Overcounting Covid Deaths

I have long been suspicious of the official statistics on Covid deaths in the United States. Now it appears there were good reasons to be suspicious.

Leslie Bienen and Margery Smelkinson, writing in The Wall Street Journal, tells us public-health experts are finally coming clean by acknowledging what has long been obvious: America is overcounting hospitalizations and deaths from Covid-19. The reasons for this come down to money – hospital reimbursements from third-party insurers, especially the government.

Hospital patients are now routinely tested for Covid on admission, regardless of their admitting diagnosis, then counted as “Covid hospitalizations” even if they’re asymptomatic. Leana Wen writes in a Washington Post column, when patients die Covid is often listed on their death certificates even if it played no part in killing them. Government programs created incentives to overestimate Covid’s toll, and poor data make it difficult to pinpoint who’s still at risk and how effective boosters are.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) states a positive Covid test is enough to identify a “Covid hospitalization.” We have long since seen how the CDC gets its marching orders from this White House and acts according to their political agenda.  While increasing the number of Covid deaths artificially may seem counterintuitive to the interests of the White House, it does make it easier to continue their declared Covid emergency, which furthers their political agenda in other ways such as keeping more people eligible for Medicaid regardless of their financial means.

A few states and hospital systems have taken it on themselves to analyze their hospitalization data more thoroughly. Massachusetts requires hospitals to report how many of their Covid-positive patients have received dexamethasone, a standard treatment for Covid-induced lung inflammation. Using this method, the proportion of Covid-positive patients hospitalized for their Covid symptoms is only around 30%, though it fluctuates.

The UC San Francisco hospital system is using remdesivir, a Covid-19 antiviral drug, as a similar proxy. This results in higher numbers than using dexamethasone, since remdesivir is given to patients with milder symptoms. UCSF doesn’t report detailed data publicly, but hospitalizations “from Covid” are typically less than half of Covid-positive patients. The CDC, however, ignores these efforts to discern which hospitalizations were actually caused by Covid when it reports its data.

The CDC Data Tracker also uses state-generated data in reporting hundreds of daily Covid deaths. Many states report a “Covid death” anytime the decedent had a positive PCR test in the last two months before dying. Some are using death certificates, which may be more reliable, but even death certificates can be problematic because government policies create incentives to overcount.

Here’s how: Under the federal public-health emergency, which just began its fourth year, hospitals get a 20% bonus for treating Medicare patients diagnosed with Covid-19. That amounts to about a $35,000 average additional payment for each Covid patient. That may have made some sense at the beginning of the pandemic, when hospitals were swamped with seriously ill patients, subjected to arduous protocols and losing money from canceled elective surgery. But it is long since irrational under current circumstances.

As a doctor, I can tell you it makes no sense to test a patient for Covid who is in otherwise good health about to undergo an elective orthopedic procedure. But what hospital wouldn’t gladly accept the extra $35,000 if the patient just happens to test positive for Covid? It only makes sense to test those patients admitted with respiratory illness for whom a Covid-19 diagnosis would impact their treatment.

Another incentive to overcount comes from the American Rescue Plan of 2021, that large Covid relief bill passed by Congress in the early days of the Biden Administration. It authorized the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) to pay Covid-19 death benefits for funeral services, cremation, caskets, travel and a host of other expenses. The benefit is worth as much as $9,000 a person or $35,000 a family if multiple members die. By the end of 2022, FEMA had paid out nearly $2.9 billion in Covid-19 death expenses.

Many physicians report being pressured by hospitals and families to list Covid-19 on the death certificate, even when it had nothing to do with the death of the deceased. “Just try and leave Covid off the death certificate of a person who was asymptomatic positive and died in a car accident,” said one infectious disease doctor. “Just try.” These doctors were unwilling to be quoted by name for fear of reprisals from the hospitals they work for who are falsifying the death certificates.

