Black Education Reformers Step Up

 

(This blog usually discusses healthcare reform but some other subjects really light my fire. One of those is school choice.)

School choice is unpopular with liberal Democrats because it threatens traditional supporters like teachers unions and black political organizations like the NAACP. Yet improved education remains the surest way to escaping poverty for black and other minority children. Too often those who claim to represent these minority children are turning their backs on what’s best for them in favor of their political agenda.

I wrote of this issue in a past blog called School Choice is Making a Difference. Readers of that post will recall that the hero of that story is Eva Moskowitz, the founder of a chain of charter schools serving the needs of the minority children of Harlem. Her efforts to improve the education of these children have been hampered by the National Education Association, the nation’s largest teachers union, The American Federation of Teachers, the NAACP, and New York Mayor Bill DeBlasio.

But there is hope this may be changing. Black education reformers are stepping up and being counted even when their views contradict the Democratic Party line. Jason Riley, The Wall Street Journal columnist, writes of this in a recent column.

Riley says the Associated Press published a hit piece earlier this month that blamed charter schools for perpetuating racial segregation. This was another in a series of such attacks by the liberal media on school choice. But now others on the political left are pushing back.

Shavar Jeffries of Democrats for Education Reform, an advocate for school choice, questioned the reporter’s methodology, among other issues. Jeffries says, “The AP makes apples-to-oranges comparisons that contrast the demographics of individual charter schools to those of entire cities. This ignores the blatantly obvious fact that charter schools are concentrated in neighborhoods with high proportions of students of color to provide them an alternative to the low-performing traditional pubic schools they previously had no choice but to attend.”

Jeffries was even more incensed by the implication that somehow black students couldn’t succeed unless there were more white students. He said, “There’s no doubt there are benefits for students who attend racially diverse schools, but we take issue with the assumption that black and brown children can’t learn unless they attend school alongside white children.”

An even more harsh criticism came from Amy Wilkins of the National Alliance of Public Charter Schools. She took umbrage at the implication that school choice proponents like herself have made common cause with the racial segregationists of yesteryear.

Ms. Wilkins has a civil-rights pedigree that few could question. She is the daughter of Roger Wilkins, the black political activist, journalist and academic, who served in the Kennedy and Johnson administrations. She is the niece of Roy Wilkins, who led the NAACP in the 1950s and ‘60s, when the Jim Crow laws were still in effect. Wilkins has spent her entire adult life as an outspoken advocate for black children.

The problem, wrote Wilkins, “isn’t one article, however off-base it may be. The problem is the mindset of revanchists who peddle stories like these – professional anti-reformers who go nuts when approaches other than those they sanction and control deliver results for the students . . . they insist cannot learn at high levels.”

Riley says that black parents simply want better schools, and the strong demand for education choice among low-income families stems from the persistent failure of traditional public-school systems to provide a decent education for their children.

Wilkins goes on: “There is no comparison – none – between the enforced segregation of the pre-Brown v. Board era and the choices black families make when they enroll their children in better schools. It’s ludicrous to suggest the two are in any way similar. In fact, it’s far closer to the spirit of Jim Crow to tell a black student that she has to go to her dismal neighborhood school because the better charter school up the street is not white enough to satisfy the defenders of the status quo.”

I am excited to see this internal debate within the Democratic Party as education reformers like Jeffries, Wilkins, and Riley take on the establishment that has consistently put political agendas ahead of the needs of minority children. The clear winners in the school choice movement are these minority children and it’s time their representatives stopped kowtowing to the teachers unions and started looking out for the children they claim to represent.

Wilkins minces no words in her disdain for such people:

“To the people trying to fabricate a segregation story to deny black students educational opportunity, I have a simple message: Don’t you dare! Don’t you dare try to take away choices black families have fought for. Don’t you dare tell black families that you know better than they do what kind of school their children should attend. Don’t you dare call yourself social justice warriors while undermining the work of black school leaders and educators who are building something better for their communities.”

 

How Much Does Healthcare Cost?

 

How much does your healthcare really cost? How many days must you work each year just to pay for your healthcare? How does this compare to earlier history? How does this compare to the cost of food?

These questions are of great interest as we continue to debate the effectiveness of the Affordable Care Act, better known as ObamaCare. The whole premise for this legislation, that was passed in 2010 by the Democratic Party without a single Republican vote, was to lower the cost of healthcare and provide insurance to those who could not afford it.

Therefore, answering the above questions tells us much about the effectiveness of ObamaCare in achieving its goals.

Chris Conover, Duke University economist, has analyzed the data to answer these questions and provides his insights in a recent Forbes column. He says the latest official statistics show that Americans in 2016 spent $10,348 per person on healthcare.

How many days must you work each year just to pay for your healthcare?

The answer to this first question is the average worker worked 63 days in 2016 just to pay for his/her healthcare.\

How does this compare to earlier history?

This is nine times longer than the average worker worked to pay for healthcare in 1940.

How does working to cover healthcare compare to working to cover food costs?

The average worker must work more than twice as long to cover healthcare as to cover food costs.

 

Conover explains the average hourly wages used to calculate the above graph is for production and non-supervisory employees in manufacturing. The average hourly wage for these workers is $20.46/hour. Obviously, those who do not earn that much per hour must work even longer to pay for their healthcare. Also, those who must support non-working dependents must work enough hours to pay for the healthcare of those dependents in addition to their own.

