School Choice is Making a Difference

 

Not all heroes wear military uniforms. I have the greatest respect for our military and we owe our freedom to the men and women who serve in our defense. But some heroes fight their battles with pen and pencil rather than guns and grenades.

I’m speaking of Eva Moskowitz, a Democratic woman who is a thorn in the side of the Democratic Party, especially those in New York City. Moskowitz has the audacity to care more about the poor, minority children of New York than the politicians and teachers’ unions that are supposed to represent these children in their pursuit of an education.

As anyone who has ever studied the plight of the poor in inner cities knows, the path to escape from a lifetime of dependency is education. Education opens doors – doors of opportunity – to jobs that lead to meaningful work and greater influence and affluence. Housing and Urban Development Secretary and former presidential candidate Dr. Ben Carson is the prime example of someone who escaped poverty and obscurity through education.

Moskowitz was exposed to the problem of New York’s failing public schools as a child who grew up in Harlem in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Though she is white, she was forced to endure the same failing education system as her minority friends. Fortunately, she was blessed with parents who were both professors who supplemented her education. She would go on to achieve high academic goals including a Ph.D in history from Johns Hopkins University.

What makes Moskowitz special is she saw a problem that surrounded her and she determined to do something about it. What makes her a hero is she was willing to challenge her own political party and the leaders of minority groups to make education better for the minorities.

The Success Academy

Moskowitz founded The Success Academy, a charter school in Harlem, in 2006. Today there are seven Success Academy schools just in Central Harlem. She wanted a better education for the children of New York City where education was still failing thirty years after her own experience. By giving parents a choice of where to send their children, Moskowitz is giving those children a chance to live a better life.

Writing in The Wall Street Journal, Moskowitz can now report the latest performance numbers for her school choice movement since the results of the 2017 New York state tests were released. Here are the amazing statistics:

  • Almost half of Central Harlem students attend a charter school
  • Students meeting rigorous Common Core math standards have more than doubled since 2013 – from 1,690 to 3,703.
  • Students attending charter schools account for 96% of that growth.
  • Black and Hispanic students from Success Academy schools outperform white students across the city by 33 points in math and 21 points in reading.
  • Low-income students outperform the city’s affluent students by 38 points in math and 24 points in reading.

 

Parents are noticing the difference. This year 14,000 Harlem children were entered into a lottery for charter schools but only 3,000 spots were available. Across the city there are 48,000 students on charter school waiting lists.

I’m sure no one would contend that black and Hispanic students are genetically superior to explain these outstanding results. So the schools must get the credit. You might expect liberals who claim they are concerned about the poor and minorities would be elated at these results. Sadly, you would be wrong.

The NAACP (National Association for the Advancement of Colored People) recently called for a moratorium on charter schools, claiming they created a system that was “separate and unequal.” Lily Garcia, president of the National Education Association, the nation’s largest teachers union, also opposes charter schools. American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten even went so far as to say school-choice and charter schools were the “polite cousins” to Jim Crow segregation. Progressive New York City Mayor Bill DeBlasio is also opposed to charter schools.

In other words, when school choice and charter schools benefit blacks and other minorities, the NAACP and the teachers unions call these schools “racist.” When blacks and other minority students succeed, Democratic leaders oppose more of the same school choices.

If you’re confused you’re not alone. What’s not confusing is the agenda of these organizations that profess to be concerned about the plight of minority children but in fact are only concerned with their own political power and campaign coffers.

My hat’s off to people like Eva Moskowitz and Education Secretary Betsy De Vos who are fighting an uphill battle to improve the education and the lives of thousands of minority children despite the obstruction of those who should be applauding their efforts and supporting their work. They are true heroes.

Computers Controlling Healthcare

 

There’s an old saying that “the inmates are running the asylum.” In our current healthcare system, it’s the computers who are running the hospital.

It’s been four years since I admitted a patient to the hospital; my practice reduced now to outpatient surgery only. But recently my wife was hospitalized and I had a rare opportunity to observe hospital care from the family member’s perspective. I spent hours sitting with my wife and observing how differently hospitals function since I first entered medical school.

It’s been over forty years since I began my medical career. Back then the doctor was king and the nurses majored in patient care and the needs of the doctor. When a doctor made rounds on the patients in the hospital, the nurse went along to update the doctor on the patient’s condition and take orders on any changes needed to the patient’s treatment. Computers were people who did mathematics.

Doctors spent most of their time seeing patients, doing procedures, and staying up-to-date on medical knowledge. Nurses spent most of their time in patient care and a minimum of time doing paperwork.

Hospitals Today

Today is very different. Each time the nurse came to see my wife she, or he, was pushing a rolling computer stand. They spent more time looking at the computer screen than they did looking at my wife. They were certainly pleasant, generally efficient, and mostly competent – but they were obsessed with the computer.

They had to scan an identification band on her wrist before they could do anything. They needed “computer approval” before they could give any medication, record any vital signs, or make any requests. If I went to the nursing station to find help, I was sure to find everyone there engrossed in their own separate computer.

Each time the doctor came to make rounds, the nurses were nowhere to be found. The rapport between doctor and nurse that I had always found critical to good patient care was nowhere in evidence. All communication seemed to be via the ubiquitous computers. This was most evident when my wife was discharged and her release was delayed nearly an hour because of computer malfunction. I’m not sure if she would have ever been permitted to leave the hospital if not for the fact that the nurse didn’t want a confrontation with a family member who is on the medical staff.

I’m sure these nurses are doing their best to provide good patient care but they are hamstrung by their subservience to the computer. Doctors are not immune from the same problem.

