Improving ObamaCare – Little by Little

 

ObamaCare is getting better – little by little. The refusal of Congressional Democrats to cooperate in any way that changes ObamaCare has made wholesale repeal and replacement impossible.

But improvements are happening anyway. The repeal of the Individual Mandate was made possible by the passage of the tax reform legislation. Now people can choose to purchase health insurance without the threat of a government tax if they decide the insurance isn’t worth the money.

Other changes are being made possible through de-regulation. The latest is a change that affects small business owners. It will allow small businesses to band together to provide insurance on equal footing with corporations and unions.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says the share of workers at small businesses with employer-sponsored health benefits has dropped by 25% since 2010 (when ObamaCare was passed) as insurance costs have ballooned in part due to government mandates. Ironically, ObamaCare tried to increase the number of workers on insurance by mandating businesses cover all full-time workers (over 30 hrs. /week) for businesses with 50 or more such employees.

As a result, about 11 million workers employed by small businesses are uninsured. Others have been dumped by their employers onto state insurance exchanges where premiums are subsidized by taxpayers.

President Trump is trying to fix this problem. He instructed Labor Secretary Alexander Acosta to consider “expanding the conditions that satisfy the commonality-of-interest requirements” for association health plans under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, or ERISA. Large group plans that are self-insured (funded by unions or employers) are covered by ERISA. These plans were exempted from ObamaCare’s essential benefits requirements, although they must comply with rules regarding life-time spending limits and pre-existing conditions.

President Obama was interested in satisfying the interests of liberal supporters like unions and large corporations. President Trump is trying to level the playing field for small businesses and sole proprietorships.

Currently, small businesses must purchase coverage from insurers in the small group or individual marketplaces, which are subject to ObamaCare’s coverage mandates and controls on premium prices. The Obama Administration precluded small employers from forming association plans that are exempt from ERISA by their narrow interpretation of the “commonality of interests” membership requirements.

Secretary Acosta has now proposed new rules that would more broadly define the “commonality of interest” clause to include geographical area, as well as an industry, trade or profession. This would allow national industry groups to sponsor plans. It would also allow independent contractors, like Uber drivers or free-lance journalists, to form or join association plans.

These changes will lower the cost of health insurance premiums for all those affected.

Naturally, supporters of ObamaCare are howling that President Trump is trying to destroy the ObamaCare exchanges. But with premiums already climbing 25% or more per year, the exchanges have ceased to be a viable source of insurance for most who don’t get subsidies.

Reality is that these same supporters of ObamaCare are actually hoping for the complete demise of the system so they can then propose single-payer healthcare as the solution. But Americans deserve better than the Canadian system of long waiting lines for delayed treatment.  Changes like the Trump Administration is proposing will help us preserve the freedom of choice we all desire.

The Wall Street Journal summarizes:

“The Trump Administration can’t fix all of ObamaCare’s problems with deregulation, but it can at least provide some struggling Americans with lifeboats such as association health plans.”

ObamaCare – What’s Next?

 

Republicans are basking in the glow of passing major tax reform legislation. Will they try to reform ObamaCare again in 2018?

Some would argue that’s dead and gone, time to move on to something else. Others want to take another swipe at repeal and replacement. Which plan is best?

Avik Roy, healthcare economist writing in The Wall Street Journal, says an intermediate plan would be best. With the elimination of the Individual Mandate of ObamaCare, which was passed as a rider on the tax reform bill, there are other changes that can be made to improve the situation without a full repeal.

Why not leave things the way they are now?

Roy says the growth in spending on healthcare entitlements like Medicaid and Medicare threatens to overwhelm the Treasury, starving the federal government of the funds needed to pay for everything else, including education, welfare, and national defense. Even Democrats should recognize the importance of these other budget items. ObamaCare has increased the actual total spending and the rate of growth of spending on healthcare, despite its promises to do the opposite. (see recent post ObamaCare Fails to Contain Costs)

What changes can realistically be achieved in this partisan Congress?

Full repeal and replacement is probably unrealistic, given the absolute resistance of the Democrats to any change and the lack of unanimity on the Republican side. Fortunately, the policy landscape has improved with the elimination of the Individual Mandate and the relaxation of restrictions on alternative forms of short-term insurance by Trump’s executive orders.

