Hospitals Pressure Doctors At Your Expense – Part I

 

The world of medicine is changing. When I began my practice in 1984 the only doctors employed by the hospitals were radiologists and pathologists. Everyone else was a private practitioner.

In that arrangement, hospitals considered doctors their primary customers because the doctors determined where their patients would be treated. Hospital administrators understood they were in competition to attract doctor referrals so they treated the doctors well to earn their business.

Today, everything has changed and not necessarily for the better. A study by Avalere Health in 2016 found 42% of all doctors are now employed by hospitals. While the majority is still in privately-owned practices, this is a significant change.

Hospitals no longer look to private practitioners to fill their beds and their outpatient schedules. They expect that to come from the physicians they employ. They track the referral patterns of every physician and confront those who fail to refer consistently to their hospital.

Anna Wilde Mathews and Melanie Evans, writing in The Wall Street Journal, report on the Phoebe Putney Health System, based in Albany, Georgia. The doctors in the affiliated physician group receive regular reports breaking down their referrals to specialists or services. If the share of in-house business wasn’t viewed as adequate, administrators would press them to improve.

Doctors generally are more concerned with the quality of the service they can expect their patients to receive than the name of the hospital owner. Good patient experience after referral reflects well on them and leaves both patient and referring doctor happy. But hospital administrators are more concerned with their bottom line.

Hospitals refer to lost referrals as “leakage.” But efforts at “keepage” may mean higher costs for patients and the employers that insure them – and poorer quality results when doctors must refer to someone with a poorer reputation.

Health services are frequently more expensive when delivered in a hospital setting instead of in the doctor’s office. This is the motivation behind hospitals pressuring physicians to refer to them. This is also a major reason behind the rising cost of healthcare, which has now reached $3.5 Trillion per year according to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). The graphic below shows the cost of the service provided in a doctor’s office on the left and in the hospital on the right.

The impact of these differences is not just more money to the hospital – it is also more money out of the patient’s pocket. For a patient with employer-provided insurance, the average cost of a complicated drug administration – such as chemotherapy – was $612 when performed in hospital-affiliated facilities, and $247 in a doctor’s office in 2016.

A study this year by Yale University found that patients whose doctors worked for hospital systems were 27% more likely to get their MRIs at a hospital where their scans cost  $267 more on average – and about $90 of that extra expense was paid by the patient. (Even more is absorbed by the patient indirectly in higher premiums.)

Individual experiences can be even more dramatic. Jim Wood, a business executive in Illinois was referred to SwedishAmerican hospital for his annual lab tests in 2015 and the cost was $529. The next year the same tests were done at an independent lab and cost $57. He was sent for a shoulder MRI to the hospital and it cost $2,507 and when he compared this to a local imaging center the estimate for the same MRI was under $300, not including the doctor’s fee.

These dramatic differences can mean significant expense to the patient without necessarily providing higher quality. Is this practice wide spread and how dramatic is the shift of referrals when a hospital acquires a private physician practice?(The answers to these questions in Part II of this post next time.)

Government Targeting Doctors At Your Expense

 

As a surgeon, I often tell patients facing surgery to get a second opinion. Although I may be confident in my opinion, if I sense reluctance in the patient I will suggest they discuss their situation with another surgeon.

This process usually happens before surgery or other medical procedures. But now the government is using second opinions after treatment to accuse the doctor of fraud.

Kyle Clark and Andrew George are lawyers who are members of the Mid-Atlantic Innocence Project. Writing in The Wall Street Journal, they share the lurid details of government oversight gone astray.

Dr. Richard Paulus, a renowned cardiologist in eastern Kentucky, has been inserting stents into blocked coronary arteries to save lives for the last 21 years. Due to his stellar reputation, his volume of patients brought his name to the attention of government prosecutors looking for ways to prevent fraud. The large number of bills submitted by Dr. Paulus was the only reason he was investigated.

