The Real Cost of Healthcare – Unspoken Truths

 

Healthcare costs too much. We’re all in agreement on that. But in reality it costs far more than most people imagine.

The cost of healthcare has been rising for decades. ObamaCare was supposed to fix that. In reality, it only made it worse. While national healthcare spending was declining steadily, it now is rising once again.

The graph below shows the pattern of national healthcare spending before and after the implementation of ObamaCare. It shows that the rate of growth of healthcare spending was declining in the years just prior to passage of the Affordable Care Act (ObamaCare) in 2010. The new healthcare law didn’t actually take effect until 2014. Since then, healthcare spending is rising again, to 4.3% in 2016 according to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS).

The Impact on People

Most people don’t care much about trends in national healthcare spending. They only care about how it affects their own pocketbook. So what is the real impact on the individual?

Corporate concern for the rising costs of providing healthcare coverage to employees has prompted three major corporations, Amazon, Berkshire Hathaway, and J.P. Morgan, to form a cooperative non-profit venture to try to lower these costs. These businesses aren’t doing this out of charitable interests. They want to lower their corporate expenses and therefore raise their corporate profits.

There are many skeptics of this approach and I have mentioned these in an earlier post called AmazonCare – The New Solution? Employees of these corporations might believe this new venture, if it succeeds at all, will only benefit the shareholders and not them. Here is where they are wrong.

The real cost of healthcare is not only what it costs out of your pocket every time you go to see the doctor. It must also be measured in the total cost, not only of the treatment, but for the insurance that partially covers that treatment.

The biggest problem in solving the problem of rising healthcare costs is that the consumer is separated from the real price. Unlike when you buy groceries, most patients never really see the full price of their healthcare. Most people get their healthcare insurance through their employer and they have no idea what the employer is paying for that insurance. They don’t see how it impacts them.

You may believe that the cost doesn’t affect you because it doesn’t come out of your paycheck. But in reality, it does. The more your employer pays for health insurance, the less is available to pay you increased wages. ObamaCare has raised the cost of health insurance coverage for employers and thus has lowered the wages, and potential for wage increases, of employees.

The Tax Exclusion

The other factor in hiding the true cost of healthcare is the tax exclusion of employer-provided health coverage. Since shortly after WWII, the tax laws of this country have excluded taxation of healthcare benefits provided by employers. This first occurred during a time of wage and price controls when employers began competing for new workers by offering health insurance. The IRS exempted these benefits from taxation – and this has continued long after the rescinding of those wage and price controls.

Labor unions and employers have resisted any changes in these rules, which has enabled them to offer bigger and better healthcare benefits while avoiding any increases in payroll or income taxes. As a result, wages have remained low while expensive healthcare benefits have fueled increased healthcare spending.

Clark Havighurst, writing in The Wall Street Journal, believes working-class Americans may be paying $1 Trillion a year too much for health care and could benefit from major changes in the way they purchase it. More understanding of this truth might persuade voters to hold both Democrats and Republicans accountable if they fail to address this issue.

Changes in the current tax laws that exempt health insurance expenses for employer-provided coverage, but not for those who purchase their own, have long been advocated by health economists. It is projected that in the decade from 2016 to

2025 this policy will result in more than $4 Trillion in lost payroll and income tax revenues. Solving this discrepancy would not only level the playing field for all Americans, but go a long way toward solving our rising national debt problem.

Ultimately, solving the rising cost of healthcare must be about transparency. Consumers must know the true cost of any product if they are to make informed decisions. Medical treatment is no exception. As transparency increases, consumers will demand – and get – competitive pricing, which will lower the cost and improve the quality – as competition always does.

A Bipartisan Effort to Solve the Healthcare Crisis

 

Everyone knows there is a healthcare crisis in America. But Congress seems unwilling or unable to fix it. What to do now?

Bill Frist, former heart surgeon and Senate Majority Leader, has formed a bipartisan group called United States of Care to try to come up with real solutions. Frist quotes Sir William Osler, sometimes called the father of modern medicine, who said, “The good physician treats the disease; the great physician treats the patient who has the disease.”

Frist writes in Forbes that our patient is the United States health care system, and it is very sick. Unfortunately, we have been debating this issue for over a hundred years since the Progressives of President Teddy Roosevelt tried to socialize our healthcare. Frist says the bipartisan divide has lost focus on the patient. It’s time to change that.

United States of Care is a diverse collection of voices including caregivers, health care industry leaders, patient advocates, entrepreneurs, former elected officials, and activists. They disagree on many topics but they are all passionate about finding solutions. Here is what they do agree on:

  • No American family should face the prospect of going bankrupt due to unforeseen medical bills
  • Every American ought to have access to some kind of quality health care, within their budget, regardless of where they live or how healthy they have been in the past
  • Solutions for which we advocate must be fiscally responsible so that they are sustainable.

