Should Teens Have Confidential Time With the Doctor?

 

The teenage years are a difficult time of transition from childhood to adult. Physical and emotional changes occur rapidly and many teens suffer from lack of self-confidence and insecurity. This is nothing new; indeed it has been happening since man first inhabited the world.

But now there is a push from some to allow teens the privacy of confronting these issues with their doctor – without a parent in attendance. In an age when schools can’t give an aspirin to a child without parental permission, this is a radical change.

Brianna Abbott, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says, “Adolescent-health experts and doctors are stepping up efforts to increase teenagers’ access to confidential health care and help them develop skills to navigate their own health care. Groups such as the American Academy of Family Physicians, the American Academy of Pediatrics and others have long pushed for adolescents to have individual time with their doctors, but these recommendations are unevenly practiced, pediatricians and adolescent-medicine specialists say.”

Abbott describes how this works: “When Hannah Regan was about 14 years old, her family doctor in Kentucky started a new routine. During checkups, the doctor would ask Hannah’s mother to briefly step out of the exam room, Then, in private, Hannah would discuss a questionnaire she filled out about smoking, drinking, mental health and other sensitive issues. There were awkward moments, she says, but she appreciated the time alone with her doctor.”

The implication of this change is that doctors know what’s best for your son or daughter and you should trust them to steer your child in the right direction – both medically and morally. The authority for this change comes from academic medical institutions such as the American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Academy of Family Physicians.

As a parent, should you support this change? Can you trust your child’s physician to share your moral convictions? The answer should be a firm No!

The American Medical Association (AMA) was the largest organization of physicians in the United States when I became a doctor forty years ago. I trusted they would represent the best medical opinions and share my moral convictions regarding medical treatments. I was wrong.

I soon learned the AMA supported abortions and organizations like Planned Parenthood that provided abortions. They encouraged homosexuality even though the homosexual community was being devastated by the AIDS epidemic. They promoted condoms for prevention of sexually transmitted disease but never suggested abstinence outside of marriage would be more effective. They chose the path of political correctness rather than suggest any sort of moral convictions. (Today the AMA represents only about one in four American doctors.)

These are the same people who want you to trust them to provide your teenager with the best medical and moral advice. You cannot trust them to suggest abstinence from sexual activity when a birth control pill will prevent the only medical problem they’re concerned about. You cannot believe they will object to things like alcohol, marijuana, or other substance abuses except in excesses that will cause obvious harm to their health. Doctors are much more tuned in to disease treatment than prevention.

Parents who are willing to cooperate in this push for teen confidentiality are abdicating their parental responsibility. It may be much easier for them to let the doctor talk about sensitive issues but the result may not be what they expect.  Doctors can’t be expected to be parents. They especially can’t be expected to keep secrets from parents that may impact the health of their child. Parenting is a tough job – but no one else should be asked to fill your shoes. Take the time to really be a parent. If your teenager has more trust in the doctor than you, you’ve got work to do!

The Democrats’ New Health Plan

 

Nancy Pelosi is running from Medicare for All. Despite all the hoopla by presidential candidates to jump on Bernie Sanders’ bandwagon, the Speaker of the House realizes that’s a trap that will hurt their party and the country.

Instead, she is proposing new legislation to “make ObamaCare work better.” This is actually in line with polling that says most of the country would prefer improving ObamaCare over Medicare for All. But is this new legislation she is proposing getting it right?

John C. Goodman, healthcare economist writing in Forbes, analyzes her plan and finds it has three elements:

  • Expanding health insurance subsidies to everyone.
  • Creating a national reinsurance pool to subsidize insurance companies
  • Reversing Trump administration regulations that permit limited-benefit insurance.

 

This makes as much sense as Medicare providing government-paid health insurance to seniors only because they are over 65, regardless of income. This new proposal would use taxpayer dollars to subsidize the rich who don’t need subsidies. It would also prop up expensive premiums to help insurance companies who also don’t need any help. In addition, it forces healthy families to buy insurance that doesn’t meet their needs for a price that is artificially high – just like current ObamaCare.

But Goodman says the worst feature of the plan is that it doesn’t solve ObamaCare’s most important problem: people with chronic health conditions are unable to see the best doctors and enter the best hospitals.

Both parties are trying to earn the public’s trust when it comes to healthcare. The Democrats have been more successful in convincing voters they will protect their healthcare – even though they created the current failing system entirely on their own. But they have demagogued the issue, with the help of the mainstream media, and most people falsely believe Republicans will take away important protections for their healthcare.

The result is premiums have doubled, deductibles have doubled and tripled, and access to care is increasingly restricted to an ever-narrower network of providers.

