Another ObamaCare Replacement Plan

 

The doctor is in the house – well, actually the Senate. Dr. Bill Cassidy, also known as Senator Cassidy (R – LA), is still trying to come up with a cure for ObamaCare.

With the help of fellow Republican senators Lindsey Graham (SC), Dean Heller (NV) and Ron Johnson (WI) and former Senator Rick Santorum (PA), Cassidy has put together a new ObamaCare replacement bill called Graham-Cassidy-Heller-Johnson. This bill is intended to address the concerns of moderate Republicans who didn’t support the last Republican proposal called The Better Care Reconciliation Act.

Avik Roy, writing in Forbes, says the BCRA wasn’t supported by Senator Rand Paul (KY) because it did too much to replace ObamaCare. BCRA wasn’t supported by moderates like Susan Collins (ME), Dean Heller (NV) and Lisa Murkowski (AL) because they were reluctant to reduce federal spending on healthcare programs, especially Medicaid.

Block Grants

This new bill attempts to win the moderates with a proposal that gives states the option to take their ObamaCare funds and make their own decisions about how to spend them. The idea is to give block grants to the states, which could be used to design healthcare systems of their own choice. This would allow blue states to preserve ObamaCare, or even introduce single-payer healthcare, while red states could choose more market-driven plans which permit greater freedom to choose your own coverage and your own doctor.

Democrats should welcome such flexibility because it would allow them to pass single-payer legislation without Republican support in blue states like California, New York, and Vermont. These states are sure to take such steps if this legislation is passed but don’t expect Democrats to assist Republicans if it means replacing their beloved ObamaCare. They still believe they can get single-payer healthcare for the whole country, not just their bluest states.

The Best of Graham – Cassidy

Roy says the best features of this new bill are:

  • Repeal of ObamaCare’s Individual Mandate
  • Repeal of ObamaCare’s Employer Mandate
  • Increase in annual contributions to Health Savings Accounts (HSAs)
  • Phase down state-based Medicaid provider taxes
  • Increased ability to purge Medicaid rolls of ineligible patients
  • Per-capita allotment for the legacy Medicaid program
  • Permits work requirements for Medicaid eligibility
  • Ends the bias in Medicaid toward wealthier states

 

The Worst of Graham – Cassidy

Roy says the bill is weak in these ways:

  • Permits single-payer initiatives funded by government subsidies
  • Repeals few of the tax increases of ObamaCare
  • Requires states to subsidize insurance plans that conform financially to plans states offer in their Children’s Health Insurance Programs (CHIP)
  • Gives more money to states that focus on enrolling those with incomes between 50 and 138% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL)

 

Deadline Looming

Unfortunately, there is a deadline looming, September 30th, for passage of any bill through the Senate under the 2017 rules of reconciliation. That gives Graham – Cassidy only two weeks to get 51 votes, anticipating no support from the Democrats. If they fail they will have to wait for 2018 fiscal year to bring the bill up again under reconciliation rules.

Once again, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) will represent a significant obstacle since they seem to have “baked in” a number between 16 and 18 million Americans who will drop their insurance if the Individual Mandate is repealed. So when the CBO scores this new bill you can be sure Democrats, and possibly moderate Republicans, will harp on the CBO projections. Republicans must disregard the pressure of these projections and spare the country from another year of ObamaCare. They must trust the doctor knows what he is doing.

Charter Schools Anniversary Heralds Progress

 

Charter schools are here to stay. September 8th marked the 25th anniversary of the charter schools movement that began in St. Paul, Minnesota. This is a good time to take notice of the progress these schools have made in our education system.

Recently I expressed my admiration for one of the leaders of the charter school movement, Eva Moskowitz of Harlem, New York City (School Choice is Making a Difference). Today we’ll see how school choice through charter schools is having a national impact.

David Osborne is the author of a new book called Reinventing America’s Schools: Creating a 21st Century Education System. In an excerpt from his book he describes some of the significant achievements of the charter schools:

  • After four years in a charter, urban students learn about 50% more a year than demographically similar students in traditional public schools. (Stanford Center for Research on Education Outcomes)
  • The American cities that have most improved their schools are those that have embraced charters wholeheartedly.

