Single-Payer Healthcare Wastes Money and Time – Part I

 

ObamaCare is dying. GOP plans to replace it are floundering. What’s next?

For progressives, the answer is single-payer healthcare. Senator Bernie Sanders has already introduced his bill for single-payer called The Medicare For All Act. Currently there are 16 Democratic senators in support of his bill. A recent Politico poll showed 49% of Americans favoring “a single-payer health care system.”

I have written extensively in the past on this issue from a doctor’s point of view. I have discussed the poor medical outcomes in countries with this system (Canada, Great Britain, Sweden) and the prolonged waiting times for treatment. Now I would like you to hear the opinion of a well-known healthcare economist.

Chris Conover, Duke University healthcare economist, has written a series on reasons to oppose a single-payer healthcare system from an economist’s perspective. He gives us five reasons single-payer is a bad idea. Today we will discus the first of these five reasons.

Deadweight Losses

The number one reason is what economists call “excess burden” of taxes, better known as “deadweight losses.” To understand these terms it is fundamental to understand that “whatever you tax, you get less of.” It is also fundamental to understand that every tax shrinks the economy to some extent resulting in a loss of welfare for consumers and producers. This impact varies with the type of tax.

The graphic above depicts how this tax burden varies with different types of taxes. The marginal excess burden (deadweight loss) is the drain on the economy that results from the type of tax. The burden is highest for income taxes and lowest for payroll taxes. This burden is reflected in lower GDP, which means fewer jobs and lower wages. (This should be of great concern to those who oppose the current Republican proposal to lower income taxes.)

Deadweight losses are typically expressed as a percentage of the revenue raised. So the average excess burden represents the entire amount of such losses as a fraction of the entire amount of tax revenue raised. This excess burden rises with the tax rate.

Conover estimates deadweight losses for the federal tax system overall averages 44 cents for every dollar of revenue raised. Since the entire American healthcare economy is $3.5 Trillion, if we raised that amount through federal taxes, we’d have to accept welfare losses of $1.5 Trillion per year! This is the burden on the GDP imposed by such taxes. This burden means fewer jobs and lower wages.

How large would the deadweight losses be under Medicare For All?

The left-leaning think tank Urban Institute has calculated the plan would add $32 Trillion to federal health spending in the first decade, or $3.2 Trillion per year. To put this in perspective, the total federal tax revenue currently is only $3.6 Trillion annually.

Senator Sanders has offered a variety of options to finance his plan including a payroll tax of 7.5%. This approach would lower the deadweight losses from 44% to 38% – but they would still amount to $1.33 Trillion per year. This loss of GDP would represent loss of jobs and wages that benefit the same working class workers Sanders is supposed to be helping!

Other options include increasing income taxes, but a review of the graphic above shows this would increase deadweight losses the most! (52%!) If the income tax rates were raised on the wealthy, the burden would be even higher (up to 165%!), causing a net negative growth of GDP, greatly impacting jobs and wages on lower income families. So “socking it to the rich”, as liberals favor, would actually be harder on the poor.

The Urban Institute analysis suggests that if the Sanders plan were currently the law of the land, an added $2.5 Trillion in federal revenues would be required to finance it just in 2017. In other words, we’d need an additional increase in federal tax revenues of 72.2%! There would be a hidden cost of $1.1 Trillion in deadweight losses in 2017 alone.

This calculates to an extra burden in taxes of $3400 per citizen or $13,400 per family of four. To put this into perspective, remember that President Obama sold the American public on ObamaCare promising everyone a reduction of their health insurance premium costs for a family of four of $2500 per year. The Sanders plan would effectively be asking the same people to accept an increase in their healthcare costs of $13,400 per year. That’s five times worse than Obama’s promise! How could anyone support such a plan?

This is only the first of five reasons Conover gives us for opposing single-payer healthcare. Next post we’ll discuss his second reason.

Trump is Not Sabotaging ObamaCare

 

Stop! Take a deep breath. Don’t panic. The world is not about to come to an end – and the ObamaCare insurance market is not about to implode.

Yes, that’s what the liberal media and the Democratic leaders want you to believe. And some, including California Attorney General Xavier Becerra, are suiting the Trump administration, claiming he’s breaking the law. In reality, he’s upholding the law!

I’m talking about the subsidies to health insurance companies the Obama administration illegally paid without Congressional approval – and the Trump administration continued – until now. I talked about this issue in an earlier post (To Bailout ObamaCare or Not to Bailout?).

Cost Sharing Reductions

The issue is all about Cost Sharing Reductions or CSRs, which are not the same as the subsidies paid for low income Americans to purchase ObamaCare policies on the exchanges. CSRs are payments by the government to the insurers to subsidize deductibles and co-pays for lower-income individuals – those below 250 percent of the Federal Poverty Level – who purchase coverage on ObamaCare’s exchanges.

