Is Tax Reform Fatal?

 

Can a tax reform plan be fatal? Sounds preposterous – but not for some opponents of the new Republican tax reform bill.

John C. Goodman, economist writing in Forbes, says, “You know you are in the silly season when the charges against sensible tax reform become more and more outrageous. The silliest and most outrageous is based on this causal reasoning: The Republican tax measure repeals the ObamaCare mandate, requiring people to purchase health insurance; without the mandate, fewer people will insure; and without insurance, more people will die.”

Who would be so foolish to say such things? None other than ObamaCare architect Jonathan Gruber and former Treasury Secretary Lawrence Summers. Summers has recently been criticized by other economists for ignoring his own past writings in attacking tax reform. Gruber is the same guy who once said, “Lack of transparency is a huge political advantage.”

The clear message of these two liberal economists is that the government knows what’s best for you and should compel you to follow their advice.

Gruber is actually the one who convinced President Obama that an Individual Mandate was necessary to make his new healthcare law work. Obama had spoken against such a mandate in the 2008 presidential campaign.

Gruber was heralded by the liberal media including The New York Times’ Catherine Rampell who wrote this in 2012:

“Mr. Gruber has spent decades modeling the intricacies of the health care ecosystem, which involves making predictions about how new laws will play out based on past experience and economic theory. It is his research that convinced the Obama administration that health care reform could not work without requiring everyone to buy insurance.”

 

Gruber and Summers are relying on a study done by Sommers, Long and Baicker. They looked at mortality in 19 counties in Massachusetts and 513 statistically similar counties in other states four years before and after Massachusetts imposed an individual health insurance mandate in 2006. That study concluded that increased Massachusetts health coverage reduced mortality by 8.2 deaths per 100,000 people between ages 20 and 64. Sommers et al. interpreted the results to mean that expanding health insurance nationwide would prevent one death per year for every 830 people newly insured.

Goodman says if Gruber and Summers are right, then the estimated 20 million Americans who gained health insurance under ObamaCare should prove their point. If true, and if people in the rest of the country are like people in Massachusetts, deaths for people ages 20 to 64 should have fallen by roughly 24,000 a year. But the sad truth is that crude death rates for the people in that group rose from 341.2 per 100,000 in 2011 to 352.6 in 2015. They even rose in Massachusetts!

While this is not proof Gruber and Summers are wrong, it should make discerning minds very skeptical of their claims. Most people in the age group 20 to 64 are relatively healthy and their deaths are often attributable to accidents, suicide, and homicide. In 2006, the year of the Sommers et al. study, deaths from accidents were 11.9%, suicides 4.3%, and homicides 2.3% of total deaths.

From 2006 to 2010, the age-adjusted death rate from accidents fell 17 percent in Massachusetts for people in the same age group. Victims who require emergency treatment cannot be denied care in U.S. hospitals for lack of health insurance. A lower accident rate alone would lead us to expect a lower mortality rate in Massachusetts relative to the rest of the country regardless of who has health insurance.

The truth is that health insurance has little or no effect on mortality rates. The issue has been studied by former Congressional Budget Office director June O’Neill, former Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality director Richard Kronick, and Berkeley professor David Card. They concluded that any mortality effects of coverage are small. The Oregon Medicaid Experiment, which began in 2007, continues to find little or no impact of health insurance on medical outcomes. The uninsured have fared no worse than those with health insurance, at least those on Medicaid.

As Democrats like Gruber and Summers see their previous accomplishments like ObamaCare come to ruins, it’s little surprise that they try to defend their work. But it’s inexcusable to make bogus claims that bear no resemblance to reality just to try to score political points.

One last point that needs to be emphasized since Democrats and the media continue to repeat a false narrative: The repeal of the Individual Mandate will not cause, force, or trigger anyone to lose health insurance. It will only eliminate the tax penalty for those who choose not to purchase health insurance. Everyone can still purchase health insurance with the same subsidies that were previously available.

ObamaCare Fails to Contain Costs

 

ObamaCare was intended to lower the costs of healthcare. In fact, one of the many broken promises of President Obama was the impact his new healthcare legislation would have on the rising cost of healthcare.

On December 15, 2009, President Obama asserted that the Senate healthcare bill, which passed nine days later, would “finally reduce the costs of health care.” He repeatedly claimed the bill would “bend the cost curve” (a term of art championed by former Office of Management and Budget (OMB) director Peter Orszag and used repeatedly by the president in explain his goals for the proposed plan.)

This deception was based on the fact that in the final year of the 10 year projection used by the Medicare actuary to score the plan, the rate of growth in health spending under the Senate bill (essentially the version signed into law) would be slightly lower (6.9%) than under the status quo (7.2%). However, these projections were largely based on robbing from Medicare ($716 billion over the next ten years).

At the time ObamaCare was passed, these promises were pure speculation. Today we can analyze how close they came to reality.

Healthcare Spending Rising Faster Since ObamaCare

Joseph R. Antos and James C. Capretta, writing in The Wall Street Journal, can now tell us that ObamaCare failed to contain costs. Whether you interpreted “bend the cost curve” to mean lowering actual costs or merely lowering the rate of growth of costs, by either standard ObamaCare has failed.

In their report they say America’s healthcare spending rose 4.3% in 2016. That is the third straight year it outpaced economic growth. Total health spending last year was 17.9% of GDP, up from 17.2% in 2013. 

The above graphic depicts the Annual Growth Rate for National Healthcare Spending, according to the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), from 2002 to 2013. This reflects the period just before implementation of ObamaCare in 2014. You can see from this graphic that the rate of growth of healthcare spending was declining from 9.7% in 2002 to a low of 3.7% in 2012. But since this graphic, the rate of growth of spending is now in the third straight year of growth after implementation of ObamaCare; currently at 4.3%.