Conover also points out that the true expense for most families is hidden. If you only kept track of out-of-pocket spending and the amount deducted from your paycheck to pay for health insurance, you would miss a lot. Out-of-pocket expenses only account for 11 percent of healthcare spending. The employee share of health insurance spending accounts for less than 20 percent.

Only 28 percent of all healthcare spending is paid directly by households. All the rest appears to be paid by others. But Economics 101 tells us that any amount paid by your employer ultimately comes out of your compensation and all taxes are ultimately paid by households.

Historical Trends

There are several reasons for the increased hours needed to pay for healthcare compared to historical norms. They include:

  • Medical technology changes – these are more valuable and expensive
  • Decline in cost of other necessities – food, clothing, shelter
  • Decline in out-of-pocket spending (83% 1940, 11% today) led to increased wasteful spending

 

ObamaCare has failed to influence this trend, even though that was one of its primary goals. At the present trend, the time costs of paying for healthcare are approximately five times that of paying for food. With the inflation of healthcare costs, workers are spending one extra day per year working to pay for their healthcare. This trend cannot continue forever. When it will stop depends on how long the American people are willing to put up with ObamaCare.

The Media Grinch That Stole Christmas

 

Republicans have put more money in the pockets of all taxpayers just in time for Christmas – but hardly anyone realizes it.

Republicans have just passed the largest tax cut in the last 31 years, since the Reagan Tax Cuts of 1986, but Democrats and the media have conspired to confuse the public about what just happened. I can’t think of anyone who would object to having more money in their paycheck if they really understood.

But the Democratic Party of obstruction and misinformation, with much help from their co-conspirators in the mainstream media, have successfully distorted the truth. They are the Grinch that stole Christmas.

According to a CNN poll, 55% of Americans oppose the GOP tax reform plan and only 33% favor it. Other polls show only 17% of Americans think they will get a tax cut in the new bill when the actual number is 80%. The truth will come in the form of more take-home money in their February paychecks.

My hometown newspaper, The Orlando Sentinel, led with a headline that said TRUMP TRIUMPHS ON TAXES – CORPORATIONS, WEALTHY BENEFIT MOST. Yes, corporations got the largest tax cut of anyone, from a world-leading 35% down to a below average 21%. But anyone who has studied Economics 101 will understand that when U.S. corporations have to pay more taxes than anyone else in their competitive world, the real losers are the Americans who work for these companies. A large tax cut for corporations that makes them more competitive in the world will result in more American jobs at better wages – and that’s good for all Americans.

The Democrats are trying to spin this GOP victory by claiming corporations would pocket their tax cuts rather than invest in their workers. The media happily is promoting this myth. Here’s the actual response from the corporate world within hours of passage of the bill:

  • AT&T will increase its U.S. investments next year by $1 Billion plus pay $1000 bonuses to 200,000 employees
  • Comcast pledged $1000 bonuses to 100,000 employees and will invest $50 Billion over the next five years
  • Wells Fargo and Fifth Third Bancorp pledged to increase theier minimum wage to $15 per hour; Fifth Third will pay $1000 bonuses to 3000 workers
  • Nexus Services is giving a 5% pay raise to its employees and hiring 200 more

 

Who pays the current taxes?

The top income tax rate of 39.5% was lowered to 37%. The top 1 percent of taxpayers are currently paying 40% of all income taxes. The top half of taxpayers pay 97.3% of all taxes. The bottom half pays 2.7% of all taxes. The below graphic shows these numbers in a dramatic fashion.

Therefore, it’s pretty difficult to give a tax cut to those who aren’t paying taxes. Yet, even though the bottom half pays almost no taxes at all, 80% of Americans will see more money in their paychecks this February. Even the liberal Tax Policy Center had to acknowledge that 90% of the middle class will get a tax cut in 2018 that averages $1600. In fact, many families that don’t pay taxes at all will be receiving money from the government for the refundable tax credits that have been increased from $1000 to $2000 per child.

Perhaps the most alarming “fake news” being promoted by the media is the impact this legislation will have on healthcare insurance. The Associated Press report in The Orlando Sentinel says the tax bill “triggers the loss of health care coverage for millions.” This blatant distortion of the truth is referring to the repeal of the Individual Mandate of ObamaCare, which was attached to the tax bill.

The Individual Mandate of ObamaCare forced all Americans to purchase healthcare insurance, whether they wanted it or not, or pay a tax to the federal government. In other words, the government coerced millions of Americans into purchasing a product they may or may not want or be punished by the assessment of a tax.

The Congressional Budget Office estimates that about 13 million Americans will choose not to purchase this healthcare insurance once the tax penalty is eliminated. (That should tell you how much people value this healthcare insurance.) This voluntary elimination of their healthcare coverage is what the AP is referring to when it claims the tax bill will “trigger” the loss of health care coverage. All of those people will still be able to purchase healthcare insurance with the same subsidies that were available before – they just won’t be taxed if they choose not to purchase the insurance instead. Those who choose not to purchase the health insurance will save the cost of the insurance plus avoid the previous tax that could be up to as much as $2000 per year.

This scandalous misrepresentation of the truth by our mainstream media threatens our democracy today. In order for democracy to survive, we must have a free and independent media – which we have. But that media also must be unbiased and report the truth without a political agenda. Otherwise the people remain uninformed or misinformed – either way of which is unacceptable.

(For more on this subject see earlier posts in Archives: Demagoguery in the Tax Reform Debate, The Individual Mandate – Worst Tax Ever?, Killing ObamaCare Mandate Would Lower Taxes)