According to a new study published in Health Affairs, doctors now spend an average of 3.08 hours on patient visits and 3.17 hours on their computers each day. The authors said, “Over time, log records from physicians showed a decline in the time allocated to face-to-face visits, accompanied by an increase in the time allocated to desk-top medicine (computers).”

Furthermore, since doctors are paid only when they see patients and not when they spend time on the computers, they are receiving less compensation. The authors suggested their findings highlight the misalignment of the current fee-for-service payment policy and the potential for physician burnout with EHR (electronic health records) use.

A separate study appeared in the Annals of Internal Medicine in 2016 noted doctors spent only 27% of their office day on direct face time with patients but nearly half (49.2%) of their day on computers and other desk work. Even when in the exam room with patients, only about half (52.9%) of that time was spent talking to the patients while 37% was spent on the computer or other desk work. Then, at the end of their day, doctors spent about 2 more hours completing EHR or other desk work.

Decreased time in patient care, decreased control of the healthcare treatment environment and decreased compensation all lead to frustration in providers, both doctors and nurses, and a diminished patient care experience. This is contributing to the doctor shortage as more and more doctors retire early and fewer doctors are trained. This trend will not have a happy future.

VA Progress Under Trump

 

Finally there is progress at the Veteran’s Administration. It’s now over three years since the scandalous revelations of 2014 when veterans were dying while waiting for appointments to see a doctor.

The Coburn Report

Senator Tom Coburn (R – OK) investigated the VA scandal and released a report called “Friendly Fire: Death, Delay, and Dismay at the VA.” The tragic consequences of this scandal of mismanagement are highlighted in the report:

  • The report identifies $20 Billion in waste and mismanagement that could have been better spent providing health care to veterans.
  • More than 1,000 veterans may have died as a result of VA misconduct over the past decade.
  • The federal government has paid out $845 million for VA medical malpractice since 2001.
  • Most VA construction projects are over budget and behind schedule, inflating costs by billions of dollars.

 

During the Obama administration little progress was made in solving the many problems and reversing the perverse culture that contributes to the dilemma. But recent signs reveal the Trump administration is having better success.

According to David A. Patten, writing in Newsmax, Trump started working on the problems even before he was inaugurated. In December last year Trump convened a group of highly respected healthcare officials at his Mar-a -Lago estate in Florida. The group was put together by highly respected Dr. Bruce Moskowitz and included Mayo Clinic CEO John H. Noseworthy, Paul Rothman of Johns Hopkins Medical Center, Dr. David Torchiana of Partners Healthcare and Dr. Toby Cosgrove of The Cleveland Clinic.

As a result of that meeting, many ideas were put forth on how to fix the VA. The right leader was needed to implement these changes and President Trump appointed Dr. David J. Shulkin as the new Secretary of Veterans Affairs. Shulkin was the former president and CEO of New York’s Beth Israel Medical Center. He won Senate confirmation with the only 100 – 0 vote.

Shulkin recognized immediately that he needed the power to hold VA officials accountable who were not performing well. The result was an executive order by Trump to establish the VA Office of Accountability and Whistleblower Protection. He also authorized the VA secretary to use “all available authorities to discipline or terminate any VA manager or employee who has violated the public’s trust.”

Shulkin has instituted an aggressive series of reforms:

  • “Stop Fraud, Waste and Abuse” campaign to save millions of taxpayers’ dollars
  • New electronic record keeping system to replace old paper-based system. The new system is the same as already exists in the Department of Defense which makes the two systems compatible to share records.
  • Wait times for appointments posted online to increase transparency
  • Free mental health services to all veterans, regardless of service records. This is a serious attempt to lower the suicide rate currently at 20/day.
  • Decision Ready Claims – electronic claims process to process the backlog of 90,000 disability claims.
  • Choice program enhanced – to allow veterans to seek private care outside the VA system. Over 500,000 community providers are participating.
  • Low-rated medical centers being investigated. Fourteen identified centers are currently under investigation.

 

Problems Persist

Despite all this good news, there are still problems due to the federal bureaucracy that is deeply entrenched. The case of Brian Hawkins is a good example, which was reported by The Wall Street Journal.

Hawkins was director of the Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Washington, D. C. until April when he was fired after the Inspector General, Michael Missel, issued an emergency report on his facility. His report found 18 of 25 sterile storage areas for supplies at the D.C. facility were dirty.

The hospital had no effective inventory system, so doctors and nurses had to routinely cancel or delay procedures for lack of supplies; they used recalled or expired products on patients. The facility had run up 194 official reports of safety incidents involving patients since 2014 – and those were merely the incidents reported. Vendors removed equipment because the hospital failed to pay its bills.

Hawkins was dismissed on July 28 for having “failed to provide effective leadership at the medical center.” Hawkins claims he was wrongly terminated and appealed to the Merit Systems Protection Board, which was established in 1979 to protect federal employees from abusive treatment. Unfortunately it has become a union-supported shop dedicated to protect employees from discipline. The board issued an immediate stay on his removal, meaning the VA must continue to employ Hawkins while he fights dismissal.

Secretary Shulkin plans to use the Hawkins case to test the VA Accountability Act’s new powers of removal. He will fire Hawkins again, under the new law, which bars him from appealing to the Merit Board. He will then have 21 days to appeal the firing to an internal board made up of fellow senior executives or go to court.

Hopefully this case will set a precedent that will give the VA Secretary the powers he needs to hold his employees accountable. Veterans’ lives are at stake.