 

Their mission is to:

  • Find points on which a majority of Americans agree
  • Address those points on a state-government level
  • Educate the public on areas of healthcare policy that can be misunderstood

 

Here are some profound statements taken from the website of United States of Care:

  • 27% of American families have delayed care because of concerns about the cost
  • 28 million Americans have no health insurance
  • 4 in 10 adults with insurance say they have trouble affording the deductibles

 

These statements testify to the failure of ObamaCare to solve the real problems of our healthcare system. One in four Americans is delaying treatment because of cost. Universal coverage, as promised by Obama, never happened. Even 40% of those with insurance can’t afford their deductibles – which means they can’t afford their treatment. A better way is obviously needed.

Here is the immediate plan for United States of Care:

In 2018, United States of Care will focus on:

  • Harnessing On-the-Ground Learning: Listening to personal stories and local experts and harnessing public opinion to shape policies that reflect the hopes and concerns of the majority of Americans who don’t want to be without the care they need.
  • Providing Policy Support:Providing resources and actionable approaches to state and federal policymakers, drawing on a wide range of expertise, facilitating stakeholder engagement, and connecting the dots between the interests of citizens and their elected representatives.
  • Developing New Ideas:Identifying and developing new solutions that make progress toward the principles of expanding access to affordable care.
  • Driving Real Changethat improves the health and well being of Americans now and on a lasting basis.

 

This is certainly a laudable effort and I wish them the best of success. Perhaps this bipartisan group can make real policy suggestions that Congress will heed, and maybe even legislate. That’s more than Congress is doing now. If not Congress, then perhaps state governments will enact these suggestions and find the solutions that actually make delivery of better healthcare possible for all Americans.

The Changing Face of Healthcare

 

Most people today have never had a house call from their doctor. I confess that I’ve never had one myself. But I have made a few house calls in my time. There’s no doubt, however, that this practice is a dying art.

Bob Greene, writing in The Wall Street Journal, interviewed Dr. Charles Kemper of northern Wisconsin who practiced for forty years in the town of Chippew Falls, population 14,000. Dr. Kemper, now retired, is 98 years old and recalls a different era in medicine.

“The relief in their eyes,” said Dr. Kemper. “That’s what I saw when they opened the front door. There was often deep worry in their eyes, too, but the main thing I saw was relief; relief that I had come to their home, that I had arrived. That’s a look that a man never forgets.”

Dr. Kemper practiced from the 1940s to the 1980s. I began my career in 1975 when I entered medical school. Even then we were being discouraged from making too many house calls because of the limitations of such visits compared to the vast array of technology and resources available in modern hospitals. But something was being lost in the doctor-patient relationship.

Dr. Kemper still exhibits the “old school” attitudes of so many of the doctors I trained with and practiced among in the last forty years. “It was never a nuisance,” Dr. Kemper said. “If someone was calling at 3 a.m., I didn’t have to ask them if it was an emergency. They wouldn’t be calling me if it wasn’t. I was out of bed and out of the house within 10 minutes. I didn’t waste time asking if they thought it could wait until morning, Of course it couldn’t. They needed me there, and they needed me now.”

Unfortunately, there are fewer doctors today with his attitude. Even in my career I’ve seen a declining interest among younger physicians to see patients in the hospital emergency room, let alone make house calls. Doctor-patient relationships are taken for granted.

When I started my practice in the 1980s, it was routine for me to see every patient who needed an orthopedic consultation in the hospital ER. It was the rare case indeed when the ER physician handled the problem and simply referred the patient to my office. Today, it is just the opposite. It is rare when the orthopedic doctor-on-call actually goes to see the patient.

I know this because many people wind up in my office seeking treatment when they didn’t get it in the ER by the orthopedist-on-call. Even worse, many who show up in that doctor’s office a few days later are turned away because the doctor doesn’t accept their insurance. This is called “abandonment” by the legal profession and by the ethical standards of medicine of my generation.

This problem is not limited to orthopedics. Most primary care physicians today don’t even go to the hospital. They rely on “hospitalists”, physicians employed by the hospitals, to care for their patients when they are hospitalized. My “old school” primary care physician just retired and I’m having difficulty finding a new one who is willing to make hospital rounds.

Sadly, this trend is continuing from the era of Dr. Kemper, to my era, to the present generation of physicians. Doctors are forgetting that they have a sacred oath to care for the sick and injured whenever it is necessary; not just when it is convenient. The culture of medicine is changing, and not for the better.

This is why I oppose any system of healthcare that removes all incentives from doctors to provide the best quality care for all patients. Fee-for-service and an open market where patients can choose their doctors incentivizes doctors to do their best for everyone. They establish relationships and by doing so they build a reputation in the community that will last throughout their career.

On the other hand, single-payer systems, like Canada and the VA, remove all incentives for such quality care since patients have no choices in selecting their doctors. Doctors need not concern themselves with building a quality reputation when their income is standardized and the flow of patients is guaranteed. The result is sub-standard care, inefficiency and delays in treatment.

America has always enjoyed the best quality healthcare in the world. But changes in our culture and our healthcare system now threaten the future of that care. Only a return to a system that gives patients maximum flexibility in choosing their doctors and doctors maximum incentives to provide the best care possible can alter that future.