The Misleading Language of Healthcare Reform

 

It’s hard to understand anyone when you don’t speak their language. In politics there is a language of its own that will leave you confused unless you understand what people, and the media, are saying. Here are some examples of language used in the healthcare debate that may have you confused:

When is a “cut” not a cut?

When critics, or even the media, are talking about the GOP Medicaid reform legislation that doesn’t “cut” spending. It merely slows the rate of growth of spending from a current twice inflation to a new growth rate of medical inflation (higher than overall inflation) until 2025. Thereafter it will continue to grow at the rate of overall inflation. In Washington, anytime Congress reduces the growth of spending it is referred to derisively, and inaccurately, as a “cut.”

When does voluntarily dropping your health insurance mean the government forced you to “lose” your coverage? When critics are talking about the CBO scoring of the GOP healthcare legislation that gives people a choice about buying insurance. The CBO believes that merely dropping the Individual Mandate that forces people to purchase insurance will result in 15 – 18 million Americans voluntarily choosing to drop their insurance that they don’t believe they need nor want to pay for. The CBO actually just predicts fewer people will have coverage, but critics mislabel this as “lost coverage.”

When does stimulating the economy to create more jobs for everyone mean a “tax cut for the rich?” When critics are talking about the GOP elimination of ObamaCare taxes on investment. ObamaCare raised taxes on everyone, but especially on higher income Americans with a 3.8% tax on investment income. Although the rich can afford this, economists agree this investment tax acts as a disincentive that harms the economy, costing America thousands of jobs; jobs mostly for low-income people. If the final bill retains this tax, as liberals and moderates demand, it may seem “fairer” because it taxes the rich more, but the real losers will be people looking for jobs.

When does reducing the growth of an out of control entitlement mean “throwing people off Medicaid?” When critics describe the changes the GOP wants to make to ensure Medicaid will be available for those who really need it in the years to come. ObamaCare changed the original intent of Medicaid to cover the poor, children, pregnant women, the elderly, and the disabled into an entitlement for able-bodied unemployed adults for the first time. The GOP Senate bill calls for states to decide for themselves if they want to continue to cover these adults who refuse to go back to work. States with innovative Medicaid programs with work incentives, like Indiana, have reduced their rolls of Medicaid as people go back to work and get employer-provided or subsidized private insurance. Expansion of Medicaid has actually resulted in fewer dollars to cover those who really need the help because of the expanded coverage of those who don’t.

When does asking people with expensive health conditions to pay a little more than healthy Americans for their health insurance mean “eliminating coverage of pre-existing conditions?” When critics misrepresent the GOP changes to ObamaCare. Pre-existing coverage will still be available to everyone but with new provisions to prevent “gaming the system” which raises premiums for everyone. Those who have chronic, expensive conditions rightly will pay a little more than the healthy but not the actual full cost (which is subsidized by high-risk pools). The bill calls for $138 Billion in funding for these high-risk pools. No one will be denied coverage due to pre-existing conditions as in the pre-ObamaCare era.

When does “millions of people will die” from loss of health insurance mean millions chose to drop insurance coverage they didn’t need and didn’t want? When critics describe the CBO projections for insurance coverage after the GOP healthcare bill is passed. This alarmist rhetoric is designed only to frighten the uninitiated. No one needs to die for lack of healthcare treatment – unless we adopt a single-payer system (which Democrats want!) that allows the government to decide who gets treatment and who doesn’t. (See Charlie Gard crisis in Great Britain.)

When is it considered “fair” to force young and healthy people to pay more than the actual cost of their health insurance premiums? When progressives passed ObamaCare. Though they usually promote “redistribution of income” from the wealthy to those with less income, ObamaCare actually did the opposite in some ways; forcing young and healthy people (who are usually poorer) to pay more so that older and sicker people (who are generally wealthier) could pay less. Now, as the GOP tries to correct this problem, critics argue they are being “cruel” to make older people pay more. If the young and healthy people aren’t given a good value for their insurance premium they will refuse to enroll (which they did!) forcing everyone to pay more and undermining the financial stability of the system. That’s one of the main reasons ObamaCare is currently collapsing.

Cruz Compromise

As I write these words, Senator Ted Cruz has offered a compromise in the Senate bill to address this last problem. He wants to allow insurance companies to provide low cost insurance plans with less complete coverage to those young and healthy people who don’t need the expensive coverage of ObamaCare. These “mini-med” plans were widely available before ObamaCare and were quite popular, but the Obama administration outlawed them when passing ObamaCare.

I hope this post will better educate you on the “language” of this healthcare debate. Unfortunately, you can’t count on critics of Republicans, or even the media, to explain exactly what they are saying.

