What’s Wrong With Taxpayers Financing HealthCare For Unauthorized Immigrants?

 

Last month I discussed how American taxpayers are paying $18.5 Billion to finance the healthcare of illegal (unauthorized) immigrants, according to the work of Duke University economist, Chris Conover. (How Taxpayers Finance Healthcare For Unauthorized Immigrants) Today, we’ll discuss Conover’s four reasons why this is a bad idea.

  • Federal tax financing is unconstitutional
  • Federal tax financing is unnecessary
  • Federal tax financing is immoral
  • Federal tax financing is inefficient

 

Federal Tax Financing is Unconstitutional

This is a simple argument. There just is nowhere in the Constitution that authorizes or requires Congress to appropriate funds for this purpose. Since all federal funding requires Congressional appropriation, any such funding is unconstitutional.

In fact, Medicaid and ObamaCare expressly forbid funding of healthcare for illegal immigrants – though it happens anyway. The prime example of this is in the State of California where the Health For Kids Act allows state Medicaid funds to be used for healthcare for unauthorized immigrant children.

Federal Tax Financing is Unnecessary

Since Federal taxpayers finance $11.2 Billion of the $18.5 Billion needed to cover healthcare for unauthorized immigrants, state and local governments would need to pick up this additional expense if federal dollars were excluded. Conover says this would only require a 0.2% increase in state and local taxes – a nominal additional amount.

Having state and local governments pick up the tab would be a good thing since it would incentivize them to be more efficient in the spending of these dollars. It would encourage innovative thinking to lower expenses and improve efficiency and quality of care.

Voters in each state could determine their willingness to provide such care and this would likely lead to redistribution of residents according to the election results. This is currently happening as a result of the new changes in the Trump Tax code. Voters have already shown wide variations in their willingness to pay for expanded Medicaid under ObamaCare.

Federal Tax Financing is Immoral

One way of financing healthcare for unauthorized immigrants might be charitable donations. But if such funding proved inadequate, would we consider it moral to seize the same money involuntarily from American taxpayers? We don’t consider it moral to force taxpayers to pay for abortions, so why should they pay for healthcare for illegal immigrants?

There is a prevailing attitude among some Americans that we are obligated to provide the same standard of living to the rest of the world that we enjoy here in America. Such people are welcoming the caravan of illegal immigrants storming our southern borders in California as I write these words.

But America cannot take on the troubles of the whole world lest we have the same troubles here in our own country. Conover says, “A claim that Americans have some sort of obligation to level up the entire world to the same standard of care as we are willing to provide to our poorest citizens, i.e., those on Medicaid, is fiscally untenable. Medicaid spending per enrollee was $5,736 four years ago. That’s only about 71% of overall U.S. health spending per capita. But more than 70 percent of the world’s population live in nations with health spending per capita below 10 percent of U.S. levels. Ten percent of U.S. levels in 2014 would be $800. Even if we assumed the U.S. spent twice what it needed to on Medicaid, closing the gap between America’s poor and the rest of the world in terms of healthcare would imply spending about $2,000 per person for 4.9 billion people. That would be 9.8 Trillion dollars – more than half the nation’s GDP in 2014.”

In other words, we literally can’t afford it! Taking on a debt you can’t afford to pay is immoral itself.

Federal Tax Financing is Inefficient

Some might argue that collecting taxes to pay for the $11.2 Billion in federal financing of unauthorized immigrant healthcare is more efficient than increasing charitable giving. But Conover points out the fallacy of this argument. He says that there is a 44 cents/dollar expense collecting federal taxes. If the federal government was considered a charity, in the parlance of CharityWatch, the federal government would be given an efficiency rating of D.

In other words, the federal government is very inefficient about the way they collect and spend your taxes. Surprise! There are many charitable organizations that could do the same job much more efficiently – and therefore more cheaply.

If we want to provide charitable donations to support a cause we believe in we can always do so without government intrusion. Support for the victims of hurricanes is a prime example. But federal taxpayers’ dollars shouldn’t be used to support programs or people who are breaking the laws of the same government.

Cancer Therapy Ads Hide the Truth

 

If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is. That’s an old maxim that applies to a lot in life – and especially to cancer treatment advertising.

Cancer patients are among our most vulnerable consumers. The diagnosis of cancer sends shock waves through our systems and we desperately want to hear there is a solution to our disease. Cancer treatment centers take advantage of that desperation.

Steve Salerno, writing in The Wall Street Journal, gives us the unfortunate truth behind many of those cancer center advertisements that sound – well, just too good to be true. By 2020 the treatment of cancer is expected to generate $207 Billion in medical bills. That’s a lot of incentive for those in the cancer treatment industry.

The Annuals of Internal Medicine published a study of cancer treatment advertising in 2014 and found that they relied on emotional appeals evoking hope or fear, while pointedly omitting useful information. “Eighty-eight percent touted treatments and only 18 percent mentioned screening, even though early diagnosis is more critical to survival than the interventions romanticized on TV. Risks appear in barely 2% of ads.”

Typical ads include testimonials, sometimes featuring celebrities. “Natural” remedies are often mentioned to tap into the growing cachet of alternative medicine. Such ads prompted urology oncologist, Dr. Benjamin Davies, to write in Forbes, “Eating a balanced (organic?) diet after your prostate cancer surgery has no effect on your cancer outcome. None. Suggesting it is part of ‘the plan’ insinuates it will. It will not.”