These federal prosecutors hired a pair of other doctors to review the past cases of Dr. Paulus to determine if they warranted insertion of stents. In some of these cases the doctors working for the government disagreed with Dr. Paulus as to the severity of arterial blockage. Paulus had estimated 60% blockage in some cases, while the other doctors’ estimation was 30% or less. The government then declared Dr. Paulus guilty of unnecessary procedures as part of a scheme to defraud Medicare, Medicaid or private insurance companies.

The basis for this conclusion was two previous federal appellate court rulings that cardiologists can’t reasonably disagree by more than 10% to 20% about arterial blockage. This is a legal standard, not a medical one. Doctors can certainly disagree widely about the degree of blockage.

Clark and George have found 93 examples in scientific journals in which two cardiologists disagreed on the severity of a blockage by more than 40%. Sometimes they even disagreed by 100%, meaning one thought the artery was wide open while the other thought it was entirely blocked!

The judge who presided over Dr. Paulus’ trial understood this better than the jury. Judge David L. Bunning overruled the jury when they brought a guilty verdict and granted an acquittal.

The federal prosecutors in the Paulus trial refused to accept Judge Bunning’s acquittal. They appealed to the Sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. The Appeals Court overturned Judge Bunning’s acquittal without disputing the 93 examples given by Clark and George to refute their opinion. Sentencing is scheduled for March, 2019.

This disturbing example of government oversight gone astray has frightening implications. When doctors can lose their freedom over a simple difference of opinion, we are all at risk for compromised healthcare. The next time a cardiologist considers inserting a life-sustaining stent in your artery, he or she may remember this case and pass on the chance. If you die from a heart attack soon thereafter, who will your family sue, the government or your doctor? The government is obviously more concerned about saving money than about saving your life.

 

Obesity – A Threat to National Security?

 

Is obesity a threat to our national security? That may seem farfetched but a closer look should give us all pause.

Dr. Bill Frist, a heart and lung transplant surgeon and the former U.S. Senate Majority Leader, says we have a serious problem. A recently published report called Unhealthy and Unprepared, was released by a group of 750 retired generals and admirals that call themselves Mission: Readiness. The report says 71% of young Americans are ineligible to serve in the military because of obesity.

Frist says this alarming finding, coupled with declining interest in military service, is making it difficult for our military to find suitable recruits to protect our country and our interests abroad. The Army reports it was unable to meet recruiting goals for this year as of September.

The implications of these findings threaten our national security and the future of our healthcare system. If not addressed soon, generations of children will grow up to have serious and potentially life-threatening health issues. This will have a profound effect upon our military and the cost of healthcare for these individuals.

Young people with obesity are more likely to experience diabetes, heart disease, fatty liver disease, and serious bone and joint issues in later life. Overweight adolescents have a 70% chance of being obese as adults.

Frist says there is a solution to this problem. Research shows that high-quality early childhood education and care programs can help teach children the importance of physical activity and nutrition. Programs that require children to be active at school and provide them with healthy meals can provide a foundation for health and well-being later in life.

The State of Tennessee has taken a step to do something about the problem. They passed the Tom Cronan Physical Education Act, which will require elementary schools to provide at least 60 minutes of physical education per week. Frist joined with organizations like the American Heart Association (AHA) and NashvilleHealth to support this legislation.

Personally, this sounds a bit like re-inventing the wheel. I can remember as a child during the Kennedy administration we were all required to do similar physical education for the same purpose. Last I checked our human bodies still need the same level of physical activity to maintain proper health and fitness. Makes you wonder why these national guidelines were forgotten. Frankly, only 60 minutes in a week seems insufficient.

The AHA fitness guidelines for adults are at least 150 minutes per week of moderate intensity aerobic exercise or 75 minutes of vigorous aerobic activity or a combination of both, preferably spread throughout the week.

The value of regular exercise can’t be over-emphasized. Good exercise habits must be developed in children – and maintained as adults. A recent period of low back pain reminded me of the importance of exercise even to aging bodies, as well. We never outgrow the need for exercise if we want to remain healthy and fit. It’s the right thing to do at any age.