ObamaCare Hurts the Poor

 

Democrats believe they are the only party that cares about the poor. The liberal mainstream media promotes this false premise. ObamaCare is a perfect example.

ObamaCare was passed exclusively by Democrats in 2010 with the expressed purpose of improving the healthcare of the poor. It has been successful in increasing the rolls of the insured by about 20 million, 15 million of those newly enrolled in Medicaid. I could easily argue that those 15 million people are worse off on Medicaid than they would be without insurance, but that’s an issue I’ve addressed before. (Medicaid Solutions For the Poor)

ObamaCare Taxes the Poor

Today I want to talk about the ObamaCare tax on the poor. The Wall Street Journal reports that IRS data offers insight into who paid the ObamaCare Individual Mandate tax in 2015 for not buying health insurance.

For those of you who receive your health insurance through your employer, you may not be aware of this tax. For the first time in our nation’s history, the federal government can tax you for failing to purchase something – in this case health insurance. The Supreme Court ruled in 2012 that it was not constitutional to assess a penalty fine for failure to purchase insurance but it was constitutional to assess a tax. Chief Justice John Roberts made this distinction in order to render the law constitutional.

IRS data shows that in 2015 about 8 million Americans paid the tax which totaled about $3 Billion in revenue. More than one in three of the taxed households earned less than $25,000, which is roughly the federal poverty level for a family of four.

More than 75% of penalized households made less than $50,000 and 9 in 10 earned less than $75,000. Fewer families paid the tax in 2015 than in 2014, yet government revenues increased to more than $3 billion from about 1.7 billion since the tax increased. In 2014 the tax was $95 or 1.0% of income. In 2015 it increased to $325 or 2.0% of income. In 2016 it increased to $695 or 2.5% of income and thereafter it will be adjusted upward for the cost of living.

In other words, the federal government collected over $3 billion dollars from people who couldn’t afford to purchase health insurance or considered it such a poor value it wasn’t worth the money. Is this any way to treat our low-income families?

Ironically, ObamaCare also contributed to this problem by destroying the individual insurance market, depriving these same people of low-cost alternatives. High-deductible, catastrophic plans that were popular with the same people are no longer available due to the restrictions of ObamaCare.

Supporters of ObamaCare will argue that subsidies are available for those who don’t qualify for Medicaid. But 8 million Americans didn’t get enough in subsidies to make the purchase of private insurance affordable, or a wise economic choice.

So the plight of low-income Americans is this: accept Medicaid, a second-class healthcare system (if eligible), purchase expensive healthcare insurance with deductibles so high it is unusable, or pay the tax if you choose not to purchase the insurance. Which choice would you make if you were in their shoes?

This is the choice Democrats and Republicans like Senators Paul, McCain, Collins and Cruz are leaving the poor when they refuse to replace ObamaCare.

The Talcum Powder Cancer Scare

 

As I write these words on Halloween, this is not intended as another frightening moment. Just when you thought you were at least safe in your own bathroom, there comes a new reason to be scared.

In August of this year a jury ordered Johnson & Johnson, manufacturers of Johnson’s Baby Powder, to pay $417 million to Eva Echeverria for failing to warn her about the risk of using their product. This 63 year-old woman has terminal ovarian cancer and has been using this baby powder for more than 40 years. Who knew it was so dangerous?

The Scientific Evidence

There is no scientific evidence that talcum powder, or baby powder, causes cancer. The American Cancer Society (ACS) says talc, in its natural form, contains minute amounts of asbestos, a substance known to cause cancers in the lungs when inhaled. However, all talcum products used in the home in the United States have been asbestos-free since the 1970s (over 40 years ago).

Here is the statement of the ACS concerning ovarian cancer and talcum powder:

“Many studies in women have looked at the possible link between talcum powder and cancer of the ovary. Findings have been mixed, with some studies reporting a slightly increased risk and some reporting no increase. Many case-control studies have found a small increase in risk. But these types of studies can be biased because they often rely on a person’s memory of talc use many years earlier. Two prospective cohort studies, which would not have the same type of potential bias, have not found an increased risk.”

 

Amanda Fader, a gynecologic oncologist at Johns Hopkins University says, “The scientific body of literature is not compelling at this time to support a strong association between talcum powder and ovarian cancer, let alone to say any one specific case was associated with powder.”

Judge Grants New Trial

The dreams of trial lawyers of turning talcum powder into the next asbestos racket appear to have been squelched, according to The Wall Street Journal editorial board. They report that California Superior Court Judge Maren Nelson has granted Johnson & Johnson a new trial after their appeal of the verdict.

Judge Nelson ripped apart the plaintiff lawyers’ arguments and evidence. First, trial lawyers tried to hold Johnson & Johnson liable even though its subsidiary JJCI had manufactured the baby powder since 1967. The judge noted that the law is well established that ordinarily a holding company cannot be held liable for the acts of its wholly owned subsidiary absent evidence that the consumer unit was an agent of the company – a fact not shown by the lawyers.