Although these payments must be appropriated by Congress, the Obama administration made the payments without approval anyway. The result is a lawsuit called House of Representatives v. Price (the current HHS Secretary). This lawsuit was originally filed in 2015 against the Obama administration by the House of Representatives. In 2016, Federal Judge Rosemary Collyer ruled in favor of the House and slammed the Obama administration with an injunction to prevent further payments. However, the injunction was later stayed at Congress’ request, putting the legality and existence of CSRs in limbo.

Therefore, President Trump is simply refusing to break the law since these payments have already been ruled unconstitutional without Congressional approval.

The CSRs have continued under Trump until now because he expected the Republican-led Congress to pass healthcare reform. But since that didn’t happen, he is terminating these illegal payments – and calling on Congress to pass new legislation to fix this problem.

The Democrats in Congress are demagoguing the issue, calling this “sabotage” of ObamaCare, conspiracy to harm the poor, sending a wrecking ball into the American healthcare system, and (as usual) killing people.

According to The Wall Street Journal, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) predicted premiums would increase if the subsidies ended. This is to be expected. However, the WSJ editors say, “ The CBO also noted that the added expense would be covered by subsidies for individuals that increase with premiums. The market would continue to be stable (my emphasis) by CBO’s report, and the change won’t invite the ObamaCare death spiral that Democrats would love to pin on Republicans. More generous individual subsidies mean the insurers now predicting Armageddon will still get paid.”

The solution is simple – Congress must appropriate the money in the usual way. But this will require Democrats and Republicans to agree on something. President Trump is putting the ball in their court and forcing them to work together. Senator Chuck Schumer has been saying for months he was willing to work with Republicans once repeal was off the table. Now it’s time to put up or shut up, Chuck.

Privacy v. Medical Research – Which is More Important?

 

I’m sure we’re all in favor of medical research. Although we’ve made tremendous progress in the last century toward solutions to the many diseases that ravage the human body, there is much work yet to be done.

But how much of your privacy are you willing to give up to further the progress of medical research? That’s the heart of the question at stake in new government legislation that Congress passed unanimously last December.

The 21st Century Cures Act

Twila Brase, R. N., writing in The Wall Street Journal, is president of the Citizens’ Council for Health Freedom. She calls attention to the little known threat that medical research poses to our privacy. The 21st Century Cures Act has been hailed as the biggest healthcare reform since ObamaCare for its generous increases to the budget of the National Institutes of Health. It designates nearly $2 Billion for cancer research, and sets aside $500 million in 2017 alone to address the opioid crisis.

This good news is tempered by the fact that the same legislation weakens patients’ privacy rights. This decline in protections for our privacy began in 1996 with the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). As every doctor knows, this legislation placed restrictions on the handling of medical records in private offices and hospitals to protect privacy. But it also allowed government-funded researchers to collect and even share patients’ medical and genetic information without their consent.

But the 21st Century Cures Act takes it one step further. Brase says, “The law tries to create an “information commons”; a government-regulated pool of data accessible to all health researchers, regardless of background, training or motive.”

Are patients willing to sacrifice their privacy to speed research?

A 2007 survey by the Institute of Medicine found that only 1% of Americans were willing to have their health information shared for research without their consent. Yet the new law doesn’t give patients in government-funded research any way to opt out of sharing their medical data. In fact, it prohibits “information blocking” by healthcare providers, creating a mandate for them to share data with the researchers.

How have the courts ruled on this issue?

Federal courts have upheld forced data sharing because patients “voluntarily” give personal health information to their doctors. But some jurists and legal scholars disagree, arguing that today’s laws don’t provide constitutional privacy protections.

Even liberal Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote in the recent 2012 ruling of U. S. v. Jones, “It may be necessary to reconsider the premise that an individual has no reasonable expectation of privacy in information voluntarily disclosed to third parties.” She warned that the current privacy laws are “ill suited to the digital age.”

How readily available is private medical information?

Some would argue that the data can’t be traced back to individual names. It is stripped of the usual identification data including names, street addresses and Social Security numbers. But researchers have shown great ingenuity despite these protections. Harvard researchers examined about 600 anonymous profiles from a genome-research project using only birth date, sex and ZIP code. They were able to identify nearly half of these people by name.

In 2013, a group of researchers led by MIT’s Yaniv Erlich took anonymous genetic information and cross-referenced it against a public database genealogists use to match small differences in Y chromosomes with certain family trees. They were able to identify dozens of completely “anonymous” people.

New legislation recently introduced in March, 2017, by Rep. Virginia Foxx (R – NC) is called The Preserving Employee Wellness Programs Act. It would give companies leverage to push genetic tests on their workers. Those who opt out could have their insurance premiums raised by up to 50%. It is obvious this could lead to discrimination in hiring since companies would have the incentive to avoid hiring people with high-risk profiles.

What is an acceptable price to pay for advances in cancer research, heart disease, and other chronic debilitating diseases? The Fourth Amendment of the Constitution never envisioned these kinds of tradeoffs when it prohibited “unreasonable searches and seizures.” But the Internet age has forced us to consider the reality of a world where privacy is fast disappearing.