Dr. Steven Woloshin, a medical communication researcher, wrote an editorial in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) describing his view of these cancer center advertisements: “The appeals raise the stakes, in essence saying you can be saved provided you make the right choice or doomed if you do not.”

Cancer treatment centers are big business. In the decade from 2005 to 2015, ad spending by U.S. cancer centers climbed from $54 million to $173 million. Cancer Treatment Centers of America spent $100 million by itself. In 2016 alone, M.D. Anderson Cancer Center of Houston had seven rotating TV spots that were viewed about a billion times.

Cancer Treatment Centers of America has been widely criticized for deceptive advertising. Their ads proudly tout “genomic testing,” which guides patient-specific chemotherapy. However, the ads fail to mention that there is a dismal success rate of such tests in trials. Only 6.4% of patients were successfully matched with a drug, according to a 2016 study published in Nature.

Part of the problem is that these so-called “direct to consumer” treatment ads do not fall under the jurisdiction of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). We’re all familiar with pharmaceutical company advertising that is required to reveal all the potential side effects of the drugs they’re pushing. Unrealistic success rate predictions as seen in cancer center ads would never be tolerated by the FDA.

Tim Calkins, professor of marketing at Northwestern University said in an interview with NPR radio last year, “Hospitals aren’t held to FDA standards at all, so a hospital can go out and say, ‘This is where miracles happen. And here’s Joe. Joe was about to die. And now Joe is going to live forever.”

Perhaps this explains a phenomenon discussed in Atul Gawande’s book, Being Mortal. Gawande reports that oncologists typically approach many of their cancer patients with the hope they can survive two or more years while patients report they are expecting to survive ten or twenty years. This gap in expectations may reflect the unrealistic advertising many of the same cancer treatment centers are promoting.

None of this is intended to destroy the hopes of cancer patients. Hope is vital for the successful treatment of any medical condition, especially cancer. Cancer survival statistics are improving. But hope must be balanced with realistic expectations lest patients feel abandoned in their desperate search for the truth about their future.

Here are some realistic cancer five-year survival rates taken from The American Cancer Society:

  • Cervix – 69%
  • Leukemia – 63%
  • Ovary – 46%
  • Brain/nervous system – 35%
  • Lung – 19%
  • Liver – 18%
  • Pancreas – 9%
  • Breast – nearly 100% (without metastasis) to 22% (with metastasis)

 

These survival rates reflect averages with each diagnosis but may vary widely according to the stage of disease at diagnosis. (Note the wide variation with breast cancer.)

If your doctor has just given you a diagnosis of cancer, stop and take time to think before you act. Discuss it with your doctor, consider a second opinion, and then pray. Don’t look to the TV for your answers.

Doctors Blamed For the Opioid Crisis

 

Everyone by now realizes there is an opioid crisis in this country. It has become a political football kicked around by politicians trying to win votes from those Americans whose families have been impacted by this crisis. Naturally, it is easier to find people to blame than solutions to the problem.

Doctors are to blame because they just insist on giving patients opioids. That’s the opinion of at least one journalist. Keith Humphries, writing in The Washington Post says there are many other drugs besides opioids that could be used for pain relief except for the ignorance of doctors.

Humphries blames doctors for not using opioid alternatives on the following:

  • Opioid manufacturers’ “ruthless” marketing
  • Inadequate training in pain management
  • Insufficient referrals to a pain psychologist
  • Insufficient insurance coverage for pain management and physical therapy

 

Humphries says doctors get only an average of seven hours of pain management training in medical school. He says the solution is “enhancing insurance benefits (Medicaid and Medicare) for psychological and behavioral pain care services provided by interdisciplinary pain management clinics as well as funding training on pain management in medical schools and continuing education programs serving physicians and other health professionals.”

Who knew it was so easy to solve the problem?

This is typical journalistic pabulum we’ve come to expect from mainstream media like The Washington Post. The solution is always government funding of more insurance benefits, more education and more government control.

In reality, doctors continue to educate themselves long after medical school. I am required to have 40 hours of continuing medical education (CME) every two years just to maintain my medical license – and more to retain specialty board certification. Last month I attended the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) meeting and spent three full days in CME classes. About five hours of that time I spent in learning modern methods of pain management after surgery.

Here are a few observations that Mr. Humphries should consider:

  • Opioids are more effective in managing pain than the alternatives
  • Patients expect (demand) opioids for serious pain
  • Alternatives are generally available OTC and have been previously tried
  • Experience rather than training has proven opioids effective
  • Pharmaceutical marketing to physicians is practically non-existent for opioids in the last twenty plus years (in my experience)
  • Medicaid expansion under ObamaCare has contributed to the opioid crisis – not relieved it (see Medicaid and The Killer Drugs)

 

Doctors would prefer to prescribe non-opioids except for the following:

  • Patients have been programmed to believe non-opioids are ineffective
  • Non-opioids can be prescribed over the phone – but patients in real pain will usually refuse them
  • Non-opioids usually have fewer side effects, like constipation and addiction – yet patient acceptance is poor
  • Opioids are generally less expensive than non-opioids

 

Most doctors would be ecstatic if there were truly effective non-opioid alternatives to prescribe for their patients in pain. The last of these was Vioxx, a non-steroid anti-inflammatory drug that was very effective in pain relief. Unfortunately, it was taken off the market in 2004 for dubious claims of cardiac toxicity. I’m still waiting for its replacement.