Democrats Choose Abortion Over Lower Premiums

 

Abortion has become the defining issue of the Democratic Party. Killing unwanted babies in the womb seems to trump every other issue.

Last post I told you how Democrats had thrown the interests of Catholics under the bus in favor of abortion (Democrats Choose Abortion Over Catholics). Today we’ll see how seeking abortion funding is more important to them than funding that lowers premiums for low-income Americans.

Cost-Sharing Reduction Payments

In an earlier post (ObamaCare – To Save or Not to Save?) I explained the debate that was raging in Congress over cost-sharing reductions (CSRs), which are payments to insurers by the government intended to lower premiums and deductibles for healthcare purchased by low-income individuals on the exchanges. These CSRs were illegally made by the Obama administration without Congressional appropriations.

The Trump administration ceased these illegal payments until Congress took appropriate steps to authorize them. This issue was part of the recent Congressional debate before passage of the omnibus spending bill.

Republicans were willing to approve the CSRs in an effort to lower premiums and deductibles for low-income Americans. Democrats wanted the same thing – so where’s the problem? Democrats also wanted to throw out the Hyde Amendment, which prohibits federal taxpayer funding of abortion except in extreme circumstances. The Hyde Amendment has been in effect since first passed in 1976.

Democrats Choose Abortion

The $1.3 Trillion spending bill is now history. It was passed and reluctantly signed by President Trump last week. Who won and lost in the CSRs v. Hyde Amendment debate?

The clear losers are low-income individuals who will have to pay higher premiums and deductibles next year. The CSRs were not approved. The Congressional Budget Office estimates premiums will rise about 10% on the exchanges next year. 

Why weren’t the CSRs approved? The Wall Street Journal says Democrats are blaming Republicans for “demanding the inclusion of abortion restrictions they knew would be unacceptable to Democrats. Republicans say they negotiated in good faith and that Democrats rejected reasonable rules on abortion.”

Notice that both sides agree that the issue of contention is abortions, not lowering premiums and deductibles for low-income Americans! In other words, Democrats have chosen the issue of abortion over the issue of lower-cost healthcare for low-income Americans.

Democrats seem to believe that defending abortion is a bigger political issue than the cost of healthcare. It’s a bigger issue even than propping up their failing ObamaCare. Perhaps they believe that when premiums rise in November, just before the mid-term elections, voters will thank them for fighting for abortion funding even though this fight resulted in higher healthcare costs for them.

Could there be another explanation?

It’s also just as possible that Democrats believe that voters will blame Republicans for their higher healthcare premiums and not blame Democrats for insisting on government funding of abortions. Just as Democrats seem to believe that keeping DACA legislation unsettled is a better election issue than actually solving the problem, they may believe that higher healthcare costs is a winning issue – even though the cause is ObamaCare – and their insistence on funding abortions.

Democrats Choose Abortion Over Catholics

 

The Democratic Party has long been the political party of choice for most Catholics. Democratic Senator John F. Kennedy of Massachusetts gave Catholics their first-ever occupant of the White House. I can still remember the furor this caused in 1960 as many feared the Pope would become our defacto president.

Over half a century later most people, including most Democratic Party leaders apparently, take the Catholic vote for granted. That may be about to change.

The archbishop of New York, Cardinal Timothy Dolan, is taking Democrats to task for their failure to improve schools for low-income Americans – and their unabashed support of abortion.

Support for Schools

Dolan, writing in The Wall Street Journal, says the support of the Catholic Church for Democrats dates back to the 19th century when the first archbishop of New York, Archbishop John Hughes, “displayed dramatic reverence for the dignity of Irish immigrants.”

He notes the schools at the time were hostile to these immigrants so he initiated Catholic schools to provide children with a good education sensitive to their religion and to prepare them as responsible, patriotic citizens. The schools worked and many remain open today; but that may not last.

Dolan cites recent legislation in the State of New York that has repeatedly blocked education tax credit legislation, which would have helped middle class and low-income families make the choice to select Catholic or other non public schools for their children. Opposing the bill reduces the ability of fine Catholic schools across the state to continue their mission of serving the poor, many of them immigrants. Democrats are fierce supporters of the teacher’s unions and oppose school choice.

