Singapore Healthcare Worth a Look

 

ObamaCare is the healthcare system of America, but neither Republicans, nor Democrats really like it. Republicans have been trying to repeal and replace it since President Trump was elected in 2016, but a few divisive Senators prevented that from happening. Democrats claim to support it (they were responsible for 100% of the votes that passed the legislation in 2010), but spend most of their time talking about replacing it with a single-payer system or Medicare for All.

Is there a better system anywhere in the world?

Singapore may be the answer to that question. Singapore has long been promoted by healthcare economists and policy experts as a model system. While America is generally regarded as the place to get the most advanced medical treatment possible, the Singapore healthcare system compares favorably with the U.S.

Former U.S. Secretary of State, George P. Shultz, and Vidar Jorgensen, writing in The Wall Street Journal, believe we would do well to look closer at Singapore. Here are some important statistics in comparing the two systems:

  • U. S. Life Expectancy – 78.7 years
  • Singapore Life Expectancy – 85.2 years
  • Singapore infant and maternal mortality rates less than half U.S. rates
  • U. S. healthcare spending 18% of GDP
  • Singapore healthcare spending 5% of GDP

 

What accounts for these differences?

The two biggest problems in holding down costs in the U.S. healthcare system are third-party payers and lack of transparency in medical prices. Both contribute to stifling competition. Competition always leads to lower pricing and improved quality, no matter what industry you’re comparing. Most consumers of medical treatment don’t know what they’re paying for their care – and aren’t really interested because third-party payers (insurance companies and the government) are paying most or all of the bills. This means patients don’t compare pricing in order to get the best value for their healthcare dollars.

When you go to purchase a car, you always compare prices before you buy. No third-party will be picking up the tab so you want to know you’re getting a good deal. But when insurance companies or the government are responsible for the bill, you don’t care what they’re paying. This is why healthcare costs are rising faster than inflation.

Here is how Singapore does better:

  • Price Transparency– All healthcare providers in Singapore must post their prices and outcomes so buyers can judge the cost and quality.
  • Health Savings Accounts– Singaporeans are required to fund HSAs through a system called MediSave and to purchase catastrophic health insurance. As a result, patients spend their own money on health care and get to pocket any savings.
  • A limited but effective safety net– The MediFund program serves those who, after exhausting their health savings and government subsidies, still need help paying their bills.

 

These differences in the Singapore healthcare system have provided the financial incentives that led to price and quality competition so intense that healthcare costs are 75% lower in Singapore than in the United States. Imagine a 75% discount on your next healthcare bill! Scrips College economist Sean Flynn estimates a heart-valve replacement costs $12,500 in Singapore ($160,000 in the U.S.) and a total knee replacement $13,000 ($40,000 in the U.S.).

All of this is possible in the U.S.

The Trump administration has pushed for more price transparency through an executive order that requires insurers and providers to make price information available to beneficiaries, enrollees and participants in healthcare plans. Naturally, healthcare providers, especially hospitals and insurers are pushing back at any attempts to open their books to comparisons. But people spending their own money need to have information to find value in their healthcare spending.

Health Savings Accounts (HSAs) were introduced in America in 2003 as part of the Medicare Part D legislation of the Bush administration. But limitations on qualifications and yearly contributions have made them much less effective than they could be. I personally established an HSA account some years ago, but once I switched from private health insurance to Medicare at age 65 I was no longer eligible to make additional contributions. This needs to change if we want to lower healthcare costs. HSAs should be encouraged by increasing annual contribution ceilings and expanding eligibility to all Americans, no matter their age or insurance provider.

America can do better, but it will require bipartisan agreement that the goal is to empower consumers with prices to compare and incentives to spend less by allowing them to benefit from the savings. Competition is a wonderful thing, but it requires a level-playing field where consumers can make their own decisions in their own self-interest.

 

 

Supreme Court Upholds Religious Freedom

 

Just when you thought the Supreme Court had been highjacked by the liberals, conservatives received some good news.

