Charlie Gard Crisis Offers Warning to America

 

Charlie Gard’s life was short but all Americans should be thankful he was born. He was the world’s most famous baby for awhile and everyone should be paying attention to what happened to him.

For those of you who’ve been on vacation for the last month, Charlie Gard was an 11-month-old British child who was fighting for his life due to a rare genetic disease. He was on life-support in a London hospital. British medical experts said there was no hope for him yet they refused to let his parents take him out of the hospital. They insisted he must die in the hospital.

Charlie Gard’s situation drew the attention of President Trump, Pope Francis, the British courts and the European Court of Human Rights. The Wall Street Journal editorial board weighed in with their opinion, too:

“It may be that the experts the British and European courts invoke are right, that even with treatment Charlie won’t live much longer than he might with new interventions. But it’s not their decision to make. Or shouldn’t be. Charlie’s mother says the hospital won’t allow her and her husband to bring their boy home, meaning that if he is to die, it will be with the hospital and not at home with those who love him. Which raises a question: Whose baby is Charlie, anyway – his parents’ or the state’s? In this delicate case, Britain’s national care system has elevated technical expertise over parental love.”

 

This is what happens when you allow socialized medicine into your country. The state becomes the final arbitrator of all healthcare decisions. When further medical treatment is not considered “a good investment”, further treatment is denied. When someone’s life expectancy doesn’t meet government standards, treatment is ended. Even where you will die is determined by the state! When the state is allowed to make these decisions for the family, who’s to say when they will decide that other “abnormal conditions” will not be treated, such as Down’s Syndrome, cerebral palsy, or even hemophilia?

The sordid details of this tragedy are just now being revealed. Despite having loving parents who were willing to take him home and love him until he died, the court ordered a guardian to “represent” the child’s interests, refusing to allow the child to leave the hospital. Bill McGurn, columnist for The Wall Street Journal, says the guardian runs a charity with connections to a sister organization that promotes assisted suicide! Until 2006 this organization was called the Voluntary Euthanasia Society.

McGurn summarizes the disintegration of society this case represents:

“The essence of civilization is that the strong protect the weak. But Charlie Gard shows that the barbarian no long comes wielding a club and grunting in some undecipherable tongue. These days the barbarian comes as an expert, possessed of all the requisite certification – and an unquestioned faith in his absolute right to impose final judgments about the “quality of life” of other people’s loved ones.”

An American Example

This kind of situation is closer to home than you think. J. J. Hanson is a Marine Corps veteran of the war in Iraq. He was living the American dream with a good job, happily married with an infant son, when one day he suddenly had a Grand Mal seizure. After a series of tests, he was discovered to have a brain tumor, a Grade 4 glioblastoma multiforme. This is one of the worst forms of brain cancer. Neurosurgeons told him it was inoperable and chemotherapy or radiation was unlikely to be helpful. He was given four months to live.

Not surprisingly, depression followed this prognosis. But he is thankful that he does not live in a state where assisted suicide was an option. With his family’s support he pursued standard and experimental treatment options. He didn’t accept the grim prognosis of his initial doctors and committed himself to all available remedies. Fortunately, he lives in a country where people can still get treatment of their condition even when the prognosis is poor.

Today he is three years older and his wife is expecting another baby. He has formed an organization called Patient Rights Action Fund that fights assisted-suicide legislation across the country. Hanson says, “If suicide becomes a normal medical treatment for terminally ill patients, lives will be tragically shortened, as patients who might have outlived their prognoses by months or even years kill themselves prematurely.”

 

The Warning

If single-payer healthcare is passed in America we will see children like Charlie Gard and adults like J. J. Hanson denied the treatment they desperately need. We will see the government making determinations of who receives treatment and who does not. We must never let this happen.

The Republican ObamaCare Train Wreck

 

The Republican train to repeal and replace ObamaCare has gone off the tracks. The result will be a healthcare system in wreckage.

For seven years the GOP has talked about repeal and replacement of the failing ObamaCare system but when given the chance to make historic improvements, they flinched. Too many cooks spoiled the soup.

Politics is a team sport and Republicans have not learned this truth. Democrats may have bad ideas but they stick together. There are too many big egos in the Republican Party who insist on getting attention from the media by opposing their party’s reforms.

Who’s to blame?

Republican defectors include Senators Susan Collins (Maine), Lisa Murkowski (Alaska) and the irascible Senator John McCain (Arizona). Other defectors include Republican Governors John Kasich (Ohio) and Brian Sandoval (Nevada) who heavily influenced their respective senators, Rob Portman and Dean Heller. Others who contributed to defeat include Senators Rand Paul (Kentucky) and Mike Lee (Utah). All of these should be held accountable by the voters in future elections.

President Trump should be given at least some of the blame for failing to sell his healthcare reform on the stump. His “tweets” and White House photo ops were insufficient to sell his Republican Congressional leaders or the public on the importance of reform.

What’s next?

None of this has changed the fact that ObamaCare is rapidly failing. The problem is most people get their health insurance from their employer (160 million) and don’t see the impact rising premiums have on their paycheck. The employer absorbs the rising costs but wages have to stagnate to accommodate the overhead increases.