Support for Life

The second issue is the sanctity of life. Dolan recalls a recent funeral of a great African- American woman, Delores Grier, who was a convert to Catholicism. Grier was named vice chancellor of the archdiocese three decades ago by Cardinal John O’Connor. She was passionate about civil rights, especially the right to life of babies in the womb.

Grier attributed her pro-life sensitivity to Rev. Jesse Jackson who preached that abortion was an act of genocide against minorities. Time has proven Jackson correct. In 2013 there were more black babies aborted in New York (29,007) than were born (24,758), according to the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene.

The support for the sanctity of life and for good education were early values that seemed better supported by Democrats than Republicans. Dolan recalls his own grandmother telling him, “We Catholics don’t trust Republicans.”

The Modern Democratic Party

But all that has changed. The Democratic Party has come a long way from the stance of President Bill Clinton in 1992 who said abortion should be “safe, legal, and rare.” Today it has become a litmus test for Democratic candidates. Democratic Party Chairman Tom Perez recently insisted pro-life candidates have no place in the modern Democratic Party.

Democrats have recently proposed new legislation, called the Reproductive Health Act, which says doctors would not be required to care for a baby who survives an abortion. The newborn would simply be allowed to die without any attempt to save the child nor any legal repercussions. Abortions would be legal right up to the moment of birth. Who could have imagined that anyone would propose legislation to legalize the butchery of someone like Dr. Kermit Gosnell, the Philadelphia abortionist who was convicted of murdering three infants born alive after abortion?

Dolan closes his comments with an apology: to Archbishop Hughes, Dolores Grier, and his Grandma Dolan – for the need to write these words. But the Democratic Party of their day that cared about educating the poor and protecting the unborn are nowhere to be found today.

ObamaCare – To Save or Not to Save?

 

Is ObamaCare worth saving? That’s the question before Congress as they debate new funding for this failing healthcare system.

Congress is considering an omnibus-spending bill and, as usual, unpopular spending is being weighed against spending everyone likes. The issue is CSRs, cost-sharing reductions, which are payments to insurance companies to defray out-of-pocket expenses or deductibles for low-income individuals.

These CSRs were approved by the Obama administration without Congressional appropriation so a federal judge declared them illegal. The Trump administration stopped the practice last year.

But the issue has come up again as insurers threaten large premium increases that will be announced just before the 2018 mid-term elections. GOP lawmakers are hesitant to give Democrats a campaign issue they can use against them.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says moderate Republicans are demanding a “stability” deal for ObamaCare as the price of repealing the law’s penalty for declining to purchase health insurance in the tax bill (The Individual Mandate). That deal included billions in cost-sharing payments as well as reinsurance, which subsidizes high-cost patients to lower premiums for everyone else.

But the numbers have sky-rocketed since the last proposal. Last year Maine Republican Susan Collins proposed $5 billion over two years. This time the proposal is $30 billion over three years.

The problem is Democrats wrote the law to make sure insurers got paid one way or another. Premiums are higher without the cost-sharing payments so insurers benefit. The law’s tax credits grow in generosity as premiums rise, so the taxpayers pay the higher cost. Either way insurers get paid.

To add insult to injury, insurers are “Silver loading”, increasing premiums especially on Silver plans because these are tethered to the tax credits. In reality, the ultimate cost to the taxpayers is actually less when making the CSRs than allowing the tax credits to rise. Bizarrely, some left-wing advocates now oppose the CSRs they previously demanded because the tax-credit formula is more lucrative!

Then there is the Hyde Amendment, which blocks taxpayers’ dollars from funding abortions. The Trump administration and Speaker Paul Ryan have taken a stand to defend this amendment, but Democrats are trying to bully them into submission to get a deal. Apparently the abortion lobby isn’t satisfied with the hundreds of thousands of abortions already performed every year – and the half-billion in federal funding of Planned Parenthood, the nation’s largest abortion provider.

Republicans will rue the day if they give in on the Hyde Amendment. Although abortion providers have found many ways around Hyde, the symbolic message sent with a GOP defection on this principle would be devastating to their November chances. It’s time to make Democrats choose between abortions and funding the favorite achievement of the Obama presidency – ObamaCare.