ObamaCare Still Alive – But On Life Support

 

If you’re covered by ObamaCare health insurance you can relax. It’s not going away anytime soon.

Federal Judge Reed O’Connor recently declared ObamaCare was unconstitutional. The ruling came as a result of 20 state attorneys general who sued because they believed the Affordable Care Act’s Individual Mandate is no longer legal. The judge ruled in their favor – and then declared the whole law unconstitutional without the Individual Mandate.

This issue was reviewed in 2012 by the Supreme Court when the Obama administration was challenged even before the new healthcare law was implemented. The Individual Mandate was considered the financial lynchpin of the law because it coerced Americans to purchase healthcare insurance – which the architects of the law felt was necessary to fund the system. However, they denied it was a tax and insisted it was simply a penalty for non-compliance.

Chief Justice John Roberts of SCOTUS broke a tie by declaring the law constitutional – but only if the Individual Mandate penalty was actually a tax. He said the government had a right to tax those who failed to comply with the Individual Mandate – even if the Democrats who passed the law insisted it wasn’t a tax!

This controversial ruling has always been a stumbling block for acceptance of the law and when the Trump administration pushed repeal of the mandate, which Congress passed along with the tax reform legislation of 2017, it gave Republicans the excuse they were looking for to challenge the law in court.

Legal Issues to Overcome

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton argued in Texas v. U.S. that since Congress has repealed the mandate, the tax is no longer a tax, and ObamaCare is thus illegal. Judge O’Connor agreed with that logic. However, one legal complication is that Congress in 2017 repealed the financial part of the Individual Mandate, not the structure of the mandate itself. Republicans used budget rules to pass tax reform so they couldn’t repeal the mandate’s express language.

There is also something called reliance interests to consider. Because the law has been operating since 2014, there are millions of Americans who currently rely on the law for their healthcare insurance. These interests argue against judges repealing the law by fiat.

Then there is the issue of severability. This doctrine calls for restraint in declaring an entire law illegal merely because one part of it is. The WSJ believes even the right-leaning Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals (Texas) judges will overturn Judge O’Connor on this point.

Therefore, there is little reason for panic if you are covered by ObamaCare. The law remains in effect while this judge’s ruling is appealed to the Fifth Circuit Court and there is good reason to believe the ruling will be overturned.

Democrats will use this ruling to pound Republicans for denying health insurance for pre-existing conditions if the law is overturned – when that was never their intention. But this demagoguery was quite effective in the Mid-term elections.

Republicans must beware a panic reaction that leads them to comprise their interests in improving on ObamaCare by striking a deal with Democrats that reinforces ObamaCare. It is still a poor healthcare system that needs replacing.

ObamaCare is Getting Better

 

ObamaCare enrollment is down 11% from last year. Yet in the recent mid-term elections, Democrats were able to convince many voters they should trust them to protect their healthcare.

This paradox of declining ObamaCare popularity mixed with voter loyalty to Democrats on healthcare is largely due to the media’s refusal to give President Trump credit for anything. In fact, the Trump administration is continuing to improve ObamaCare – without Congressional cooperation.

President Obama made a habit of using executive orders to enact legislation he couldn’t get through Congress. President Trump has followed his example in this age of partisan politics. While the Supreme Court struck down many of the Obama executive orders, the Trump changes to ObamaCare have yet to be challenged. That may be because most people regard the changes as good news.

John C. Goodman, healthcare economist writing in Forbes, details the improvements Trump has made or proposed. Here is his list:

Personal and portable health insurance

Employer-provided health insurance is not taxed so employees receive this without a tax consequence. However, individuals who purchase their own health insurance must pay for it out of income that is taxed (both federal and state income taxes and FICA payroll taxes). This makes it very beneficial to receive your health insurance through your employer.

Therefore, when people leave their job and must find their own individual health insurance policy, there is a large additional expense for taxes. This also contributes to the “pre-existing condition” problem that has received much attention in the media. Before ObamaCare, these pre-existing conditions allowed many insurers to deny coverage to some people with chronic health conditions.

By allowing people to take their healthcare insurance with them when they leave their job we could solve both problems. Yet, the Obama administration penalized employers who did this by fining them $100 per employee per day, or $36,500 per employee per year – the largest fine of all in ObamaCare.

The Trump administration is proposing to get rid of those fines and actually encourage the purchase of individually owned insurance, using employer funds, through something called a health Reimbursement Arrangement (HRA). Small businesses are already allowed to do this as a result of the 21st Century Cures Act, passed in 2016. The new Trump proposal is to allow all employers to do the same.

To facilitate this change and make ObamaCare more popular, the Trump administration announced states will have the ability to:

  • Create risk pools and/or risk reinsurance
  • Create defined contribution accounts
  • Use ObamaCare money to create a new and different system of subsidies
  • Create new insurance options including non-qualified health plans

 

The Treasury Department has estimated as many as 10 million people will obtain individually owned insurance through their employers under these new rules. Harvard Business School’s Regina Herzlinger thinks the number could be much higher than that.