CBO Predictions Deeply Flawed

 

If the officials that referee the game are biased, it’s very hard to win.

In the game of politics, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) calls the game. The CBO is supposed to be non-partisan, not subject to political favoritism, so their “scoring” of the impact of proposed legislation is important. But how accurate is their work and how non-partisan?

If you’re a regular follower of this blog, you know I’ve discussed this issue before (How Accurate is the CBO?). Today, I discuss it further because of its importance in the current healthcare debate and because there is more evidence of the CBO’s shoddy work.

Three Different Bills – Same Conclusions

Avik Roy, healthcare economist writing in Forbes, compares the CBO scores of three different Republican healthcare bills:

  • Restoring Americans’ Healthcare Freedom Reconciliation Act of 2015 (RAHFRA)
  • American Health Care Act of 2017 (AHCA)
  • Better Care Reconciliation Act of 2017 (BCRA)

 

  1. RAHFRA – Full defund of ObamaCare and no replacement:

This bill passed both the House and the Senate in 2015, repealing the Individual Mandate, the ObamaCare Medicaid expansion, and all the subsidies for ObamaCare insurance exchanges including all of the ObamaCare tax hikes. No replacement of ObamaCare was in the bill (no funds to subsidize purchasing insurance). President Obama vetoed the bill.

The CBO scoring of the bill estimated 22 million fewer insured by 2026.

  1. AHCA – Gradual defund of ObamaCare and flat tax credit replacement:

The AHCA passed the House earlier this year and was sent to the Senate for deliberation. It varied from the earlier RAHFRA bill in that the repeals of ObamaCare’s Medicaid expansion and exchange subsidies are phased out over several years. The bill also repeals the regulations that tend to drive up ObamaCare premiums; overcharging young people through 3:1 ratio age bands, and actuarial value mandates. The system of new flat tax credits will cost $375 billion over 10 years.

The CBO scoring of the bill estimated 23 million fewer insured by 2026.

In other words, spending $375 billion more than RAHFRA would actually reduce coverage by a million more!

  1. BRCA – Gradual defund of ObamaCare and means-tested tax credit replacement:

The Senate alternative to the House AHCA bill replaces flat tax credits with means-tested tax credits. This benefits low income Americans more. The Senate bill spends $616 billion over 10 years compared to $375 billion for the AHCA. You would expect this $241 billion additional spending would lead to more people with insurance – right?

The CBO scoring of the bill estimated 22 million fewer insured by 2026.

In other words, the CBO believes the additional $241 billion spending buys coverage of only one million more. Even more ludicrous, if you compare these numbers to the RAHFRA, the CBO believes the additional $616 billion in spending for low-income Americans results in zero improvement in coverage! 

How can we explain these irrational numbers?

The answer seems to be the Individual Mandate. In the most recent scoring of the BRCA, the CBO estimates that 15 million people will voluntarily drop out of the insurance market if the Individual Mandate is lifted. This is expected in the first year after repeal of this mandate.

In other words, the CBO has “baked in” a 15 million reduction of the number of people insured with any repeal of the Individual Mandate – a government regulation that forces people to purchase a product they clearly don’t want.

It is ironic, if not tragic, that one of the most reviled portions of ObamaCare, the Individual Mandate – a new regulation so widely detested that it was challenged to the Supreme Court – has become the biggest obstacle in repealing and replacing ObamaCare with a new healthcare system that serves the people better. Somewhere on a golf course President Obama must be smiling.

Medicaid Expansion’s Three Flaws – Part III

 

This is the third in a three-part series on the flaws in the ObamaCare expansion of Medicaid. Part I addressed The Enhanced Federal Matching Rate. Part II addressed the Failure to Alter Medicaid’s Open-ended Matching Rate Structure. Today we will address The Lack of Integration with Private Health Insurance.

It is established fact in academic circles that private health insurance is superior to Medicaid in terms of access to care and health outcomes. The reasons for this is beyond the scope of this post but can be found in my book, The ObamaCare Reality, and in others such as Priceless by John C. Goodman.

With this in mind, Chris Conover, Duke economist, asks an important question:

“Why do we believe in separate but equal in health care when we long ago abandoned that notion in education?”

If we want to provide equal treatment in healthcare, Conover says we must address three issues that are relevant in evaluating Medicaid:

  • Medicaid Crowd-Out
  • Medicaid Churn
  • Perverse Work Incentives

 

Medicaid Crowd-Out

The first issue is that Medicaid tends to crowd out private coverage, meaning that many people effectively trade superior private coverage for inferior Medicaid coverage. How big is this problem?

