Medicaid Expansion’s Three Flaws – Part II

 

This is the second in a three-part series that discusses the three flaws in the ObamaCare Medicaid expansion. In Part I we discussed The Enhanced Federal Matching Rate. Today we will discuss the Failure to Alter Medicaid’s Open-ended Matching Rate Structure.

Failure to Alter Medicaid’s Open-ended Matching Rate Structure

As I discussed in Part I, Medicaid has traditionally had a matching rate structure that fuels excess spending: its open-ended matching rate. For every dollar that states choose to spend on Medicaid, the federal government matches that with anywhere from $1 to $3 federal dollars, depending on that state’s specific matching rate.

Chris Conover, Duke University economist writing in Forbes, says this has been proven to fuel excessive spending. An analysis by Thad Kouser at UC Berkeley showed that all other things being equal, shifting a state from the lowest to highest federal matching rate increases discretionary Medicaid expenditures by 22 percent.

In other words, states spend more the more you match their spending. The consequence of such incentives is that in 2014 we spent 93 times as much on Medicaid as we did in 1970, less than 50 years earlier. The formula encourages states to expand their programs as much as possible, knowing that at least half the cost or more will be picked up by the taxpayers of other states.

This problem has been exacerbated by ObamaCare which has given us The Enhanced Federal Matching Rate that was discussed in Part I of this series. Now states can expand their Medicaid spending knowing their neighboring states will help pick up $9 dollars of the added expense for every $1 dollar they spend.

The Impact of Medicaid Spending

States must balance their budgets by law, unlike the federal government. They can’t print money when they run out. Therefore, they must make hard choices to balance Medicaid spending with other critical expenses like K-12 education, higher education, transportation, corrections, public assistance and others. It is easy for them to be irresponsible in their spending when someone else is picking up most of the tab.

Despite this open-ended matching rate, Medicaid is gobbling up more and more of state budgets while education and other needs go lacking. This chart shows how the portion of state spending on Medicaid has changed since 2000 and how this has affected other state spending. The result has been a steady decline in state spending on education, transportation, and public safety.

Shares of Total State Spending by Category – 2000 and 2014

 

Medicaid Benefits Wealthy States

The matching formula is intended to provide more help for poor states and less for wealthier states – but the opposite is true. This has been true even before ObamaCare but it is worse now. The following graphic shows how the three highest income states – The District of Columbia, Connecticut, and Massachusetts – are among the 6 states receiving the largest amounts of federal Medicaid dollars.

Medicaid is a Boondoggle for Wealthy States

 

Calculations by Christopher J. Conover

Georgia, on the other hand, falls in the bottom fifth of states in terms of per capita income, yet Washington, D. C. gets nearly 5 times as much federal funding per poor person despite being the wealthiest “state” in the union.

The reason for such disparity is a floor on the federal match rate for Medicaid (FMAP) where even the wealthiest states get a 50% discount on their Medicaid spending. Without this floor, a wealthy state like Connecticut would get only a 10.81% match rather than the 50% they actually get. Most egregious is the District of Columbia, which by law receives matching funds at a 70% discount, even though they have the highest per capita income of all. This gives wealthy states a strong incentive to expand coverage to many people who are not poor because the additional cost will be shared with other states.

Post-ObamaCare

This significant bias toward wealthy states was well-known before ObamaCare. Now the situation is even worse. With the Enhance Federal Matching Rate these wealthy states get a 90% match to cover the non-disabled adults they have added to their Medicaid rolls.

The Urban Institute, a liberal think tank, says their research showed that 10 states actually would make money on the Medicaid expansion – a net reduction in the total amount of Medicaid spending financed with state dollars compared to what they would have spent under ObamaCare had they not expanded. None of the states depicted in the graphic below is among the poorest quintile of states based on per capita income.

10 Lucky States That Literally Made Money by Expanding Medicaid

Calculations by Christopher J. Conover

 

What Does AHCA Do About the Medicaid’s Open-ended Federal Matching Rate?

The AHCA completely eliminates the federal matching rate formula starting in 2020 by giving states options for a per capita cap or block grant. The year 2016 is used as a base to prevent states from ratcheting up spending before 2020. The cap would vary by eligibility category and state, reflecting the enormous variation that now exists on both dimensions.

The block grant option is available to states only for the eligibility groups that are not disable or aged. Conover anticipates most states will choose this option rather than the per capita caps since there is less risk. The per capita cap is more generous than an earlier proposal by President Clinton because it allows spending to grow by the more generous yardstick of medical inflation (4%) rather than real growth in GDP (about 2%).

In summary, Conover says, “the good news is that shifting to per capita caps would save money by controlling Medicaid spending at a more sensible rate than the current open-ended matching rate does. The downside is that the new system largely will preserve rather sizable inequities across the states.”

