unintended consequence of delaying public acceptance of the unavoidable truth. For a novel coronavirus, one that the world has never been previously exposed to, nothing short of inhumane lockdowns, and all of their unacceptable consequences, is likely to stop the spread of the virus. The best approach is to protect the most vulnerable and learn to live with the virus until an effective vaccine and the achievement of herd immunity brings the pandemic to an end.

He concludes, “Until the reality of viral spread in the U.S.—with or without mask mandates—is accepted, political leaders will continue to feel justified in keeping schools and businesses closed, robbing young people of the opportunity to invest in their futures, and restricting activities that make life worthwhile. Policy makers ought to move forward with more wisdom and sensibility to mitigate avoidable costs to human life and well-being.”

 

 

Trump Lowers Drug Prices – Good or Bad Idea? – Part II

(This was originally posted 7/17/20.)

(Author’s note: As we enter the last few weeks of the presidential campaign, there are several campaign issues which have been previously addressed in this blog. These include Medicare for All, single-payer healthcare, socialism, school choice and others. In the next few weeks I will be re-posting many of my previous posts on these issues as a review for voters. For this limited time I will be posting five days a week instead of the usual twice a week. These earlier posts will be intermingled with new posts on current topics.)

 

Last post I discussed the Trump executive orders to reduce drug prices. I outlined the Trump plan with the following points:

  • Ban drug-maker rebates in Medicare Part D
  • Benchmarking Medicare’s reimbursement rates to International Pricing Index
  • Specific lowering of drugs at Federally Qualified Health Centers

 

The Wall Street Journal editorial board opposes this plan and I discussed their reasons. For a review of their reasons for opposition, visit Part I. Today I will discuss another point of view from one who supports this plan.

Support for the Trump Plan

Avik Roy, healthcare economist writing in Forbes, supports the Trump plan. Roy supports the International Pricing Index (IPI), although he would prefer if the benchmark focused on countries with private health insurance, instead of single-payer systems, like Canada and the United Kingdom. While Medicare can generate savings by using an index that includes single-payer nations, it would generate even greater savings if the index was focused on countries with the most market-oriented health care systems.

He says the latest Trump plan, which calls for HHS Secretary Alex Azar to come up with a plan to test whether such a rule would reduce costs and improve outcomes, turbocharges the IPI. Instead of Medicare paying drug companies at the average price of a group of industrialized countries, Medicare would pay the lowest price among comparably wealthy nations.

He states this makes eminent sense. In any normal market, the biggest purchaser of a product is able to negotiate the lowest bulk price for that product. In the bizarre world of Medicare dug spending, taxpayers are forced to pay the highest price even though they represent the largest market in the world for prescription drugs. Furthermore, the most-favored-nation approach will do the most to reduce seniors’ out-of-pocket costs, and the most to reduce entitlement spending and thereby the deficit.

He supports the Trump plan which requires pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs) to pass their discounts or “rebates” directly to the patients using those drugs, in way that would improve the efficiency of the prescription drug market and lower costs for seniors. He says that rebates amount to about $30 billion a year.

He also approves of eliminating providers from jacking up rates on drugs they obtain through the federally supported FQHCs and pocketing the difference. He argues these drugs have been provided by federal support and patients must not be overcharged when they receive treatment.

The drug lobby argues that these interventions by the Trump administration will undermine the “free market” for prescription drugs. Roy says a truly “free market” for prescription drugs does not exist in the U.S. He makes two points:

  • Branded drugs in the U.S. are protected by government-imposed and government-enforced monopolies through the patent system. Monopolies are not markets. He argues drug-makers have used the system to extend their monopolies through trivial and non-innovative modifications to existing drugs in order to continue raising their prices.
  • The U.S. health care system makes it easy for drug makers to charge whatever they want. The tax exclusion for employer-sponsored insurance prevents patients from shopping for the coverage and care that serves them best. Insurance mandates force coverage of certain drugs regardless of their cost. Medicare Part B effectively writes blank checks to drug companies to charge whatever they think they can without causing excessive reputational damage.

