Canada’s Long Wait Times for Healthcare

 

How long do you want to wait to see the doctor? That’s the real question to ask when you consider single-payer healthcare like Canada.

Single Payer Healthcare

It’s no secret that Democrats want to bring you single-payer healthcare to replace the current ObamaCare disaster. Presidential candidate Bernie Sanders made it the focus of his campaign. He likes to call it “Medicare For All” and has introduced a bill in the Senate by the same name.

I’ve been opposed to this idea for quite some time since I researched my book, The ObamaCare Reality, which was published in 2015. There is plenty of historical evidence that every country where this system has been tried has resulted in long waiting times for healthcare. This includes Great Britain, Sweden, and our neighbor to the north, Canada.

Fraser Institute Report

The Fraser Institute is a leading public policy think tank in Canada. Their most recent report entitled, Waiting Your Turn: Wait Times for Health Care in Canada, documents the 2017 status of Canadian waiting times.

According to The Wall Street Journal editorial board, the Fraser Institute surveyed physicians in 12 specialties across 10 provinces and found, “a median waiting time of 21.2 weeks between referral from a general practitioner and receipt of treatment.” This is actually worse than 2016 when wait times were 20 weeks. So the problem is getting worse. The Fraser Institute has been doing this survey since 1993 and the wait times now are 128% longer than their first survey.

The wait to see a specialist for a consultation is now 177% longer than in 1993, while the wait from consultation to treatment is 95% longer than in 1993. The shortest waits are in radiology and oncology. The longest waits are for orthopedic surgery, neurosurgery, and ophthalmology.

Stop and think about that. You go to your primary care physician – a general practitioner (not an internist) and you’re referred to a specialist. You must wait over five months before you get to see that specialist!

Of course there are negative consequences of such long waits. Author Bacchus Barua says the negative consequences can include “increased pain, suffering, and mental anguish” and sometimes “poorer outcomes – transforming potentially reversible illnesses or injuries into chronic, irreversible conditions, or even permanent disabilities. In many instances, patients may also have to forgo wages while they await treatment.”

Waiting times for diagnostic testing are also long. The report says, “This year, Canadians could expect to wait 4.1 weeks for a computed tomography (CT) scan, 10.8 weeks for a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and 3.9 weeks for an ultrasound.”

Apparently it does matter where you live. The shortest wait times are in the province of Ontario and the longest are in Manitoba. While wait times decreased slightly in Ontario, Newfoundland, and Labrador, they increased nationwide on average due to appalling delays in provinces like New Brunswick where the median wait from general practitioner to treatment is 41.7 weeks!

The Canadian government is aware of these long waiting times and has even given in to paying private physicians to provide healthcare outside the system to alleviate the extreme delays. The same has happened in Great Britain and Sweden due to the unacceptably long waits. Yet this Fraser report shows the situation is getting worse.

The WSJ says the basic law of economics that scarce resources must be rationed by price or by time applies here. The impact on Canadians is clear from the report: “Ottawa’s decision to mandate a single-payer system in 1984 has consigned ailing Canadians to queues. Some 1,041,000 patients are in line waiting for treatment, a 6.9% increase in 2017.”

Canadians have responded by increasingly traveling to get their care in other countries. Nearly 63,500 Canadians went abroad last year for their care. We must make sure that never is necessary for Americans. We must stop single-payer healthcare in the U.S. before it ever happens.

(For more on single-payer systems, see my Archives.)

Measuring Poverty Under ObamaCare

 

The U.S. Census Bureau is finding new waves to measure poverty. Since 2011, they have been using a new method called Supplemental Poverty Measure (SPM). This new measure takes into account various safety net programs.

The SPM now takes into account the hundreds of billions of dollars given by the federal government to the needy including food stamps, cash assistance programs, Medicaid, Medicare, and ObamaCare. It makes adjustments for major expenses such as out-of-pocket medical spending, income, and taxes.

The significance of these new measures can be seen by noting that the new measure of out-of-pocket medical spending alone added 10.5 million people to the ranks of the poor in 2016. With this new SPM, we can see that poverty rates have declined for children, non-elderly adults and the elderly since the inception of ObamaCare.

Chris Conover, Duke University healthcare economist, helps us unpack the details of the new measure. He notes the new measure accounts for the benefits provided by Medicaid and Medicare by subtracting out-of-pocket medical expenses from income to determine the net amount available to spend on necessities such as food, clothing, shelter, and utilities.

Compared to the traditional poverty measure, the SPM reduces the measured poverty rate among children. The reason for this is that most children’s medical expenses are covered by Medicaid or the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP). This is seen in the below graphic:

However, the new SPM also notes increased poverty among the elderly. The elderly are covered by Medicare, not ObamaCare. Medicare has an actuarial value of 80% – that means 80% of the costs are covered by the federal government. The remaining 20% must be covered by the individual. Although many elderly purchase supplemental plans to cover this 20%, these policies increase out-of-pocket medical costs. Since the SPM measures these costs, it reflects higher numbers in poverty.