Medicaid Expansion’s Three Flaws – Part I

 

Medicaid is a flawed healthcare system for the poor. If you’ve followed this blog for long you know I’ve said that many times. Today I want to begin a three-part series that addresses the three major flaws of the ObamaCare Medicaid expansion. It is crucial to understand these flaws because they are the source of the major debate going on now in the Senate that will determine the future of the healthcare system.

Before we begin, it is necessary to understand how Medicaid operated before the passage of ObamaCare and then see how it changed.

Medicaid Before ObamaCare

Before the passage of ObamaCare, the federal government support of this cooperative program with the states was about two-thirds of the expense. The federal government paid about 2 of every 3 dollars spent and the state picked up the third dollar. In theory, the program was designed to redistribute federal taxpayers’ dollars from wealthier states to poorer states by giving poorer states a higher match for every dollar they spend. (In reality the system actually benefits wealthier states more as we will discuss in Part II.)

This federal support varies significantly from state to state and so does state eligibility. In Minnesota, where the income threshold is the highest in the nation, you are eligible to be on Medicaid even if you earn up to 275% of the Federal Poverty Level (FPL). In Alabama, which has a much lower average income, you are only eligible for Medicaid if your income is less than 25% of the FPL.

Medicaid After ObamaCare

ObamaCare is mostly about the expansion of Medicaid. Originally, it tried to force all the states to expand Medicaid or lose their federal matching funds. The Supreme Court struck down this involuntary expansion and made it voluntary. The end result was only 31 states plus the District of Columbia expanded Medicaid.

The ObamaCare Medicaid expansion changed the rules about Medicaid. First, it changed the eligibility rules making anyone eligible up to 133% of the FPL. Second, it agreed to pay 100% of the additional costs of these newly eligible enrollees for three years, then reduced the federal support in stages down to 90% in 2020 and indefinitely thereafter. Third, it made it unlawful to be uninsured and therefore forced many people previously eligible for Medicaid, but not enrolled, to enroll in the system to avoid paying a tax.

The result of these changes is about 15 million more Americans enrolled in Medicaid. The cost of this expansion is now $574 billion when last measured in 2016.

There are flaws in the system that threaten to bankrupt it. Chris Conover, healthcare economist at Duke University, writes in Forbes that he believes there are three flaws in the Medicaid expansion:

  • The Enhanced Federal Matching Rate
  • The Failure to Alter Medicaid’s Open-ended Matching Rate Structure
  • The Lack of Integration with Private Health insurance – especially the new health care Exchanges created under the law

Today we will address the first of these flaws and the others in Parts II and III.

The Enhanced Federal Matching Rate

The “carrot” that lured states into expanding Medicaid was the 100% match in the first three years declining to 90% after 2020. However, the concept that the federal government can actually meet these expectations in the face of a federal deficit that reached $20 Trillion this year, is delusional, in Conover’s opinion. But even if we could afford it, it is a spectacularly bad idea for these reasons:

  • States Vary Greatly in Altruistic Willingness–to-Pay – If we use state Medicaid dollars per $100 of taxable resources as a crude measure of differences in the willingness-to-pay for the health needs of their poor, there is literally a four-fold difference between the states of Ohio and Washington.

States Vary Greatly in Altruistic Willingness-to-Pay

  • ACA Privileges Able-Bodied Adults Over Historically-Favored Vulnerable Populations – Medicaid was originally intended for pregnant women, infants, children, the elderly, and the disabled. Privileging able-bodied adults makes no sense. Extending government-paid healthcare to these adults only encourages them to remain on government dependence rather than become productive members of the work force. ObamaCare tried to make it look like the lion’s share of this expanded Medicaid coverage would be born by the federal government, in short to over-ride the historic judgment against such a policy.

 

  • ObamaCare’s 90% Enhanced Match Rate Put a One-Way Cost-Driving Ratchet on Steroids – This change in the matching formula only encourages wasteful spending and in Conover’s words: “discourages states from economizing; creating a one-way ratchet effect that fuels ever-rising Medicaid spending. The 90% federal matching rate under the expansion puts such incentives on steroids; now, states that save $1 of Medicaid funds get to pocket only 10 cents of those savings, while states that waste $1 pay only 1 dime more.”

 

Last year’s annual report on Medicaid issued by the HHS showed that the average cost of the ACA’s Medicaid expansion enrollees was nearly 50% higher in 2015 than HHS projections. An important factor was that states faced with such weak incentives to contain costs were not nearly as tough as they usually are in negotiating good rates with managed care companies.

The most recent CBO projections show federal Medicaid costs will increase another 67% over the next decade.

How Does the AHCA Alter the Enhanced Federal Matching Rate?

The American Health Care Act (AHCA) being debated in Congress now currently calls for continued enhanced federal matching through 2019 but in 2020 it replaces the program with per capita caps on federal spending that will vary by state and eligibility category. States will get a higher amount for elderly Medicaid recipients.