 

Roy concludes with these words: “President Trump has many faults, but he deserves credit for tearing up this stale ideological oaf. His executive order could save tens of billions in taxpayer funds, and help millions of low-and middle-income Americans better afford their medicines.”

There you have it – two opposing points of view on an issue we all can relate to. We all want lower drug prices but we also want new and innovative drugs available as soon as possible. The Covid-19 pandemic has made this issue highly relevant as we all wait eagerly for the development of new drug therapies and an effective vaccine.

Is this new Trump plan to lower drug prices a good or a bad idea?

Let me know what you think.

A Tragic Lesson About Socialism

 

(This was originally posted 9/10/18.)

(Author’s note: Today is Halloween. I can’t think of a scarier idea than socialism in America. This post recalls the tragic consequences of socialism in Venezuela today.)

 

For most people with any gray hairs it is a given that socialism is evil. The lessons of the failed governments of Cuba and the Soviet Union are still fresh in our memories.

But for many young people socialism has become the “latest thing.” Recent polls suggest as many as 43% of Americans favor socialism over capitalism – and most of these are young people. Unfortunately, they are being led down this destructive path by an elder statesman, Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont, and his young acolyte, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, Democratic Congressional candidate from New York.

The evils of socialism are being demonstrated in dramatic fashion not far from our southern border in Venezuela. Venezuela is a tragic example how socialism has brought economic disaster and resultant famine and hyperinflation upon a nation with the world’s richest oil reserves!

This dramatic real-world tragedy is playing out in Venezuela while American socialists talk of utopian dreams with their heads firmly planted in the sand. The real story is told by Daniel Pipes, president of the Middle East Forum, in a article published in The Wall Street Journal.

Pipes gives us the background needed to understand just how bad socialism can be. Venezuela discovered vast oil reserves in 1914 that brought the country vast revenues and produced a relatively free economy. By 1950 Venezuela enjoyed the fourth highest per capita income in the world, behind only the U.S., Switzerland, and New Zealand. As late as 1980, it boasted the world’s fastest growing economy in the 20th century.

However, beginning in 1958, government interference in the economy, including price and exchange controls, higher taxes, and restrictions on property rights, led to decades of stagnation. Per capita real income declined0.13% from 1960-1997, despite their strong oil production.

A Tragic Decline

Pipes tells us the reality of Venezuela today:

“Today the country with the world’s largest oil reserves suffers from a severely contracting economy, runaway inflation, despotism, mass emigration, criminality, disease, hunger and starvation, with circumstances deteriorating daily. Venezuela’s economy contracted by 16% in 2016, 14% last year and a predicted 15% in 2018. Inflation was at 112% in 2015 and 2,800% at the end of last year. Economist Steve Hanke finds an annualized rate of around 65,000% for 2018, making Venezuela’s one of the most severe hyperinflations ever. Food shortages led to an average weight loss among Venezuelans of 18 pounds in 2016 and 24 pounds in 2017.”

 

What caused this crisis?

Socialism. Hugo Chavez convinced Venezuelans to try it in 1999, then stole, dominated, polarized and jailed anyone who disagreed. With about a $1 trillion in oil sales during his 14 years as president, he had the means to launch massive social spending programs to secure votes to strengthen his control. Then he replaced oil professionals with his agents, stooges, and sycophants further consolidating control.

As former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher once said, “The trouble with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people’s money.”

Hugo Chavez didn’t reach that situation because he died in 2013, about a year before oil prices tumbled, when he sought cancer treatment in Cuba and was “assassinated by Cuban malpractice” according to Fox News reports. However, his successor, Nicolas Maduro, has proven even more brutal and incompetent. The result of Maduro’s handling of the economy is the disaster chronicled above.

The lesson of the evils of socialism could not be clearer for the world today. It is the job of our national media, and all clear-thinking Americans, to educate people to the tragedy playing out not far from our southern beaches. It’s time our young people stopped listening to the sirens of socialism and got in touch with reality.