Medicaid Reform

Roy believes the most important change and the greatest opportunity is in reforming Medicaid. To put this in perspective, the cost of government spending on the ObamaCare exchanges in 2016 was $42 Billion. The cost of Medicaid to the federal taxpayers was $358 Billion and to state taxpayers was $208 Billion for a total of $566 Billion in 2016. In other words, Medicaid spending is more than ten times the spending on the ObamaCare exchanges.

It gets worse. By 2025, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) project national Medicaid spending will reach $929 Billion, an increase of 64%. By comparison, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) projects national defense spending in 2025 of $726 Billion, an increase of 24% over 2016 levels. That means Medicaid spending will exceed our national defense spending in the next 7 years!

This might make sense if Medicaid spending was a good investment in the health of our people. However, multiple studies have shown that Medicaid patients have no better healthcare outcomes than people who are uninsured. This is primarily because of the problems of access to healthcare experienced by Medicaid patients.

ObamaCare made all of this worse by extending eligibility to able-bodied adults for the first time. This added about 15 million to the rolls of Medicaid.

Roy suggests Republicans address this problem by several approaches:

  • Revive the Graham–Cassidy Plan – which proposed block grants to the states with the flexibility to design their own Medicaid programs. Focus it solely on Medicaid to convert states’ healthcare entitlements into competitive insurance markets.
  • Per-capita allotments – that tie long-term Medicaid spending to various measures of inflation. States must first get the flexibility to reduce waste and fraud and to focus Medicaid resources on the people who most need them.

 

The long-term savings from Medicaid entitlement reform would significantly impact the rest of the federal budget, allowing funding of badly needed welfare reform, infra-structure spending, and national defense. We cannot allow these critical issues to become underfunded because of the current avalanche of Medicaid spending.

(For more on Medicaid spending see my last post, California Medicaid Spending Out of Control.)

California Medicaid Spending Out of Control

 

California often leads the nation. California leads the nation with the highest state income tax of 13.3%. The next closest state is Oregon at 9.9%. California also leads the nation in Medicaid spending at $81.9 Billion. New York is a distant second at $62.8 Billion.

It’s true that California has the largest population of any state, comprising 12% of total U.S. population. But California also receives more than 30 percent of all Medicaid expansion spending.

Medicaid Overenrollment

Like most liberal governors, California Governor Jerry Brown chose to expand Medicaid under ObamaCare. When the state agreed to this expansion it predicted enrollment would max out at 910,000 able-bodied adults, according to Josh Archambault, writing in Forbes. 

But as of July, 2017, expansion enrollment had reached 3.8 million. Nearly four million able-bodied adults are now receiving free Medicaid, a healthcare system originally intended as a safety net for poor children, seniors, and those with disabilities.

This is having catastrophic consequences for the state and federal taxpayers. Initial projections of the expansion cost were roughly $11.6 billion in the first three years. The actual cost during those same three years grew $43.7 billion. That’s nearly four times original projections. Costs per enrollee are also rising from just over $4,500 in 2014 to over $5,800 in 2015 – a massive 30% rise in a single year.

The Hidden Cost

Archambault says there is an even greater cost than the billions of taxpayers’ dollars being spent. He says,

“The untold story of expansion is that with every additional able-bodied adult who receives Medicaid, California gets further and further away from its goal of helping the truly needy – because every able-bodied adult pushes the most vulnerable on traditional Medicaid further away from the care and services they need. As California adds more able-bodied adults to its Medicaid expansion rolls, it siphons away resources for its truly needy citizens.”

The growth of California Medicaid spending has not gone unnoticed. Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin, chairman of the U.S. Senate’s Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, sent a letter to Governor Brown requesting information and expressing concern about the rapid spending surge the state is experiencing. He is looking for explanations for why the states’ Medicaid enrollment has risen so much past projected rates and what steps are being taken to slow enrollment and curb spending. It is not clear what response he got from Governor Brown.

It is time to move able-bodied adults off the rolls of Medicaid and onto the rolls of the work force. This will not only provide them with jobs but with better healthcare. With the economy growing again under President Trump after 8 years of stagnation under President Obama, many new jobs should be created. That will be good for them and for state and federal taxpayers.