Growing Old – Life’s Most Difficult Challenge – Part II

 

Perspective is everything. It determines how you view the world and the life you are living. Anyone from the United States who has traveled to a third world country will immediately understand what I’m saying. It gives you a whole new appreciation for the blessings we enjoy in this country.

Dr. Atul Gawande, a Harvard general surgeon, discusses the importance of perspective in his book Being Mortal. Gawande tells us of important research by Stanford psychologist Laura Carstensen. She studied the emotional experiences of nearly two hundred people over many years of their lives. The subjects ranged in age from 18 to 94 when they entered the study.

Before her study, the assumption was made by others that the narrowing of life runs against people’s greatest sources of fulfillment and therefore you would expect people to grow unhappier as they aged. But Carstensen’s research found the opposite.

This raised another question. If we shift as we age toward appreciating everyday pleasures and relationships rather than toward achieving, having, and getting, and if we find this more fulfilling, then why do we take so long to do it? Is this just a learned behavior that comes with age?

A personal experience changed Carstensen’s perspective on this crucial question. She was nearly killed in a car accident when she was only twenty-one. Riding in a VW minibus with friends, the drunk driver rolled the vehicle over an embankment. She suffered severe head injuries and internal bleeding and barely survived.

She spent a long time in rehabilitation, surrounded mostly by elderly patients. The road to recovery included studying psychology by listening to audiotapes brought to her by her father. She quickly realized she was living the phenomena she was studying. She decided to make studying the elderly her life’s work.

Fifteen years later she developed a new hypothesis to test: How we seek to spend our time may depend on how much time we perceive ourselves to have.

This brings us back to the word perspective. If you’re young and healthy you have a perspective that there are no limits to what you can do. If you’re old and sick you have an entirely different perspective. This determines your outlook and your priorities.

Carstensen’s hypothesis has stood up under testing. In general, the younger the subjects were, the less they valued time with people they were emotionally close to and the more they valued time with people who were potential sources of information or new friendship. However, among the ill, the age differences disappeared. The preferences of a young person with AIDS were the same as those of an old person.

When your perspective says “the sky is the limit”, you’re willing to delay gratification, invest years in gaining skills or knowledge, to plan for a brighter future. When your horizons contract – when the future is finite and uncertain – then your focus shifts to the here and now. Everyday pleasures and people closest to you become your priority. These findings held up across cultural and racial differences.

When you understand the dynamic of perspective then you are better able to determine the best way to spend your declining years. You better prioritize your time and better appreciate your blessings. Sounds like a good idea at any time in life.

Growing Old – Life’s Most Difficult Challenge – Part I

 

Growing old isn’t for cowards. Just ask anyone who’s been there. While only in my seventh decade, I’m beginning to understand what they mean.

Average life expectancy in the United States in 2017 is 78.6 years according to the National Center for Health Statistics. That’s actually a decline of 0.1 years from previous studies in 2015.

The average life expectancy in 1967 was just 67 years. Therefore, in the last fifty years modern medicine has increased our life expectancy by nearly twelve years. That means a lot of people living longer and needing assistance in their later years.

The Rise of Eldercare

If you’re in your eighth or more decade, you realize that time is getting short. If you’ve enjoyed good health thus far, you might even live into your nineties, but you’re certainly on borrowed time. If you’re a man your chances of reaching 100 are 0.48%; if you’re a woman they’re 1.66%. Do you feel that lucky?

Fifty years ago most people lived out their last years at home with the help of family members, friends, and the occasional assistance of home nursing. Today, an increasing number of people will end up in nursing homes as their health declines.

Dr. Atul Gawande, a Harvard general surgeon, writes in his book Being Mortal that nursing homes proliferated after a 1954 law was passed that provided funding to relieve hospital overcrowding. Then Medicare was enacted in 1965, which raised the federal standards and provided additional government support for hospitals and nursing homes. The number of nursing homes exploded and by 1970 some thirteen thousand had been built.

Naturally this wave of nursing homes was followed by reports of elder-abuse and tragedies. Gawande reports a nursing home fire trapped and killed thirty-two residents in Marietta, Ohio, that same year. In Baltimore, a Salmonella epidemic in a nursing home killed thirty-six elderly residents.

All of us have heard such stories and all of us have probably visited a nursing home to see a friend or relative at one time or another. Most come away from such experiences thinking, “I’ll never live in a nursing home myself!”

The Value of Freedom

Many modern nursing homes are beautiful structures and boast of nutritional meals, exercise facilities, activities coordinators and readily available medical care when needed. But residents of these facilities yearn for one thing that is seldom available – freedom. The interests of the nursing home management are principally safety and efficiency and that means rules and regulations that minimize risk.

But the interests of elderly residents conflict with these institutional goals. Most residents want to retain the freedom to live their lives on their own terms – with assistance only when absolutely necessary. They want to get up when they’re ready, eat when they’re hungry, and sleep when it’s necessary. They want to retain their mobility as much as possible, even at the risk of a fall that might be serious.

