Junk Science Prevails in Roundup Settlement

 

The Wall Street Journal editorial board calls it “a shakedown for the history books.” They are referring to the recent settlement by Bayer to pay up to $10.9 billion to settle with plaintiff attorneys who claim its weedkiller Roundup causes cancer.

Bayer has agreed to pay as much as $9.6 billion to settle some 125,000 cases and unfiled claims. In exchange, 25 law firms say they don’t intend to take on more litigation. Bayer will set aside another $1.25 billion for a future class-action settlement brought by a different set of trial lawyers. Bayer and those attorneys agreed to establish a five-member panel of scientists to consider whether glyphosate, the active ingredient in Roundup, causes non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma.

Why would Bayer agree to this settlement?

The science isn’t settled. There is no proof that glyphosate causes cancer. Last year, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), certainly no friend of corporations, said it wouldn’t approve product labels claiming the weedkiller causes cancer because that would “constitute a false and misleading statement.” Federal Judge William Shubb issued a permanent injunction preventing California from requiring a cancer warning on the herbicide. He noted that nearly every regulator that has looked at the evidence “has found that there was no or insufficient evidence that glyphosate causes cancer.”

The only exception to this pattern is the World Health Organization’s International Agency for Research on Cancer. The WHO has been in the news a lot lately due to its failures to contain the corona virus pandemic and their cozy relationship with China. The Trump administration just announced their intent to withdraw from participation in WHO because of their incompetence and political bias. According to the WSJ, the WHO believes everything from sipping hot cocoa to talking on a cell phone might give you cancer. It determined glyphosate is “probably carcinogenic” only after writing off evidence to the contrary, Reuters reported. One of the advisers who helped conduct the group’s glyphosate analysis concurrently received pay from trial lawyers. Naturally, he has since testified in the Roundup litigation.

Bayer has lost some spectacular trials so far. In the first Roundup case heard, the San Francisco Superior Court limited Bayer from discussing the EPA’s conclusions, but allowed the plaintiff attorneys to wax on about findings from the International Agency for Research on Cancer. In the second case, the plaintiff’s attorney ignored the court’s limits on admissible evidence, a violation that was “intentional and committed in bad faith,” Judge Vince Chhabria determined later. In a third case, an Alameda County Superior Court judge prevented jurors from hearing about a comprehensive new EPA review in which federal regulators concluded Roundup doesn’t cause cancer and poses no danger to health when used as directed.

These three cases alone cost Bayer more than $2.4 billion in jury penalties. Judges have since reduced this to $190 million but Bayer is still appealing. But their future is not bright, given that they face some 52,000 plaintiffs as of April.

The Bayer settlement is based on gambling that the panel will reach the same conclusion as regulators in the U.S., the European Union, Australia, Japan, and elsewhere – that glyphosate isn’t a carcinogen. If they’re right, the legal system has done them a great harm. If they’re wrong, they should pull Roundup from the market before anyone else is harmed.

(Note: In an ironic twist to this story, Judge Chhabria is now expressing skepticism about the terms of the Bayer settlement. In a four-page order refusing to delay a July court hearing in the case, he questioned “whether it would be constitutional (or otherwise lawful)” to hand the issue to a panel of scientists instead of judges and juries. In other words, he prefers to let ordinary people (juries) settle this scientific issue rather than a panel of scientists. He went on to say, “In an area where the science may be evolving, how could it be appropriate to lock in a decision from a panel of scientists for all future cases?” Here he makes a good point, for our scientific knowledge is always evolving. However, if future science proves that claims glyphosate causes cancer are proven false, will the courts demand a refund of Bayer’s money?)

Biden Chooses Teachers’ Unions Over Students

 

There is a war being fought for the minds of our most vulnerable children.

On one side are those who want to give parents the choice of which schools their children attend. These people advocate school choice and charter schools, which enable minority children to escape poor public schools. This provides these children with a quality education that gives them the tools to escape poverty. (see School Choice – The Key to the American Dream.)

On the other side are those who want to protect the jobs of teachers’ unions and poor teachers. These people are more concerned with the political support of teachers’ unions and less concerned with the education and future of minority children. They are counting on the loyalty of minority parents who traditionally have voted Democratic despite years of that party’s ignoring the needs of their children.

Joe Biden just made his choice – he chose to support the teachers’ unions. He chose to put teachers and unions ahead of students and their future.

Biden recently pledged his support of the National Educators Association (NEA), one of the largest teachers’ unions in the country. His wife, Jill, is an NEA member. He proudly announced, “When we win this election, we’re going to get the support you need and the respect you deserve. You don’t just have a partner in the White House, you’ll have an NEA member in the White House. And if I’m not listening, I’m going to be sleeping alone in the Lincoln Bedroom.”

Biden made his priorities clear to the NEA in March, when it endorsed him in the Democratic primary. He said, “No privately funded charter school – or private charter school – would receive a penny of federal money.”

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says this is a departure even from the days of President Obama. From 2000 to 2017, the share of public-school students who attended a charter school rose from 1% to 6%. Those statistics represent thousands of stories of children, many of them black and Hispanic, who escaped failing schools to get a better education.

