School Choice – The Key to the American Dream

 

We hear a lot in the media lately about injustice and inequality in our country. People are protesting for fair and equal treatment of blacks and other people of color. They are calling for reparations that will somehow make up for the sins of our forefathers and give blacks a better chance to achieve the American dream.

Why aren’t these same people protesting for school choice?

Education is the key to escaping poverty. There is no argument on this point. Without an education, there is no future. Without an education there is no American dream. Yet the same people who tell us we aren’t “woke” enough to understand the plight of the African-Americans in this country, oppose school choice.

Thomas Sowell is a black economist and senior fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution who has a new book coming out called Charter Schools and Their Enemies. In a recent Op-ed in The Wall Street Journal, he extolls the virtues of charter schools. In particular, he holds up the example of The Success Academy of New York City. Sowell writes, “Their predominantly black and Hispanic students already pass tests in mathematics and English at a higher rate than any school district in the entire state. That includes predominantly white and Asian school districts where parental income is some multiple of what it is among Success Academy students.”

There has long been an accepted educational dogma that blacks and Hispanics from low-income neighborhoods can’t compete with higher-income whites. But charter schools are proving this dogma incorrect. Given the choice to attend these schools, blacks and Hispanic students from these low-income neighborhoods are succeeding.

Why do Democrats and civil rights leaders oppose charter schools and school choice?

Sowell explains: “The success of New York City’s charter schools is not only a threat to educational dogmas. Competition from charter schools is an existential threat to traditional public schools in low-income minority communities, which tend to have even lower educational outcomes than traditional public schools as a whole.”

Not only are these low-income minority children in charter schools outperforming the public schools, they’re doing it in the same buildings! In 28 classes in these buildings, fewer than 10% of the students reached the “proficient” level on statewide tests. All 28 classes were in traditional public schools. All charter school classes at the same grade levels in the same buildings did better– including six grade levels where the charter school majorities reaching the “proficient” level ranged from 81% to 100%.

The opponents of charter schools and school choice insist that charter schools “skim the cream” of students, leaving the public schools worse off. This seems plausible – until you understand that admission to New York City charter schools is by lottery– and not by students’ academic records or test results.

Even considering that more motivated students are more likely to enter the lottery, only a fraction of those who enter the admissions lottery win. The majority of these motivated students remain in the traditional public schools. In 2019 there were more than 50,000 New York City students on waiting lists to transfer into charter schools.

The real reason that Democratic politicians and civil rights leaders oppose charter schools and school choice is because they depend on the support of teachers’ unions to get elected. The success of charter schools means the loss of taxpayers’ support for public schools. It is estimated that if every child in New York City seeking to enter a charter school could be accepted, it would mean the loss of over a billion dollars a year to the public schools and teachers’ unions.

In an effort to thwart charter schools, opponents have tried to limit the number of charter schools allowed – regardless of whether these charter schools are good, bad or indifferent. Most states have such laws, though the only purpose these laws serve is to impede the exodus of students from traditional public schools. In cities across the nation, public school officials are blocking charter schools from using school buildings that have been vacant for years to prevent transfers into charter schools from taking place.

School choice is all about creating competition in the school system that raises the quality of education for everyone. Competition always raises quality and lowers the cost of any product in the marketplace. Education is no different. School choice will raise the standards for educating children of all races and all income levels. It will weed out poor-performing schools and teachers and select only for the best of both. The losers in this scenario are poor teachers, teachers’ unions, and politicians who depend upon their support. It’s time those who profess to be concerned about the future of blacks and other minorities show their true colors – by supporting school choice and charter schools.

Former Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice has called school choice “the civil rights issue of our times.” It’s time the civil rights leaders turned their backs on the teachers’ unions and started supporting the children of the people they claim to serve.

Covid Models Get It Wrong

 

I admit I’m jealous. In my profession as an orthopedic surgeon, I’m not allowed to make mistakes. If I do, someone is sure to file a medical malpractice case against me. But in the world of meteorologists – and Covid models – mistakes are ignored with no loss of credibility. When are we going to learn?

Case in point is the University of Washington Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (UW), which has been consistently wrong about predicting Covid future experience but is still quoted by the media. It’s about time we stopped talking about their models.

The Wall Street Journal has also had enough. Their editorial board has called out their mistakes. Here’s some of their predictions from the recent past:

  • UW forecast New York would need 49,000 regular beds and 8,000 ICU beds at the peak of the pandemic.
  • N. Y. Governor Andrew Cuomo’s experts projected 140,000 regular beds and 40,000 ICU beds needed.
  • Actual regular beds needed was 18,825 and 5,225 ICU beds at the peak
  • Actual regular beds needed were only 38% and ICU beds 65% of the UW model predictions – even though New York was the epicenter of the pandemic.
  • Actual regular beds and ICU beds needed were only 13% of Governor Cuomo’s experts’ predictions

 

Governor Cuomo now admits their mistakes. “All the early national experts, ‘Here’s my projection model.’. . . They were all wrong. They were all wrong. . . There are a lot of variables. I understand that. We didn’t know what the social distancing would actually amount to. I get it, but we were all wrong.”