This overcounting of deaths from Covid not only raises the costs of Covid for third-party payers, but falsely raise the fear of the public. The authors summarize: “These programs create a vicious circle. The overstatement provides a justification to continue the state of emergency, which keeps the perverse incentives going. With effective vaccines and treatments widely available, and an infection fatality rate on par with flu, it’s past time to recognize that Covid is no longer an emergency requiring special policies.”

 

(Dr. Bienen is a veterinarian who conducts research on zoonotic diseases and public-health policy. Ms. Smelkinson is an infectious-disease scientist whose research has focused on influenza and SARS-CoV-2 (Covid-19).

Bivalent Covid Vaccines and Deception

 

Have you had your bivalent Covid booster yet? My wife and I have, but will it give us better protection from Covid infection?

To hear it from the Biden Administration, the answer is unequivocally yes. To emphasize the importance of getting the new booster, the Health and Human Services Department is running radio ads warning that if you’ve had Covid, you could get it again and experience even worse symptoms. To avoid this scenario, they recommend you get the new booster.

Allysia Finley, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says this is deceptive advertising. But she says we shouldn’t be surprised that the public health establishment is praising the new vaccine boosters. Federal agencies took the unprecedented step of ordering vaccine makers to produce them and recommending them without data to support their safety or efficacy.

No one is surprised that a new bivalent vaccine was developed to help stay ahead of the ever-changing virus variants. We do the same thing every year with the influenza vaccines. The idea of updating mRNA Covid shots every season originally held great promise. One advantage of this new mRNA technology is that manufacturers can tweak the genetic sequence and rapidly produce new vaccines targeting new variants. The new bivalent vaccines were targeted for the BA.4 and BA.5 Omicron variants, as well as the original Wuhan strain.

But Finley reports three scientific problems have arisen.

• First, the virus is evolving much faster than the vaccines can be updated.
• Second, vaccines have hard-wired our immune systems to respond to the original Wuhan strain, so we churn out fewer antibodies that neutralize the new variants specifically targeted by the new boosters.
• Third, antibodies rapidly wane after a few months; although cellular immunity lasts much longer.

Two studies in the New England Journal of Medicine recently showed that bivalent boosters increase neutralizing antibodies against the BA.4 and BA.5 variants, but not significantly more than the original boosters. In one study, antibody levels after the bivalent boosters were 11 times as high against the Wuhan variant as the BA.5 variant. The authors opine that immune imprinting “may pose a greater challenge than is currently appreciated for inducing robust immunity against SARS-CoV-2 variants.” This isn’t unique to Covid or mRNA vaccines, though boosters may amplify the effect. Whenever you are first exposed to a virus, such as children with the flu, your future response is affected.

All this is not alarming, though it does contradict November press releases from Pfizer and Moderna asserting that their bivalent vaccines produced a response to the BA.4 and BA.5 variants four to six times that of the original boosters. In hindsight, these claims were misleading as these recent studies reveal. Neither vaccine maker conducted a randomized trial. They tested the original boosters last winter, long before the BA.5 surge and four to six months after trial participants had received their third shots. The bivalents, by contrast, were tested after BA.5 began to surge, nine to eleven months after recipients had received their third shots.

What is alarming is that this shows us once again that our public-health officials are more interested in promoting conformity to their recommendations than they are in giving us scientifically tested information. Finley says the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) ordered the vaccine makers in June to update the boosters against BA.4 and BA.5, then rushed in late August to authorize the bivalents before clinical data were available. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) recommended the bivalents for all adults without any evidence that they were effective – or even needed.

The CDC actually published a study in November, (long after they promoted the bivalent vaccines) which estimates the bivalents were only 22% to 43% effective against infection during the BA.5 wave – their peak efficacy. As antibodies waned and new variants took over later in the fall, their protection against infection probably dropped to near zero. Another CDC study in December reported that seniors who received bivalents were less likely to be hospitalized than the unvaccinated, and 73% less likely than those who had received two or more doses of the original vaccine. But neither study controlled for important confounding factors – such as the small minority who got bivalents were probably also more likely than those who hadn’t to follow other Covid precautions or seek treatments such as Paxlovid.

