States Become Laboratories of Healthcare

 

U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Brandeis is credited with coining the phrase “laboratories of democracy” to describe state governments. He used this phrase in 1932 in his opinion in the case New State Ice Co. v. Liebman to describe “how a state may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country.”

Today, some states are following this suggestion as they respond to recent changes in ObamaCare by the Trump administration. Liberal states are pushing back on Trump’s de-regulation while conservative states are embracing these changes with more of their own.

For example, ObamaCare imposed a mandate for the first time in our history that forced all Americans to purchase health insurance or pay a tax penalty. This so-called Individual Mandate was so unpopular it was loosely enforced by the Obama administration. The Trump administration repealed it entirely as part of the tax reform bill of 2017.

But now some states are requiring their own residents to pay the tax penalty again – to their state. The State of New Jersey just imposed a “state Individual Mandate” for any resident who fails to purchase health insurance.

Stephanie Armour, healthcare reporter for The Wall Street Journal, says this practice is gaining popularity in liberal state governments. Other liberal states with mandates include Vermont, Massachusetts, and Oregon.

The Trump administration recently increased flexibility of short-term health plans that are non-compliant with all the ObamaCare regulations in order to give patients options to purchase less-expensive plans. Republican state governments have embraced these plans while Democratic state governments have taken steps to limit such plans. The Trump administration also is allowing flexibility in selling plans outside the ObamaCare exchanges. Some states are blocking these changes for their residents. Some conservative state governments are adding work requirements for able-bodied adults who receive Medicaid support.

The different approaches of various states reflect the broad national divide on the issue of healthcare. Conservatives want to give people more flexibility to choose the insurance plan that best meets their needs. Liberals believe the government should make those decisions for you. They are still trying to preserve ObamaCare, despite its failings, and reject Trump administration efforts to fix some of the problems.

Is this a good or a bad thing?

I regard this as a good thing. This will give states the freedom to devise their own healthcare systems and measure the impact on their state without forcing the rest of the country to go along. Liberal states can preserve all the awful regulations of ObamaCare while conservative states can enjoy the freedom of deregulation. The people of each state can decide for themselves if they are better or worse off. It won’t take long to measure the differences.

The differences will impact not just healthcare but state economies as well. Armour says, “ The states’ accelerating tendency to peel off in different directions will have significant financial repercussions for nearly 30 million U.S. small businesses, about 17 million people who buy individual coverage, 75 million Medicaid recipients and scores of hospitals and insurers.”

This trend should continue as long as complete repeal and replacement of ObamaCare is stymied by Congress. The “laboratories of democracy” should soon reveal which direction Americans prefer. I’m betting on an exodus from blue states where high taxes and high healthcare costs will eventually make residence there economically – and medically – unaffordable.

High Deductibles Breaking U.S. Healthcare

 

More Americans have health insurance today than before ObamaCare. But the U.S. healthcare system is still broken.

If you can’t afford the deductible, what good is your insurance? That’s the question many families are asking themselves when they face healthcare decisions. High deductibles are making expensive treatments like surgery and physical therapy unaffordable for many of my own patients.

According to the Federal Reserve, about 40 percent of Americans can’t afford an unexpected $400 medical expense. The graph above shows the rise in deductibles in recent years.

John Tozi and Zachary Tracer, writing in Bloomberg, say since the early 2000s, employers have mostly embraced high-deductible health plans. The thinking has been that requiring workers to shoulder more of the cost of care will also encourage them to cut back on unnecessary spending. But the 2008 recession put added pressure on the family to hold down expenses. Many families put off routine care or skipped medications to save money. The result is a pent-up need for medical treatments even as deductibles are rising even higher.

The truth is that even for many middle class families, these high-deductibles are unaffordable. The result is delayed or neglected medical treatment.

Why are deductibles rising so fast?

The bottom line is that ObamaCare is a failing healthcare system that can’t provide good medical treatment at an affordable price. The reasons for this are many but the main problem is community rating. The architects of ObamaCare elected to scrap the traditional pricing structure of health insurance using actuarial analysis in favor of a community rating system.

Community rating forces insurers to spread the risks of pre-existing medical conditions over only three price levels rather than the usual six. Simply put, high-risk patients, usually older, pay less than the actual cost of coverage while young and healthy individuals must pay more than the actual cost. This unpopular method of pricing was supposed to work because ObamaCare mandated that everyone purchase health insurance or pay a tax penalty. But millions of healthy young people rejected this mandate, preferring to pay the nominal tax (if held accountable) rather than purchase expensive health insurance they didn’t need.

As ObamaCare continues to fail, with more and more Americans refusing to purchase expensive insurance, premiums and deductibles are rising even faster for those who do purchase insurance. This situation cannot continue much longer.

