School Choice Saves Lives

 

School choice has been shown to do many things. It gives parents a choice in where they send their children to school. It allows poor children to attend better schools they normally couldn’t afford. It gives children with great potential the education to realize that potential. It gives many minority children living in poverty the chance to escape that poverty and realize the American Dream. It has been shown repeatedly to improve test scores.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board reports several studies have found that school choice also reduces arrests and that private-school students experience less bullying. This is attributed to stricter discipline in those schools compared to public schools. School choice programs also allow parents to pull their kids out of public schools if they are struggling and send them to schools that are safer or a better cultural fit.

And now comes a study in the journal School Effectiveness and School Improvement that examined the link between school choice and mental health. The Cato Institute’s Corey DeAngelis and Western Carolina University economist Angela Dills analyzed the correlation between adolescent suicide rates and the enactment of private-school voucher and charter programs over the last several decades.

Their study found states that enacted charter school laws witnessed a 10% decrease in suicide rates among 15-to-19 year-olds. Private school voucher laws were also associated with fewer suicides, though the change was not statistically significant. The effect is believed to be larger if more students received vouchers.

WSJ says the researchers also looked for any correlation between students who attended private school as teenagers and their mental health as adults. After controlling for socioeconomic factors, individuals who attended private schools were two percentage points less likely to report a mental health condition when they were about 30 years old.

This means school choice is saving lives. With lower suicide rates in teenagers and improved mental health even into the third decade, these studies strengthen the argument for school choice in all states.

Dills explains, “It’s likely that private schools face stronger competition pressures to provide a safer school environment and improve mental health if they want to remain open. Public schools, on the other hand, are more likely to be burdened with government regulations that make it difficult for them to control discipline policy and create strong school cultures.”

The Covid pandemic, with closure of many public schools, has exacerbated this problem. But even before the pandemic, mental illness represented a growing problem among young adults. Between 2007 and 2015, suicide rates doubled for females age 15 to 19 and increased by 30% for males. Suicide is the second leading cause of death for young adults. Four times as many children ages five to 17 commit suicide in a typical year than have died of Covid-19.

The obvious solution to this growing problem is to promote school choice – and reopen the schools. Based on this data, Covid-19 is far less of a threat to children than suicide.

Vaccination Distribution Better in Some States

 

Which states are doing the best job of vaccinating their people? That’s the most important question that should be on the minds of the Biden administration.

Job One for Joe Biden is dealing with the Covid pandemic that is still widespread in our nation. If he fails to get the pandemic under control, the rest of his agenda will be meaningless. Therefore, making sure vaccine is getting into the arms of most Americans must be his first priority.

Distribution has been following the federalism model, which allows states to make their own decisions after the federal government makes recommendations. The CDC initially recommended healthcare workers and nursing home residents receive the vaccine first. There was not much argument over that, but the next priority group began the bickering.

According to The Wall Street Journal, after six weeks since the first distribution of vaccines were shipped, the U.S. has administered some 53% of the distributed vaccines. The gap continues to grow between states that are getting shots into arms, and those arguing over who gets what and when.

North Dakota has administered some 84% of its supply as of January 23, and West Virginia about 83%. Compare that to states like California (45%) or Alabama (47%) and you see that federalism is showing what works and what doesn’t work. WSJ says President Biden is fortunate to inherit Operation Warp Speed. Biden says he’ll trigger the Defense Production Act to expand vaccine production, but doesn’t say how he’d build on the existing plan.

The most successful state rollouts have been those that departed from overly prescriptive federal rules. North Dakota stuck with the initial recommendations to vaccinate healthcare workers and nursing home residents, but then opened the program to anyone age 65 and up, as well as adults with underlying health risks. Florida did the same. This makes perfect sense since we should be vaccinating those at greatest risk first and age is the number one determinant of risk.

