Single-Payer Healthcare Wastes Money and Time – Part III

(Author’s Note: This is the fourth in two series of posts explaining what’s wrong with single-payer, government-run healthcare. Recent interviews with medical school and public-health policy students have shown this information is desperately needed to warn our youth of the evils of this form of healthcare. This series was first published in October, 2017 and is re-published here.)

 

In Part I and Part II of this series, I discussed two of five reasons to oppose Senator Sanders’ Medicare for All Act, which calls for single-payer healthcare, from economist Chris Conover’s point-of-view. Today we will look at the third of his reasons.

Healthcare Rationing

Rationing of healthcare treatment occurs in all known single-payer healthcare systems including Canada, Great Britain, and Sweden. Conover says this occurs in two different ways:

  • Deliberate administrative decisions – to deny certain expensive medical technologies
  • Inevitable shortages – created by a system that imposes price controls that underpay providers.

Deliberate Administrative Decisions

In any single-payer healthcare system there is an administrative body empowered to make decisions regarding the availability of healthcare treatment. These bureaucrats, frequently not physicians, concern themselves with the cost of treatment and measure that cost against the likely outcome. They then arbitrarily deny those treatments considered too expensive or too unlikely to produce significant improvement in health, or both.

This administrative body in Great Britain is known as the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE). Advisory committees to NICE use a threshold for recommending treatments of between L20,000 and L30,000 (British pounds) per quality adjusted life year (QALY). Since 1 British pound currently equals $1.29 (American), that translates to roughly $26,000 to $39,000 per QALY.

To see how this is put into practical usage, consider Medicare currently spends approximately $88,000 per year on kidney dialysis for each patient with end-stage renal disease. Without it these patients will die unless they get a kidney transplant. So Americans evidently are willing to pay $88,000 per year to keep people alive. But this would equal a cost/QALY of $185,000.

In Great Britain this would greatly exceed the NICE cost-effectiveness threshold. If the greater U.S. GDP per capita (34%0 is mixed into the equation, the cost/QALY could rise to as much as $52,000. But this is still far below the true cost of kidney dialysis. Therefore NICE would deny the kidney dialysis treatment – and people would die.

Rationing by Waiting

The second form of rationing, caused by shortages, is rationing by waiting. Insufficient numbers of providers (doctors and hospitals) and diagnostic technologies (CT scanners, MRI scanners, Ultrasound, Radiation, etc.) leads to long waiting times for routine services and surgery, even for non-elective procedures like cancer treatment.

The Fraser Institute of Canada reports, “The median wait time in Canada in 2016 was 20 weeks – the longest ever recorded – and more than double the 9.3 weeks Canadians waited in 1993, when the Fraser Institute began tracking wait times for medically necessary elective treatments.”

This problem is getting worse, not because of significant growth in the population, but because of significant decline in the number of physicians. The evidence coming from studies of the Canadian system shows that physicians deliberately reduce the supply of their services, but working fewer hours, retiring early, or moving to other countries. Thus waiting times are due to a combination of excess demand (see the impact of free care in Part II) and shrinkage of supply.

A study by Wharton Business School professor Patricia Danzon concluded: “In Quebec, in the two years immediately after the introduction of universal health insurance, home visits dropped by 63 percent, telephone consultations fell by 41 percent, physician time spent per office visit declined by 16 percent, and office visits rose by 32 percent.” There is no reason to believe American physicians would react any differently if that system were imposed on our country.

Time spent waiting is not limited to physician services. In Canada, hospitals are paid a fixed budget per year giving the perverse incentive to fill their beds with low cost “bed-blockers” (to prevent more expensive patients from filling those beds). To illustrate the impact of this, consider that Canada has the same supply of beds per capita as the U.S. (2.7/1000 population) but the average length of stay in Canada is 36% higher. The consequence is suffering that is avoidable as patients wait months rather than weeks for various types of surgery.

What is the cost of such rationing if Medicare For All is enacted here?

It is difficult to measure the cost of lives put on hold until proper treatment can be given. Who knows the economic impact, let alone the human cost of such delays?