To lower healthcare insurance premiums and deductibles, a new healthcare system, free of the onerous regulations like community rating in ObamaCare, must be implemented. When Democrats stop trying to preserve a failing system they implemented, and recognize single-payer is not the solution, Americans can look forward to affordable healthcare insurance once again. Until then, look for your healthcare premiums and deductibles to continue rising. That’s the sad truth.

America Cannot Afford Socialism

 

During the American Revolution, the cry was often heard, “The British are coming! The British are coming!” Today, we should be just as vigilant in declaring, “The Socialists are coming! The Socialists are coming!” We can’t afford to let that happen.

The New York Election Results

Recently, ten-term Democratic Congressman Joe Crowley was beaten by socialist Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez in New York’s 14th congressional district primary election. Ocasio-Cortez is a member of the Democratic Socialists of America and a former organizer for Senator Bernie Sanders’ presidential campaign.

Like Sanders, she is a vocal advocate of “Medicare for All”, the socialized medicine legislation introduced by the Vermont senator. This would be a government takeover of all America’s healthcare. Also known as single-payer healthcare, this plan has become a main feature of the Democratic Party platform.

Can America afford “Medicare for All”?

Sally Pipes, writing in Forbes, says a reality check is in order. Sanders tried to implement such a plan in his state of Vermont in 2014. Then-governor Peter Shumlin pushed a single-payer system in the state legislature until he learned the plan would cost $4.3 billion annually. That equaled 88% of the entire state budget. To fund this would require a 12.5 percent state payroll tax and a sliding-scale individual tax of up to 9.5 percent of income. Shumlin pulled the legislation, admitting it “might hurt our economy.”

Last month, in North Carolina, Democratic state representative Verla Insko promoted her own single-payer bill – until she faced reality. An analysis by the state legislature’s Fiscal Research Division estimated the cost of single-payer at $70 billion, $42 billion of which would have to come from the state. That would have been almost double the state budget. This estimate was actually conservative. The Civitas Institute, a free-market think tank in North Carolina, has estimated the first year cost of implementing single-payer at $101 billion!

California had a similar experience last year. California State Assembly Speaker Anthony Rendon, a Democrat, pulled the plug on the single-payer legislation passed by the state Senate after deeming it “woefully incomplete.” The bill was estimated to cost $400 billion each year with no means to pay for it.

Even Senator Sanders admits “there will be pain” if the nation adopts his Medicare for All plan. The plan he touted on his 2016 presidential campaign would have cost $1.4 Trillion per year – even by his own estimates. He called for a new 2.2 percent income tax, a 6.2 percent tax on employers, and higher income taxes on the wealthy. The Urban Institute, a liberal think-tank, estimated Sanders’ plan would cost $32 Trillion over 10 years.

This is a good time to quote former Prime Minister of Great Britain Margaret Thatcher who once said, “The problem with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people’s money.”

Pipes points out that America is already struggling to afford our current Medicare system for the elderly and disabled only. In 2017, the federal government spent more than $700 billion on Medicare – a 65 percent increase over just 10 years. Annual costs per capita are expected to increase 4.6 percent per year over the next decade. The latest Medicare Trustees report released in June states the part A Trust Fund, which covers payment for hospital care, will be depleted in 2026.

Pipes says, “in other words, America is struggling to pay for “Medicare for Some” – much less “Medicare for All.” As single-payer candidates like Ocasio-Cortez will soon discover, no amount of enthusiasm for single-payer can overcome basic math.”

Democratic Backlash

Even some leading Democrats have their concerns about socialist candidates like Ocasio-Cortez. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi was quick to reject media descriptions of Ocasio-Cortez as “the new face of the Democratic Party.” Pelosi said, “They made a choice in one district. It is not to be viewed as something that stands for anything else.”

Former Democratic Senator and Vice-Presidential candidate Joe Lieberman writes in The Wall Street Journal to encourage Democrats to vote for Joe Crowley in November since his name will still be on the ballot. He is the endorsed candidate of the Working Families Party.

Lieberman says about Ocasio-Cortez, “Her dreams of new federal spending would bankrupt the country or require very large tax increases, including on the working class. Her approach foresees government ownership of many private companies, which would decimate the economy and put millions out of work. . . She has received the most attention for calling to “Abolish ICE,” Immigration and Customs Enforcement. This makes no sense unless you no longer want any rules on immigration or customs to be enforced.”

Recent surveys suggest 40 percent of Americans, mostly young people, favor socialism over capitalism. For those who naively support socialism, and haven’t learned the lessons of history, they need look no farther than Venezuela today where rampant inflation, food shortages, and rioting in the streets demonstrate the outcomes of a socialist economy. This should be solid evidence that America cannot afford socialism.