We have learned from the release of emails from the White House that they used their director of digital media, Rob Flaherty, to promote the White House public-health policy agenda by intimidating social media companies including Facebook, Twitter, and Google (YouTube). (see White House Censorship) It is not a stretch of the imagination to believe the same pressure was put upon the FDA and CDC to promote these bivalent vaccines before there was clinical evidence of their safety and effectiveness.

Am I sorry I got the bivalent vaccine? No, but I am sorry our public-health officials are determined to push the White House public-health policy agenda, regardless of whether or not it is scientifically based and clinically proven to be safe and effective.

Sports and Freedom of Religion

You know the world is in trouble when people go to a hockey game and a culture war breaks out. That’s what happened to Philadelphia Flyers defenseman Ivan Provorov when he refused to participate in wearing a “Pride Night” hockey jersey bearing the rainbow flag or use a rainbow-taped hockey stick during warmups before the team’s game recently.

Provorov is a Russian Orthodox Christian who refused to compromise his religious beliefs. He told reporters he declined to participate “to stay true to myself and my religion.” He added, “I respect everyone. I respect everybody’s choices.” But it seems there are many who don’t respect his.

The Founders of this country came here to express their own religious freedom when the King of England wouldn’t tolerate their deviance from his choices. Now, over 300 years later, a Russian professional hockey player playing in America is being told he doesn’t have the freedom to express his own religious beliefs. He must comply with the beliefs of others.

This is so contrary to the ideals of America that even an American Orthodox Jew has come to his defense. Tal Fortgang, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says, “American pluralism is a glorious thing. Dedication to shared ideals and the commitment to living peacefully among compatriots of all colors and creeds can bring out the best in us. It unites people of all religions, national origins and other historical sources of division in defending our aspirations to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Yet that pluralism is in peril today, compelling me, an American Orthodox Jew, to defend Ivan Provorov, a Russian Orthodox Christian and professional hockey player.”

To his credit, Mr. Fortgang even admits he is a die-hard New York Rangers fan! Yet the injustice of Mr. Provorov’s treatment by the media, and many of the fans at the hockey game, was so outrageous he couldn’t remain silent.

The irony not lost on those fair-minded thinkers like Mr. Fortgang is that this event, called “Pride Night”, is part of the National Hockey League’s “Hockey Is for Everyone” campaign. Mr. Fortgang says the NHL is engaged in race, gender, and sexuality-based outreach in seemingly unassailable terms: All are welcome. But as religious Americans are aware, this seldom is the meaning. A message of ostensible tolerance – be whoever you want to be and live your truth – is hardly the gentle embrace of “love thy neighbor as thyself,” as the Bible has stated it. Instead, it is quiet coercion: Bake the cake. Wear the jersey. Bend the knee.

When Romans ruled the world, you complied or were crucified, or lost your head. Today, you suffer the persecution of the media and the culture warriors. Mr. Fortgang asks the question, “Why else has one man’s dissent stirred such outrage? The You Can Play Project, which aims “to ensure the safety and inclusion of all LGBTQ people in sports,” works with the NHL in its campaign. A You Can Play executive told ESPN that Mr. Provorov “negatively impacted” Pride Night. One hockey commentator tweeted that Provorov “obviously does not respect everyone,” because “if he did. . . he would have taken part in warm-up and worn the Pride Night jersey.”

Another commentator tweeted: “The Flyers should have responded by not allowing him to play in the game. . . Freedom of expression doesn’t give you freedom from the consequences of your words or actions.” Really? There must be consequences if you disagree with someone else because of your religious beliefs? This is England in 1620 all over again.

This intolerance by the left is liberalism turned on its head. The classical liberal ideology called for tolerance of everyone’s point of view. Today’s liberals are intolerant of anyone who disagrees with them. Unfortunately, the NHL, NBA, NFL, and others have become so tied to corporate interests that insist upon virtue signaling that the purity of sports as a form of entertainment has been lost in the shuffle, and religious freedom, along with basic rights of freedom of speech, have been trampled underneath by the crowd.

 

Bravo to Mr. Fortgang, for speaking out about this injustice! May there be others like him.