Taxpayers Lifting Heavy Burden of Healthcare

 

The burden of carrying healthcare by taxpayers is getting heavier every year. We can thank President Obama for that, even though he promised ObamaCare would “bend the cost curve down” for healthcare spending.

According to Chris Conover, Duke healthcare economist writing in Forbes, by 2025, federal, state and local taxpayers will be financing fully two-thirds of American health care! This is seen dramatically in the graph below:

You won’t get this data from the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) because they do their calculations differently. They report the federal government will pay only 29.7% of health spending in 2026, while state and local government will pay only 10.9%, making a grand total of just 40% of total healthcare spending.

But Conover says they arrive at this low figure by ignoring the literally hundreds of billions of dollars in health-related tax expenditures – the largest of which is the tax exclusion for employer-provided health coverage.

In 2016 alone, the federal government lost over $300 billion in revenues due to such tax expenditures and states/local governments lost an additional $40 billion. By 2025 the federal tax revenue loss alone will exceed more than half a trillion dollars!

Why is this important?

Conover says, “At the margin, each dollar of tax-financed health spending shrinks the economy by 44 cents.” That means when government pays for two-thirds of healthcare and healthcare consumes 19.9% of GDP (the official CMS forecast for 2025), these figures imply we will forego 5.9% of GDP due to tax-financed healthcare.

In other words, we will lose $1.1 Trillion dollars of economic stimulus! That amounts to an expense of about $3,000 per U.S. resident. I’m sure that money would go a long way toward alleviating the financial difficulties of most Americans.

The point of all this is we should be minimizing rather than maximizing the share of health spending funded by taxpayers. Economists call this drag on the economy an enormous “excess burden.” The government should get out of the business of financing the healthcare of the wealthy through Medicare and go to a means-tested system of government support rather than one based solely on age.

Conover says the $300 billion a year tax exclusion could be used to finance a new system of “universal tax credits that would provide everyone with the means to purchase catastrophic coverage but not incentivize people to purchase lavish policies with little cost-sharing or that cover routine care that grown-ups can and should budget on their own.”

Think about this. No one expects that homeowners insurance will pay for mowing the grass nor for auto insurance to pay for gasoline and oil changes. Why do people expect health insurance to pay for routine medical expenses?

If we treated health insurance like homeowners or auto insurance there would be more money saved in taxes and premiums that could fuel the economy and raise our standards of living.

Medicaid – The Defense Killer

 

I’ve written recently on the adverse impact of Medicaid on our states (Medicaid – The State Killer). Now it seems it is having an even more alarming impact on the defense of our nation.

At a time when tensions are higher than ever with North Korea, the importance of a strong defense could not be clearer. But although the intent of President Trump is to strengthen our military and our missile defense, the drain on our federal budget by Medicaid is significant.

Senator John McCain (R – AZ) is a strong advocate for military spending since his days as a Navy pilot shot down in Vietnam who spent years as a prisoner-of-war. Yet McCain recently voted against the Senate’s bill to reform ObamaCare that would have dramatically reined in future Medicaid spending. Never has a military hawk’s vote had a more negative impact on the military.

The Wall Street Journal recently called McCain to task for his vote in an editorial. Although Trump has promised to increase military spending, McCain has criticized his defense budget because he believes the increased spending is not enough.

The reality is that the structure of federal spending has changed dramatically since the days of President Reagan in the 1980’s when huge increase in defense spending contributed to the demise of the Soviet Union. Increases in entitlement spending including Medicaid, Medicare, and Social Security have increased from 25% in the 1960’s, to 42% in the 1980’s, to an all time high of 60% today. That leaves much less for the military, whose portion of the budget has dropped from more than 25% in the 1980’s to about 15% today.

As Medicaid spending increases, defense spending decreases. This trend has been getting worse in the last eight years as seen in the graphic below:

This pattern was deliberate by the Obama administration and Trump is trying to reverse the trend. But the key to a reversal is the reform of entitlements and Medicaid is a great place to start. Even though the Senate bill would not have cut a single dollar from current spending, the dramatic ratcheting down of future spending would have given us some control over the budget, allowing for greater increase in defense spending. The Senate bill McCain blocked would have saved as much as $772 billion over 10 years. That would buy a lot of defense!

With the heated rhetoric going back and forth between us and North Korea and nuclear missiles pointed at our shores, not to mention growing conflicts in the Middle East and the War with ISIS, it is imperative that we have a strong military. The key to that initiative is controlling our healthcare spending. It’s time for the grown-ups in Congress to put aside their local concerns and do what’s right for the country. A nuclear war with North Korea makes those concerns pale in comparison.

 

(My last post, Lowering the Cost of Health Insurance Premiums was very popular. For those of you who would like to learn more, here is a link to Senator Ron Johnson’s CNN interview.)