Danzon concluded that patient time costs under a single-payer health system likely amounted o anywhere form 10 to 110 percent of spending on physician services. Government actuaries project we will spend $717 Billion on physician services in 2017, meaning Medicare For All would impose anywhere from $72 to $789 Billion in hidden costs not include in the Urban Institute estimates of the cost of the Sanders plan.

Conover calculates the grand total hidden cost associated with rationing typical in the Canadian single-payer healthcare approach proposed by Sanders would range from $152 to $914 Billion per year. He considers these to be extremely conservative numbers because they do not attempt to account for the adverse effects on health and longevity from the exclusion of high-priced medicines and treatment likely under a single-payer system.

So far, we have three reasons to oppose single-payer healthcare:

  • Deadweight Losses of $1.1Trillion
  • Additional Wasteful Spending of $524 Billion
  • Additional rationing costs of $152 to $914 Billion

 

Altogether, that’s between $1.7 Trillion and $2.5 Trillion in additional hidden costs in the first year alone with single-payer healthcare! (Remember, these costs are not including the obvious costs of just paying for the healthcare!)

 

For more reasons to oppose this system, tune in next time.

Single-Payer Healthcare Wastes Money and Time – Part II

(Author’s Note: This is the third in two series of posts explaining what’s wrong with single-payer, government-run healthcare. Recent interviews with medical school and public-health policy students have shown this information is desperately needed to warn our youth of the evils of this form of healthcare. This series was first published in October, 2017 and is re-published here.)

 

In Part I of this series, I discussed the first of five reasons to oppose single-payer healthcare from economist Chris Conover’s point-of-view. Today we will look at his second reason.

The Moral Hazard

 Conover says the second reason to oppose single-payer healthcare is the enormous waste it would create due to the moral hazard. This is an economist’s term for the waste created whenever you give someone something for free. Anyone given something for free will consume more of it and will be less likely to shop for a lower price (because it’s already free!). In other words, consumers will use more of the product or service and pay more for it (because someone else is paying the real cost).

This is just as true for healthcare, except when there is an emergency. Since very little of healthcare is actually an emergency, the moral hazard is a very real problem.

Many years ago the RAND Health Insurance Experiment (HIE) proved this point. The HIE randomly assigned thousands of families to different types of health insurance plans ranging from a free care plan (much like Senator Bernie Sanders’ single-payer plan) to a very high deductible plan with a large amount of cost sharing. There was an upper limit on cost sharing so that no family spent more than a certain fraction of family income.

The graphic above shows three different healthcare plans and the results of the RAND HIE. The green band shows wasted spending and the results show there is 30% wasted spending with free care, but much less with the other plans.

That means the Sanders Medicare For All Act can be expected to waste 30% of the money spent. In other words, the value of the healthcare spending under such a system is only 70% of the cost. The annual difference in between the free care group and those with a more sensible cost-sharing design was nearly $2100. Fully 82% of that cost differential represented waste!

How much waste would there be under Medicare For All?

The exact amount cannot be calculated until more details are given about the plan. But according to the Urban Institute, which estimated the Sanders plan would cost $3.277 Trillion per year, we can estimate his single-payer plan would waste over $1 Trillion per year. In addition , it would also include $308 Billion in long-term care services.

To be sure, there is waste in the current system, too. I won’t bore you with the details, but Conover calculates the Sanders plan would cause a net increase in waste of $524 Billion per year.

But wouldn’t free care save lives?

This is the favorite argument of progressives pushing this agenda. Unfortunately, this is wishful thinking. The RAND HIE also compared health outcomes – including risk of death – across all plan participants. Conover says,

“There was not a dime’s worth of difference in health outcomes for the average patient. More scientifically, we can say there was no statistically significant difference in health outcomes (including risk of death) when those who got free care were compared to those with cost-sharing plans, including those in high-deductible plans whose actuarial value was only 54%!”

 

The only exception was that high-blood pressure and corrected vision problems were worse in those groups with high cost-sharing plans.

So far we have learned that Senator Sanders’ Medicare For All Act will produce:

  • $1.1 Trillion in deadweight losses
  • $524 Billion in additional wasteful spending

 

That should be more than enough reasons to oppose this plan but we have three more to go! Stay tuned for Part III in this five-part series.

