Never Had Covid? Maybe You’re Wrong

It’s been two and a half years now since the Covid pandemic emerged from China. Most people world-wide have now likely been infected with the virus at least once, according to many leading epidemiologists. If you think you’ve never had Covid, you’re either lucky or you’re wrong.

Some 58 % of people in the U.S. had contracted Covid-19 through February of this year, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Since then, a persistent wave driven by offshoots of the infectious Omicron variant has kept daily known cases in the U.S. above 100,000 for weeks. Those numbers, however, only count confirmed positive tests. They don’t count people who never got tested.

Julie Wernau, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says geneticists and immunologists are studying factors that might protect people from infection, and learning why some are predisposed to more severe Covid-19 disease. For many, the explanation is likely that they have in fact been infected with the virus at some point without realizing it, said Susan Kline, professor of medicine at the University of Minnesota Medical School. About 40% of confirmed Covid-19 cases are asymptomatic, according to a meta-analysis published in December in the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Many people, like me, have never tested positive for Covid, but they have had “a slight cold”, without a fever, extreme fatigue, or loss of smell and taste – symptoms typically associated with Covid. We may have actually had Covid without knowing it. About 90% of people who get Covid-19 make antibodies that can be detected in their blood, said Sheldon Campbell, a pathologist and lab-medicine doctor at Yale Medicine. But no one is going to do these tests on asymptomatic people.

And then there are those who contract asymptomatic Covid, and yet don’t make antibodies. Most tests can’t distinguish antibodies from infection versus those from vaccination. Because current Covid-19 vaccines target the virus’s spike protein, using a test that looks for antibodies that target a different protein, called the nucleocapsid, can distinguish a prior infection even in those who have been vaccinated. However, the CDC and the FDA discourage antibody testing in many cases, in part because they only show that a person was infected or vaccinated, not how much protection antibodies might provide.

Researchers are currently studying factors that might keep the virus from infecting some people, or that affect how a person responds to the virus. These factors may explain why some patients are immune to the virus and others contract serious disease. Research has suggested that mutations in genes that drive immune response to viruses can affect a person’s ability to fight the disease.

There is some evidence that some people who may have been exposed to certain coronaviruses before the pandemic are equipped with cells that attack SARS-CoV-2 before it can spread, said Steve Jameson at the University of Minnesota Medical School. “Some people come with a little bit of a head start,” he said. People who don’t know whether they have been infected should be careful, he warns, because they might get sick as antibodies wane and new variants arrive.

“There are plenty of people who’ve had the vaccines or even had Covid and then have gotten Covid again,” said Dr. Jameson. “It’s not as if it makes you immortal.”

Woke Medical Education

The wave of woke medical education is gaining strength and will soon crash down on unsuspecting medical students. That’s the message of a recent Wall Street Journal editorial.

Three months ago, I wrote a post called The “Woke” Doctor’s Office which discussed the alarming Op-ed of Dr. Stanley Goldfarb, a former associate dean of the curriculum at the University of Pennsylvania’s Perelman School of Medicine. Dr. Goldfarb reported his concern that healthcare is being infected by the radical ideology that has corrupted education and public safety. He said while critical race theory (CRT) and crime waves have been in the news, the public is largely unaware of medicine’s turn toward division and discrimination. He said the premise behind all this radical new thinking is that healthcare is systemically racist – that most physicians are biased and deliver worse care to minorities.

Now it seems Dr. Goldfarb’s comments were prescient. In their lead editorial, WSJ editors expose this woke thinking by those who have great influence over the curriculum in every medical school in America. They explain the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) is a nonprofit based in Washington, D.C., that represents and advises medical schools. It also has influence with the Liaison Committee on Medical Education, the national accreditor that sets med-school standards. With that kind of influence, when the AAMC tells med schools how to teach, America’s future physicians will be obliged to listen.

The AAMC expects aspiring doctors to become fluent in woke concepts such as “intersectionality,” which the AAMC defines as “overlapping systems of oppression and discrimination that communities face based on race, gender, ethnicity, ability, etc.” That means med students who managed to avoid learning CRT in college or high school will now get it shoved down their throats in medical school.

They will also be expected to demonstrate “knowledge of the intersectionality of a patient’s multiple identities” – not to be confused with personality disorders – and “how each identity may result in varied and multiple forms of oppression or privilege related to clinical decisions and practice.” WSJ suggests this sounds as if every medical diagnosis will have to be made with an accompanying political and sociological analysis.

