Vaccination Priority – Who Gets the Vaccine First?

 

The rollout of the Covid vaccines has failed to live up to expectations for a number of reasons. Disputes between state and federal officials, varying opinions on priorities, and insufficient supplies of vaccines are just a few of the excuses we’ve heard.

Politics, unfortunately, has only added to the confusion and the difficulties of getting vaccines in the arms of vulnerable Americans. Federalism gives states the freedom to make their own decisions about distribution of the vaccines and some states have clearly done a better job than others.

I am blessed to live in the state of Florida. We have a governor, Ron DeSantis, who has done a wonderful job of keeping our people safe while reopening our economy with safety guidelines. This has kept our virus infection numbers reasonable while maintaining our economy and our schools. He has also shown good judgment in the distribution of the vaccines.

The CDC recommended “Phase A” provide vaccine to healthcare workers and nursing home residents as the top priority. There was not much disagreement on this initial prioritization. Certainly, you should be sure your healthcare workers get vaccinated first, since they not only are at high risk but must provide the treatment others will need. Nursing homes have been the sites of over 40% of all Covid deaths, so they also must be a high priority.

The real trouble comes after that. Many states want to place “essential workers” ahead of the elderly who are not living in nursing homes and others who are at high risk. Teachers unions want teachers to get higher priority, restaurant associations want restaurant workers to get higher priority, police associations want police to get higher priority, and on and on. A system of simplification is needed, based on risk.

There is no question that risk is associated with age for this virus, all other factors considered. The older you are, the greater your risk. Paul E. Peterson, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says age must be the determining factor in prioritizing vaccinations.

Florida Governor DeSantis says more than 80% of Covid deaths in Florida are in persons over age 65. In Massachusetts the average age of death from the virus during roughly the first two weeks of December was 80. Over that short period, 420 octogenarians and older in the state died – a death rate of 143 per 100,000. The death rate for those between 70 and 80 was 33 per 100,000. For those between 60 and 70, the rate was less than 10 per 100,000. Rates for those in their prime working years – 30 to 50 – are only about 1 in 100,000.

Therefore, it is clear that age should be the number one determinant of vaccine eligibility. Not only does this prioritize by risk, but it also simplifies the eligibility documentation. By simply producing a driver’s license, people can be certified for vaccination. This is working well in Florida and should be adopted in all states.

This is not to suggest that others are not vulnerable. Many younger Americans are still at high risk due to immunocompromised conditions including cancer, obesity, diabetes, and chronic lung and heart conditions. They should also receive the vaccine as soon as possible.

Peterson says, “The need for simplicity and speed is similarly important. Shortening the pandemic by one month would save thousands of lives. This isn’t the right moment for deliberate selection among multiple claimants for protection. Keep it simple. Tempus fugit: Vaccinate the population before autumn leaves begin to fall.”

Misinformation Makes Pandemic Worse

 

Last year was a year like no other in my lifetime; perhaps in no one’s lifetime since the Spanish Flu pandemic of 1918. I lost my maternal grandmother in that one, so I’ve heard a lot about it. It infected 500 million in the world, about one third of the world’s population at that time. Death counts for that flu vary from between 17 million and 50 million, making it one of the deadliest pandemics in human history.

That was over a hundred years ago and modern medicine has come a long way since then. Today, we have antibiotics to treat the pneumonia that so often complicates influenza. We have much finer critical care units with sophisticated equipment and better trained doctors and nurses. This puts us in much better shape to handle a pandemic, but misinformation has often stymied attempts to control the spread of the virus and led to unprecedented economic harm.

Dr. Scott W. Atlas, of the Hoover Institute at Stanford, served from August through November as a special adviser to the Corona Task Force of President Trump. He says, “the politicization of the pandemic has made things worse by adding misinformation and vitriol to the mix. With vaccines finally being administered, we should be entering a joyous phase. Instead we endure still more inflammatory rhetoric and media distortion.”

 

Atlas says Americans need to understand three realities:

  • First – All 50 states independently directed and implemented their own pandemic policies. In every case, governors and local officials were responsible for on-the- ground choices – every business limit, school closing, shelter-in-place order and mask requirement. No policy on any of these issues was set by the federal government, except those involving federal property and employees.

 

  • Second – Nearly all states used the same draconian policies that people now insist on hardening, even though the number of positive cases increased while people’s movements were constrained, business activities were strictly limited, and schools were closed. Governors in all but a few states – Florida and South Dakota are notable exceptions – imposed curfews, quarantines, directives on group gatherings, and mask mandates.

 

Gallup and YouGov data show that 80 – 90% of Americans have been wearing masks since early August. Lockdown policies had horrendous impacts on local economies, families and children, and the virus spread anyway. Those who promote more lockdowns are ignoring these results.

