Democratic Demagoguery Over Medicaid

 

Webster’s dictionary defines demagoguery as “appealing to the emotions and prejudices of people in order to gain political power.” This accurately describes the Democrats in Congress as Republicans discuss Medicaid reform.

Medicaid is badly in need of reform. There is no doubt of that. ObamaCare greatly expanded this second-class healthcare by about 15 million Americans bringing the total enrollment numbers in 2017 to 74.6 million according to Medicaid.gov. One in five Americans is on Medicaid.

The cost of Medicaid to the American taxpayer was $545 billion in 2015, a growth of nearly 10% over 2014. The rate of growth slowed down in 2016 but the cost grew to $574 billion. Projections for 2017 are for slower growth in federal spending but increased growth in state spending.

ObamaCare can be fairly described as mostly an expansion of Medicaid. This change in the healthcare law expanded the number of insured by 20 million, but 15 million of those were enrolled in Medicaid. This happened for two reasons:

  • Expanded eligibility in those states agreeing to Medicaid expansion
  • Mandates that forced previously un-enrolled eligibles to enroll to avoid a tax

 

Republican Reforms

Republicans have been working to reform Medicaid in the states for the last ten years. The modern era of Medicaid reform began in Indiana in 2007 under Governor Mitch Daniels who signed the Healthy Indiana Plan (HIP) that introduced consumer-directed insurance options, including Health Savings Accounts (HSAs). Two years later Rhode Island applied for a Medicaid block grant that gives states a fixed sum of money in return for Washington’s regulatory forbearance.

According to The Wall Street Journal editorial board, both programs were designed to improve the incentives to manage costs and increase upward mobility so fewer people need Medicaid. Over the first three years, Rhode Island saved some $100 million in local funds and overall spending declined about $3 billion below the $12 billion cap. The fixed block grant encouraged the state to innovate, such as reducing hospital admissions for chronic diseases or transitioning the frail elderly to community care from nursing homes.

Rhode Island joined the ObamaCare Medicaid expansion but has held “per member, per month “ spending – the category of block grant adopted by the House – to a minus 0.5% trend over the last five years without cutting eligibility or services. Notably, that measure excludes patients added under Medicaid’s ObamaCare expansion, who tend to be healthier and thus require less spending than the typical enrollee. As a result, overall per member, per month costs are falling 2.5% a year.

Even far-left liberal New York Governor Andrew Cuomo has accepted the block grants. After a scandal where federal investigators concluded the state had systematically manipulated Medicaid payment formulas to generate federal payola for more than two decades, Cuomo agreed in 2014 to a Medicaid waiver that caps “global spending” at the growth rate of long-term healthcare inflation (3.6%).

Vice President Mike Pence, formerly Governor of Indiana, updated the HIP plan with a reform called HIP 2.0 in 2015. The architect of this, Seema Varma, is now administrator of Medicaid nationally. Their insight was that able-bodied, working-age adults living near the poverty level need a different type of coverage than do Medicaid’s most vulnerable beneficiaries.

In other words, those adults with the capacity to work should be incentivized to do so and ultimately to get off Medicaid. Medicaid was never really intended for such people until ObamaCare brought them into the eligibility ranks.

The HIP plan requires enrollees to pay 2% of their income to an HSA. The first $2,500 is picked up by the state, the money rolls over, and unused consumer contributions are refunded pro rata when they leave HIP 2.0. This plan is working well in Indiana.

According to a recent audit by the Lewin Group, 70% of Hoosiers in HIP 2.0 make their regular contributions even though 85% of them are below the poverty level. If they fail to keep up their contributions they are bounced back to basic Medicaid. HIP 2.0 also is paired with skills training, job searches and career counselors to help people move from public assistance to the workplace.

These kinds of reforms are currently happening in 21 states, showing that programs with incentives to save money and provide training and job searches can lower costs and move people off the Medicaid rolls onto employer-provided or private insurance, saving money and providing improved healthcare.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board says this progress is being ignored by Democrats:

“This reform honor roll could continue: the 21 states that have moved more than 75% of all beneficiaries to managed care, Colorado’s pediatric “medical homes” program, Texas’s Medicaid waiver to devolve control to localities from the Austin bureaucracy. But liberals and the media ignore this progress as they try to frighten the GOP into doing nothing.”

 

Finding ways to improve Medicaid – and ultimately to move people from government healthcare to private insurance – is the next important step in fixing the problems with our healthcare system that have only been exacerbated by ObamaCare. This is the Senate’s chance to make that step.

Misleading Assumptions Confuse Healthcare Debate

 

Let’s start by agreeing that the goal is the best possible healthcare treatment for every American. That means the best access to medical care. But achieving that goal is much more complicated than it seems. To understand this complexity it is necessary to address some common assumptions that may seem intuitive but in fact are misleading.

