Solving ObamaCare – A New Proposal – Part II

 

In Part I of this series I discussed a new healthcare proposal known as the Health Care Choices Proposal.

Their policy proposal promises to:

  1. Improve choices and lower costs, while protecting vulnerable Americans
  2. Give flexibility and resources to states to achieve those goals
  3. Ensure people can opt into the private coverage of their choice

 

In Part I we learned what their proposal promises to achieve. Today we will learn how they propose to make it work.

How Real Reform Works

  • The federal government would provide a fixed amount of funding to each state – Under ObamaCare, the federal government sends billions of dollars to insurance companies to subsidize insurance policy premiums. Under this proposal, Washington would issue grants to states. The initial grants would be based on the amount of ACA spending as of a fixed date. Then, over time, the grant would be based on a state’s number of low-income residents. States would use the money to help vulnerable citizens obtain coverage.
  • Each state would take responsibility for using federal money to make insurance more affordable – States would be enabled to be laboratories of innovative policy and thereby:
    • Reduce premiums – by reinvigorating broken, private health insurance markets that failed under ObamaCare’s one-size-fits-all structure.
    • Individuals and families would choose the coverage that best fits their needs – With a consumer-centric approach, the insurance markets can offer plans to meet individual needs – more freedom of choice.
    • Give low-income people more choices – Instead of being forced onto Medicaid or a narrow ObamaCare network, these people would be empowered to use their government assistance to buy a private health plan of their choice.
    • Protect people with pre-existing conditions without making coverage so costly for the young and healthy – ObamaCare forced the young and healthy to subsidize the older and sicker Americans. By eliminating the ObamaCare regulations that made this necessary, the cost of coverage will come down – and states will have resources to help people with more expensive conditions access coverage without driving up costs for everyone.
    • States would have better incentives to protect the most vulnerable – instead of chasing federal Medicaid expansion dollars to add new enrollees while neglecting those already on the program and in need.
    • Encourage wider coverage – by removing restrictions on insurers’ ability to use innovative approaches.
    • Spend grant money only on health care – The federal government must hold states accountable for spending federal dollars.

 

Greater Access to HSAs

This proposal would take two key steps to improve HSAs so they can be more flexible, more widely available, and give consumers greater control over how their HSA dollars are spent, including seeing the doctor of their choice.

  • Roughly double HSA contribution limits – from $3,450 per individual and $6,850 per family today.
  • Make more plans HSA-compatible – Today, a policy must have a deductible of at least $1350 (individual) or $2700 (family). This proposal would change the requirement to qualify, so that any plan with an actuarial value less than a specified level (e.g. 70%, 80%) would be HSA-compatible.

 

Is this new proposal the solution?

It does not promise to fix everything that is wrong with our health sector today. But they believe it is the logical next step in helping our private health sector recover from Washington’s failed approach. It is clear that the top-down big government style of ObamaCare – that would get even worse with single-payer systems – is not the answer.

This approach is to empower consumers to have the choices and control they need to protect themselves and their families. Who do you think should be in control of your healthcare – you or the federal government?

Solving ObamaCare – A New Proposal – Part I

 

ObamaCare is failing – everyone who is not a Democratic politician or receiving government subsidies for their healthcare insurance knows that. Even many of those same Democratic politicians who deny the problems are pushing for ObamaCare’s replacement with a single-payer healthcare system.

ObamaCare Failing

ObamaCare average premiums for individual health insurance rose 105% in the first four years since it took effect in 2014 – from $232 to $476 a month on average. As you might expect, the number of people with individual policies continues to fall. Fewer people had individual policies in December 2017 than in December 2014. Also, the number of small firms offering health benefits to their workers dropped by 24% between 2012 and 2016.

The main reason for declining enrollment in ObamaCare is that it forces people to pay more for policies that restrict, rather than expand, their access to care. Networks are getting narrower, deductibles and copays can be prohibitively expensive, and access to doctors and hospitals is limited. Half of all those individuals purchasing coverage on the ObamaCare exchanges have only one “choice” of insurance to purchase. Yet, government spending continues to soar. The “bending of the cost curve down”, as promised by President Obama, never materialized. Just another broken ObamaCare promise.

What is the solution for the rest of us? Republicans failed to garner enough of their own votes and not a single Democratic vote for their repeal and replacement plans. That leaves the country with the same failing system and no present alternative. Single-payer healthcare is not the solution, as demonstrated in the failed systems of Canada, Great Britain, and Sweden. Worse yet, it is unaffordable. What else can we do?

The Health Policy Consensus Group is comprised of state health policy experts, national think tank leaders, and members and leaders of grassroots organizations across the country. They are committed to market-based policy recommendations that give people access to the health plans and doctors they choose at a price they can afford so that they can get the care they need. To achieve that goal they have a plan they call the Health Care Choices Proposal.

Their policy proposal promises to:

  1. Improve choices and lower costs, while protecting vulnerable Americans
  2. Give flexibility and resources to states to achieve those goals
  3. Ensure people can opt into the private coverage of their choice

 

What would this proposal achieve?

