Escape From ObamaCare

 

Slowly, but surely, Republicans are crafting an escape from ObamaCare.

The repeal of the Individual Mandate and the relaxation of regulations initiated by the Obama administration regarding short-term, limited duration insurance plans (STDLI), has rearranged the deck chairs on this sinking healthcare system.

Phil Gramm, former Senator from Texas and now visiting scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, says now is the time to complete the escape from ObamaCare. To make this possible, he says two things are needed:

  • HHS should grant waivers to states that want to let private insurers offer state-approved plans that are exempt from ObamaCare coverage mandates. This will enable these states to expand healthcare freedom within their borders.
  • Congress should amend ObamaCare to permit insurers to sell individual policies outside of the exchanges that are totally independent of ObamaCare regulations.

 

These two steps would dramatically increase the options available to all Americans. Those who benefit from ObamaCare now could continue within the system. Most of these are getting federal subsidies to purchase their otherwise exorbitant policies.

The rest of the country could purchase the newly available policies that would sell at about one-third the cost of ObamaCare policies.

The Idaho Test

The State of Idaho has stepped to the plate to take on these regulations. It is the first state to allow plans that stray from ObamaCare’s coverage mandates. Blue Cross of Idaho has proposed five “Freedom Blue” plans outside the state’s exchanges. The plans proved coverage similar to what is available on the exchanges – but at about one-third the price. That’s because these plans use actuarial analysis in pricing the policies rather than the ObamaCare methods that use “community rating” and “guaranteed issue.” Those methods artificially drive up the prices, especially for the young and healthy.

Gramm suggests Idaho make these state-approved plans renewable every 12 months. This would allow them to qualify for the STDLI exemptions recently implemented by the Trump administration.

Naturally, Democrats see this effort by Idaho as a threat to the long-term survival of ObamaCare – and they can’t let that happen. Senators Patty Murray and Ron Wyden have joined forces with Rep. Frank Pallone and Richard Neal to try intimidation of the State of Idaho. They have threatened massive fines and demanded emails and phone records but thus far Idaho hasn’t flinched. If Idaho succeeds, numerous Republican-led state legislatures are sure to follow.

The Impact on ObamaCare

The impact of this movement by state legislatures will be to turn the ObamaCare exchanges into a large high-risk pool. Democrats will try to get Congress to approve higher subsidies for the exchanges because premiums will have to rise to account for the loss of more young and healthy Americans. It will be impossible for Democrats to deny people who have voluntarily fled the exchanges the freedom to buy cheaper policies independent of ObamaCare regulations. That should provoke a healthy discussion about the best ways to fund high-risk pools – either by states or the federal government.

The Congressional Budget Office has projected only 7.4 million Americans still enrolled in ObamaCare by 2021. That’s only 2.2% of the population. These numbers were estimated after the elimination of the Individual Mandate but before the recent changes to STDLI plans implemented by the Trump administration.

The rest of the country will enjoy the newly found freedom to purchase the insurance plan of their choice at a price based on actuarial analysis – not one artificially raised by ObamaCare regulations. The freedom and savings enjoyed by most Americans should end any more discussion about single-payer healthcare (socialized medicine) in the future.

Financing Healthcare for Unauthorized Immigrants

 

Your federal tax dollars are financing unauthorized (illegal) immigrant healthcare. In my last post, How Taxpayers Finance Health Care for Unauthorized Immigrants, I explained the ways this is happening. Today we’ll discuss the pros and cons of the current system.

Chris Conover, healthcare economist at Duke University, says the current policy allows states and local governments to use their resources (their tax dollars) to make exceptions to federal programs that exclude unauthorized immigrants. That means liberal states like California, New York, Massachusetts, and Washington can choose to encourage such immigrants by providing free health care, while more conservative states can choose not to provide such support.

This is not a matter of compassion for the needs of such immigrants but rather a matter of political ideology. Democrats have long avoided policies that discourage illegal immigration because they see these people are useful political foils and probable future Democratic voters. Republicans prefer to discourage illegal behavior and wasteful spending of precious resources on those who have entered this country illegally and don’t have the means to pay for their care.

But the truth is that society will have to absorb the cost of unpaid healthcare one way or the other. This is precisely why encouraging the immigration of anyone who cannot support himself or herself is bad policy.

Current Funding for Health Care of Illegal Immigrants

According to the Pew Research Center, there were 11.3 million unauthorized immigrants in the U.S. in 2016. Of these, 3.9 million (34%) are ineligible for Medicaid or ObamaCare coverage under federal law. (The rest are presumed to be receiving employer-provided healthcare insurance.)

America’s uninsured, as of 2013 (latest figures available), generated $84.9 billion in uncompensated care costs, or $1,257 per person.

  • 39% was covered by various federal programs (DSH payments to hospitals)
  • 23% was covered by state and local governments
  • 12% came in the form of physician charity care
  • 25% was covered by hospitals (cost-sharing)

 

What would happen if federal and state taxpayers refused to subsidize the healthcare of unauthorized immigrants?