Having health insurance leads to healthcare treatment. The assumption many people make is that having healthcare insurance leads to getting healthcare treatment. In fact, the wrong kind of healthcare insurance may be an obstacle to healthcare treatment. The best example of this is Medicaid. Since only about half of doctors accept Medicaid patients (and most of those limit the number of Medicaid appointments) it is very difficult for these patients to actually receive medical care. Furthermore, they are prevented from paying cash to those doctors who don’t accept Medicaid since this is illegal – the doctors could lose their licenses. As a result Medicaid patients have poor access to healthcare and use ERs for primary care 40% more than even the uninsured according to an Oregon study.

ObamaCare exchange private insurance is better than Medicaid, but not much. More doctors will accept this insurance than Medicaid, but the deductibles are so high ($6000 average for individuals; $12,000 for families) that they often can’t use this insurance, either. They have insurance, but still lack good access to healthcare.

Having any healthcare insurance is better than having none – This seems intuitive, but again it may be inaccurate. If your insurance is Medicaid, you may face the access problems I discussed above. For this reason and others, one-third of all Medicaid-eligible patients before ObamaCare did not enroll in this free government healthcare insurance.

Why not enroll in a free healthcare insurance program? Without Medicaid the uninsured can negotiate cash discounts from virtually any doctor they choose to see. Therefore, they have better access to healthcare without insurance. True, they risk catastrophic medical bills if they become seriously ill but many accept this risk. In reality, numerous medical studies have demonstrated that the uninsured have better healthcare outcomes than those on Medicaid.

The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) is non-partisan and accurate – If only this were true! (see my recent post How Accurate is the CBO?) In reality, the CBO has demonstrated time and again that it leans left with overly optimistic predictions about ObamaCare and overly pessimistic predictions about the American Health Care Act. Here is a graph showing the accuracy of the CBO in predicting ObamaCare enrollment:

The CBO is using faulty data with unreasonable expectations for the status quo (ObamaCare) when comparing it to the proposed new healthcare (AHCA). Most importantly, CBO predictions reflect what they think people will choose to do; not what the law will force people to do. Many will choose to drop their Medicaid or ObamaCare exchange insurance if freed from the government mandates that forced them to enroll in a plan they didn’t want.

The status quo (ObamaCare) is better than the proposed change (AHCA). Kimberley Strassel of The Wall Street Journal called the AHCA a “home run”. The AHCA is not perfect – far from it. It’s just so much better than ObamaCare that she characterized the improvement that way. But the AHCA is a good start for the process of finding a better way. (It could be improved by making the tax credits means-tested rather than flat to increase support for poorer Americans with less for those with higher-incomes.)

Left out of the discussion is the fact that ObamaCare is in a death spiral and will certainly collapse completely within a year. Many states will be down to one insurance provider in 2018 and some will have none! So the status quo is unacceptable and a better system must be found.

Free insurance for everyone is a good thing. Of course, there’s no such thing as “free insurance” because the taxpayers are paying for it. But the goal of Democrats is to provide “free insurance” for everyone. Senator Bernie Sanders likes to call it “Medicare for all.” The assumption here is that this solves all the problems because everyone will have health insurance. Yes, they may have health insurance – but they won’t necessarily receive healthcare.

This kind of system is referred to as “single-payer” healthcare – a variant of socialized medicine. The government pays all the healthcare bills – and is in complete control. That means they choose your doctor, your appointment time, and even your treatment – if you get treated at all! In such systems the government routinely decides that anyone over a certain age is no longer eligible for some treatments.

In every socialized medicine system in the world, (Canada, Great Britain, Sweden) the government controls costs by controlling access to healthcare. This not only delays treatment but leads to poorer healthcare outcomes. If you compare cancer treatment outcomes in these countries to our country we are dramatically better. That’s why anyone from these countries with the money to afford it comes to the U.S. for their healthcare. (see my recent post Single-Payer v. Market-Oriented Healthcare: Which is Better?)

But you don’t need to look outside this country to see the failure of socialized medicine. Right here in America we have a large socialized medicine system – it’s called the VA. The entire VA system is paid for and controlled by the government. These patients all have health insurance – yet many have died waiting to get medical treatment.

In 2014 it was revealed this tragedy was happening at the Phoenix VA and many others as well. Although there have been some improvements since then, the same basic problems persist. The only real solution is giving veterans the freedom to seek their healthcare through private physicians outside the system. Socialized medicine always leads to delayed treatment – and poorer healthcare outcomes.