South Dakota added law enforcement and corrections staff to its initial tiers, and then moved quickly to inoculate 65 and older adults and school workers. The states with the highest per capita vaccination rates are all rule-breakers: (as of January 23)

  • Alaska – 12,885 per 100,000
  • West Virginia – 11,321 per 100,000
  • North Dakota – 9,602 per 100,000

 

Compare those numbers with the states with the lowest vaccination rates:

  • California – 5,568 per 100,000
  • New York – 5,816 per 100,000

 

The best performing states also showed creativity about how best to distribute and administer the vaccines, even if that meant departing from federal advice. North Dakota began planning its vaccine rollout last summer and chose to distribute vaccine supplies to healthcare providers statewide – not only to hospitals or public health systems. West Virginia opted out of a federal program putting CVS and Walgreens in charge of vaccinating most nursing homes, which has proved especially slow. Instead, the state used a network of 250 local pharmacies, most of which had existing relationships with patients, which sped up scheduling and paperwork. It also used the National Guard to help deliver vaccines to the state’s long-term care facilities.

Federalism benefits most when using the “laboratories of democracy” in each state to learn valuable lessons about what works and what doesn’t. Those states with the poorest vaccination rates should pay attention to those most successful if they want to vaccinate their people faster and more efficiently.

Biden’s Covid Plan is Trump’s Plan – Again!

 

In 1987, Joe Biden ran for president. As a 44-year-old Senator, he was considered an up and coming star of the Democratic party and one of seven hopefuls for president that year. As chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, he would preside over the confirmation hearings of Judge Robert Bork, a controversial conservative nominated to the Supreme Court. This would give him great visibility in the coming presidential election campaign and the political stars seemed to be aligning in his favor.

But a few days before those confirmation hearings began, a scandal erupted. Biden had made a speech in his presidential campaign at the Iowa State Fair. Investigative journalists pieced together footage of U. K. Labour Party leader Neil Kinnock giving a speech that Biden had clearly used for his Iowa speech without giving attribution to Kinnock. Other examples of Biden’s plagiarism were soon found and he had to drop out of the presidential campaign only three months after he began.

In the 2020 presidential election campaign, Biden came out with his plan to curb the spread of the Covid pandemic. It was so similar to President Trump’s plan, the Wall Street Journal editorial board stated, “The Democratic nominee is also promising a better virus strategy, which would be wonderful if he had one. But the virus plan he’s pushing is little different on the substance than what the Trump Administration is already doing.” (see Biden’s Covid Plan is Trump’s Plan)

Now that he is president, Joe Biden has just announced his plans to deal with the Covid pandemic. He has promised 100 million vaccinations in the next 100 days. According to The Wall Street Journal, the new strategy is focused partly on ramping up vaccinations and curbing the spread of the virus through mask wearing, testing data and treatments, and includes new executive orders and directives. One order directs agencies to use their authority, including the Defense Production Act, to meet shortfalls in supplies such as masks, while another establishes a pandemic testing board to expand testing supply and access. Another order requires masks in airports and in certain transportation such as many trains, ships, intercity buses and airplanes.

In the immortal words of Yogi Berra, “It’s deja vu, all over again!” This is just a repackaging of the Trump plan. His promise to produce 100 million vaccinations in the next 100 days is not much of a challenge. According to outgoing CDC Director Dr. Robert Redfield, the Trump administration has nearly reached a million vaccinations a day already. A Bloomberg compilation of state vaccination data confirms the rate of inoculations – which has been gradually accelerating since late December – averaged 912,497 per day during the final week of the Trump administration.

The real reason for the slower than predicted vaccination process is blue state governors who have refused to accept Trump administration recommendations. The rollout has been particularly slow in those states while state and local officials argue over vaccination priorities. Mask mandates may sound like a good idea, but it is doubtful they will make any significant difference since masks seem to be already required in all public spaces. The lower-than-usual flu infections this season have been attributed to the widespread use of masks around the world.

All the focus on lockdowns, masks, social distancing, hand washing, and other measures designed to ameliorate the spread of the virus will have much less impact than the vaccination of the population. The important thing to do now is get vaccinated; the sooner the better. Joe Biden wants to take credit for “stopping the pandemic”, but the real credit goes to those who made the vaccines available in record-breaking time.