The Urban Institute, a liberal think tank, has estimated that if Medicaid expansion occurred in all 50 states, instead of just 31, there would be an additional 13.4 million people enrolled in Medicaid. But, 2.1 million of these already have private insurance on the ObamaCare exchanges and 6.4 million others have either employer-provided or non-group private insurance.

In other words, crowd-out of private health insurance exceeds 60% under the Medicaid expansion. If the Supreme Court had failed to strike down the mandatory expansion of Medicaid, about 8.5 million Americans would have been stripped of their private insurance and dumped on Medicaid!

This phenomenon is not new. The RAND Corporation estimated nearly 40% of the Medicaid expansion population ended up dropping other forms of health insurance to be enrolled in Medicaid. ObamaCare architect Jonathan Gruber even stated:

“Our results clearly show that crowd-out is significant; the central tendency in our results is a crowd-out rate of about 60%.”

Conover asks the relevant question: “So why are we so eager to shovel 8.5 million Americans into second-class coverage?” He calls for a system designed to integrate Medicaid with private insurance instead of replacing it. This is currently happening in states that received waivers including Florida, Texas, and Indiana.

Medicaid Churn

ObamaCare actually disallowed enrollment for subsidized private insurance if your income fell below the Federal Poverty Level (FPL) – even in states that declined to expand Medicaid. The Obama administration used this lever and the attempt to force all states to expand Medicaid in a deliberate effort to move people from private insurance to Medicaid.

In doing so, they created a “coverage gap” for those unfortunate Americans who found themselves just above the poverty level but living in states that declined to expand Medicaid. These people received neither Medicaid nor subsidies to purchase ObamaCare Exchange insurance. This decision created a coverage gap for 2.6 million people. This is depicted in the graphic below:

However, a much larger group is affected routinely by Medicaid Churn, where they move back and forth between private insurance and Medicaid depending on their fluctuating income. Any change that puts them above 138% of FPL causes them to fall off Medicaid and requires them to enroll in ObamaCare Exchange insurance. Likewise, any fall below that level dumps them back onto Medicaid.

It is estimated that each year approximately 6.9 million Americans are affected by churn. Even liberal economists Benjamin Sommers and Sara Rosenbaum have estimated that over a given year, 50 percent of adults below 200 percent of FPL (28 million individuals) would experience a shift from the exchanges into Medicaid or vice versa. Clearly this is not a trivial problem.

Perverse Work Incentives

Lastly, we must consider the perverse work incentives of Medicaid. A National Bureau of Economic Research study calculate that if 21.3 million additional adults gain Medicaid coverage following the ObamaCare expansion, approximately between 511,000 and 2.2 million fewer individuals will be employed as a result of the labor supply response.

Conover summarizes: “In short, for every 1,000 people who gain Medicaid expansion coverage, anywhere from 24 to 103 end up losing their job. This is a tragic loss to the economy as well as the self-esteem of Medicaid recipients.”

Stanford economist Lanhee Chen put it this way: “This research provides strong evidence for the contention that enrolling in Medicaid traps people in poverty and makes it harder for them to make their way into the middle class.”

What Does AHCA Do About Medicaid’s Lack of Integration With Private Coverage?

The AHCA gives states flexibility in administering their Medicaid programs. If a state chooses to maintain eligibility for the expansion population, any new enrollees in that eligibility category after January 1, 2020 will receive the state’s matching rate computed according to traditional rules. That means reverting to the pre-ObamaCare matching rate.

Those who previously qualified for the expansion will be grandfathered in. However, due to the churn we discussed above, eventually most of these people will revert to the traditional matching rate like the newly eligible. Thus the AHCA will likely dramatically reduce the adverse effects of Medicaid on work effort and crowd-out of private insurance coverage.

The flexibility of the AHCA will incentivize states to enhance the integration between Medicaid and private insurance. This is already happening in many states that requested ObamaCare waivers (see Democratic Demagoguery Over Medicaid). This will allow states to experiment with new programs that adjust cost-sharing requirements allowing higher co-pays for ER visits that should decrease the over-utilization of these facilities for primary care visits. It will also allow states to introduce work requirements without federal approval to motivate able-bodied adults to reduce their dependency on the government.

Conclusions

The AHCA has been criticized by proponents of ObamaCare, but it substantially improves upon the status quo. It does so in the following ways:

  • Abolishes the enhanced federal matching rate of ObamaCare
  • Redresses many of the most severe problems with Medicaid’s matching rate structure
  • Increases state flexibility to offer improvements to reduce the lack of integration of Medicaid with private insurance

 

No system is perfect but the AHCA will be a big improvement over ObamaCare.