Keren Brown Wilson originated the concept of Assisted Living in the 1980s to serve the needs of her mother who refused to live in a nursing home. The concept was built around a facility that was as much like home as possible. At home you decide how you spend your time, how you share your space, and how you manage your possessions.

Wilson opened Park Place, in Portland, Oregon, in 1983 and the concept was an immediate hit. The State of Oregon closely monitored the residents and in 1988 they issued their findings. The residents’ satisfaction with their lives increased, and their health was maintained. Their physical and cognitive functioning actually improved. The incidence of major depression fell. And the cost for those on government support was 20 percent lower than it would have been in a nursing home.

Since that time the number of Assisted Living facilities has grown tremendously. Wilson’s company, Assisted Living Concepts, went public. By 2000, the company had grown to more than three thousand employees and by 2010 the number of people in assisted living facilities was approaching the number in nursing homes.

But that’s when the good news stops. Since that time the concept became so popular that developers started calling all kinds of facilities “assisted living” but without following the model that made Wilson’s original idea so successful. These newer facilities fell into the same trap that made nursing homes intolerable for many before – the loss of freedom.

Concern over safety and lawsuits increasingly limited what people could have in their assisted living apartments and what activities they were allowed to do. In many places it became a mere layover on the continuum from independent living to full nursing home care. If you’re in the market for an assisted living facility be sure it will provide the freedom you want. Remember, it’s your life – make the most of it while you still can.

 

(Next post: Growing Old – Life’s Most Difficult Challenge – Part II)

 

Single-Payer More About Power Than Money

 

The issue is power – government control – more than money. That’s the lesson to be learned from our friends across the pond. We can thank Great Britain for the latest lesson in the evils of single-payer healthcare.

Alfie Evans is a toddler from England who suffered seizures at age seven months and has been hospitalized ever since at Alder Hey Hospital in Liverpool. Eventually his condition deteriorated to the point where life support measures were necessary. His doctors diagnosed him with a severe neurological condition of the brain.

The hospital took his situation to court in February requesting permission to remove his life support with the expectation he would soon die. The doctor treating Alfie testified she believed the child would “only be able to muster just a handful of breaths and survive just a few minutes if ventilation were completely stopped. Any decisions we come to are rigorous, and me personally I would not be making this decision unless I felt 100% it was the right decision.”

The court approved the hospital’s request but the decision was appealed by the family. This week the British Court of Appeal upheld the earlier court’s ruling.

In the mean time, the family reached out to the world for assistance and got it. The Catholic Church, at the request of the Pope, accepted the expense of transferring the child to an Italian hospital for continued treatment. But British authorities refused.

Alfie was taken off life support this week but the expected outcome has taken the doctors and the hospital by surprise. Alfie is still alive!

Government Control

Whether or not Alfie Evans survives this ordeal is not the issue. The issue concerns the British government’s need to control the outcome. Alfie’s parents are not being allowed to choose their child’s treatment. Despite having made medical and financial arrangements for the child’s ongoing treatment at an Italian hospital, the British hospital and government has refused to comply with their wishes.

James Freeman, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says, “it’s not a question of money or the use of the British medical resources. The Catholic Church and the Italian government are ready to take the child off Britain’s hands. It’s a question of a medical and legal system that denies parents the right to make such decisions. Such abuse appears to be part and parcel of a health system dominated by the state rather than the individual or the family.”

This case is eerily similar to that of Charlie Gard, another British infant whose parents wanted to take him to the United States for continued treatment but the British government refused. (see Charlie Gard Crisis Offers Warning to America)

Could this happen in America?

There is precedent for this in the United States. The State of Texas gives hospitals the power to make such decisions. Betsy McCaughey, writing in The New York Post, says:

           “Texas law gives life and death power to hospitals, never mind what families want. In most states, including New York, families are likely to win if they go to court to stop a hospital from pulling the plug. Unfortunately, they don’t know that and get steamrolled by hospital staff. . 

            In 2005, a court gave a Houston hospital the go-ahead to turn off the ventilator keeping baby Sun Hudson alive, over the mother’s objections. In 2017, again with a court’s OK, another Texas hospital cut off life support from 46-year-old Chris Dunn, who was awake and communicative, but descending into organ failure because of pancreatic cancer. His mother pleaded with the judges that the hospital was “trying to play God.” But Texas law gives hospitals that power.

            George Pickering’s adult son was on life support in a Texas hospital. Doctors declared him brain-dead, but Pickering felt his son squeeze his hand to communicate, and was convinced he could recover. When the hospital started to cut off life support, Pickering holed up in his son’s room with a handgun to stop the process. “They were moving too fast,” he said. He was arrested and jailed, but when he got out, his son had recovered – a rare outcome.”

 

This should be a wake-up call for America. While situations like this have rarely occurred in states like Texas, there is little doubt they will become commonplace if we implement a single-payer healthcare system like Great Britain.

The wave of intrusive government control in our lives can only be halted by an electorate determined to stop it!