 

Here are some examples of the cities that have embraced charter schools:

New Orleans

  • New Orleans, which will be 100% charter schools next year, is America’s fastest improving city in education.
  • New Orleans schools have doubled or tripled their effectiveness in the last decade since turning to charter schools.
  • More than 80% of their students are African-American and an equal percentage qualifies for free or reduced-price lunches.
  • Despite these numbers, New Orleans became the first high-poverty city to outperform its overall state in 2015 and 2016.

 

Washington D. C.

  • 20 years after introducing charter schools, 46% of public-school students attend charter schools.
  • Charter schools outperform traditional public schools despite receiving $6,000 to $7,000 less per pupil annually.

 

Denver

  • 10 years after introducing charter schools, 42% of students attend charters or innovation schools.
  • In those 10 years Denver schools have gone from the slowest academic growth of Colorado’s 20 largest districts to its fastest.
  • Denver schools now approach the state average on standardized tests despite the fact that 70% qualify for subsidized lunches.

 

In other states like New Jersey, Indiana, Massachusetts and Tennessee, charter schools are making a big impact. Many states are noticing the success of Louisiana and introducing charter schools, especially in urban school districts.

Teachers’ unions hate all this because most charter schools are not unionized. But Osborne has an appropriate response to them: “If someone discovered a vaccine to cure cancer, would anyone limit its use because hospitals and drug companies found it threatening?”

Hurricanes Focus Our Attention

 

Hurricanes have a way of making everything else seem irrelevant. As I write these words, Hurricane Irma is bearing down on my state of Florida.

It’s September 10, just one day from the 16th anniversary of the 9-11 terrorist attack that killed about 3,000 Americans and I haven’t heard one word about that mentioned in the news media. Usually this time of year it’s the number one subject on every newscast.

Politics has taken a back seat to the overwhelming needs of the people of Texas after the devastation of Hurricane Harvey and the pending disaster of Hurricane Irma in Florida. People across the country are focused on the alarming weather maps that depict the awesome power of a hurricane in bold and impressive colors. News coverage of anything else becomes irrelevant as people riveted to the television wait for the next advisory from the meteorologists at The Weather Channel.

President Trump sensed the importance of bringing the country together in this time of crisis. To mitigate the situation he made a deal with the Democrats that would expedite funding for disaster relief and continue funding of the government for at least three more months.

Democratic leaders Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi were all smiles after this unexpected presidential capitulation to their short-term goals. The president was thinking more of the needs of the country than partisan politics – a much-needed attitude in Congress that hopefully these Democratic leaders will remember next time funding of the government comes up again.

Even the constant coverage of protests demanding the removal of Confederate statutes and the racial divide in this country are no longer the big stories. The issues that divide our country are suddenly less important than the issues that bring us together. No one is demanding disaster relief only for Democrats or Republicans.

Hurricanes demand your attention. They just won’t let you become distracted by other concerns that are far less important. They force you to consider what really matters in a world where we have so many trivial distractions such as the latest iPhone or what’s trending on social media.

I have a brother who lives in California where earthquakes are all too common. Earthquakes come without warning. There’s no time to plan – only time to react. That means you can’t make preparations, you can’t take steps to mitigate the damage apart from building codes for better construction. You can’t spend time working out a plan to keep your family safe. There’s no time for considering the future.

Hurricanes, however, give you time to think; time to prepare. They force you to make choices about your priorities and the things that really matter. It starts with your family – safety comes first. Is it safe to stay in your home or should you evacuate? If you evacuate where do you go? How many friends do you have who would be gracious enough to accept you if you wanted to take refuge in their home?

You have to make choices about your property. What things are irreplaceable and what things don’t really matter? Ultimately the only thing that is irreplaceable is human life.

We don’t like to consider that we might lose our life in a hurricane but it happens to people every year. We try to pretend we’re only really worried about our property but everyone who has ever faced a Category 5 hurricane must also consider their own destiny. It’s a good time to remember that there are some things we don’t control in this world. Meteorologists have gotten very good at measuring the strength of hurricanes and pretty accurate predicting where they will go, but they have no control over what they do.

Actress Jennifer Lawrence is blaming President Trump for these hurricanes but even Trump doesn’t have that much power. Only God can make a hurricane and only He is in control of the outcome. It’s a good time to ask yourself if you’re ready to stand before Him if the hurricane is coming for you.