Golf and Your Doctor

Golf is often associated with doctors. The doctor’s day off to play golf is a well-worn cliché about the profession. How much does this cliché reflect reality?

Someone has actually taken the time and expense to study this question! Although I was intrigued with reading the study, it may be the most useless expenditure of time on research I’ve ever read.

I confess that I’m a physician who loves to play golf. I even chose to move from my home state of Pennsylvania to Florida in part because it would afford me the opportunity to play golf year round. But I never thought I’d read a research study devoted to analyzing the golf habits and talents of physicians.

The study was recently published in The BMJ under the title: Golf Habits Among Physicians and Surgeons: Observational Cohort Study. The stated objectives of the study were: To examine golfing patterns among physicians, the proportion who regularly play golf, differences in golf practices across specialties, the specialties with the best golfers, and differences in golf practices among male and female physicians.

The study comprised 41,692 physicians who actively logged golf scores in the U.S.G.A. amateur golfer database. This is 4.1% of the total of 1,029,088 physicians in the U.S. Men comprised 89.5% of physician golfers and among all male physicians, 5.5% play golf. Only 1.3% of female physicians play golf.

The highest proportion of physician golfers were in orthopedic surgery (8.8%), urology (8.1%) and plastic surgery (7.5%). The lowest proportion of physician golfers were in internal medicine and infectious disease (<3.0%).

The best golfers were in thoracic surgery, vascular surgery, and orthopedic surgery. These physicians scored about 15% better than specialists in endocrinology, dermatology and oncology.

How often does your doctor actually play golf?

These results were surprising. The idea that most physicians have a regular day set aside to play golf was mostly shattered by this study. Male golfers played an average of 14.8 games in the first six months of 2018 and female golfers played an average of 12.8 games. This works out to about one game of golf every 12.5 days or about once every two weeks.

How do physicians compare as golfers to non-physician golfers?

Overall, physicians were at best average golfers. The mean handicap among physicians was 15.0, which is slightly worse than the performance of non-physician golfers according to the U.S.G.A.

What have we learned through this study that impacts patient care?

Nothing. The study researchers state, “The association between golfing and patient outcomes, costs of care, and physician well-being are unknown.” Nevertheless, they are undaunted in their pursuit of future related research. They conclude:

“The findings of this study suggest several areas where research is needed and where federal research support—perhaps through a dedicated agency of the National Institutes of Health—might be warranted. Is patient mortality associated with the amount of time a patient’s physician plays golf (either negatively, because physicians release stress on the golf course, or positively owing to decreased availability and time spent away from developing clinical skill)? Do costs of care increase and patient outcomes worsen in the days after a physician has had a bad round of golf?

I’m sure you’ll be anxious to hear the results of such future research, especially if it is funded with your federal tax dollars. 🙂

 

Medical School Admission Getting Tougher

 

It’s always been tough to get into medical school. But now it may be tougher than ever before.

Frankly, I’m surprised. With doctors retiring earlier than ever or leaving clinical care for administrative or other non-clinical positions, I expected a decline in medical school enrollment. For a while that was true, but not any more.

Despite the growing shortage of doctors, there is a growing interest in medical careers. Ilana Kowarski, writing in U.S. News & World Report, quotes Dr. Robert Hasty of the Idaho College of Osteopathic Medicine, who says demand for a medical education is “near an all time high.”

“People really want to become physicians, and now more than ever. I would say this is especially true of the millennial generation. And I can tell you that, here at (our school), we hear from high-quality applicants everyday … and these are people with really high MCAT scores and GPAs, that this is their second year, third year or even fourth year applying to medical schools. And years ago, they would have gotten accepted the first time through, but the demand is just incredible.”

The Association of American Medical Colleges says there were more than 10,000 more applicants seeking admission to American medical schools in 2018 than ten years ago, a 25% increase over the ten-year period. Hasty says young people are especially eager to find work that allows them to have a positive impact on society, and the emphasis on science, technology, engineering and math in contemporary U.S. schools has boosted the number of people who want to become doctors.

“The current millennial generation, their desire to serve and give back is really incredible,” he says, adding that Generation Z, which is just starting to apply to medical school, also shows a strong interest in public service. Hasty also suggests that U.S. high schools and colleges are doing a better job of engaging students in science classes than they had in the past, which is spurring an uptick in interest.

Doctor Shortage

There is no doubt we have a significant shortage of doctors that is expected to get worse. The AAMC estimates the shortage between 42,600 and 121,300 by the year 2030. Class sizes have increased 30% since 2002 to make up the difference. Is there also a medical school shortage? Would more medical schools solve the problem?

Jason Farr, senior vice president of The Medicus Firm, a health provider recruiting company in Texas, says the real problem is residency jobs. He says there aren’t enough residency jobs for the number of current medical school graduates so more graduates won’t solve the problem.

