Access to Healthcare is the Problem – Not Insurance Coverage

 

The American healthcare system is focusing on the wrong problem. Instead of worrying about the impact new legislation will have on health insurance coverage, we should be worrying about providing better access to healthcare treatment.

If you’re wandering alone in a desert looking for water, it will do you no good to discover a Groupon coupon for a free case of bottled water. You can’t drink the coupon and the coupon is worthless unless you can find the water.

That’s why as a doctor I have become increasingly frustrated with the healthcare proposals coming out of Washington. Let me give you a few examples:

Medicaid

Medicaid is essentially free healthcare for those who are eligible. But to carry the analogy further, Medicaid is like having the Groupon coupon for free water in the desert. You may have a Medicaid card that guarantees you free healthcare, but it’s worthless unless you can actually get healthcare treatment.

Medicaid patients have very poor access to healthcare because the reimbursements to providers are so low that few will accept them as patients. Even those who do accept Medicaid usually have very limited numbers of appointments reserved for Medicaid patients. That means long waiting times to receive appointments and therefore to receive healthcare.

This forces Medicaid patients to go to the emergency rooms 40% more often than even the uninsured according to the Oregon Healthcare Experiment study of 2007. This poor access to healthcare is the major reason that Medicaid healthcare outcomes are no better than those without insurance (according to the same study) and worse than those with private insurance in nearly every other study.

VA Healthcare

In 2014 it was revealed that many veterans were actually dying while waiting to see the doctor at VA Hospitals. Long waiting times for appointments due to the inefficiencies and incompetence of the VA system were costing many veterans their lives. Those who served in our military in defense of our country were being neglected because they had poor access to healthcare.

This problem was identified in the Phoenix VA Hospital but was later found in many other VA hospitals around the country. The VA system is a socialized medicine model and like all socialized medicine systems in the world, it rations care by delaying treatment. Rationing is controlled by limiting access to treatment. (Single-Payer systems have the same problem.)

ObamaCare

Proponents of the Affordable Care Act (ObamaCare) proudly point to increased coverage of Americans by this healthcare legislation. About 20 million more Americans have coverage since the 2010 passage of this Act.

But about 15 million of those have new Medicaid coverage. However, as discussed above, these newly covered Americans still have an access problem. The other 5 million mostly have ObamaCare exchange policies because large government subsidies have made their premiums affordable.

However, they still have an access problem. They may be able to get in the door of the doctor’s office, and even get an examination, but high deductibles often make it difficult if not impossible for them to get the treatment they need. As a surgeon I know that many of these patients can’t afford the deductibles they need to pay in order to receive the surgery necessary to treat their problem.

(Next post: the solution)

The Individual Mandate – Worst Tax Ever?

 

If you’re following the tax reform debate in Congress, you know that the Individual Mandate of ObamaCare is suddenly the talk of the town. The Senate has just added the elimination of the Individual Mandate to its tax reform bill.

I wrote about this in an earlier post (Killing ObamaCare Mandate Would Lower Taxes) after Senator Tom Cotton (R – AK) raised this possibility in earlier debate. Now the idea has gained traction with his fellow GOP senators – and with good reason.

Chris Pope, senior fellow at The Manhattan Institute, writes in The Wall Street Journal that he considers the Individual Mandate “the worst tax ever.” He gives the following argument for this strong opinion:

“If you were deliberately trying to design the most arbitrary, painful and pointless tax possible, how would you go about it? First, you would structure it to inflate the cost of an essential product. Then, you’d create exemptions so vast that only 5% of taxpayers were subject to it. You might even ensure that it hit people only when they were particularly vulnerable – like when they’d lost a job. Finally, you would use it to drive enrollment in entitlements, so that it increased the federal deficit by $338 billion. In short, you would design something that looks very much like the Affordable Care Act’s individual mandate.”

 

So eliminating this tax makes good sense for several reasons:

  • It would lower the cost of an essential product – healthcare insurance
  • It would eliminate an unfair tax that affects the poor disproportionately
  • It would lower the federal deficit by $338 Billion

 

Why was the Individual Mandate created in the first place?

That’s a good question. In the presidential campaign of 2008, candidate Barack Obama opposed the idea and argued strenuously against it in the primary against Hillary Clinton. In fact, he said, “If a mandate was the solution, we could try that to solve homelessness by mandating everybody buy a house.”