In short, the enhanced federal matching rate of ObamaCare ends in 2020. States that chose to continue their expansion of Medicaid to include able-bodied adults would continue to receive a federal subsidy to cover them after 2019 but it would be based on the traditional matching rate.

The CBO estimates that the AHCA will reduce Medicaid spending by $834 Billion in the next decade but does not divulge whether this is attributed to spending caps or the elimination of the enhanced federal matching rate. Either way, it is a huge step forward toward containing the runaway costs of Medicaid.

Hysteria Over Senate Healthcare Bill

 

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer complained about the “secrecy” of the healthcare bill proposed by Senate Republicans. Then he gave a prepared speech condemning the bill just moments after it was released for his review. That should tell you how fairly this legislation is being evaluated by his party.

In reality, the Senate bill meets every essential principle for healthcare reform that a bi-partisan group of healthcare researchers agreed must be included. (see Healthcare Reform Principles That Cross Party Lines)

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says, “The bill is an imperfect compromise between moderate and conservative Republicans, and it makes pains to accommodate different interests and the Americans, states and businesses that have adapted to ObamaCare over the years. . . But the reform is a major improvement over the U.S. healthcare status quo that will worsen if the bill fails.”

Avik Roy, healthcare economist writing in Forbes, was an outspoken critic of the House bill, the AHCA, but he now praises the Senate version. (see High Praise for the Senate Healthcare Bill)

The Senate Version of the AHCA

The House of Representatives passed the American Health Care Act (AHCA) and the Senate is deliberating over its version of the bill. The Senate bill, called The Better Care and Reconciliation Act of 2017 (BCRA), uses the House bill as a frame of reference but differs in several ways.

Things That Are the Same in Both Chambers:

The Senate bill is the same as the House in these ways:

  • Replaces ObamaCare subsidies with tax credits for people who purchase insurance on the individual market
  • Ends Medicaid’s status as an open-ended entitlement
  • Transitions Medicaid to block grants by per capita enrollment
  • Increases flexibility for states to innovate their Medicaid program
  • Repeals ObamaCare tax hikes including the 3.8% on investment income
  • Begins to resolve some of the healthcare system’s flaws

 

Things That Differ in the Senate Version:

The Senate bill differs from the House bill in these ways:

  • Medicaid transitions over 4 years (House 3 Years) and ties the grants to inflation with no adjustment (House tied to inflation plus 1%)
  • Eliminates the enhanced Federal Matching Rate – Pre and Post ObamaCare enrollees will be treated the same. (begins 2021)
  • Senate tax credits are more generous than the House – but means tested
  • $100 Billion for a “stability fund” to support insurance markets
  • Uses ACA program called “1332 waivers” to eliminate regulations and mandates to give states flexibility to design new insurance products
  • Maintains the “community rating” with 3:1 ratio pricing of ObamaCare

 

The Senate bill is “kinder” to the poor and harder on the rich than the House bill. The tax credits are means tested, which will translate into more credits for the poor and less or none for higher-incomes. The House tax credits also created work disincentives since people earning just enough to leave Medicaid would face higher out of pocket expenses for healthcare. The Senate tax credits avoid this problem.

But it also is “meaner” to the young and healthy because it maintains the 3:1 pricing that drives up premiums for them and benefits older, sicker Americans. This issue would be my criticism of the bill but apparently it was needed to win enough votes from moderates.

Taxes that are passed on to consumers are eliminated and industry taxes that depress economic growth and jobs are eliminated, too. This will fuel economic growth, creating more jobs for all Americans. Democrats will portray this as a “tax cut for the rich” but it really is simply eliminating the “tax hike” of ObamaCare that slowed down our economy.

The Medicaid enhanced federal matching rate of ObamaCare is eliminated which fueled wasteful spending and threatened to overwhelm the federal budget. States that refuse block grants will have to accept the “traditional matching rates” for residents that existed before ObamaCare – which average 52% federal support.

The changes in Medicaid are some of the biggest improvements over ObamaCare. These changes allow states the flexibility to design their own innovative programs that will lower costs and improve quality for their residents. Such programs have already begun under waivers granted by the Obama administration and are proving successful in states like Indiana, Rhode Island, and Florida. The AHCA will ensure such programs will grow and expand to other states without the need for federal waivers.

If the Senate passes this bill, it will go to a conference committee where members of both chambers of Congress will work out the differences in the two bills until they come to a consensus. At this point, I think the Senate bill comes closer to the changes needed to garner enough votes for passage in both chambers.

The importance of this moment cannot be overemphasized. The WSJ put it this way:

“The Senate bill is imperfect, but it includes many conservative policy victories that have long been Republican goals. It’s not too much to say this is a defining moment for whether the GOP can ever reform runaway entitlements. If Republicans fail, the next stop is single payer.”