Single-Payer Healthcare Wastes Money and Time – Part I

(Author’s Note: This is the second in two series of posts explaining what’s wrong with single-payer, government-run healthcare. Recent interviews with medical school and public-health policy students have shown this information is desperately needed to warn our youth of the evils of this form of healthcare. This series was first published in June, 2017 and is re-published here.)

 

ObamaCare is dying. GOP plans to replace it are floundering. What’s next? For progressives, the answer is single-payer healthcare. Senator Bernie Sanders has already introduced his bill for single-payer called The Medicare For All Act. Currently there are 16 Democratic senators in support of his bill. A recent Politico poll showed 49% of Americans favoring “a single-payer health care system.”

I have written extensively in the past on this issue from a doctor’s point of view. I have discussed the poor medical outcomes in countries with this system (Canada, Great Britain, Sweden) and the prolonged waiting times for treatment. Now I would like you to hear the opinion of a well-known healthcare economist.

Chris Conover, Duke University healthcare economist, has written a series on reasons to oppose a single-payer healthcare system from an economist’s perspective. He gives us five reasons single-payer is a bad idea. Today we will discus the first of these five reasons.

Deadweight Losses

The number one reason is what economists call “excess burden” of taxes, better known as “deadweight losses.” To understand these terms it is fundamental to understand that “whatever you tax, you get less of.” It is also fundamental to understand that every tax shrinks the economy to some extent resulting in a loss of welfare for consumers and producers. This impact varies with the type of tax.

The graphic above depicts how this tax burden varies with different types of taxes. The marginal excess burden (deadweight loss) is the drain on the economy that results from the type of tax.  The burden is highest for income taxes and lowest for payroll taxes. This burden is reflected in lower GDP, which means fewer jobs and lower wages. (This should be of great concern to those who oppose the current Republican proposal to lower income taxes.)

Deadweight losses are typically expressed as a percentage of the revenue raised.  So the average excess burden represents the entire amount of such losses as a fraction of the entire amount of tax revenue raised. This excess burden rises with the tax rate.

Conover estimates deadweight losses for the federal tax system overall averages 44 cents for every dollar of revenue raised. Since the entire American healthcare economy is $3.5 Trillion, if we raised that amount through federal taxes, we’d have to accept welfare losses of $1.5 Trillion per year! This is the burden on the GDP imposed by such taxes. This burden means fewer jobs and lower wages.

How large would the deadweight losses be under Medicare For All?

The left-leaning think tank Urban Institute has calculated the plan would add $32 Trillion to federal health spending in the first decade, or $3.2 Trillion per year. To put this in perspective, the total federal tax revenue currently is only $3.6 Trillion annually.

Senator Sanders has offered a variety of options to finance his plan including a payroll tax of 7.5%. This approach would lower the deadweight losses from 44% to 38% – but they would still amount to $1.33 Trillion per year. This loss of GDP would represent loss of jobs and wages that benefit the same working class workers Sanders is supposed to be helping!

Other options include increasing income taxes, but a review of the graphic above shows this would increase deadweight losses the most! (52%!) If the income tax rates were raised on the wealthy, the burden would be even higher (up to 165%!), causing a net negative growth of GDP, greatly impacting jobs and wages on lower income families. So “socking it to the rich”, as liberals favor, would actually be harder on the poor.

The Urban Institute analysis suggests that if the Sanders plan were currently the law of the land, an added $2.5 Trillion in federal revenues would be required to finance it just in 2017. In other words, we’d need an additional increase in federal tax revenues of 72.2%! There would be a hidden cost of $1.1 Trillion in deadweight losses in 2017 alone.

This calculates to an extra burden in taxes of $3400 per citizen or $13,400 per family of four. To put this into perspective, remember that President Obama sold the American public on ObamaCare promising everyone a reduction of their health insurance premium costs for a family of four of $2500 per year. The Sanders plan would effectively be asking the same people to accept an increase in their healthcare costs of $13,400 per year. That’s five times worse than Obama’s promise! How could anyone support such a plan?

 

Author’s Note: This is only the first of five reasons Conover gives us for opposing single-payer healthcare. Next post we’ll discuss his second reason.