Yet, when he became president, he was convinced by ObamaCare architect Jonathan Gruber that a mandate was necessary to force the young and healthy to purchase unnecessary health insurance to subsidize the cost of older and sicker Americans. Based on this premise, Obama promised all Americans their insurance premiums would go down an average of $2500 per year.

In reality, premiums have skyrocketed, increasing on average about $3500 per year by 2016. The average annual premium in 2016 was $5,712, while median healthcare spending was only $709 in 2014.

According to a Manhattan Institute Issue Brief recently released, the Individual Mandate is superfluous to the ACA’s core guarantee of affordable coverage for individuals with pre-existing conditions. They state it is subject to so many exemptions that recent studies have failed to discern any impact of the mandate on the proportion of Americans who are uninsured. They believe the ACA’s guarantee of affordable insurance to low-income individuals and those with pre-existing conditions is due entirely to the law’s subsidy provisions.

The failure of the Individual Mandate to positively influence the market can be attributed to the following:

  • Insistence by the Obama administration that parents be able to claim their children on their own insurance plan up to age 26
  • Low tax penalties for non-compliance
  • Lax accountability for non-compliance.

 

Pope summarizes the impact of the Individual Mandate:

“The main effect of the mandate has been to concentrate the burden of subsidizing the chronically ill on those who lack employer-sponsored health insurance or eligibility for public entitlements. This is a very low-income group: 79% of households that had to pay the mandate tax had annual incomes of less than $50,000.”

 

No wonder Obama opposed the idea in the first place. Just another example of the “unintended consequences” of progressive programs that are supposed to help the poor. It’s time to get rid of this costly and unfair tax once and for all.

Killing ObamaCare Mandate Would Lower Taxes

 

As Congress debates the Republican Tax Reform plan, a novel idea has emerged to lower your taxes – repeal the ObamaCare Individual Mandate.

What is the ObamaCare Individual Mandate?

ObamaCare requires every American to have insurance coverage – or pay a penalty tax. The tax in 2016 was 2.5% of household income (above the $10,350 filing threshold for single adults) or $695, whichever is greater. This tax is very regressive, meaning it affects the poor disproportionately. In 2015, 96% of payers were household earning less than $100,000. Most high income earners are covered by employer-provided insurance or Medicare.

This tax penalty raised $3 Billion in 2015. However, according to The Wall Street Journal, Arkansas Senator Tom Cotton says abolishing this mandate would actually increase revenue for the federal government.

Here’s how:

Last December, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projected that repealing the mandate would save $416 Billion over 10 years because fewer people would sign up for Medicaid or receive subsidies on the exchanges. Fewer workers might also enroll in employer-sponsored plans, which could result in more taxable compensation (insurance benefits are not taxable but higher wages are).

The CBO estimated in July that repeal of the employer and individual mandates of ObamaCare would yield $275 Billion in savings. Senator Cotton estimates a future score might project even greater savings, about $300 Billion, since next year’s average premium tax credit has ballooned by 45%. Insurers have increased prices on the benchmark Silver plans to make up for cost-sharing subsidies withdrawn by the Trump administration (because they were not funded by Congress).

The CBO has long been a thorn in the side of Republican efforts to repeal and replace ObamaCare because of their projections of the number of Americans who would lose their health insurance. Ironically, the dubious methodology of the CBO in overestimating the impact of reform efforts may be useful to the GOP efforts in the tax debate. The faulty estimates that hurt reform proposals will mean fewer Americans will sign up for insurance and subsidies, thereby lowering necessary federal spending.

Therefore, without changing Medicaid or cutting spending, federal revenues would increase merely by eliminating a law that forces Americans to purchase a product they don’t like and can’t afford.

Furthermore, with the Individual and Employer Mandates out of the way, new efforts to repeal and replace ObamaCare wouldn’t be shackled with the adverse impact of the CBO scoring that always overestimated the reduction of insurance coverage due to the loss of these mandates. Democrats have used the CBO scoring in the past as a cudgel to impede GOP reform. Now it would be easier to pass meaningful reform measures such as the Graham – Cassidy bill.

The WSJ editorial board believes this idea is a winner politically and as fiscal and health policy. It raises more federal revenue and paves the way for healthcare reform – both important goals to achieve.