  • Hospitals might raise their charges – This might allow them to pay for some of the expense, but is limited by the ceilings for charges established by federal programs such as Medicaid and Medicare and by commercial insurance plans.
  • Hospitals might spend less on non-essentials and discourage unauthorized immigrants from using their facilities – There is no doubt hospitals could be more frugal and build less-expensive facilities.
  • Physicians would provide more charity care – There is a long-standing tradition in the medical community of providing such care and it will continue regardless of federal policies.
  • Patients might have to pay more ­– Paying patients would likely absorb more of the expense of uncompensated care through higher payments for their own care.
  • Voters would likely demand more accountability in immigration policies – If the cost of paying for healthcare for illegal immigrants was borne by voters, there would likely be pushback against those politicians who favored illegal immigration. This is precisely why Democratic politicians pay lip-service to fixing the illegal immigration problem yet undermine every effort to actually solve the problem.

 

How much does it cost you to pay for healthcare for illegal immigrants?

I asked you this question in the previous post that introduced this discussion. The actual number, based on an expense of $18.5 billion per year paid for by 324 million Americans, is $57 per resident. The portion paid by federal taxpayers, $11.2 billion, is $34 per U.S. resident.

That seems like very little money; perhaps not an issue worth fighting about. But Conover reminds us it is just that sort of thinking that has led us to today’s dismal reality that unfunded liabilities facing our country are now estimated at roughly $200 Trillion and rising. (Our annual budget is about $4 Trillion.)

There you have it – the pros and cons of our current system. But is there a better way? Stay tuned for more on this issue in the future.

How Taxpayers Finance Health Care for Unauthorized Immigrants

 

How much do you spend each year to pay for healthcare for unauthorized immigrants? (“Unauthorized immigrants” is the Department of Homeland Security’s politically correct term for illegal immigration.)

Most people would probably answer zero! There’s no such category in your family budget and you’re probably aware that Medicaid, Medicare, and ObamaCare all expressly prohibit coverage for illegal immigrants.

Taxpayer Support

Chris Conover, healthcare economist at Duke University, estimates American citizens finance $18.5 billion in healthcare treatment for this population through various tax-payer funded programs. Here’s a breakdown of that number:

  • $4.6 Billion paid by federal taxes
  • $2.8 billion paid by state and local taxes
  • $3.0 billion paid by “cost-shifting” by hospitals
  • $1.5 billion paid by physicians’ charity care
  • $0.9 billion paid by federal tax exemptions for non-profit hospitals
  • $5.7 billion paid by the employer tax exclusion

Of that total, federal taxpayers provided $11.2 billion in subsidized care in 2016.

Aren’t these unauthorized immigrants excluded from healthcare coverage?

Here is a summary of how federal tax dollars can be used for healthcare treatment of unauthorized immigrants:

Where Use of Federal Dollars to Fund Health Care for Unauthorized Immigrants is Expressly Prohibited

Medicaid – Medicaid and CHIP (Children’s Health Insurance Program) both exclude any federal funding to cover unauthorized immigrants, except for payment for limited emergency services. Medicaid does allow coverage for individuals who would be eligible “except for their immigration status.”

States, however, can and do use state-only Medicaid programs to cover such individuals. California is the prime example of this practice. California’s Health for All Kids Act provides unauthorized immigrant children with access to coverage through Medi-Cal, the state Medicaid program. This is the largest state program that provides coverage for all children regardless of immigration status. Other blue states that participate in such programs include New York, Illinois, Massachusetts, Washington, and the District of Columbia.

ObamaCare – Under the ACA, immigrants must be lawfully present to purchase a Qualified Health Plan, or to be eligible for an Advance Payment for Premium Tax Credit or Cost-Sharing Reduction. California’s Governor Jerry Brown applied for a federal waiver to allow the state to offer unauthorized immigrants to purchase health plans on its ObamaCare exchange, but withdrew his request on January 18, 2017.

Where Use of Federal Dollars to Fund Health Care for Unauthorized Immigrants is Indirectly Permitted

There are several “end-arounds” that allow health care for unauthorized immigrants to be indirectly funded using federal dollars.

Medicaid DSH Payments

DSH payments, or “disproportionate share hospitals”, are hospitals that serve a large number of Medicaid and low-income uninsured patients. These payments are limited to 100% of the costs incurred. These payments do not discriminate between unauthorized and authorized immigrants, or even consider immigration status at all. Therefore Medicaid dollars indirectly subsidize care for unauthorized immigrants.

Medicare DSH Payments

The same is true for Medicare. No distinction is made for immigration status. Medicare, therefore, subsidizes unauthorized immigrant care.

Community Health Centers

Federally qualified community health centers provide primary care for medical, dental, mental health and pharmacy services. There is no consideration for immigration status or ability to pay for care.

Tax Exemption

Non-profit hospitals and other health facilities receive tens of billions of dollars in benefits from federal tax exemptions including income taxes, public charitable contributions, and the value of tax-exempt bond financing. Unauthorized immigrants benefit from this federal largesse.

Employer Tax Exclusion

The tax exclusion enjoyed by all employers for providing employee healthcare insurance applies to any unauthorized immigrant employed by the company.

Next post we’ll discuss the pros and cons of such federal taxpayer assistance in providing healthcare for unauthorized immigrants.