Biden seems eager to repudiate this record and put space between his intentions and the record of the Obama administration. He told the NEA his plan involves, “higher salaries for educators,” “universal pre-K”, and “tripling the funding for Title 1 schools.” He also pledged to “double the number of school psychologists and counselors and nurses and social workers in school,” and to “help educators wipe out the burden of their own student debt.”

The WSJ says, “Teachers first. Put it on a bumper sticker, Mr. Biden, and hope people don’t notice the corollary is that students, and especially poor and minority students, come second.”

 This practice of supporting teachers’ unions at the expense of minority children has been successful for many years for Democratic candidates. But the 2018 Florida gubernatorial election proved minority parents are paying attention. Post-election analysis showed that the difference in this closely contested election was the votes of black women. They chose Ron DeSantis, a white Congressman, over Andrew Gillum, a black mayor of Jacksonville.

According to CNN exit polling of 3,108 voters, of the roughly 650,000 black women who voted in Florida, 18% or about 117,000 chose DeSantis. This exceeded their support for GOP U.S. Senate candidate Rick Scott (9%). In other words, they selected the Republican gubernatorial candidate but not the Republican senatorial candidate. William Mattox, director of the Marshall Center for Educational Options at the James Madison Institute, writes in The Wall Street Journal that the reason is school choice.

 Joe Biden is surely aware of these statistics but betting on the loyalty of black and minority voters. It’s time these parents made the right choice – and voted for their children’s future. It’s time they supported the only presidential candidate who will support School Choice – President Trump.

 

Time to Reopen Schools

 

 

The process of reopening our economy is now well under way, but not the school system. As school officials argue over when and how to reopen the schools this fall, some on the left are resisting this move. The Wall Street Journal editorial board says, “Everything else about the coronavirus has become politicized in America, so why not a return to school as well?”

President Trump has pushed for schools to reopen and Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos has supported this policy. Naturally, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi condemns this idea in the strongest possible terms. She said, “I think what we heard from the secretary was malfeasance and dereliction of duty.” So much for civility in Washington these days.

What have we learned from history?

In 1951 the nation was deeply entrenched in the polio epidemic that was especially devastating to children. The same question was posed by health officials then: Should polio close schools? Here is an abstract from the Journal of School Health, published September, 1951:

“The recent severe poliomyelitis epidemic has again revived the question: Shall the schools be closed or children kept out of school in the presence of an epidemic? There has been some agitation for school closure here and some parents delayed sending their children to school last fall. Such parents reason thus: Public health people tell us to avoid crowds; at the same time, they advise us to send our children to school where they may be exposed. On the surface such advice seems inconsistent but practically it has been found, both in America and Britain, that school attendance has no effect on epidemics of polio or any other communicable disease. Numerous epidemiological studies have proved this point beyond controversy.”

“Anderson and Arnstein in “Communicable Disease Control,” 1948, in discussing poliomyelitis, say: “School closure, as well as closure of moving picture theaters, Sunday schools, and other similar groups, is frequently attempted in response to popular demand that ‘something be done.’ Although tried repeatedly, it is of no proved value, never altering the usual curve of the epidemic; nor has the disease been more prevalent or persistent in those communities with the courage to resist such demands.”

 

Former commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration, Dr. Scott Gottlieb, agrees it is time to reopen the schools. Writing in The Wall Street Journal, Gottlieb says it can be done safely with certain precautions. He says Germany and Norway reopened schools with stringent precautions such as distancing and wearing masks. But when Israel reopened schools, large outbreaks followed, although most infections in both teachers and students were mild.

He suggests the use of hand-washing stations will be routine. Desks will be farther apart. Teachers should be given protective equipment. Classes may be staggered and students may wear masks. Colleges should use pooled testing of students and teachers to reduce risk, and this practice could be adopted widely. Timing of reopening and the measures necessary may vary according to local prevalence of disease.

How risky is the coronavirus to children?

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 30 children under age 15 have died from Covid-19. In a typical year 190 children die of the flu, 436 die from suicide, 625 from homicide, and 4,114 from unintentional deaths such as drowning. Only two children under age 18 have died in Chicago – less than were killed in shootings in a recent weekend! In New York City, 0.03% of children under age 18 have been hospitalized for Covid-19 and 7.5 in one million have died. The death rate for those over age 75 is more than 2,200 times higher than for those under 18.

The differences between Covid-19 and poliomyelitis are significant. Polio was especially virulent and widespread in children and caused crippling effects and many deaths. Covid-19 has been especially benign in the young and rarely causes permanent effects or death. The largest study of 2,100 pediatric Covid patients from China found that 5% of children developed severe disease with low blood oxygen; 0.6% became more critically ill with respiratory failure, shock or multiple organ dysfunction. There is some investigation currently underway concerning a rare inflammatory syndrome related to Covid that can make children seriously ill and damage their hearts.

The risks of children contracting the disease must be measured against the risks of leaving them home where their education and socialization are likely impaired. “Missing school can have serious consequences for child health and wellbeing, particularly for students with disabilities or with special healthcare needs,” American Academy of Pediatrics President Sally Goza said recently.

While some parents are able to effectively educate their children at home, most parents do not have the skills or means to adequately perform those duties. It is the children who will suffer the most. Since the risks and potential sequalae of Covid are far less than polio, the prudent choice is to send children back to school.