Those in the individual market see those rising premium costs unless they receive generous subsidies from the government. But even they experience the rising deductibles that now average $6000 for individuals and $12,000 for families. These numbers will undoubtedly increase when the 2018 rates become known.

Republicans will now be forced to reach across the aisle to get Democratic support for any improvements. While this makes sense since bipartisan support makes for better policies, the Democratic position will lead us closer than ever to single-payer healthcare. This was their real intent in 2009 at the beginning of the Obama healthcare reform legislation, but they knew it was politically impossible then to get widespread support. Today that may be possible.

What will single-payer healthcare mean?

I have written extensively on this subject in the past and a review of this blog’s archives will be instructive.(Single-Payer v. Market Oriented Health Care) Single-payer healthcare is a variant of socialized medicine, which puts the government in full control of healthcare spending and treatment decisions. Not only will you lose the freedom to choose your doctor and your treatment, you will have to wait longer to receive any medical care – and then only what the government chooses to allow.

Republicans will be blamed for this failure but it should be remembered that not one Democrat stood up to help the Republicans save the country from the failures of ObamaCare. There is plenty of blame to go around.

IPAB “Death Panel” Deadline Looms

 

While the Senate debates the repeal of ObamaCare, an important deadline looms.The Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB), created by ObamaCare, must be repealed by August 15th of this year.

What is the IPAB?

IPAB is a panel of bureaucrats empowered with the authority to make cuts in Medicare programs and spending without Congressional approval. These unelected government officials would be unaccountable to the voters and the duly elected representatives in Congress.

The board is composed of 15 individuals appointed by the President. This body of unelected officials will make their recommendations based on the growth of Medicare spending. In each year that Medicare’s per capita costs exceed a certain threshold, IPAB will be responsible for making proposals to reduce this projected cost growth to the specified threshold. The policies will then take effect automatically unless Congress specifically passes legislation blocking them and the president signs that legislation. This can only be done by a three-fifths “super-majority” vote.

The purpose of IPAB is to give political cover to the White House so that unpopular cuts in Medicare spending can be made without political repercussions. These unelected officials will be unaccountable to the voters.

ObamaCare stipulates that fewer than half of the 15 members of the IPAB can be involved in providing or managing the delivery of Medicare items and services, including healthcare providers. Furthermore, no member can serve as a practicing physician or be otherwise employed. Board members are appointed by the President but must be confirmed by the Senate.

To date no one has been appointed to the board. But the law stipulates that the HHS Secretary is a voting member of IPAB – and can act unilaterally if there are no other IPAB members appointed. Therefore, current HHS Secretary Tom Price has the power to make recommendations to cut Medicare spending – and it would take a “super-majority” of Congress to alter these recommendations. While this is less frightening under the leadership of Price than it was under his predecessors, Kathleen Sebelius and Sylvia Matthews Burwell, it is nevertheless a great deal of power in the hands of one individual.

ObamaCare has provisions built into it that will make it nearly impossible for future Congresses or Presidents to block these proposals. These provisions have the effect of eliminating any accountability to the people. In my latest book, The ObamaCare Reality, I reference the work of Michael Cannon who gives five reasons for this:

  • ObamaCare exempts the board’s proposals from the rulemaking requirements that Congress imposes on other executive branch agencies. The law does not require IPAB to hold hearings, take testimony, or receive evidence from the public.
  • ObamaCare authorizes IPAB to submit its proposals directly to Congress as “legislative proposals.” The President’s constitutional authority is undermined by this provision because it removes his discretion on what legislation is submitted to Congress.
  • Once the legislative proposal is submitted to Congress, ObamaCare protects it by codifying changes to the normal parliamentary rules that permit the Senate or the House of Representatives to modify the proposal. Then, if Congress fails to pass an alternative proposal that achieves the same budgetary goal, the IPAB proposal becomes law automatically.
  • If Congress fails to repeal IPAB through the restrictive procedure laid out in the law, then after 2020, Congress loses the ability to even offer substitutes for IPAB proposals. The HHS Secretary is then empowered to implement IPAB’s proposals even if Congress does enact a substitute. To constrain IPAB at all, Congress must do so between January and August of 2017.
  • ObamaCare gives IPAB and the HHS Secretary the sole authority to judge their own actions by prohibiting administrative or judicial review of the Secretary’s implementation of an IPAB proposal.

 

How can this unconstitutional seizure of the authority of Congress and the President be stopped?

The law specifies precisely how IPAB can be repealed:

  1. Wait until the year 2017.
  2. Introduce a specifically worded “Joint Resolution” in Congress, both the House and Senate, between January 1 and February 1, 2017.
  3. Pass that resolution by a three-fifths “super-majority” vote in both the House and Senate by August 15, 2017.
  4. The President must then sign the “Joint Resolution.”

 

There are only two weeks left for Congress to get this done!

 

Here is a prescient warning from the past:

“The conviction grows that if efficient planning is to be done, the direction must be “taken out of politics” and placed in the hands of experts – permanent officials or independent autonomous bodies. . . .The delegation of particular technical tasks to separate bodies, while a regular feature, is yet only the first step in the process whereby a democracy which embarks on planning progressively relinquishes its powers.”

Friedrich Hayek, 1944 – The Road to Serfdom