Goodman explains that all this has happened because ObamaCare has perverse incentives. Insurance companies are incentivized to attract only the young and healthy and avoid the sick. They hold down costs by only using providers who will accept the lowest fees. The best doctors and hospitals refuse these low fees. This has created insurance plans that are little better – and in some cases worse – than Medicaid with a high-deductible (which is even worse than Medicaid!)

This new Democratic plan doesn’t solve any problems and creates some new ones – more taxpayer funding of those who don’t need subsidies and removing Trump regulations that have lowered the cost of health insurance for millions of Americans.

A better model for improvement would mimic the Medicare Advantage plans that forces private insurers to compete for enrollees who pay subsidized premiums. These popular and growing plans with seniors could be applied to all age groups. But Democrats won’t use this model for improvement – because it was originally introduced by Republicans under President George W. Bush.

Winning the Healthcare Debate

 

Who is winning the healthcare debate? Based on the mid-term elections, it seems that Democrats are winning. Is this correct and is it good for the country?

These are critical questions as we move into the 2020 presidential election campaign. The winners in the healthcare debate should be those whose ideas will benefit the healthcare of the citizens most. But that may not be happening.

John C. Goodman, healthcare economist writing in Forbes, thinks the Democrats are winning the debate – but not because they have the best ideas. He blames Republicans for losing because they are always on the defensive and do a poor job of explaining their ideas.

Goodman says the Republicans, under President Trump, have recently done three things that help liberate people from the burdens of ObamaCare:

  • Eliminated the Individual Mandate
  • Allowed purchase of short-term insurance (STLDs)
  • Allowed Association Health Plans (AHPs)

 

These three changes are making healthcare more affordable for millions of Americans. The Council of Economic Advisers (CEA) reports that the people who benefit from these changes will experience a gain worth $45 Billion a year! The CEA concedes that this will lead to slight rises in premiums for middle-income enrollees as healthier people exit ObamaCare, but the benefits to those who gain far outweigh the costs to those who lose.

But Democrats use emotional talking points to overcome facts and reason. They argue that these Republican reforms weaken protections of ObamaCare. Although only about 5% of people with private insurance are buying individual plans, the vast majority, who have employer-provided plans, view the individual market as the market of last resort. Therefore, they vote on emotional reactions to the Democratic scare tactics even though they are not affected.

Goodman says these Democratic scare tactics will continue to be effective in the healthcare debate unless Republicans come up with better answers. He points out four Republican mistakes:

  • Republicans are usually unable to explain why young, healthy families choose “skimpy” plans (STLDs) over “comprehensive” plans (ObamaCare) and why that is the right choice, even when the out-of-pocket premium is the same.

Low-income, healthy families would always prefer a lower-deductible plan even if the total coverage is much less. They don’t have the money to afford high deductible plans that offer much greater coverage and they don’t worry about high expenses from serious illness. ObamaCare forces them to purchase high-deductible comprehensive plans but they prefer the STLDs because they can afford them.

 

  • Republicans do not seem to understand that public insurance and private insurance must complement each other, and they are unable to explain how the complementarity is going to work when they advocate limited benefit insurance.

Sometimes public sector funding does a better job than private funding. Rare birth defects and substance abuse including alcoholic mothers are good examples. Goodman suggests public coverage for these conditions be available for everyone and only an option in private insurance. Otherwise, private insurance gets too expensive.

 

  • Republicans have never been able to explain convincingly how care for people with pre-existing conditions will be just as good or better under any proposal they have ever favored.

To counter this problem, Pete Sessions, Mark Meadows and other House Republicans proposed a House resolution on pre-existing conditions last year. It said that in any reform of ObamaCare, states must:

  1. Guarantee that people with health problems will get better health insurance.
  2. Set as an attainable goal: People who migrate from the group market to the individual market should be able to find similar insurance in terms of price, quality and access to care.
  3. Allow health plans to specialize and offer better care for such conditions as cancer, heart disease and diabetes.

 This is a good way to assure voters they are looking out for them.

  • While everyone agrees that the healthy subsidize the sick under ObamaCare, Republicans have never explained the alternative. Who should subsidize the sick and how should that subsidy work?

Most Americans get their health insurance from their employer because the federal government doesn’t tax it as income. But when you leave your employer because you are sick, you’re forced to purchase your own insurance when you need it most and can afford it least. A better solution is to allow states to impose a small premium tax on all group insurance that would subsidize above-average-cost patients forced into the individual market. Employers could avoid the tax by helping their employees buy individually owned insurance – which travels from job to job (like an IRA).

Healthcare is a complex issue not easily explained to voters. Republicans have better ideas but Democrats have better talking points that stress scare tactics over facts. If Republicans want to win over voters in the healthcare debate, they will have to be better communicators.