 

  • Third – The federal government’s role in the pandemic has been grossly mischaracterized by the media and their Democratic allies. That distortion has obscured several significant successes, while undermining the confidence of ordinary Americans. Federal financial support and directives enabled the development of a massive, state-of-the -art testing capacity and produced billions of dollars of personal protective equipment. Federal agencies met all requests for supplemental medical personnel and hospital-bed capacity.

 

The federal government also expedited development and delivery of lifesaving drugs, such as novel antibody treatments that reduce hospitalizations of high-risk elderly by more than 70%. According to HHS, more than 200,000 doses of these monoclonal-antibody drugs have been delivered to hospitals in all 50 states. Under Operation Warp Speed, the federal government took nearly all the risk away from private pharmaceutical companies and delivered highly effective vaccines, hitting all promised timelines.

President-elect Biden has warned that more lockdowns may be necessary. Bill Gates has called for lockdowns for another six months. Dr. Anthony Fauci has suggested lockdowns may be needed until more people are vaccinated. Yet empirical data from the U.S., Europe, and Japan show that lockdowns don’t eliminate the virus and don’t stop the virus from spreading. They do, however, create extremely harmful health and social problems beyond a dramatic drop in learning, including a tripling of reported depression, skyrocketing suicidal ideation, unreported child abuse, skipped visits for cancer and other medical care.

Stanford’s Dr. Jay Bhattacharya says, “For younger people, the lockdowns are so harmful, so deadly, there’s really no good justification, especially when considering their extremely low risk from Covid-19.” (see Covid Update Simplifies Strategy).

Dr. Atlas says, “States and cities that keep their economies locked down after highly vulnerable populations have been vaccinated will be doubling down on failed policies that are destroying families and sacrificing children, particularly among the working class and poor.”

The real culprit in this pandemic of misinformation is the media. Atlas says, “The media has done its best to misinform the public with political attacks about who is to blame for this pain and misery even as it diminishes the great achievement of the new vaccines. The decline of objectivity in journalism has been evident for years. Now we see that even respected scientific journals, which are supposed to vet and publish the best objective research, have been contaminated by politics. Social media has become the arbiter of allowable discussion, while universities intimidate and suppress the free exchange of ideas necessary to uncover scientific truths.”

I couldn’t have said it better, myself. This same conclusion was reached by Dr. Marc Siegel in his recently published book Covid: The Politics of Fear and the Power of Science. For more on this see my recent post The Political Discreditation of Hydroxychloroquine.

Covid -19 Immunity Could Last for Years

 

With all the good news about vaccines now available for the Covid-19 virus, what will we worry about next? The answer is “How long will the vaccine immunity last?”

There is good news on that question from Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). A new study shows Covid-19 patients who recovered from the disease still show robust immunity from the coronavirus eight months after infection. The authors of the study believe immunity to the virus probably will last for many years.

Neel V. Patel, writing in MIT Technology Review, says this should alleviate fears that the Covid-19 vaccine would require repeated booster shots to protect against the disease and finally get the pandemic under control.

“There was a lot of concern originally that this virus might not induce much memory,” says Shane Crotty, a researcher at the La Jolla Institute for Immunology in California and a coauthor of the new paper. “Instead, the immune memory looks quite good.” 

The study, published January 6 in Science, contrasts with earlier findings that suggested Covid-19 immunity could be short-lived. Many feared this would put millions who’ve already recovered from the virus still at risk. But the new study suggests reinfection should only be a problem for a very small percentage of people who’ve developed immunity – whether through an initial infection or by vaccination. The few individuals who fail to develop long-lasting immunity will be protected by the development of herd immunity in the larger population.

The study took blood samples from 185 men and women who had recovered from Covid-19. Each person provided at least one blood sample between six days and eight months after their initial symptoms, and 43 of the samples were taken after six months. They also measured the levels of several immunological agents that work together to prevent reinfection: antibodies, B Cells, and T Cells.

The researchers found that antibodies in the body declined moderately after eight months, although levels varied wildly between individuals. But T-Cell numbers declined only modestly, and B-Cell numbers held steady and sometimes inexplicably grew. That means that despite decreases in free-flowing antibodies, the components that can restart antibody production and coordinate an attack against the coronavirus stick around at pretty high levels. The same mechanism that leads to immune memory after infection also forms the basis for immunity after vaccination, so the same trends ought to hold for vaccinated people as well.

There is additional encouragement found in the study of people who have recovered from SARS, a close cousin of the virus that causes Covid-19. A study published in August showed that T-Cells specific to SARS can remain in the blood for at least 17 years, bolstering hopes that Covid-19 immunity could last for decades.

While this is only one study with a limited number of patients, it gives us all much encouragement that immunity from this Covid virus will last, possibly for years. This is great news and should be additional motivation for everyone to get vaccinated