Second, the judge also deemed the plaintiff’s evidence lacking. No causal link has been established between talc and ovarian cancer, as even one plaintiff expert testified. They tried to use support from an epidemiologist but the judge noted “the expert did not properly employ the methodology she espoused.” The judge also dismissed the plaintiff’s unscientific contention that the condom industry’s discontinuation of talc after 1994 demonstrates its carcinogenic risk.

Judge Nelson concluded, “The documents and testimony, granting all evidence in favor of the plaintiff do not support liability . . . much less support a finding of clear and convincing evidence that a punitive damage was appropriate.”

I guess we don’t have to accuse our mothers of child-abuse for using that baby powder on us – at least not yet.

Single-Payer Healthcare Wastes Money and Time – Part V

 

This is the fifth in a five-part series that gives economic reasons to oppose a single-payer healthcare system such as that proposed by Senator Bernie Sanders called The Medicare For All Act.

Chris Conover, Duke University economist, has given us four reasons, hidden costs, thus far:

  • $625 Billion to $1.1 Trillion in deadweight losses from new taxes (Part I)
  • $453 to $626 Billion in additional waste (Part II)
  • $152 to $914 Billion in costs resulting from rationing (Part III)
  • $23 to $152 Billion in social losses from reduced innovation (Part IV)
  • Thus the hidden costs of Sanders’ plan are $1.24 Trillion to $2.8 Trillion per year ($3,800 to $8,500 per U.S. resident)

 

This should be plenty of reasons to oppose the Sanders Medicare For All plan. But even if someone should try to refute these numbers, as someone certainly will, Conover gives us a fifth reason we cannot dismiss – our nation cannot afford it.

 

What will the Sanders Plan actually cost?

The Sanders campaign of 2016 used the projections of Gerard Friedman, economist at The University of Massachusetts – Amherst, to claim his plan would actually reduce healthcare expenditures by $6.3 Trillion over ten years (13.3%). These numbers have been challenged by other economists, including the liberal think-tank, The Urban Institute.

  • Ken Thorpe, Emory University economist and advisor to the Clinton health plan, estimates the Sanders plan would cost $24.7 Trillion over a decade and add a budget shortfall of greater than $1 Trillion per year.
  • The Urban Institute calculated the Sanders plan would increase federal spending by $32 Trillion over a decade (232.7%), an increase in healthcare spending of $6.6 Trillion (26%).
  • Conover has critiqued the Friedman report and found he underestimated the cost by $16.6 Trillion by failure to calculate deadweight losses and the cost of moral hazards.
  • Avik Roy, Manhattan Institute economist, critiqued the Friedman report and found the Sanders plan would increase the federal deficit between $14.4 Trillion and $19 Trillion.

 

Current Unfunded Liabilities

In 2015, the U.S. had a fiscal gap of $210 Trillion. Economists calculate this number by taking the sum of the current federal debt plus the present value of all future tax revenues minus all future federal program costs. When that number is a negative one, there is a fiscal gap or unfunded liability.

Federal debt + future tax revenues – future federal programs expenses = fiscal gap

Present value means it is the additional amount Americans need to have in the bank today earning interest at the U.S. Treasury bill rate in order to finance all our future promises. Health programs such as Medicare, Medicaid and ObamaCare are huge sources of such enormous unfunded liabilities (55% in 2012).

  • State and local governments add $38 Trillion to this number
  • $210 Trillion amounts to $644,000 per U.S. resident
  • $210 Trillion is more than 11 times the GDP in 2016
  • The total wealth in all U.S. households is only about $94.8 Trillion
  • To close this gap would have required raising all federal taxes by 58.5% or cutting federal spending by 37.7%.

 

These numbers are staggering to behold, too much for our comprehension. Therefore it is no wonder that politicians have been “kicking the can down the road”, avoiding the harsh reality of dealing with these deficits. But what they are really doing is stealing from their children and grandchildren who will be forced to pay for their reckless spending.

It’s time to stop the madness. Here is the reality this generation must face. If the Urban Institute calculations are correct, and they are certainly a liberal think-tank unlikely to oppose liberal policies, the Sanders Medicare For All Act would only make this situation worse. It would increase the fiscal gap by a minimum of $61 Trillion!

The Bottom Line

  • The Sanders plan will impose hidden costs ranging from $1.25 Trillion to as much as $2.8 Trillion per year.
  • The Sanders plan will increase the fiscal gap by a minimum of $61 Trillion
  • America cannot afford this expensive new entitlement.
  • No amount of “taxing the rich” will pay for this.
  • This will require us to steal from our children and grandchildren – which is morally unacceptable!