Tax Fairness

These changes will go a long way toward leveling the playing field when it comes to tax fairness. For higher income families, purchase of their health insurance will mean substantial tax benefits. For lower income families who don’t pay income taxes, their only tax subsidy at work is the avoidance of the payroll tax. With these changes these families will be able to use employer money to obtain subsidized insurance in the exchanges.

Flexible Savings Accounts

More than 30 million Americans have a Health Savings Account (HSA). These accounts allow them to manage some of their healthcare dollars but these accounts are rigidly constrained. HRAs, by contrast, can wrap around any health insurance plan and are available to pay for expenses insurance doesn’t apply. Employer deposits to HRAs would give employees access to the full range of products available on the individual market. Money not spent on premiums would be available to pay other expenses, including deductibles and copayments.

Insurance Tailored to Family Needs

Under the new executive order, employers can deposit up to $1,800 in an Excepted Benefit HRA, from which employees can purchase all types of primary care, including phone and email consultation, Uber-type house calls, services at walk-in clinics, etc. These options were unavailable with original ObamaCare. Now families can tailor their insurance to their specific needs.

Free Market Health Insurance

The Trump administration has increased the duration of Short Term Limited Duration (STLD) health plans from 3months (Obama) to 12 months and allowed guaranteed renewals for up to 3 years. These plans are much cheaper than ObamaCare because they do not have to conform to all ObamaCare regulations.

The Trump administration has also allowed the sale of a separate plan, called Health Status Insurance, which protects people from premium increases due to changes in health condition should they want to buy STLDs for another 3 years.

With these two plans purchased together, people can remain insured indefinitely with plans that mimic a typical employer-provided plan. Estimates of expected enrollees in such plans range from 1.9 to 4.3 million. Goodman believes even these estimates are too conservative. He says, “Yet as long as people are free to chose insurance that meets individual and family needs and as long as it is fairly priced, I think the real number will be even higher.”

 

 

Flu Shot or Not?

 

It’s that time of the year again. No, I don’t mean Christmas. I mean that time when we all have to decide whether or not to get a flu shot.

Many people skip the flu shot vaccine because they don’t think they need it – or they don’t think it will be effective. Either way you’re taking a big risk. At the very least you’ll suffer through weeks of flu symptoms that will probably keep you out of work for at least a few days. At worst it could actually be fatal. (My maternal grandmother died in the flu epidemic of 1918.)

As of November 9, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) was reporting moderate flu activity in Georgia, Louisiana and Oklahoma, and low or minimal activity across the remainder of the country. Influenza A (H1N1), influenza A (H3N2), and influenza B viruses are all circulating, with influenza A (H1N1) being the predominant strain so far. The CDC says this one has shown up in 78.3% of samples tested since late September, with H3N2 21.7% and influenza B 13.1%.

The good news is this year’s influenza vaccine contains an A (H1N1) – like virus, an A (H3N2) – like virus, and a B – like virus. The quadrivalent vaccines include these three viruses plus a B 2013 – like virus (Yamagata lineage). This means this year’s vaccines are likely to be effective. As of November 9, 159 million doses have already been administered.

Did you get yours?

The CDC says coverage with the flu vaccine among adults was 37.1 percent during the 2017-2018 flu season compared to 43.3 percent the prior year. Coverage was lower in every age group last year but vaccination increased with age from 26.9 percent among adults aged 18 – 49 to 59.6 percent among adults aged 65 and up. Lest you think the flu is innocuous, there were 959,000 hospitalizations and 79,400 deaths last year! Overall effectiveness last year was about 40 percent.

Rachael Zimlich, R.N., writing for Medical Economics, says a new seasonal influenza vaccine aimed at senior patients is moving forward in the clinical trials process after showing early success in offering additional protection to this particularly susceptible population. The new nanoparticle, NanoFlu, has moved forward to Phase 2 clinical trials with 1,375 older adults enrolled to assess dose and formulation of the vaccine before moving onto a Phase 3 study – perhaps in 2019 – to test immunogenicity.

“The low effectiveness of seasonal influenza vaccines, and in particular the A (H3N2) component of the vaccine, during the 2017-2018 season emphasizes the need for a more effective vaccine,” said Gregory M. Glenn, M.D., president of research and development at Novavax, the company developing NanoFlu. “We believe this addresses important public health challenges caused by influenza and offers a significant advantage over current influenza vaccines.”

Influenza is a serious illness and should be taken more seriously than many people do. While current influenza vaccines have had mixed success in preventing illness, there is hope for improvement in the future and no reason to spurn the protection currently being offered. Get your flu shot today!