The impact of these out-of-pocket medical expenses can be seen in the last two bars on the far right of the above graphic. The difference is roughly 40% – and this single factor accounts for an increase in the measured poverty rate from 10.7 percent to 14.0 percent in 2016. 

The Impact of ObamaCare

The poverty rates among children, non-elderly adults and the elderly have declined since 2010 when ObamaCare was passed by Congress. Is this due to ObamaCare or in spite of ObamaCare?

The economy has grown, albeit slowly, since the recession of 2008. This is certainly one reason for declining poverty rates since 2010. But Conover found some surprises when unpacking the numbers.

  • For children and non-elderly adults, the decline in poverty rates was unaffected by out-of-pocket medical expenses
  • For the elderly, poverty actually increased when using SPM but excluding out-of-pocket medical expenses

 

How to explain these findings?

ObamaCare had a limited effect on the elderly. It was not meant to alter Medicare. Many seniors gravitated to Medicare Advantage Plans to lower their healthcare costs but ObamaCare actually tried to restrict these plans. Despite these restrictions, these plans grew from 11.1 million in 2010 to 17.6 million participants by 2016.

The “donut hole” that affects Medicare drug plans saw a gradual closing that helped some. According to the National Committee to preserve Social Security and Medicare, “since passage of the ACA in 2010, more than 9.4 million people with Medicare have saved over $15 billion on prescription drugs.”

So it is unclear just how much ObamaCare has actually impacted poverty. But it certainly is clear that the new Supplemental Poverty Measure has improved our ability to measure the number of Americans living in poverty.

Is ObamaCare Killing People?

 

I’m sure the architects of ObamaCare had good intentions. They never would have considered that this new healthcare legislation might actually lead to an increase in deaths. In fact, I’m sure they assumed the opposite.

But well-intentioned legislation often has unintended consequences.

New Study Results

The Wall Street Journal reports the findings of a new study in the Journal of the American Medical Association Cardiology suggests regulations in ObamaCare could be responsible for an increase in deaths.

A little known provision of ObamaCare included monetary incentives and penalties designed to induce changes in healthcare delivery and lower costs. These experimental payment models were rolled out nationally without careful study and the result is unintended side effects.

One example is the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, which penalizes hospitals with above-average readmissions for Medicare patients. Since readmissions drive up spending, the goal of the penalties is to encourage providers (hospitals and doctors) to take measures that reduce repeat hospitalizations. Examples would be providing patients with clearer discharge instructions and coordinating with primary-care physicians.

Hospitals are compared with national averages and cited if their 30-day readmission rate exceeds the average. Therefore, hospitals can actually be penalized even if they reduce readmissions. The penalties are assessed by reducing Medicare payments. A wide variety of medical conditions are monitored including knee and hip replacements.

Proponents of ObamaCare have touted data showing that readmissions have fallen since the penalties took effect in 2013. That’s not surprising if hospitals lose money. But the real question is what impact this has had on the patients.

The JAMA researchers examined the impact on quality of care. Their study of 115,245 Medicare patients hospitalized with heart failure looked at patients in the four years prior to and the first two years following implementation of the program. They found that the 30-day readmission rate decline to 18.4% from 20% after introduction of the penalties. But the 30-day mortality rate increased from 7.2% to 8.6% – which means about 5,400 additional deaths per year!

In other words, fewer patients were being readmitted but many more were dying.

The researchers speculated on the reasons for this increased mortality and hypothesized hospitals may be trying to “game the system.” Possible strategies included:

  • Hospitals delaying readmissions beyond 30 days to avoid penalties
  • Increasing observation stays to lower in-patient admissions
  • Shifting in-patient care to emergency departments
  • Hospitals with above-average readmissions are more likely to care for low-income patients with complicated medical cases – higher risk patients

 

The JAMA researchers concluded that, “like drugs and devices, public health policies should be tested in a rigorous fashion – most preferably in randomized trials – before their widespread adoption.”

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says, “Sounds like good advice, but not the sort that ObamaCare architects and masters of the economic-planning universe like Peter Orszag and Jonathan Gruber are inclined to take.”

As surgeons we are always looking for ways to do surgery through smaller incisions that will allow faster recovery. But we must always measure these new procedures against the high quality gold standard of the conventional procedure. Speed of recovery is never an improvement if the quality of outcomes is sacrificed.

The lesson here is clear. New government programs in healthcare must not only meet economic goals but must also maintain the same high quality medical standards established by the present system. Lower costs are never worth the price of more deaths.