First, SCOTUS announced a unanimous decision condemning the “faithless electors” in the 2016 presidential election who chose to vote independent of their state’s election results. Then, by a 7-2 vote, the Court upheld the Trump administration rules that expanded moral and religious exemptions to a federal requirement that employer-provided health insurance plans cover birth control with no out-of-pocket expenses.

Not only Chief Justice John Roberts, a recent supporter of liberal opinions, but also liberal Justices Elena Kagan and Stephen Breyer, along with reliable conservatives Samuel Alito, Clarence Thomas, Neil Gorsuch, and Brett Kavanaugh voted with the majority. Only liberal stalwarts Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Sonia Sotomayor dissented.

Brent Kendall, writing in The Wall Street Journal, reports the majority opinion, written by Justice Thomas, said the administration “had the authority to provide exemptions from the regulatory contraceptive requirements for employers with religious and conscientious objections.”

The issue received national attention following the passage of the Affordable Care Act (ObamaCare) which mandated employers provide birth control and abortifacients (drugs that induce abortion) to all employees who requested them. They then provided exemptions for many industries and political supporters including churches, but not for religious affiliated organizations or privately owned businesses.

Hobby Lobby, a national arts and crafts store, was the first to challenge the law successfully in the courts. The Supreme Court ruled in their favor, but the decision was narrowly worded and did not provide relief for many other organizations. The Little Sisters of the Poor, a Catholic charity of nuns, was not considered exempt from the law.

The Trump administration issued new rules in 2018 that broadened the exemptions to allow many employers to cite religious or moral objections to drop contraceptives without provision for alternate coverage. These new rules were challenged by the states of Pennsylvania and New Jersey and brought before the Supreme Court. Lower court rulings that opposed the Trump administration rules forced the decision to come before SCOTUS.

It is reassuring in these times of liberal ascendancy on the Court to see that the Justices can sometimes see things as the original founding fathers imagined them. There is no greater freedom that we hold dear than the freedom to worship in our own way and operate our businesses and our lives in accordance with our own religious beliefs. The Supreme Court has upheld the American way of life – at least for this moment.

Support for Trump’s Medicaid Proposal

 

Last week I discussed President Trump’s plans to improve Medicaid (Trump Improving Medicaid). His administration has proposed offering states block grants to design their own plans to improve Medicaid efficiency and control costs so that those who need Medicaid the most will get the treatment they need.

Support for this program comes now from an unexpected place. Insurance industry analyst, Robert Laszewski, says those who support ObamaCare should support Trump’s proposal.

Laszewski is a strong supporter of Medicaid expansion, if not the failed provisions of ObamaCare. He believes Republicans should expand Medicaid eligibility in all states as ObamaCare permits.

The Trump proposal would enable states to choose to accept either a single annual lump-sum payment, or a lump-sum payment based on the number of able-bodied adults in that state’s Medicaid program. The proposed block grant program would not apply to people traditionally eligible for Medicaid such as pregnant women, poor children, and the disabled.

Currently 36 states have expanded Medicaid eligibility under the ObamaCare rules. That means anyone, even able-bodied adults, earning 138% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) or less is eligible. States get reimbursed 90% of their costs from the federal government on these patients, but less on those eligible by the old guidelines.

This expansion of Medicaid eligibility has produced much higher usage of Medicaid by this newly eligible population than those previously enrolled; 16 times higher according to some studies. The result of these higher than expected costs has been tremendous strain on state budgets. The Trump proposal is designed to address this situation.

There is wide variation in the eligibility of Medicaid enrollees in those 14 states that have not expanded Medicaid. The graphic below shows this variation:

Wisconsin has created its own Medicaid expansion apart from ObamaCare by allowing anyone earning up to 100% of FPL to be eligible, but not accepting the ObamaCare rules that permit up to 138% of FPL.

Critics of the new Trump proposal argue that by fixing funds for Medicaid at a growth rate lower than paid in the past will result in less money and therefore fewer benefits and fewer people covered. Laszewski calls out these critics: “In my mind, the people that are opposing the Trump administration’s block grant proposals are letting their ideology stand in the way of millions of people becoming eligible for substantial, if not optimal, Medicaid benefits.”

If you favor expanded Medicaid eligibility to all 50 states, you should favor the Trump proposal.