All medical school students should be taught that black women are at higher risk for a type of breast cancer known as triple-negative and women of Ashkenazi Jewish heritage are at greater risk of the BRCA gene mutation. Naturally, Caucasian men and women are more susceptible to skin cancers, especially melanoma, than African-Americans and others of darker skin color. Oriental men and women are more prone to develop OPLL, a condition of the spine that leads to spinal stenosis. There are many other racial differences in prevalence of disease. While these differences in disease prevalence by race exist, this doesn’t mean these conditions are really about “systems of power, privileges, and oppression” in our society.

WSJ says, “Social and economic circumstances clearly can affect individual health behavior. But the hyper class and racial consciousness that the AAMC wants to instill in doctors may result in worse care for minorities. “Systems of oppression” as a standard of analysis could easily become medical fatalism. . . The implicit message is that the best way to help patients is to expand the size and scope of government.” Sounds like a message written by Senator Bernie Sanders and those who favor socialized medicine.

Most young people who pursue a career in medicine want to help patients. Now they will be taught that “an intricate web of social, behavioral, economic, and environmental factors, including access to quality education and housing, have greater influence on patients’ health than physicians do.” My concern is that such “woke medical education” may discourage the brightest of our youth from pursuing careers in medicine.

According to the American Medical Association (AMA), the U.S. is facing a projected shortage of between 37,800 and 124,000 physicians in the next 12 years. Since training new physicians can take up to a decade, the urgency of this problem cannot be overstated. Yet changes in the medical school curriculum, as we have just discussed, could easily exacerbate this shortage as fewer qualified candidates apply to medical school.

The bottom line is that medicine is probably the least biased, racially influenced profession in the world. This is a solution in search of a problem – a solution that I predict will lead to worse healthcare – not better.

Covid Omicron Variants and Reinfections

It seems like everyone is getting Covid these days, but not many are really sick or hospitalized. There’s a reason for this – Covid Omicron variants. Should we be worried?

Jeremy Kamil, M.D. is a virologist who answers this question in an article published recently in The New York Times.He says the most recent infections are largely due to the BA.5 Omicron variant. It is the latest of several Omicron variants that have emerged since early 2022. It is more transmissible than earlier Omicron variants, most likely because it’s better at evading our existing antibodies.

BA.5 and its close cousin BA.4 have a key mutation that enables them to sneak past an important class of so-called broadly neutralizing antibodies. These particular antibodies did a great job of preventing infections from a wide swath of earlier Covid variants. But there have been changes. As most of us have observed, many of our vaccinated friends and family members have been infected with the coronavirus for the first time. Some have even been reinfected shortly after their first bout with Covid.

Reinfection a few weeks after recovery is rare, but it happens, depending upon the immune system of the individual. Scientific studies have shown that people who previously contracted Covid-19 are much less likely to get infected with the variant of the day than people who had never seen the virus, and this trend holds true for Omicron. Research from Qatar has shown those who were infected with BA.1 Omicron were significantly less likely to experience BA.4 or BA.5 breakthrough infection months later.

Some studies have found that Omicron variants may induce weaker antibody response than earlier variants, but this is most likely because Omicron causes less severe disease, thanks to immunity from vaccines and prior infections. Immune response is usually proportional to the immune challenge – greater challenge, greater response. This is true for Covid, as well as other infections such as influenza. Vaccines are a great way around this problem; they stimulate our immune systems to make antibodies, without the need for being infected.

This current situation may produce anxiety when we see people getting infected despite being vaccinated, or having been infected with Covid. But despite Omicron’s knack for circumventing antibodies, it’s clear that prior immunity, from either vaccines or previous infections, still protects us from severe outcomes such as hospitalization or even death. There has yet to be a variant that negates the benefits of vaccines. Furthermore, there is no debate that prior immunity reduces the severity of subsequent infections. What’s more, catching the coronavirus more than once or after vaccination does not necessarily put one at risk for the most serious and chronically debilitating forms of long Covid.

Dr. Kamil recommends the FDA move swiftly to authorize new booster shots that target Omicron variants. Existing data suggest that updated shots, even based on earlier Omicron lineages, would be more effective at preventing infections than continuing to use the current vaccine boosters, which are based on the original 2019 coronavirus spike protein.

We all know that the influenza vaccine is updated every year to allow for mutations in the influenza virus. The same is true of the Covid virus. We need, and should expect, annual updates in the Covid vaccine to keep our immune systems protected from Covid virus mutations.

Dr. Kamil summarizes: “Most immunologists I know are cautiously optimistic about our long-term prospects. We don’t know exactly what this virus will do next, and we should never be dismissive of those who have a high-risk profile or are dealing with long Covid. Nonetheless, most of us can have faith in our immune systems, especially when we make use of vaccines and boosters. Recorded history may hold little precedent for the ongoing Covid-19 pandemic. But this is not our immune systems’ first rodeo.”