  • Empower consumers with more choices – Replace open-ended federal payments to insurance companies with grants to states, so they have resources as well as more flexibility to reinvigorate broken private individual and small group markets. This approach would empower patients, lower premiums, increase choices, and protect the vulnerable.
  • Reduce costs by unwinding heavy federal mandates and allowing states to innovate – By eliminating ObamaCare’s mandates and pricing restrictions, they will empower people to access health insurance that is more affordable and widely available. States will have the resources to create innovative solutions and encourage more competition among insurers on choice and costs.
  • Refocus subsidies on those who need them most – Direct block grants to the states would enable states to better target assistance to those in need.
  • Provide security and protect high-cost patients – Today, ObamaCare’s subsidies provide coverage for the vulnerable but increase costs for everyone else. In contrast, this policy proposal would help people who need assistance in getting coverage, as well as dedicate a portion of the grant to offset the costs of the most-expensive patients, reducing premiums for everyone else.
  • Ensure that all Americans can choose a private health plan – Instead of forcing millions of people into government-run Medicaid programs, this policy proposal would give them the option of using these support dollars to buy private coverage – which will provide them with higher-quality care.
  • Protect life – Funding for these grants to the states would run through the existing Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP). Life protections are written into the CHIP statute, permanently prohibiting federal taxpayer dollars from being used to pay for abortions.
  • Put federal spending on a real budget – Currently, federal spending rises dollar-for-dollar with premium increases. With this proposal of fixed grants to states and greater flexibility to reinvigorate private markets, spending can be controlled. By putting spending on a budget, states would have new incentives to ensure that taxpayers dollars are used wisely.

 

In Part II of this post we will discuss how this Health Care Choices Proposal really works.

California Spurns ObamaCare Relief

 

Once again the California legislature has put politics above the people’s needs. If it’s not raising electric rates in a vain attempt to save the planet, or wasting precious water needed for crops to preserve tiny fish, it’s propping up a failed healthcare system, ObamaCare, instead of making it easier for Californians to get healthcare.

Trump Improvements to ObamaCare

Less than two weeks ago I wrote a post highlighting the ways the Trump administration had taken steps to alleviate some of the suffering caused by ObamaCare (Trump Improvements in ObamaCare Helping Millions). This listed four significant improvements that make it possible for Americans who can’t afford the expensive ObamaCare policies to find relief. Those four improvements were:

  • Short-term, limited duration plans (STLD) – These plans are free from most ObamaCare regulations, lowering their costs by 50 – 80 percent.
  • Renewable plans – These plans allow consumers to stay on their affordable coverage for up to 36 months and lock in low rates in their plans even if they get sick.
  • Ending the Individual Mandate – President Trump has already signed the legislation that will eliminate the onerous Individual Mandate, that forced all Americans to purchase healthcare insurance or pay a tax penalty, beginning in 2019.
  • Association Health Plans – The Trump administration Labor Department has made it easier for small businesses and self-employed Americans to band together to purchase more affordable insurance through these plans. (see earlier post ObamaCare Relief for Small Business)

 

California Rejects Relief

But now the California legislature, in an obvious attempt to push back against all things Trump, has rejected the STLD plans. This bill currently sits on Governor Jerry Brown’s desk awaiting his signature.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says critics consider these STLD plans to be junk insurance because they aren’t required to provide all the ObamaCare mandated coverage, such as mental health services. Yet they still must be subject to California’s state benefit mandates and thus must cover treatments for diabetes and other commonly needed healthcare services.

In 2017 the average short-term plan sold in California by online broker eHealth cost $184 a month compared to $426 for a midlevel plan on the ObamaCare exchanges. An estimated 600,000 Californians would select a STLD plan next year if given the choice.

But the California legislature doesn’t want to give them that choice. In a classic example of “ruling class” thinking, they don’t believe the people should be allowed to make their own choices. The bill’s sponsor, Democratic state Senator Ed Hernandez, says that STLD plans offer a “false sense of security.” But the Trump rule requires that insurers inform customers in a prominent place that the insurance isn’t as comprehensive as ObamaCare plans.

Alex M. Azar, II, the new Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS), says opinions on ObamaCare fall into two categories: those who receive generous government subsidies and therefore love ObamaCare; and those who pay the full brunt of these expensive plans and therefore can’t afford ObamaCare. These STLD plans were designed to give the second group an affordable alternative.

Democrats in other states, like Illinois, have also tried to prohibit renewability guarantees to clamp down on STLD options. But Republican Governor Bruce Rauner vetoed that bill. Wisconsin Democrat Tammy Baldwin is pushing a resolution under the Congressional Review Act to reject the Administration’s short-term rule.

These misguided attempts to resist changes to ObamaCare by the Trump administration are blatant efforts to oppose Trump – at the expense of those citizens of their state they were elected to represent. This is a sad example of how politics has become more important than people.