Despite the media’s attempts to overhype the resurgence of cases, the actual numbers are tell a different story. In Texas, hospitalizations have been climbing, but weekly fatalities are down 40% from a month ago. Covid patients occupy fewer than 55 of all hospital beds, and more than a quarter are available. Even in Houston, where the largest increases in hospitalizations have occurred, Covid patients occupy only 6% of hospital beds. More than 20% are unused.

Covid-19 patients take up a small share of ICU beds in most states that have reopened including California (16%), Texas (11%), Georgia (10%), Utah (9%), Wisconsin (8%) and Florida (7%). Nearly all states have plenty of hospital beds and ICU capacity.

Yet the UW models are once again predicting dire expectations and the media is promoting their claims despite their earlier mistakes. UW now projects that reopening will cause deaths to triple in California and increase six-fold in Florida and Arizona through September. I live in Florida – and I’m not worried.

Stanford epidemiologist John Ioannidis discusses models and why their predictions are often wrong in a new paper. He says models overshot by making faulty assumptions about virus reproduction rates and homogenous susceptibility. A Massachusetts General Hospital model predicted more than 23,000 deaths within a month of Georgia reopening but the state had only 896.

Ioannidis writes, “In the presence of strong groupthink and bandwagon effects, modelers may consciously fit their predictions to what is the dominant thinking and expectations – or they may be forced to do so. Forecasts may be more likely to be published or disseminated, if they are more extreme.”

In other words, the worse the prediction, the more the media will accept and promote it. No wonder the media – and the models -have lost all credibility.

Trump Improving Medicaid

 

I’m no fan of Medicaid. It’s a second-class healthcare system that offers free healthcare at government expense but reduces access to doctors and hospitals. What good is free healthcare if you can’t get it?

President Obama’s Affordable Care Act (ObamaCare) greatly expanded the eligibility for Medicaid from its originally intended categories of poor children, pregnant women, the disabled and seniors to include able-bodied adults who earn less than 138% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL). This may benefit those who get free healthcare coverage, but it is bankrupting the federal government and those states who accepted the expanded Medicaid coverage. Unfortunately, like many government efforts, the people they intended to help aren’t getting the benefits they need.

President Trump is trying to do something to improve this situation created by the Obama Administration. Naturally, Democrats are claiming this is an attack on healthcare for the most needy, when in fact it will benefit those people the most.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says the biggest beneficiaries of this Trump plan will be Democratic states and low-income Americans. The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) in a recent letter invited state Medicaid directors to apply for block grants under Section 1115 of the Social Security Act. That law allows the Secretary of Health and Human Services to approve state “demonstration projects” to experiment with plan designs, payment models and delivery.

This is nothing unusual in itself. The Obama Administration enticed several Republican states into expanding eligibility under the ACA by giving them waivers to require cost-sharing by beneficiaries and provide premium assistance for private plans, among other things.

The Trump Administration is taking this one step further by allowing states more flexibility to manage their ObamaCare expansion populations in return for a cap on federal funds in the form of a per-capita limit or lump-sum payment. If the states manage to spend less than the cap, they could keep a share of the federal government’s savings. The goal is to give states an incentive to control skyrocketing costs, especially for able-bodied adults who gained coverage under the ACA.

Under the old Medicaid rules, the federal government pays between 50% and 76% of the cost for the disabled, children, pregnant women and the elderly. Under the ObamaCare expansion rules, the feds pick up 90% of the tab for able-bodied adults earning up to 138% of FPL. In other words, states can spend $1 and get $9 free. (Taxpayers get to spend $9 and get nothing free.)

These incentives have led to more liberal spending on these newly eligible Medicaid enrollees. According to CMS, these enrollees cost the government $16 more per person than other eligible adults. This is resulting in exploding expenses for state governments that accept the ACA Medicaid expansion. Since states must balance their budgets, the net result is less money for all Medicaid enrollees and for education expenses.

The Trump plan of block-grant waivers would allow states more flexibility to control these costs with innovative ideas such as requiring cost-sharing by ObamaCare beneficiaries as long as the co-pays and premiums combined don’t exceed 5% of income. Benefit plans could also be changed as long as they align with ObamaCare guidelines.

Other cost-saving measures might include “closed formularies” that limit which drugs are covered in the plan. Since states currently must pay for all medically necessary drugs, the waiver would give them more leverage to negotiate discounts with drug makers. Democratic governors who complain about out-of-control drug prices will like that.

These Trump plan changes would only apply to able-bodied adults, the demographic previously excluded from Medicaid eligibility entirely. Presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg says these reforms “breaks America’s promise to those in need.” This is clearly untrue.

Similar block-grant waiver programs have been done in the past with good results. President Bush granted such waivers to Rhode Island and Vermont and a 2011 follow-up audit by the economic consulting firm Lewin Group concluded it was “highly effective in controlling Medicaid costs” and “improved access to physician services” for Medicaid patients with asthma, diabetes, heart problems and mental disorders. This latter conclusion is critical. Anything that actually improves access to healthcare is a good thing – and saving money while doing that is government at its finest.

The WSJ editorial ends with an important question: “Block grants would help realign ObamaCare’s perverse incentives that encourage states to spend more on healthy folks and less on those who need care. Do Democrats loathe President Trump more than they want to help their citizens?”