Lowering the Cost of Health Insurance Premiums

 

Most people want to lower health insurance premiums. In fact, this heads the list of most desired improvements in our healthcare system in repeated polling. So understanding what drives up the cost of premiums is crucial to making premiums less expensive.

There is no doubt that ObamaCare caused premiums to skyrocket. Despite President Obama’s claims that his new healthcare bill would “lower premiums an average of $2500 per year” it actually caused them to increase about $3500 per year. That’s about $6000 more per year than promised.

What caused these significant premium increases?

ObamaCare made several significant changes in health insurance plans. It forced insurers to provide certain “essential health benefits” as determined by HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius. These included mammograms, prostate exams, and other routine procedures regardless of gender in all plans. In other words, the anticipated cost of these procedures was calculated into every plan, regardless of whether they were needed or not.

Every insurance plan was required to be “ObamaCare compliant”, meaning it complied with every requirement of the law, or insurers could be fined. As a result no non-compliant plans were offered.

Other requirements of “ObamaCare compliance” included plans that were “guaranteed issue” and “community rated”. These insurance terms represent a change from previous insurance practices and also affect pricing.

Guaranteed issue means policies must be offered to all applicants, regardless of previous medical treatment or pre-existing conditions. Community rating means insurers cannot charge anyone more regardless of their medical history. Insurers were only allowed to factor in age, tobacco usage, and geographical location. Age was only allowed to increase premiums by a 3:1 ratio rather than the usual 5:1 or 6:1 typically used by insurers before ObamaCare.

With these restrictions placed on insurers, premiums were guaranteed to rise. Imagine expecting to pay the same auto insurance rates for your eighteen-year-old son who has totaled three cars as your fifty-year-old wife who’s never had an accident. Imagine expecting to pay the same health insurance premiums for your eighty-year-old grandmother with heart disease as your eighteen-year-old son who’s never been to the doctor. Insurance premiums must be predicated on actuarial risk rather than government mandates or insurers will surely fail.

Which of these government mandates caused the most premium increases?

That has been the most important question when considering improvements in the system that will lower premiums the most. We now have the answer to that question.

Fred Barnes, writing in The Weekly Standard, says a new study by McKinsey & Co. was performed for the Department of Health and Human Services. The results of that study were revealed recently by Senator Ron Johnson of Wisconsin.

The study focused on premium hikes in Tennessee, Georgia, Pennsylvania, and Ohio. The increased risk for insurers from guaranteed issue and community rating caused between 73 percent and 76 percent of the rise in premiums in Tennessee from 2013 to 2017. They caused between 44 percent and 52 percent of the increase in Georgia, between 53 percent and 62 percent in Pennsylvania, and between 41 percent and 50 percent in Ohio.

Here are some examples:

For a 40 year-old male in Tennessee, the monthly premium increased from $104 in 2013 to $431 in 2017 (ObamaCare Silver plan). The increase was from $94 to $323 in Georgia, from $119 to $373 in Pennsylvania, and from $102 to $284 in Ohio.

Senator Johnson explained the findings: “Had we never passed ObamaCare, premiums should be somewhere in the $300 per month level versus $574. This is the damage done by ObamaCare. And this, I’m very sad to report is what we are not adequately addressing.”

But there is some good news. Johnson said the “good news” in the ‘root cause analysis’ by McKinsey is being ignored in Congress. He said, “The good news is you can actually cover people with high cost and preexisting conditions without collapsing insurance markets. They’re called high-risk pools.”

A second study was done by HHS to examine the impact of Senator Ted Cruz’s amendment to allow insurers to sell non-compliant policies without all the essential health benefits. Senators Johnson and Mike Lee (Utah) wrote in a letter to their colleagues, “The results are remarkable. If insurers were to offer ObamaCare –compliant plans and non-ObamaCare compliant plans there would be a significant decrease in premiums.”

The study revealed monthly premiums in the individual health insurance market would reach an average of $845 by 2024 under ObamaCare. Under the Cruz amendment with two risk pools included, premiums would be 30 percent lower for a 40 year-old man with an ObamaCare-compliant plan. But premiums for non-ObamaCare-compliant plans would be as much as 77 percent lower. The amendment would also expand insurance coverage by 2.2 million people.

Conclusions

The conclusions from these studies indicate the real culprits in rising premiums are guaranteed issue and community rating. Essential health benefits actually are responsible for only small increases. In Tennessee they’re responsible for less than 2 percent increases; in Georgia and Ohio it’s only 5 to 8 percent; in Pennsylvania it’s 7 to 11 percent. While no man wants to pay for maternity benefits and no woman wants to pay for prostate exams, these benefits have a smaller impact on rates.

The abolishment of government regulations that force guaranteed issue and community rating is the real answer to lowering premiums. Coverage of those with expensive pre-existing conditions can be provided through high-risk pools and other protections for those unfortunate enough to have chronic medical conditions. New legislation should address these culprits that are contributing to the skyrocketing cost of health insurance premiums.