Furthermore, current medical school applicants have different expectations for their medical career than earlier generations. Farr says contemporary doctors are more eager to find work-life balance than their predecessors in past eras, and many doctors are unwilling to put in the long hours that previous generations of physicians did. This means it will take many more of these new medical school graduates to replace those who are retiring now.

It is encouraging to learn that there is enthusiasm for medical careers in the younger generations and the quality of applicants may actually be getting better. Those of us near the end of our careers have lost some of our original enthusiasm because of increasing government intrusion into the practice of medicine that detracts from patient care. Perhaps these new physicians will be better able to accept these intrusions in return for reduced hours and better work-life balance. I certainly hope so, since my life expectancy may depend upon them!

Single-Payer Misinformation

 

Get ready for the misinformation coming soon. The 2020 Presidential Election Campaign will kick-off soon and the likely Democratic candidates have one thing in common.

Senators Bernie Sanders, Kamala Harris, Elizabeth Warren, Corrie Booker, and former Vice-President Joe Biden are all considered possible Democratic candidates for president in 2020. All have expressed interest in single-payer healthcare with enthusiasm that ranges from interested believers to passionate evangelist when describing Sanders.

When these Democrats begin their campaigns, be prepared to listen to their talking points. One of those talking points will be to compare the U.S. healthcare system statistics to other countries. Their favorite statistic is infant mortality.

The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) is comprised of 35 countries. It lists the U.S. as 32nd among these countries when it comes to infant mortality. Do you believe for one minute there is anywhere in the world better to have your baby than in the United States?

Dr. Scott W. Atlas, senior fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution, says the reason for this low ranking is a matter of statistical definitions. Unlike many countries, the U.S. strictly adheres to the World Health Organization’s definition, recording as a live birth any baby, “irrespective of the duration of the pregnancy,” who “breathes or shows any other evidence of life.”

By contrast, WHO noted in a 2008 report, it is “common practice” in several western European countries to register as live births only those infants who survived for a specified period. Infants who don’t survive are “completely ignored for registration purposes.” A British Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology study of Western Europe found that terminology alone cause up to 40% variation and 17% false reductions in infant mortality.

There are other misleading issues to consider. Partly because of harmful behavior during pregnancy and socioeconomic factors, premature births – the main risk factor for infant death – are far more common in the U.S. than in any other developed country. The U.S. prematurity rate is 65% higher than in Britain and more than double that of Ireland and Finland.

A Centers for Disease Control study found that standardizing for gestational age eliminated 68% of the difference in infant mortality between Sweden and the U.S. The CDC concluded, “the primary reason for the United States’ higher infant mortality rate when compared with Europe is the United States’ much higher percentage of preterm births.”

When it comes to premature births, the U.S. ranks third behind only Sweden and Norway in survival rates. This is due to greater technology and more experienced neonatologists. Heroic efforts to save such babies are commonplace in the U.S. while in Europe physicians are limited by inferior technology and training. When such babies die they aren’t even counted in their official statistics.

Sweden and Norway benefit from more homogeneous populations than the United States. America has a population heterogeneity that is four to eight times as high as in countries like Sweden, Norway, France and the United Kingdom. Countries with more homogeneous populations have lower infant mortality, but that doesn’t reflect better healthcare quality.

U.S. life expectancy is also adversely affected by personal lifestyle choices – especially smoking and obesity, but also nutrition, risk-taking, exercise and sexual practices. International differences in violence, urbanization, marriage and economic inequality also have an effect on averages.

The U.S. has a substantially higher obesity rate than any other developed nation. This is a positive reflection of prosperity in the U.S. but has a negative impact on our healthcare outcome statistics. It is not a reflection of inferior medical care. According to the OECD health statistics for 2018,

  • 40% of the U.S. population is obese
  • 17% in France
  • 13% in Sweden
  • 3% in Switzerland
  • 8% in Italy
  • 2% in Japan (longest life expectancy)

Obesity alone accounts for approximately 40% or more of the differences in life expectancy between the U.S. and almost every other country.

A more accurate way to measure the quality of healthcare is to consider access to medical care for those illnesses that cause the most deaths and the common chronic disease that lead to the most disability and death.

Dr. Atlas says, “The world’s leading medical journals report the U.S. has superior results, including for cancer, heart disease, high blood pressure, diabetes, and high cholesterol; the quickest access to life-changing surgeries that permit pain-free mobility and restore vision; superior screening rates for cancer; the earliest access to new drugs; and broad access to safer, more accurate diagnostic technology that forms the crux of modern health care. Even for the lowest-priority care, U.S. wait times are far shorter than for seriously ill patients in peer countries like Canada and the U.K.”

Remember, “statistics don’t lie but you can lie with statistics.” The United States healthcare system is the best in the world and all the speeches about the virtues of single-payer healthcare won’t change that. Why else do so many people from Canada and Europe come to the U.S. for healthcare when they can get “free healthcare” at home in their own country?