What accounts for this cost control failure?

The cost control provisions of ObamaCare simply have failed to pan out. Accountable Care Organizations (ACOs) were supposed to give hospitals and doctors incentives to become more efficient and cut Medicare costs. In 2016, only 56% of the 432 ACOs hit their benchmarks for reducing costs. Even worse, after taking into account their bonus payments, ACOs actually increased Medicare spending, by $216 million in 2015 and $39 million in 2016.

In other words, programs that were supposed to save money actually spent more money!

ObamaCare was also supposed to save money by reducing hospital readmissions. It included a provision to penalize hospitals that readmitted patients less than 30 days after discharge. But new data shows that mortality rates have also increased, suggesting the policy may have contributed to 5400 premature deaths of Medicare patients with serious heart conditions. (For more on this subject see my earlier post Is ObamaCare Killing People?)

Perhaps ObamaCare’s greatest possible cost control is one that both Democrats and Republicans want to repeal. It is referred to as the Cadillac Tax. This provision of ObamaCare is intended to reduce costs by imposing a 40% excise tax on “Cadillac “ insurance policies offered by employers – specifically on any premiums that exceed $27,500 per year for family coverage. The idea was to give employers an incentive to cut costs.

But unions objected because these policies were part of their contract negotiations and they successfully lobbied for this provision to be delayed until 2018. Republicans would also like to kill this provision in the law.

The result of all these failures is that ObamaCare has failed to contain costs. It has
“bent the cost curve” – but it bent it in the wrong direction.

 

Black Education Reformers Step Up

 

(This blog usually discusses healthcare reform but some other subjects really light my fire. One of those is school choice.)

School choice is unpopular with liberal Democrats because it threatens traditional supporters like teachers unions and black political organizations like the NAACP. Yet improved education remains the surest way to escaping poverty for black and other minority children. Too often those who claim to represent these minority children are turning their backs on what’s best for them in favor of their political agenda.

I wrote of this issue in a past blog called School Choice is Making a Difference. Readers of that post will recall that the hero of that story is Eva Moskowitz, the founder of a chain of charter schools serving the needs of the minority children of Harlem. Her efforts to improve the education of these children have been hampered by the National Education Association, the nation’s largest teachers union, The American Federation of Teachers, the NAACP, and New York Mayor Bill DeBlasio.

But there is hope this may be changing. Black education reformers are stepping up and being counted even when their views contradict the Democratic Party line. Jason Riley, The Wall Street Journal columnist, writes of this in a recent column.

Riley says the Associated Press published a hit piece earlier this month that blamed charter schools for perpetuating racial segregation. This was another in a series of such attacks by the liberal media on school choice. But now others on the political left are pushing back.

Shavar Jeffries of Democrats for Education Reform, an advocate for school choice, questioned the reporter’s methodology, among other issues. Jeffries says, “The AP makes apples-to-oranges comparisons that contrast the demographics of individual charter schools to those of entire cities. This ignores the blatantly obvious fact that charter schools are concentrated in neighborhoods with high proportions of students of color to provide them an alternative to the low-performing traditional pubic schools they previously had no choice but to attend.”

Jeffries was even more incensed by the implication that somehow black students couldn’t succeed unless there were more white students. He said, “There’s no doubt there are benefits for students who attend racially diverse schools, but we take issue with the assumption that black and brown children can’t learn unless they attend school alongside white children.”

An even more harsh criticism came from Amy Wilkins of the National Alliance of Public Charter Schools. She took umbrage at the implication that school choice proponents like herself have made common cause with the racial segregationists of yesteryear.

Ms. Wilkins has a civil-rights pedigree that few could question. She is the daughter of Roger Wilkins, the black political activist, journalist and academic, who served in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations. She is the niece of Roy Wilkins, who led the NAACP in the 1950s and ‘60s, when the Jim Crow laws were still in effect. Wilkins has spent her entire adult life as an outspoken advocate for black children.

The problem, wrote Wilkins, “isn’t one article, however off-base it may be. The problem is the mindset of revanchists who peddle stories like these – professional anti-reformers who go nuts when approaches other than those they sanction and control deliver results for the students . . . they insist cannot learn at high levels.”

Riley says that black parents simply want better schools, and the strong demand for education choice among low-income families stems from the persistent failure of traditional public-school systems to provide a decent education for their children.

Wilkins goes on: “There is no comparison – none – between the enforced segregation of the pre-Brown v. Board era and the choices black families make when they enroll their children in better schools. It’s ludicrous to suggest the two are in any way similar. In fact, it’s far closer to the spirit of Jim Crow to tell a black student that she has to go to her dismal neighborhood school because the better charter school up the street is not white enough to satisfy the defenders of the status quo.”

I am excited to see this internal debate within the Democratic Party as education reformers like Jeffries, Wilkins, and Riley take on the establishment that has consistently put political agendas ahead of the needs of minority children. The clear winners in the school choice movement are these minority children and it’s time their representatives stopped kowtowing to the teachers unions and started looking out for the children they claim to represent.

Wilkins minces no words in her disdain for such people:

“To the people trying to fabricate a segregation story to deny black students educational opportunity, I have a simple message: Don’t you dare! Don’t you dare try to take away choices black families have fought for. Don’t you dare tell black families that you know better than they do what kind of school their children should attend. Don’t you dare call yourself social justice warriors while undermining the work of black school leaders and educators who are building something better for their communities.”