ObamaCare has added 20 million Americans to the ranks of the insured – but 15 million of them are on Medicaid and the other 5 million have such high deductibles they can barely use the insurance they have. I believe there are solutions to these problems but it will not be easy in the politically charged atmosphere of Congress and with a mainstream media dedicated to promoting the distortions of Democratic talking points.

Sooner or later, there will come a tipping point when the American people will have to decide if they want socialized medicine or they want to retain the freedom to choose their insurance, their doctor, and their treatment. If they choose what Democrats are pushing, the once envied American health care system will become just another government run program.

Single-Payer v. Market-Oriented Healthcare: Which is Better?

 

 

It has been their goal from the beginning. Progressives have been pushing for socialized medicine since the days of Teddy Roosevelt. In the politically correct world of healthcare terminology it is referred to as “single-payer” healthcare.

There is no real debate happening in Congress right now between Democrats and Republicans on how to stop the collapse of ObamaCare. While Republicans favor a market-oriented system to correct the ObamaCare problems, Democrats deny the problems exist and demagogue the issue, trying to frighten the public. Their real goal is to let ObamaCare implode and then push for its replacement with a single-payer system. Which system is best for America’s future?

The Lancet Study

Chris Conover, writing in Forbes, reports a new study from the British medical journal Lancet that compares the two systems. This study adds to the growing mountain of evidence that market-oriented health care systems outperform the single-payer systems that so enamor progressives.

This study compared healthcare outcomes in the single-payer systems of Canada and the United Kingdom (UK) with those of market-oriented systems in the Netherlands, Switzerland, Singapore, and the United States.

Single-payer systems rely on a command-and-control approach to healthcare that depends on price controls and government determined capacity constraints that predictably lead to long waiting lines and lower quality care. Market-oriented systems rely on markets to ensure universal access to high quality care at an affordable price. Switzerland uses private health insurance for all of its citizens, even the poor and the elderly, providing subsidies to purchase the insurance for those in most need.

The Lancet researchers, led by Christopher Murray, uses a measure called the Healthcare Access and Quality Index (HAQ Index) to focus on mortality related to adverse effects of medical treatment. This index measures the ability of countries to avoid “amenable mortality”; i.e., deaths that hypothetically would not occur with timely and effective medical care.

Conover says amenable mortality in the U.S. accounts for about one-fifth of mortality under age seventy-five in men and nearly one-third in women. Since there are over one million deaths a year in the U.S. among those under age 75, this implies there are more than one quarter million avoidable deaths annually.

Market-oriented health systems demonstrably outperform single-payer healthcare systems

Created by Christopher J. Conover

 

This figure shows a comparison between single-payer systems in Canada and the UK on the left with market-oriented systems in Switzerland, Netherlands and Singapore on the right. The United States is depicted in the middle. Higher HAQ indexes are seen in green. To be sure, the numbers suggest that single-payer would be an improvement over the status quo (ObamaCare) but not nearly as good as the market-oriented systems in the countries on the right.

Conover has also isolated the “adverse effects of medical treatment” scores, which demonstrate that market-oriented health systems do even better at avoiding medical mistakes than single-payer countries. Contrary to intuition that might suggest more regulation by the government reduces mistakes, this study shows that greater reliance on market forces actually produces greater incentives to avoid errors. It is interesting that Singapore – which relies heavily on health savings accounts – performs the best of all on this measure.

Achieving Potential

The Lancet authors recognize that resources vary from country to country which may limit what can be achieved in avoiding preventable deaths. By these measures alone you could not expect the UK to have a HAQ Index as high as Switzerland, which has a GDP per capita twice as high as the UK. Yet despite these differences the market-oriented systems come closer to achieving their hypothetically attainable HAQ index scores than the single-payer systems. This is depicted in the graph below.

Market-oriented health systems perform much closer to their potential

compared to single-payer health systems

Created by Christopher J. Conover

 

In this graphic we can see that the United States is functioning 11.1% below what it is capable of, which by the earlier calculations results in 250,00 preventable deaths per year. If these measurements are accurate it implies that conversion to a single-payer system like Canada would improve the HAQ Index and potentially save 150,000 lives per year compared to our status quo. However, conversion to a market-oriented system such as Switzerland would save an additional 100,000 lives or 250,000 lives over the status quo.

The status quo is unacceptable. No one wants to go back to the pre-ObamaCare days. America can do better. But the answer is not single-payer healthcare. The answer is a market-oriented health system that preserves freedom of choice to pick your doctor, your insurance coverage, and your treatment – and incentivizes doctors and hospitals to provide high quality care at the lowest possible cost. Such systems in countries like Switzerland, the Netherlands and Singapore are already providing high-quality healthcare at a lower cost to both government and patients than in America today.